Everything posted by one_eyed_jack
-
NBC columnist skewers Souhan
Souhan's piece was pretty embarrassing. I understand that he's a columnist, not a reporter, but he can't come up with better takes than this? When the guy making $23 million a year begs out of the lineup because of a bruise, it’s difficult for the manager to push others to play through pain. This is the stuff of ranting ignoramuses in the Strib comments section, not a paid professional. Mauer had a bad season, but does Souhan sincerely believe that he begged out of the lineup because of a bruise? Also, this is the complete opposite of what he wrote in May, when he talked about Mauer experiencing "sharp, searing, debilitating pain"
-
Twins Make Molitor Hiring Official
I'm still trying to understand this "extended honeymoon" thing. Is your concern that by giving Molitor a 3-year deal, the FO is signaling that they are willing to tolerate 2 more years of losing?
-
Article: Twins to Name Paul Molitor Manager
I'm not sure we know enough about how that whole thing went down to say that Maddon himself acted unethically. I guess all is fair in love and war, and the Cubs felt that they had the chance to replace a good general with a great general, but it doesn't feel right to me somehow. I'll tell you this, Epstein better be right about this, because if he isn't, and the Cubbies flounder under Maddon, it could come back to bite him.
- Article: Twins to Name Paul Molitor Manager
-
Renteria is now available...
He'd be a decent candidate, but he doesn't excite me any more than either Molitor or Lovullo, so I'm not going to get worked up over it if the Twins don't rush to bring him in. And I don't see why his heritage is relevant. Is there a track record of players from Venezuela and DR performing better under managers of Mexican descent? Bruce Bochy was born in France and grew up in the US. He's had a fair few guys from Latin America on his roster (Sandoval, Pagan, Perez, Blanco, etc.) and I'd say the results haven't been too shabby. Just find a guy that's good at the job.
-
Berardino: "No contact" between Twins & Maddon
Look I'd love it if the Twins hired Maddon, but I'm not going to get worked up over it if they don't as long as they hire someone competent. I'm just not convinced that managers necessarily make a huge difference in terms of wins and losses. There are situations where they do, but it's more often for the worse, for example where you have a good team that quits on a manager they don't like, then goes back to playing hard for his replacement. But I don't think this is one of them. But hey, maybe I'm wrong, I'm open to being convinced otherwise, so I'm curious as to thoughts on this: How many wins would hiring Maddon be good for? What would you expect the difference in record to be between the 2015 Twins managed by Maddon as compared to the 2015 Twins managed by Molitor? If we'd had Maddon the last 4 years, would our record have been dramatically better?
-
Berardino: "No contact" between Twins & Maddon
Read my post again. I said the managerial change was needed. I didn't say don't fix the hole in the roof. Yes, fix it. But let's not pretend that fixing the hole in the roof will magically cause all of the other problems to go away.
-
Berardino: "No contact" between Twins & Maddon
I understand why a lot folks want Maddon, but the teeth-gnashing over the Twins not pulling a Brinks truck into his driveway the instant he hit the market is getting a bit silly. I'm glad the Twins decided to make a managerial change, but I also don't think that alone is going to have that much of an impact. Good managing cannot compensate for bad pitching. If your pitching stinks, your record is going to stink. And the Twins pitching has stunk. Bad. An average of 800 runs surrendered in the last 4 seasons. Sure Maddon could, and probably would, do some things differently to help that a bit, but it's not like hiring him would transform all of our starters into David Price.
-
Berardino: "No contact" between Twins & Maddon
LEN says the Twins did reach out to Maddon. http://www.startribune.com/sports/twins/280875292.html
-
Bumgarner
Bumgarner, wow. Kudos to the Royals. I thought the magic would wear off, and this would be a one-sided series in SF's favor. But KC was right there. Postseason baseball is awesome, hope the Twins can be part of it again soon.
-
Maddon vs. Gardy: How much of an improvement would Maddon be?
Fair enough. The blown leads probably stick out in my mind more, but it would have been more accurate to say tied or leading. My point was that there were close games that could have gone either way. In any case, I need to be done with this topic - too many painful memories. I think I'd rather re-hash the last 4 years of incompetence and irrelevance than dissect the Gardy-era playoff losses. I'd guess about 98% of the F-bombs I've dropped in my life were during those 21 playoff losses.
-
Maddon vs. Gardy: How much of an improvement would Maddon be?
Not sure I buy into the "playing soft" thing either. Who played soft? There were quite a few games where we had late leads, only to have our normally reliable bullpen (including our all-star closer) cough them up. Was Nathan playing soft? And on not using talent disparity as an excuse, I get where you are coming from, but I think it depends on what year you are talking about. Take 2009. I understand not liking the whole "little engine" thing, but I also think it's a little silly to throw out starters like Duensing and Blackburn against guys like Sabathia and Pettite, counter an infield of A-Rod, Jeter, Cano and Teixera with Tolbert, Cabrera, Punto and Cuddyer and expect to win because "upsets happen". 2010 was a different story. It was a deeper, more experienced Twins team. The Yankees were starting to look older and weaker. We had home field advantage in the new ballpark. We clinched early and were able to set up our rotation. It felt like it was our time to finally break through. That was a winnable series.
-
Article: Joe Maddon is Out in Tampa. Could Twins Get Him?
I'd be surprised if Maddon ended up here, but I wouldn't rule it out. A lot of folks said Rick Adelman, who I think you can look at as sort of the NBA version of Maddon, would never take the T-Wolves job. The T-Wolves were coming off a string of horrific seasons, and there were other jobs in bigger markets available. But Rick came here. (Of course his tenure was pretty disappointing....) And yeah, Maddon would cost more than other managers, but he'd also generate buzz and interest that other candidates wouldn't.
-
Who to Root for in the Playoffs
I watch, but I don't really have a favorite. The postseason is fun because of the dramatics. You never know how things are going to turn out. (Unlike, say, the NBA playoffs, which can be exciting, but the results are pretty predictable). The Tigers and Angels both getting swept? Hard to see that coming.
-
Derek Jeter--Unanimous HOF?
Here's a question related to Jeter's HOF candidacy: There were a few voters who refused to vote for Craig Biggio due to steroid suspicions. There's never been any solid proof that he used PED's, but their argument was basically, "He played with on a team with guys we know used, so we know it was going on around him, and we can't be sure he didn't use, so we're not going to vote for him." Doesn't that same reasoning apply to Jeter? Will any of these voters withhold their vote for him on that basis? To be clear, I'm not saying they should, I think it's a silly argument. I'm just curious as to whether any of them will actually do it.
-
Article: Reflecting on the Ron Gardenhire Era
That particular game in '04 doesn't stand out in my memory as a mismanaged one. But the various postseason disappointments kinda blend together for me at times, I just remember throwing things and swearing a lot. But seriously, if we're talking about dubious Gardenhire post season moves, the one that stands out to me is Game 1 of the 2010 ALDS - he left Frankie in one batter too long, and Granderson made him pay with a 2-run triple that turned a 3-2 lead into a 4-3 deficit. Frankie cruised for much of the night, but the Yanks started to hit him, and you could tell Liriano was a bit rattled. I would have brought in Fuentes to face the Grandyman there.
-
Article: Who Will Be The Next Twins Manager?
I'd prefer to see someone from outside the organization. A new voice with new ideas and new perspectives would be a welcome change. As for who that is, I'm open to ideas. I'll throw out a name again that I threw out a while back in a discussion of potential Gardy replacements: Ken Oberkfell. I happened to catch this article on him. http://m.mlb.com/news/article/26582426/ He's not a young guy, but it seems like he's got some ability to work with young players, and is open to blending new school and old school ways of baseball thinking. I dunno, just a thought. I've seen Jose Oqueno's name tossed around, that's an interesting thought. No interest in Guillen. I think his act wears thin very quickly. I don't insist on another decade+ run for the next guy, but I also don't want to have to be facing this decision again in a year or two.
-
Article: Ron Gardenhire Out As Twins Manager
Had to happen, probably overdue. But I tip my cap to Gardy who is a good manager and a good guy. A good Gardy memory that will always stick out to me is the 2009 season. The Twins were sitting at .500, 7 games behind Detroit on September 6th. Morneau was done for the year. They were pretty much written off. But they went on to win 18 of the next 26, getting unexpected contributions from scrubs and September call-ups, to set up the epic game 163 in the Dome's final season. It was one hell of a fun month of baseball. And I'm not sure just any manager could have done it. So thanks for the memories and best wishes, Mr. Gardenhire.
-
Most over-rated player in the last 30 years to retire after 2014 season
1) Ripken? Fernandez? Come on, these guys were on the downsides of their careers when Jeter started. 2) Horrendous may be overstating it, but yeah, he probably did get more Gold Gloves than he deserved 3) I'm sure he was helped with that to some degree, but plenty of other guys have hit in front of great hitters and not produced the way Jeter did. 4) When a guy is doing things like getting over 200 hits and finishing in the top 10 in MVP voting, I think it's really difficult to dismiss him as a compiler. 5) Yes, I agree we wouldn't hear about Jeter ad nauseum if he played in flyover country. However the guys you mentioned were pretty damn good players, much better players than you're making Jeter out to be in your other points. 6) I don't think anyone posting here knows nearly enough to fairly or adequately judge how good or bad a teammate Jeter is or has been in his career. 7) Agree on this. Winning a World Series is a team accomplishment, not an individual one. I think the whole rings argument is way overdone, even with quarterbacks in the NFL who have a unique ability to impact a game.
-
Most over-rated player in the last 30 years to retire after 2014 season
---He's never been linked to steroids by any credible evidence, but certain individual voters have refused to vote for him because they suspect him of using. (Murray Chass and Rick Morrissey are a couple of examples.) Their arguments are more guilt-by-association - i.e. Biggio played with known roiders like Camminitti, so they can't be sure he didn't use. So I will be interested to see what these guys do with Jeter. Because if they apply the same logic to Jeter's candidacy that they did to Biggio's, then they won't be voting for Jeter due to steroid suspicion.
-
Most over-rated player in the last 30 years to retire after 2014 season
A couple of things: 1) I was not trying to start a debate on the relative merits of Jeter and Biggio. I was merely wondering whether the voters responsible for denying Biggio HOF entry due to PED suspicions based on the guilt-by-association rationale would treat Jeter the same way. Just like Biggio, Jeter played with multiple guys who either admitted using or tested positive for PED's. To me, if they're going to be consistent, they should refuse to vote for Jeter as well, but I suspect they won't be. 2) IMO, there is a difference between 'overrated' and 'overexposed'. Overrated = Guys who are not that great, but talked about as though they are great Overexposed = Guys who are truly great, but whose greatness is discussed ad nauseum Yes, we hear about Jeter's greatness far more often than necessary, far more than we would have had he had the same career in a smaller market. But to me, that doesn't diminish his greatness.
-
Most over-rated player in the last 30 years to retire after 2014 season
I just can't buy into Jeter being overrated. Overexposed? There's an argument for that. It happens with all great Yankees. I may get tired of hearing about it, but I'm not going to deny his greatness. Now here's what will be interesting to me: a non-trivial minority of hall of fame voters refused to vote for Craig Biggio due to PED suspicions. Their argument was one of guilt by association - Biggio had teammates who were known users, so he may have been using too. But isn't that just as true of Derek Jeter, especially as we learn more about A-Rod? Will these same voters leave Jeter off their ballots?
-
2014 HoF ballot
---Well, while missing the HOF by 2 votes it not like being diagnosed with terminal cancer, I don't think it's that hard to see why some folks feel he got the shaft and feel a bit bad for him. To me his HOF case involves a lot of what's wrong with HOF voting - worthy players being kept out for no good reason. A bunch of people didn't vote for him last year because of the "first-ballot HOFer" thing, which is silly and illogical. It's little more than blind deference to tradition, or egotistical voters who want to make it about them and not the players. Then he lost votes this year because of the arbitrary 10-vote limit. And some won't vote for him over steroid suspicions, which are based solely on vague gossip and innuendo. Basically, it boils down the idea that he had teammates that were using PED's, so he might have been too. It will be interesting to see what these folks do when Jeter is eligible because by that logic, he shouldn't be in either.
-
Rand: 2014 HOF Results
The prediction is probably sound. Although I think Biggio might not get to 80%, I think he could make it by a hair. I think there were 5 or 6 voters who admitted to voting for him last year but not this year because he was their #11 guy. He should at get least a few of those, maybe even all of them, which would put him over the hump. But he may not get any more than that.
-
2014 HoF ballot
I like to think I'm pretty tolerant of different opinions and consider the zone of reasonable disagreement to be enormous. But reading through some of these ballot explanations, Good Lord. If you're either unable or unwilling to submit a ballot that can by supported by at least a small measure of facts, logic and common sense, you shouldn't be voting. A couple of highlights, or lowlights as it were: This buffoon, who said "I refuse to vote for a guy who cheats, as Biggio did with all that armor on his arm, so he could get hit with pitches and trot to first base as a result", but also voted for McGwire, Bonds and Clemens because they "had the numbers long before they juiced". Putting aside how completely illogical that is, consider that McGwire admitted to first taking steroids before the 1990 season. So basically he's saying that McGwire's numbers from his first 3 years in the majors were HOF-worthy. Then we have Mark Purdy, who looks at each year's ballot as a "separate election" and votes for the 3 or 4 best. So Biggio got his vote last year, but not this year. Is there anyone on earth besides Mark Purdy who thinks this make sense on any level? Look at the ridiculous results this produces. Question: Is Craig Biggio a Hall-of-Famer? Answers: 74.8% - yes 25.1% - no Mark Purdy - Umm, I dunno, maybe, it depends on who else is on the ballot And then there's Larry Rocca. His ballot: Trammell, Nomo, Raines and Morris. Looks like something that was the product of eenie-meenie-minie-moe. At least the Deadspin ballot was defensible. Ken Rosenthal was dead on when he said that there were "too many crappy ballots" submitted.