Everything posted by one_eyed_jack
-
Article: A Hall Without Jack Morris Is No Hall at All
I always enjoy following the debates on controversial candidates - I hear different perspectives, and I learn. I do not view Morris as a Hall-of-Famer. I see him as a good pitcher who had some great, even historic, moments. But my view of a Hall-of-Famer is a guy who showed consistent excellence over a long period of time. I'm a lot more moved by 10 great seasons over the course of a decade than 10 great innings on one October day. It seems to me that the case for Morris is based on the "feel" test - the BBHOF version of Potter Stewart's "I can't define it but I know it when I see it" test for obscenity. (I do not consider the silly "pitch to the score" rebuttals to his chubby ERA worthy of consideration.) He was a guy who was thought of as an ace and a big-game pitcher for a long time. So people think he belongs. A lot of voters use the "feel" test. For example, Dan Shaugnessy with his decision not to vote for Biggio (though he made a feeble attempt to justify it with stats by saying that Biggio only had one 200-hit season, so he wasn't a dominant 2B like Roberto Alomar, ignoring the fact that Alomar never had a 200-hit season.) I get where people are going with that. Some guys just have that superstar aura about them. But the problem with taking that into account in HOF voting is that often times that's a product of things like their personality or media hype that have little to do with how good they actually are. I guess I wouldn't totally object to that being considered a little bit, maybe to push a borderline candidate in. But that kind of stuff is the icing on the cake, not the cake itself.
-
2014 HoF ballot
---Agreed. There's a lot to dislike about the current voting process. (Reading some of these dunderheads' explanations of their ballots, yikes.) But Lebtard's Deadspin stunt was a lot like Chris Kluwe's last week - a childish, self-indulgent, attention-seeking tantrum masquerading as a fight against injustice.
-
2014 HoF ballot
Feel bad for Biggio. 2 votes short, and several voters have said they felt he's worthy but didn't vote for him because of the max 10. (Jon Becker tweeted that he took Biggio off at the last minute in favor of Larry Walker - are you kidding me?). That shows you the process is broken. Last year he didn't get in because of the phony "first ballot hall of famer" standard. This year he got screwed because of the voting limit. So that's two years in a row where he's kept out because there are voters are not voting for him even though they think he deserves to be in.
-
2014 HoF ballot
Love HOF debates, hate HOF voting. Here are the things that drive me nuts about the current voting body. Overvaluing postseason play and undervaluing longevity Every year I hear the baseball punditry hype the HOF candidacy of certain players for what they did in the postseason, then turn around and dismiss other guys as “compilers”. It makes no sense to me at all. It takes a truly special player to maintain a high level of play over the tough grind of a 162-game schedule year in and year out for more than a decade. But any decent major leaguer who happens to play on a good team can get hot for a couple of weeks in October. Look at your all-time leaders in any major stat. See many mediocre players near the top of the list? Now look at the list of guys who have won WS or LCS MVP award. Should we put Scott Brosius in the Hall? The “first ballot Hall of Famer” thing Either you think a guy is worthy of admission or you don’t. If you do, vote for him. If not, then don’t. But “I think he deserves to be in, but he should have to wait at least another year” is illogical and obnoxious. Hall of Fame voting is a difficult task that has devolved into a giant, sloppy mess thanks to things like this. If the voters believe in a tiered system where some guys receive higher honors than other, then that should be made official, and the voters should be allowed to vote on different levels of Hall of Famers. The “if you have to think about it, he’s not a Hall of Famer” argument Translation: I’m too lazy to put any thought or effort into this supposedly sacred process. This position is absurd on its face. Basically, if you believe this, you’re saying that there is no such thing as a borderline case. Reasonable minds can disagree about where the line should be drawn. But no matter if you draw it high or low, there will be guys who fall close to or on it. People who make silly votes shouldn't be voting I’m not even talking about token votes for fringe players, which is silly but relatively harmless. But if you’re one of those “I won’t vote for anyone who played in the 90’s” people, you shouldn’t be voting. You aren’t allowed to serve on a jury if you’ve already made up your mind that the defendant is guilty because it deprives him of the right to a fair and impartial trial. Same rationale applies here. It you’re not willing to give guys fair consideration, you should be decided their fate. Also, if you just make indefensible selections (e.g. voting for Larry Walker and Curt Schilling but not Greg Maddox or Frank Thomas), it should be the last ballot you cast.
-
2014 Celebrity Death Pool
I think it did end up going through to Musk, but I agree, more fun to see everyone's. You've got some outside-the-box picks there - I like it. Here's mine. Chuck Berry Jimmy Carter Ice Cube Sophia Loren Bill Cosby Ruth Bader Ginsberg Francis Ford Coppola Dennis Rodman Winona Ryder Dwight Gooden Shannen Doherty Gary Busey Steven Adler Jean Beliveau Elgin Baylor Gloria Steinem Jane Fonda Danny DeVito Tom Brokaw Henry Waxman Larry Holmes Leif Garrett Yoko Ono John Mcvie OJ Simpson
-
2014 Celebrity Death Pool
Musk - I tried PM'ing you my list, it told me you're inbox was full and you couldn't receive any more messages until you clear some space. Let me know if there's somewhere else I should send it, or if I can post it here.
-
Nuke the Vikings
Yeah that was pretty ridiculous. Like Leber said, because he was a Viking, people would inevitably associate him with the Vikings, and he needed to think about how he was presenting himself. Kluwe has 2 young daughters. One day they'll reaching dating age. I wonder how he'd feel about a guy coming over to his house to pick one of his girls up and talking like that at the first meeting with the parents. What sort of impression would that leave him with? (I can only imagine the look on my father's face had some guy come over to pick up my sister and started talking about "lustful cockmonsters" . Yikes.) And while I understand Kluwe taking shots at Preifer (who is a miserable human being if he really said that), and I don't understand him calling Frazier a coward. Even if you take everything Kluwe said as true, Frazier simply told him to tone it down, which is what any head coach would have done. Head coaches are there to win games, and they don't need to be putting out PR fires created by the punter. So Frazier was simply trying to avoid distractions that took the focus off of winning football games, which is what Frazier was being paid to do. But Kluwe, by his own admission, did not speak up about Preifer because he feared for his job. So like Frazier, he was motivated primarily by self-preservation. And if Frazier's self-preservation was cowardly, then so was Kluwe's. If anything, Kluwe's was more so because Frazier may not have known about the stuff Preifer was saying.
-
2014 HoF ballot
Jeter's career WAR is 71.6. Is he a "no" for you because he's under your 75-WAR cutoff?
-
Nuke the Vikings
---My views on this are very similar to yours. I think what bothers me most is the way he acts like he's doing something noble for civil rights and changing NFL culture, when really he's just doing something childish and vindictive to get revenge on a few specific individuals he feels wronged by. This isn't about a cause, this is about Kluwe. His whole "well, now that I've written this, I'll never get an NFL job" thing makes it sounds like he sacrificed his career for a cause he believes in, but that claim rings hollow because his NFL career was over anyway. In fact he waited until that was a certainty before coming forward with this. If he believed so strongly in GLBT rights, he should have spoken up, at least internally, when Preifer made the "nuke" comment. But he didn't. He was willing to continue working under Preifer as long as he was getting paid a fat salary for kicking a ball down a field. I mean could you really claim to be all about racial equality if the managers at your workplace used the N-word and made offensive racial jokes, and you remained silent until months after they fired you?
-
2013 Celebrity Death Pool
---5th place, not half-bad for a first timer.
-
Nuke the Vikings
Here’s my take on the Kluwe thing: I am completely in agreement with Kluwe’s stance on civil rights issues, but I am with Ben Leber in having a problem with the way he went about this If Preifer really said what Kluwe claims he said, he’s a disgusting excuse for a human being and had no place being a leader. My respect for Kluwe has diminished as a result of this. I applauded him for lending his voice in support of civil rights when the marriage amendment vote was still pending. But his actions are not about civil rights or helping achieve equality for the GLBT community or even changing NFL culture. This was about Kluwe being bitter, wanting attention and having an ax to grind against specific individuals. The “Chris Kluwe – Courageous Civil Rights Crusader” narrative is simply belied by his decision to stay silent in the face of comments like Preifer’s. I can understand him not going public, but by his own admission, he did not raise the issue with Frazier, Speilman or Prefier himself out of fear of losing his job. And, also by his own admission, he hoped to continue playing with the Vikings. So while he claims that Preifer is a bigot who has no business being a coach, he was more than willing to keep kicking the ball for him while accepting a salary far in excess of what many people will earn in a lifetime. He claims to feel so strongly about Preifer never coaching again, yet he himself was willing to remain silent and let Prefier keep coaching as long as he still got a paycheck. He had no good answer for when Leber pressed him on why he didn’t say something to Preifer. And Leber talked about how he spoke up to coaches when he felt there was something that needed to be addressed. So I think what we see from that is that Kluwe can talk big about his beliefs on Deadspin and Twitter, but lacks the testicular fortitude to confront someone face-to-face about them. Thus he is in no position to be labeling anyone else a coward. What we have here the one spouse’s version of why the marriage ended in the wake of an ugly divorce. I don’t think Kluwe is making any of this up, but his account is very self-serving, and I would not be surprised to learn he did and said some pretty prickish things that he conveniently left out of his Deadspin piece. I would think a lot more of this if Kluwe had at least tried to engage in some self-reflection or put himself in say, Frazier’s position. Frazier’s job was to win football games, not to enable his punter’s off the field activity choices. There are legitimate football/business reasons why Kluwe doesn’t have an NFL job. He was on the decline. There were younger, cheaper guys available. When teams can get a younger, healthier punter or kicker who is 90% as good as the incumbent veteran for less than half the cost, they do it. It happens all the time. Kluwe’s situation is hardly unique. His activism stuff may have pushed him, but he was on the edge anyway.
-
Nuke the Vikings
I wasn't crazy about the Frazier firing. He hasn't been great, some curious coaching decisions and dubious coordinator choices, but he certainly wasn't terrible. A few calls/plays/bounces go the Vikes way and they would have been in the playoffs. This despite terrible play at QB and the defensive secondary, which are the last two places you want to see terrible play. The guys continued to play hard for Leslie long after they had nothing to play for. Often times you see teams check out in that situation. I have no faith in Spielman. At all. He's too interested trying to prove that he's smarter than everyone else, and too often only ends up outsmarting himself. My prediction: Spielman will identify some obscure candidate that isn't on anyone's radar, convince himself that he sees something there that nobody else does, and hire him. (The Wilfs will like this because he will come cheap). It will be the biggest "WTF?!" moment in Minnesota sports since Kahn passed on Steph Curry to take Jonny Flynn. (Damn, even typing that still hurts.) Then smarmy Rick and his new hire, the assistant tight ends coach from Slippery Rock University or whoever the hell it is, will make a Ponder-esque reach pick of a QB in the first round. After another 2 disastrous seasons, the Wilfs will lose patience and blow the whole thing up. And we'll be right where we are today, minus 2 prime years of AP's career, plus one shiny new stadium.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Tigers, 5/24 - 6:08pm
---I think we mostly agree. Regardless of what happens off the field, the players have every obligation to put in their best effort on the field. And if that's not happening, something needs to be said. I guess what I'm concerned, or at least wondering about, is how much of that attitude flows down from the top? When an organization clearly isn't trying to win, aren't they sending a message that winning doesn't matter? It's a different situation, but as a guy who spends his winters following the T-Wolves, I became disgusted with the culture of losing that was allowed to fester in that organization for years. One failed rebuilding project after another, and they seemed to prefer getting more ping pong balls for the draft lottery to winning more games. There's a part of me that fears that the Twins are starting to head down a slippery slope to that, and we're on the cusp of another dark age like the mid-late 90's.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Tigers, 5/24 - 6:08pm
---I get what you're saying, and I don't necessarily disagree, but OTOH, there is no amount of screaming and throwing things that can turn bad players into good ones. I think those kind of tactics can produce results when you have a good team that's performing poorly. But the Twins are not a good team, and tantrums are no substitute for talent. I think the the "enough is enough" statement needed to come from the front office in the offseason. They needed to make bold moves to send a message that what happened the last 2 years was not acceptable, and that they are committed to making sure it doesn't continue. But they didn't. They brought 4th-tier free agents and penciled in unproven players in starting roles, crossing their fingers that it would all work out. It hasn't.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Tigers, 5/23 - 6:10pm
I need to stop watching this team, I'm running out of things to throw at my TV.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Braves, 5/21 - 6:10pm
So when the hell does this losing streak end? Can Vanimal get it done tomorrow? 4 in Detroit after that. No Verlander, but KC/Fister and Pelfrey/Scherzer are not matchups I'm looking forward to watching.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Braves, 5/21 - 6:10pm
The more losses like this I see, the more I'm convinced that Puckett, Hrbek, TK and company really did make a deal with the Devil back in the day: two World Series crowns for a lifetime of Minnesota sports suffering.
-
Article: Series Preview: Twins @ Braves, 5/20
---It's not bad enough that the Twins have lost 6 in a row and look poised for another season in the crapper? You had to bring that up as well? What's it gonna be when we make it 7 in a row tomorrow - Jonny Flynn over Steph Curry?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs White Sox, 7:10pm
Bloop and a blast, let's go. Dickbert mentioned this was Crain's third year with Chicago. Seems like he's been gone much longer than that. Guess its the interminable nature of the last 2 seasons.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs White Sox, 7:10pm
KC in the 8th is indefensible. I know Morneau isn't the hitter he once was, but he has done a really nice job in the field this year.
-
Justin Morneau staying or leaving?
I don't think it's an easy call with Morneau. He hasn't returned to peak form, but he's been better than he generally was in 2011 and 2012. The range of possibilities with him is huge - one bonk on the noggin could end his career, or he could find his old self and end up in the MVP conversation. Do you move him for whatever you can and go with Parm at first? Or do you keep him, hoping he'll give you a few more good year? I dunno. I'd actually lean towards keeping him unless someone makes an offer too good to refuse. The free agent market may not be as strong for him. It's a pretty good free agent class, and you have to wonder whether the expensive train wrecks in Toronto and Anaheim will give some folks pause about throwing money around. That said, all it takes is one dodo to overpay a guy. We shall see. My gut says he's gone at the deadline.
-
Article: Series Preview: Twins vs Orioles, 5/10
yeah over 162 games you're gonna have some. Every team does. But this will be the fourth game in the last 2 weeks we've gotten out to a lead and peed it away in the later innings. That's too many. If we could have held a couple of those we'd be 18-14 instead of 16-16. Not to mention what it does to my blood pressure.
-
Article: Series Preview: Twins vs Orioles, 5/10
Excruciating.
-
Best wishes to the Blackburns this Mother's Day
I didn't mean to mislead with the note there, sorry about that. It's tough stuff they're going through, it doesn't get any more stressful than that. Before reading this, I always thought of Nick Blackburn in connection with a Bobby Abreu line drive to the noggin, a gutty game 163 performance in Chicago, a dubious contract decision by the Twins, and some monumentally bad starts the past couple of years. But that's all insignificant compared to this. It sounds like this are headed in the right direction there, but they're not out of the woods yet.
-
Best wishes to the Blackburns this Mother's Day
Nick and Alicia Blackburn couldn't help but note the irony when they found out they were going to have twins | twinsbaseball.com: News Regardless of what happens with Nick's career with the Minnesota Twins, I hope all works out for their own twins.