Everything posted by Alex
-
Article: Blind faith vs. evidence and reason
No, he can't become a 6 year minor league free agent until after the 2013 season, which makes me feel even more horrible for him. he was drafted in 2006, but he didn't sign until early in the 2007 season, after his senior season of college (final year of draft-n-follows). if they don't put him on the 40 man roster (or if they do for September and then take him back off again), he would be eligible for the Rule 5 draft. But then again, when the Twins took him off the 40 man last November, no one claimed him. Hard for me to understand this one. In 8-9 years of following the Twins farm system pretty closely, nothing has confused me more than the Slama Situation. Thanks for clarifying (originally my post but I think getting rid of the double quote caused the error). It sounds like he could still be gone for nothing. For those that believe we should trust the Twins scouts, how have they done lately? If you look at how poorly they've done with them, it's arguable that they should probably abandon that approach and that those who have followed just the stats (because that's all we can) have been a bit more accurate this year, unfortunately.
-
Article: Blind faith vs. evidence and reason
If we judged every player on his first five games (and in Slama's case that would be seven innings) we'd have very few major leaguers. There's no reason the Twins can't give him 20-40 innings between now and the start of next year of years to see if they're opinion is wrong. The guy costs nothing and he's going to be able to walk after this season unless they move him to the 40-man roster. It just doesn't make sense.
-
Article: Blind faith vs. evidence and reason
Statistics can also tell you exactly what we see, and that's part of the point of the article. If we believe that the Twins are right in trotting out a player like Gray while Slama rots in Rochester, we have blind faith. I've no problem trusting scouting if it turns out to be correct, but in the Twins case, I think we can see that it's not going very well.
-
Article: Blind faith vs. evidence and reason
Great article, and I was just about to post a shorter version in the game thread. It's less about a guy like Gray being horrible than it is about the concern this puts in the Twins ability or method of evaluating players. People who were paying attention to the evidence early on haven't been surprised that Willingham has done well (maybe even better) or that that Doumit has been a successful signing. However, there was a ton of concern about Marquis, Dozier being ready, and Jeff Gray. The only person who has defied the evidence has been Deduno.
-
Twins vs Rangers, 08-25-2012, 2:05pm
Strike that campaign. Jeff Gray has been charged with Crimes Against Humanity and is being sent to the Hague Court in the Netherlands to face trial. Does MLB allow players to be removed from the 40man for that or is it more like 15 day DL?
-
Twins vs Rangers, 08-25-2012, 2:05pm
Gray definitely solidified my vote for him as chairman of the #FreeAnthonySlama campaign. Chairman of said campaign gets a free trip to Rochester...
-
Was Morneau the Dodgers' first choice?
The Twins seem like a very static organization right now. With that in mind, my prediction is they keep Morneau and end up seeing him leave to FA after another disappointing season next year for the Twins. They may not spend on starting pitching but they should, otherwise we're just "Sitting Still for Sano."
-
Plouffe = Valencia part 2
Plouffe is playing hurt. This is what happens when players play hurt.
-
Extend high-upside "prospect" Morneau today?
Somehow I don't see the Sox getting rid of one contract like that for another, even if it's only a year, and then giving up prospects in addition. Boston got a great deal here, and my point was the Twins missed out, as reports say they were contacted again this week about Morneau by LA.
-
Extend high-upside "prospect" Morneau today?
I think it's all relative. The Twins are obviously capable of producing runs, and they have a 1B waiting in the wings. What they don't have (at all) is pitching. So it's not that Morneau isn't worth signing at 3 for 7; it's just that he isn't worth signing at 3 for 7 for the Twins. His is not a position of need. Other teams might jump at that deal. That's fair I guess, and based on reports the last few hours we may have missed a one-time chance with the Dodgers. I'd be very curious to know what they were offering, but really, even if it was just taking his contract it should have been worth considering.
-
Extend high-upside "prospect" Morneau today?
Morneau is one of my favorite Twins and it saddens me to see how things have gone for him (, and this goes double so for what I'm about to say (though great to see him on the mend). There's something that's just illogical about some points in the is discussion. If he is not worth extending for something (say 3 years $7M) then how can he be worth a starting pitching prospect? What we do know is that he is not worth $15M do The irony here, and maybe the missed point, is that I actually believe the way Parmelee is playing and their comparable salaries, you're likely to get more for him than Morneau. In my opinion, if you can trade Morneau for a SP prospect and shed $15M, you do it; but I really don't see the Twins getting an offer like that. It's a no-brainer. I'd say the exact same thing is true of Parmelee. However, I don't think he's worth that either and thus no way a player making $15M can be either with the track record of injuries Morneau has and the fact that while he's hitting great, he's really not worth $15 at 1B.
-
Christensen: Mauer Needs To Swing
I think this topic, and thus the original article, is preposterous. I really like Joe C., but this was one of his more disappointing articles. Mauer, first and foremost, doesn't make outs, and he's one of the best in the league at that. That's because of his approach at the plate and that approach at the plate is why he has a high average; he swings at pitches that he knows he can either hit well or are strike 3. You can't separate those two things. Those of you that say he should have swung because he has a high average with RISP are missing. He changes this approach and he's less likely to get a hit. Now focusing on the at-bat, assuming we agree that he had one pitch to hit, we really don't know what he was looking for. I'd personally give Mauer the benefit of the doubt due to his success and assume that it wasn't the pitch he was looking for.
-
Dozier to Rochester, Florimon up
Either gotta be about confidence as Dozier said or a message that even though there's no one pushing him, he can't coast. He doesn't strike me as someone who would thinheir benefit from the latter, even though I don't think he's really shown anywhere that he'll be a true everyday player in the bigs.
-
Mackey: Blaming Payroll for Twins shortcomings is a lazy excuse
I mostly agree with Mackey though I think, as some have pointed out, his argument uses extremes and focuses mostly on the negatives in FA and spending, and the Twins added several positive pieces that way, too. In the end it is all about baseball decisions. Right now, though, I think the payroll is the focus because there are three ways to add talent to a team: the draft, trades, and free agency. The first is over and help from any draft still appears to be a couple years off. The Twins didn't make any impactful trades In terms of adding youth and talent, though maybe they will in the offseason. Which leaves only really free agency, and the fear becomes that they will cut payroll again, with the fear that they could be worse.
-
Article: Morneau vs. The Void
Exactly, and I'd add willing to give something back in return, which may not happen. At this point, I don't see the reason to free up his salary as it doesn't sound like the Twins will use it, and selling off Morneau for cheap won't put people in th seats. I'd like to see three conditions for the Twins to pull the trigger in the offseason. 1) They have a plan to do something with the money. 2) Parmelee continues to hit. 3) Someone is desperate enough to give something in return. Otherwise, why not just wait until next year's trade deadline? It's a bit of a gamble but if he continues to hit and stays healthy his demand should be way up as he'd be a great addition for another team and $7m might be more palatable for a team looking at the playoffs.
-
Dozier now and beyond
Rookies struggle at the plate, certainly. Morneau was a 900+ OPS hitter in the minors, Revere was a .300+ hitter at all levels, so while their early struggles are expected, it definitely wasn't surprising that they figured it out this year. Plouffe was consistent throughout the minors until he was 25 where he started crushing the ball at AAA. I very much hope Dozier turns out like Plouffe. I just don't see the evidence for it, and while Dozier's struggles don't surprise me this year, I also won't be surprised if they continue. As for fielding, I don't have the numbers but I agree with you that errors don't tell the story. Dozier's errors in particular, though, seem to come on plays that he should make. His UZR is -2.7, though, 18th in the majors, so it's not like he's making up for his bat with his glove. I agree he's likely the Twins starter simply by default for the next couple of years but I think in general people are a bit too optimistic about him.
-
Dozier now and beyond
I don't disagree totally, but you'd think that if he'd have hit at AAA.
-
Prediction on Parmelee recall
It will be interesting to see if there's any demand for Morneau at all even if he keeps hitting like he is. His contract is so big and teams are still going to have question marks about him that I think the market will be limited. Mackey tweeted that they should move him for a pitcher this offseason, which I think is pretty funny. I don't see anyone taking his $14M contract, health questions, and giving something up decent return as well. I like Morneau but the gain for the Twins in moving him would be saving money. Which, to my mind means that Parmelee isn't going to have a chance to get a decent number of ABs barring an injury.
-
Dozier now and beyond
That's sort of my point. Our hopes rest on him and so do the Twins, but I think that middle infield may be a high position of need among several but maybe only second to starting pitching.
-
Dozier now and beyond
Back to Dozier, I obviously hope he performs very well and it would mean good things for the Twins if he did, but I look at the evidence a little differently than those that think he can be more than a utility player, sadly, that would mean a lot of trouble for th Twins. Dozier's success has not been sustained and has come when he is older than much of the competition, so I'm worried his success is a mirage. The first season he hit well was rookie ball with an OPS at .837. But, he was 22, pretty much the top end of the age spectrum there where most players are 18-20. If you're a 22 year-old in rookie ball who hopes to be in the majors, you'd probably better be crushing the ball. His second successful hitting season was at AA as a 24 year-old, but even that season was split with 40 games at high A-ball. His numbers were similar between both, so that was good to see. While 24 is more in the middle for AA ball, IMO, a player that has potential to be a major league starter should be further along. For example, look at Twins prospects Hicks and Arcia. Both are younger than Dozier and are handling AA pitching just fine. So I'd like to see evidence of sustained success at a level commiserate with his age and development. For me, at least AAA seems like the right level for him to be showing His brief stint there wasn't impressive and he's very clearly overmatched in the pros. Do those of you that think he's going to be a legit starter/full time player have evidence for comparison that show this? For example, Bartlett was mentioned, but he hit consistently from 2003-2006 in minors, and from 2005 posted far more acceptable OBP In the pros form 2005 on (25 years old). He's a great comparison from a developmental and age perspective but was much more consistent in the minors.
-
Twins vs Red Sox, 08-04-2012, 6:10pm
Better get it done with the first five tonight...though I like Caroll for a big hit.
-
One thing we tend to overlook about Span
The book by Tom Tango. It's derived from actual numbers.
-
Twins vs. Rangers, 07/08/2012, 6:05pm
Two solid hits, and two hits off pretty good pitches. That happens, but he shouldn't have had to get 4 outs, and the fact that Dozier's error was a two base error wasn't insignificant either.
-
Twins vs. Rangers, 07/08/2012, 6:05pm
Inning would be over if it weren't for Dozier.
-
The Twins and Their Supposed "Outfield Depth"
It certainly does, though Buxton is much further away than the first two, and those first two aren't projecting to be major league starters right now.