Everything posted by Alex
-
Injuries....according to Gardy
Last year injury communication was an issue and definitely shaped the way fans perceived players (the entire bilateral leg weakness). I actually did find it odd that Gardenhire was making injury reports and then unsurprised to hear they were wrong. It's not a huge deal, but it does show just how far some of the issues with this organization run. (Though, interestingly, Doumit was highly concerned and hadn't directly heard he was on the DL, according to Joe C's article. So this kind of thing does affect players.)
-
Injuries....according to Gardy
Doumit had a calf cramp tonight. Capps sore arm and was not going to pitch tonight, according to Gardenhire. Blackburn's thigh is hurting and sounds like he might end up on the DL. Gardy mentioned an MRI for someone but I missed who it was. Anyone else catch it?
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
Woah. Dick just used OPS.
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
I think his point was simply that it's at least worthwhile to give Plouffe a couple more weeks. I think he used Casilla for comparison as is arguably a worse hitter (Aaron Gleeman mentioned that he is one of the ten worst Twins hitters in history with over 1000AB) and has a much bigger track record to prove it in the bigs yet people don't seem as upset about his being in the lineup. Even though we'd like the Twins to win more games, they're in a position where they can give Plouffe some more time, just in case before they cut ties with him.
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
Yeah, how many runs have they cost themselves far? Four? This means the Tigers are responsible for almost every run in the game.
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
This post came true in less than 5 minutes. Impressive. Coincidentally I was talking to my dad, who wasn't watching the game yet, when Tigers had runners at first and third and told him he should turn it on quick or he might miss the Twins being ahead. I was mostly joking.
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
I totally get that line in Richard III now, "My kingdom for a starting pitcher!"
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
Dick just mentioned that Twins have turned more DP than they have hit into. Wonder if it has anything to do with the number of "opportunities."
-
Game 36 - Twins @ Detroit - 3/16/12
I really don't care where he plays, but I hope he gets regular at bats for a bit.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
This is the essence of value. My answer is likely a yes, assuming that you're getting a closer to ideal Mauer, who is catching more than he is now and hitting more like expected when his contract was signed. Hopefully, the difference in hitting production between a top hitting C and average C is > the difference in hitting production between a top hitting 1B and an average one. You don't need to hope a $5M-$10M player hits 30HR/100 RBI (if those are the only numbers that concern you) because the net gain overall should be better. A player like Willingham is an excellent example of this. He plays a corner outfield position, hit 4 fewer HR than Braun and had 14 fewer RBI on a much worse team. Willingham is getting $7M this year. Braun signed an extension that averages over $21M a year (which I think includes the bonus). Now, Braun did a lot of other things better, too, but I chose to use HR and RBI since those are the stats you quoted. I'm not saying I'd rather have Willingham than Braun, but you can see the difference is much smaller there than between a top hitting catcher last year, Napoli, and an average hitting catcher like Lucroy. So, if I took Willingham and Napoli and you took Braun and Lucroy, I think I come out ahead. I should note that by themselves HR and RBI just don't matter all that much to me. There are so many things a hitter can do besides hitting a HR that add value (or take it away) while RBI tend to be a lot about chance and the hitters ahead in the order.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
@ shanewahl, I agree and I did mention it, but those are great points about the chain reaction in the roster. He obviously doesn't get the boos and vitriol because his contract is smaller and for whatever reason people think Mauer missing playtime last year was less legitimate than Morneau's. One other point: Vernon Wells contract did not paralyze the Angels...., though they could be looking at two horrid contracts...
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
@Jokin, Blaming decisions in free agency and direction of the team on Mauer's contract, or the uncertainty of his performance, is, frankly, absurd. Any front office that sets their goals for an entire season around one player would be labeled as idiotic. It's true that Mauer's contract is going to limit future FA and that how well Mauer would bounce back was/is questionable. However, he was one of many question marks and has been more positive than some. Here they are: 1. Morneau: Coming off multiple injuries, what form could he return to? So far, the answer has not been good. 2. Valencia: Could he regain 2010 form or even just be better than last year? So far, he's been worse, and hopefully he'll be back up and perform better sometime soon, but I doubt it. 3. The Entire Starting Pitching Staff: Nick Nelson again does a great job of breaking this down, but as he mentioned, they've all come up "tails." (http://www.twinsdaily.com/entry.php?41-Dangerous-Gambles-in-the-Rotation) If you want to argue that the Twins cut payroll due to all these question marks and didn't plan to win-it-all based on that I'd be fine with that, but hypothesizing that their lack of aggressiveness in FA was simply due to questions about Mauer is ridiculous, and lacks evidence. I'd further argue, though, that the Twins track record of FA shows that they have never been aggressive, especially with starting pitching. Maybe that will change, but I don't think it will under the current leadership, and I think it has less to do with Mauer that with the organizational philosophy.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
Lol! 12 PA with runner on third and less than 2 outs. 8 RBI. That not exactly a percent as a runner could score from first or second, but it seems like a good ratio. Truth be told, I'm optimistic about Mauer and tend to think the frustration about him and his contract are misplaced in terms of who should be blamed if the Twins aren't getting value out of it. I'll admit, Nick Nelson's latest blog is a major fear.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
Hehe and woba is even more fun!
-
Game 35 - Twins vs Cleveland - 5/15/12
I think this those kind of numbers tell the exact story: horrible starting pitching and a surprisingly good bullpen that essentially closes the door, though it's usually too late.
-
Game 35 - Twins vs Cleveland - 5/15/12
Watched on Gameday for a bit today and noted that the evergreens are still there....almost like ghosts...
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
This stuff can be checked: Mauer's triple slash with runners on third and less than 2 outs: .346/.417/.636, 8 RBIs With RISP in general: .379/.514/.552 14RBI (37 PA and only struck out twice and has hit into 0 GDP in these situations). Yeah, terrible..... You're dead on about the GDP, overall though. I think he's going to need to figure out a way to hit line drives if he wants to improve. Even with that, his line with a runner on 1st and less than two outs is .269/.424/.886 and 7 GDP in 33 PA. His worst hitting is with a runner on third and two outs: .200/.333/.200. This is also his smallest sample size of just 6 PA, so a couple of good at-bats here will have a positive affect. Just for good measure, with runners on his overall numbers are: .302/.456/.434 (.890 OPS) in 68 PA. Better than his stats with no one on. Like I said, these things can be checked.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
I agree, and this was the point. It should be much easier to sign/develop even average hitters at these positions, but the Twins haven't done a good job of that. You shouldn't need to spend big money to get average players at these positions and they are still excellent hitters. The difference between them and spending a ton of money at those positions is of smaller gain than at a position like catcher. See below for average WOBA by position. There's far more net gain in spending big on a SS or C than there is in a LF, RF or 1B. [TABLE] Catcher[TD=width: 60].307[/TD] [TD=width: 100]First Base[/TD] [TD=width: 60].337[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Second Base[/TD] [TD=width: 60].307[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Third Base[/TD] [TD=width: 60].309[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Shortstop[/TD] [TD=width: 60].303[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Left Field[/TD] [TD=width: 60].320[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Center Field[/TD] [TD=width: 60].324[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Right Field[/TD] [TD=width: 60].334[/TD] [TD=width: 100]Designated Hitter[/TD] [TD=width: 60].337[/TD] [TD=width: 100]MLB Average[/TD] [TD=width: 60].316 [/TD] [/TABLE] Additionally, there are two further problems with your argument. One, we should have at least 1B filled with an excellent hitter, but that's easily a worse contract than the one discussed here. (Note: I'm not bashing Morneau, here, but the point seems obvious). The other problem is the simple premise that Mauer's not valuable in terms of positional scarcity due to the fact that he doesn't have players around him. As mentioned, that's up to the Twins, not Mauer. The fact that they have haven't been able to produce/draft/accquire another even average hitter at RF is an organizational issue. The fact that they cut $15 from their payroll is an organizational issue. You cannot blame Mauer's contract for their inability or unwillingness to produce other even average talent or spend some more money in FA. It just isn't true.
-
Game 35 - Twins vs Cleveland - 5/15/12
Yeah, I don't mind seeing Plouffe get more playing time to see what they have there, or even the two speedy outfielders. Parmelee's not being helped by being up here, especially sitting on the bench most days. I think that while Dozier's performed well and I hope it continues, I hope we're not saying the same thing about his as Parmelee a month or two down the road. I like Carroll, and I'm sure the pitchers like to have him back there, but he's entered this organization at a bad time. I'd also like to see them resting Mauer a bit more and letting Morneau stay on the DL a bit longer. Why put wear and tear on the vets, especially those two?
-
Game 35 - Twins vs Cleveland - 5/15/12
To be fair to Twins hitters, four (maybe 5) of them should be in AAA. This roster looks way too much like August's and we're only 35 games in, not to mention the pitching is even worse.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
Setting aside the Mauer argument, It's just as true for real baseball. Having a good hitter and a "hitting-scarce" position allows more flexibility and allows that team to more easily fill other portions of their roster. As we saw this offseason, it's not as difficult to replace corner outfielders who can hit. With regard to almost every other fielding position, it is. In fact, of the players you mention above, only Parmelee doesn't play at a "positional scarcity." Essentially, the hope is that it's managed correctly that you can get more for your money throughout your entire team. You certainly can't get away with replacement level players (or worse) at those other positions, as you mention, but a team doesn't have to be equivalent to the Yankees or Cardinals to make use of a player like Mauer, the Twins certainly have proven that in the past.
-
Game 34 -- Twins vs Indians -- 5/14/12
Mauer does have a .400ish OBP, so he is getting on base for somebody.
-
Game 34 -- Twins vs Indians -- 5/14/12
Yeah, sadly he gave that up, along with three more so far. They're hitting him hard. Oh my. Look who is up in the pen....
-
Game 33 - Twins vs Blue Jays - 5/13/12
I responded in the other thread, but I find it ironic that I was quoted when I don't find this comparison useful. Explanation in the other thread.
-
How Overpaid is Joe Mauer?
If Mauer's contract truly handcuffs the organization, then it's certainly an issue. However, if anyone should have considered the payroll would plummet, it should have been the organization. That element is their choice, at least for this season, and they could now be in a downward spiral as far as that is concerned: cut the payroll---> not as much talent ----> not as many wins ----> fans coming to games ----> cut the payroll. I'm still of the opinion that they aren't going to spend much of that $23M even if they could have it back.