Everything posted by one_eyed_jack
- Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
I think we're talking about 2 different things here. You're talking about what should be considered "OK" in a general sense. But I'm talking about it in a more disciplinary context. Being found guilty of sexual harassment can get you fired from your job or kicked out of school. So in that context, it's important to have a clear definition of what constitutes "sexual harassment", it's not enough to do what you and the article you cited are doing and say it's just something where everyone should instinctively understand where the line is and not cross it. They gray areas I'm referring to are those where we would probably say that a guy was clumsy or misguided in making an advance and should have proceeded differently, or not at all. But his behavior was not so bad as to require official consequences. For example an issue of mixed signals where a guy mistakes a woman's friendliness for romantic interest and makes an advance that is rejected. (Your repeated claims these matters are 'easy' and 'simple' notwithstanding, this is something that happens with some regularity.) Maybe it's fair to say that he was dense and should have read the situation better, but should he lose his job or his scholarship over it? Unless he persisted after rejection, that seems draconian to me. But it would fit your definition, so he would. A few other things: 1) Consent cannot be obtained unless requested. My point was that under your broad definition, any request for consent that is rejected would qualify as sexual harassment. You seem to be saying that you shouldn't even ask unless you know the answer is going to be 'yes', but that just isn't realistic. You can't really know until you ask, hence the requirement that you ask. 2) Women are individuals. They do not all act and think the same way. So the broad, sweeping generalizations about what women know and do are not particularly helpful. 3) You keep bringing up interactions with "strangers". That doesn't seem relevant to me because sexual harassment is largely a workplace issue, and co-workers, generally speaking, are not strangers. There are different norms and expectations for when you're interacting with someone you've never seen in your life vs. someone you know. Making an off-color joke to a friend is quite different from making one to someone you've just met.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
We can all recognize the difference between obviously innocuous conduct (walking up to a woman and saying hello) and obviously disgusting conduct (walking up to a woman and asking her to disrobe). But it's always easy to see the extremes, it's the spectrum between the two that's problematic. My comment, again, was on your definition, which I don't believe even attempts to distinguish harassment from flirting. You can claim that anyone should be able to see the difference, but definitions are important. They get written into policies and laws, and are the basis for adjudication of complaints. Suppose a college had a sexual harassment policy that incorporated your definition, which has 3 elements: 1) verbal or physical behavior, that is 2) uninvited and unwelcome, and is 3) of a sexual nature Prior to any consensual sexual encounter, there has to be an expression of sexual interest of some form, yes? Under this definition, any such expression where the interest is not shared by the recipient would qualify as sexual harassment because all 3 requirements are satisfied. You can try to wave that away by saying nobody would ever bring a frivolous complaint, but the approach of creating an overly broad definition of something, then just trusting that it will be reasonably applied and not abused has been tried many times in many contexts before. It never works.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
A couple of things here: 1) You're using a dictionary definition. Dictionaries are not law, we don't dole out punishments based on what it says in dictionaries. 2) If that's really the definition that people are going to use, then it's unsurprising that there would be confusion about what sexual harassment is because it's so broad that, read literally, it could encompass virtually any flirtation or advance that is not met with reciprocal interest.
-
Most disappointing playoff losses by team
I'll say this much about the Vikings: you've gotta give them style points. The Wolves are finally emerging from a dozen-plus years of bumbling incompetence and dysfunction of Cleveland Browns proportions. The Wild and the Twins may compete, but never really contend, and are predictably bounced from the playoffs by hated but superior Blackhawks and Yankees teams. The Vikings, OTOH, are always coming up with new, interesting and creative ways to torture their fans. Taking yourself out of range for a game-winning FG attempt with Too Many Men on the Field penalty in the NFC championship game? Now THAT is original. I'm dreading what they'll do this month to rip our hearts out yet again, but I'm sure it will be something more ridiculous than we could even try to imagine sitting here today. Here's hoping they prove me wrong, but we've been conditioned to expect the worst. Ah well, Go Lynx!
-
Warne: Deeper dive into Sano allegations
While I think Betsy's story and the 'me too' movement have brought to light some serious issues that need to be addressed, I'm troubled by the impulse to jump straight from accusation to conviction and sentencing. It's an understandable reaction, but a dangerous one. Social media mobs don't exactly have a great track record of success in solving problems.
-
Sano Denies - "It didn't Happen",
Awareness helps, but calling attention to a problem and solving it are 2 different things. I'm concerned that the 'me too' movement is starting to run into some of the same issues that have made Black Lives Matter less effective than it could have been at prompting real change. Even though it's shining a light of serious but long-ignored abuses of power that have harmed a lot of people, it has no clearly defined leadership or objectives. It's just a hashtag that people start attaching to so many different issues that its meaning becomes diluted.
- Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
- Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
- Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
-
Miguel Sano accused of assault by photographer
When you choose to go to Twitter with something like that, you have to accept that you don't have control over the outcome, and your motives for coming forward aren't really relevant. The Twitterverse will do with it what it wants, it does not ask why and it is unconcerned with what you want out of it. I'm sorry if this sounds insensitive, I don't mean it as a criticism of Betsy,, and I take no position on whether this was a good or bad way for her to share her story. I'm just pointing out the realities of going directly to social media.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
I made a longer post about this in the other thread, but one point worth repeating is that there is no consensus on the percentage of accusations that are false and the 6% figure is disputed. In any case, while it's safe to say that the majority of accusations are not false, false accusations happen enough that it is both dangerous and foolish to dismiss the possibility off the bar due to its alleged rarity. I don't believe this is a false accusation, but I object to cavalierly waving away concerns about false accusations based on their alleged rarity. Even if you take the 6% figure as true, that means out of every 100,000 allegations, 6,000 are false. That's 6,000 innocent men that are unjustly punished or branded as sexual predators. Are you comfortable with that, if it means the other 94,000 face consequences? What if you, your father or your brother were among those 6,000?
-
Miguel Sano accused of assault by photographer
A few points about false accusations. First, there is no real consensus about how often they occur, but even if you take the oft-quoted 5-6% figure, that’s too common for me to consider it “incredibly” or “extremely” rare as I’ve seen it characterized in some places. Asian-Americans constitute 4.8% of the US population – would you say that Asian-Americans are “incredibly rare”? I don’t believe this is a false accusation, but I object to the approach of cavalierly waving away the possibility off the bat in this case or any other because of how rare it supposedly is. Second, these cases tend to be much more nuanced than the simplicities they are often reduced to due to Twitter’s character limit. There is a world of possibilities between “Everything the victim says is true and accurate” and “She made the whole thing up for money, fame and attention.” The fact that an accuser isn’t lying doesn’t mean that everything she says is true and accurate. It may genuinely reflect her perception of what happened, but that doesn’t mean it’s correct. Some details may be intentionally or unintentionally exaggerated or omitted. Third, while “believe the victim” is an understandable and well-intentioned approach, I think it’s dangerous. It should be more along the lines of “take the accuser seriously”. While it’s true that message boards and Twitter are not courts of law, and the accused does not get the presumption of innocence or any other rights in the court of public opinion, it would be naïve to think that social media mobs have no real impact. Private companies certainly take public perception into account when deciding on the fates of their accused employees. And when these cases go to trial, the guilt of the defendant is decided by a jury of the same regular folks who join the online mobs. If you buy into the “believe the victim” mantra, why should you as a juror even bother listening to the evidence presented at trial? Fourth, while I don’t see evidence that it’s much of a factor in this case, the race factor cannot be ignored in general. Miguel Sano’s stature and resources make this an atypical case. But do you think your average black man accused of sexually assaulting a white woman can get a fair trial in this country? And if not, what impact do you think drilling “believe the victim” into everyone’s heads does to that problem? When To Kill a Mockingbird is assigned in schools today, do they teach kids that Atticus Finch is the bad guy because he questioned a rape accuser? Here’s an article about a case where a bunch of these issues collide. Very different circumstances than Sano's case, but an interesting read that well illustrates the difficulties there can be in resolving these cases.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
Fair enough. Nick going in is certainly a lot different than Betsy going in, but I still don't think we can assume that the police would have done nothing. It depends on what Nick would have told them. If he gave them enough detail to investigate further, it's possible they would have done so. I used to work for the Hennepin County court system, I saw domestic assault cases prosecuted where the victim was uncooperative with law enforcement. Not many, but it happens. To be clear, I'm not saying that Nick or others Besty confided in should have gone to the police (I wouldn't have in Nick's shoes either), or that the police definitely would have taken it further (probably not, possible.) My only point is that the speculation doesn't help.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
I understand that knowing the accuser must make this situation somewhat emotional for you, but this is irresponsible speculation. What makes you so certain that you know how law enforcement would have reacted if she had gone to them immediately? You realize that the police investigated the allegations against Kirby Puckett and it led to criminal charges filed by Hennepin County, right?
-
Article: AL Wild Card Game Thread: Twins @ Yankees, 10/3@7:09pm CT
I'm mostly lurk and rarely post these days, but it was a fun season, and I wanted to thank all involved for making it more fun - I enjoy the content and the conversation. The ending was tough, more so because it was in the Bronx. I hate the Yankees with the white hot passion of a thousand burning suns. If this had happened in Boston or Houston, I wouldn't be nearly as ticked off as I am right now. But the future is bright. This team can score runs. The rotation and bullpen need help. Here's hoping that the postseason losing streak ends 1 year from right now.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
Look I don't truly know whether Mauer is tough or not. I've never claimed to. I was just trying to refute the line of thinking that because Souhan, a bunch of fans, and possibly one former teammate with a penchant for saying ludicrous things think he is, there must be something to it. I have no inside access to what goes on behind the scenes. But I can see what happens on the field and draw some conclusions from that. For example I think what Mauer was able to accomplish from '08-10 tends to refute Hunter's 2007 comment. I don't see how you excel as an MLB catcher to that degree while lacking toughness. To me, it's also not particularly suggestive of a guy who "begs" out of the lineup because of a bruise.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
Information? You've cited other people's opinions and perceptions. That's not information. The fact that a viewpoint is shared by a couple of local writers who like to stir up the hornet's nest, a bunch of ranting keyboard warriors in the Strib comments section, and one former teammate whose mouth moves faster than his brain does not give it legitimacy.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
Sore hip won't stop Mauer from catching Mauer playing through all kinds of pain Examples in addition to the one I posted earlier in the thread.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
Well, that assumes that Mauer could have played at 80%. But we don't know that and frankly, neither does Hunter. I noticed Hunter also went with the Favre tough guy schtick there: "Me, I grew up in a different time. I'm ready to play no matter what -- broken toe, hamstring, groin, back -- and that's the mentality I've grown to have." I'm with twinsnorth, this is macho silliness. Instead of making it the analysis of risk vs. reward that it should be, it gets made into this thing about manhood where you play "no matter what'. (And Torii has missed time due to injury in his career, so clearly he does not play "no matter what".) But getting back to the Souhan's original comment: I would believe that Mauer has been held out of the lineup on days he could have played. But Souhan said Mauer begged out of the lineup because of a bruise. That I do not find believable at all.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
Others players have defended him before. Perkins here for example. But Souhan didn't ask any other players for comment here, and they're not going to pro-actively address something like this. I don't know what Hunter said, but much as I loved watching him as a player, his memory is questionable. And while the local scribes may be closer to the team and have more access than us, that doesn't mean that they are always right, or that their word should be taken as gospel.
-
Article: Playing Hurt: A Painful Debate
The appropriate question is where is the prrof that Souhan was right. The burden is on him to support it, not on everyone else to refute it. You can't throw out a claim like that and expect it to be assumed accurate until someone provides proof to the contrary.
-
Terry Ryan: Joe Maddon had "sincere interest" in Twins job
We'll have to agree to disagree there. I like Maddon, and I appreciate that players respect him, and that he's willing to do some unconventional things. But I don't view him as a "do whatever it takes to get him" candidate. His career winning percentage is 8th among active managers. Not that it's a stat that tells the whole story, but it does not suggest to me that we're dealing with, say, the baseball equivalent of Greg Popovich opting out of his contract with the Spurs and going on the open market. In general, I think there's only so much a manager can do to win games. A bad manager can make bad moves, lose the clubhouse and turn a team with 90 win talent into a 70 win team. But no matter how good of a manager you are,you're not going to win 90 games with 70 win talent. I'd prefer Maddon over Molitor, but I seriously doubt it would make much of a difference in terms of wins and losses.
-
Terry Ryan: Joe Maddon had "sincere interest" in Twins job
What the Cubs did doesn't totally sit right with me but Renteria is a big boy and he's been around the game long enough to understand that it can be ruthless at times. I'll give Theo Epstein a little credit for being honest about it, he came right out and admitted that this wasn't fair to Rick. A lot of organizations would have thrown him under the bus instead. I'm still not sold on this idea that the Twins should have immediately gone to Maddon and offered him whatever money and authority it would have taken to get him here. I like Maddon, and I would have been happy had they hired him. But I don't see much reason to get all worked up over the fact that they didn't.
-
NBC columnist skewers Souhan
Cheers to that. I don't know what caused Mauer to have such a lame season, but it was frustrating and sad to watch. I don't doubt his desire to bounce back strong next year. If Joe starts hitting like his old self, and some of the younger guys take a step forward, this team will put some runs on the board.