Everything posted by one_eyed_jack
-
Article: Patrick Mahomes Career Retrospective
I've long wondered whether TK, Puck and Hrbek made a deal with the Devil back in the day: 2 World Series crowns for a lifetime of sports suffering. "You shall twice celebrate as world champions", Satan said, "but for the next 2 generations, should any of your local teams appear poised to win a third, it shall not happen. They may get close, but to a man, they shall fail spectacularly in the biggest of moments." And so when Satan came to enforce this unholy bargain on the Lynx, Maya Moore said to him, "Aha, but we are not men" as she calmly drained a 3 in his face.
-
Week 17: Vikings vs Bears
Yes it's hard to understate the importance of this. Cousins is getting a lot of flack for this but it's not like he had much of a chance to do anything. No QB looks good when they are under siege all night because the OL is getting worked over. Look at Super Bowl 42.
-
Week 17: Vikings vs Bears
A thousand times this. With the amount of talent on this team, 8 wins is simply not an acceptable result. Too often looked not ready to play. This team was supposed to contend for a Super Bowl and got smacked around on their home turf by the Buffalo Bills, who had only 1 other road win all season, and looked completely unprepared in a must-win game at home today. For having a dynamic receiving duo in Diggs/Thielen, a back in Cook who can make things happen and a credible QB in Cousins, they struggled to move the ball way too often. The defense played well for much of the season, but couldn't make plays when they were needed most. I'm generally not one of those knee-jerk "FIRE THE COACH!!!!" guys, I think that's done too often in sports in general not because it's the smart move, but because its the easy move. But here it seems to me that the players have grown tired to Zimmer's schtick, and it's time to stop looking at the orchestra and start looking at the conductor.
-
Harold Baines and Lee Smith are Hall of Famers
Indeed. I guess the argument for Baines over Murphy or Mattingly would be that the latters' peaks were not long enough. (it's a weak argument to me because as you say, Baines' peak wasn't all that high to begin with.) And I'm with you on Evans. Seems to me that the case for Dwight Evans is similar to but clearly stronger than the one for Baines. If you're into longevity, I don't see a serious argument for Baines over Evans. Evans had a higher peak, better overall offensive numbers, and 8 Gold Gloves.
-
Harold Baines and Lee Smith are Hall of Famers
Yeah no disrespect to Harold Baines, a respected guy who had an impressive career, but putting him in seems to noticeably lower the bar. If he gets in, so should a number of other guys whose careers peaked around the same time, and were every bit as good as Baines if not better; Don Mattingly, Dwight Evans, Lou Whitaker, and Dale Murphy are few that jump to mind, I'm sure there are others.
- Article: Joe Mauer Announces Retirement After 15 Seasons
-
Article: MIN 5, CHW 4: You Are Appreciated, Joe Mauer
I mostly lurk on this great site, don't post a whole lot, but I can't not chime in on Mauer. Great guy, great player. It's a shame that he and Morneau both had their careers so limited by injuries. In '06 I thought those 2 would be terrorizing opposing pitching for the next decade plus. I never understood the venomous hatred of Mauer spewed from the darkest corners of the Twins fan base, or why certain members of the local sports media (Barreiro and Souhan in particular) not only felt compelled to pour gasoline on that fire by spreading vicious rumors and bizarre theories about him, but take a certain savage pleasure in doing so. Who knows, maybe he's not done. Maybe a few months or even a year from now, he'll decide he's still got some baseball left in him. But in any case, it was a nice swan song today, and it left me sadder than I thought it would that I'll probably never hear him introduced at Target Field again.
-
Capital punishment
I oppose the death penalty for a number of reasons, but most significantly: 1) The number of DNA exonerations has proven that there are far, far more innocent people convicted of crimes that most folks are aware of, or at least willing to acknowledge. The risk of an innocent person getting killed by the state is too high. 2) It doesn't work. One of the main arguments in favor of the death penalties is deterrence. Death penalty convictions are pretty concentrated in a relatively small number of jurisdictions. If the death penalty were a deterrent, those jurisdictions would have consistently lower crime rates that comparable ones that do not have capital punishment. But it's not the case.
-
Josh Hader's Tweets
Indeed. It doesn't appear that there are any limits to what will trigger the wrath of the outrage mob. And if you refuse to grab your pitchfork and join, they view you as defending and supporting the nonsense that the target tweeted 10 years ago. If we want people to abandon hateful prejudices and stop staying offensive things, we should let them move on with their lives after they've apologized and done so. I don't see what's to be gained by continuing to beat them up over decades-old transgressions. Branding them for life is counterproductive. Especially when we're talking about what someone did as a kid. And can't the mob prioritize at all? There are people currently in power making statements and implementing policies that are disgustingly offensive every day. But sure, let's focus on what a relief pitcher tweeted to his few dozen followers 8 years ago when he was in high school.
-
Josh Hader's Tweets
His tweets were disgusting, but as best I can tell many of the worst ones were quotes from rap lyrics. (Odd that it's perfectly OK with most folks if you make a bunch of money selling music with said lyrics, but if they discover you quoted them in a tweet in your youth they want to burn you at the stake.) And he was 17. Legally a minor. Before you grab your virtual torches and pitchforks and join the Twitter mob against him, pause to consider whether punishing adults for bad things they said as kids is really a good direction to go. Thanks to modern technology, many adolescent thoughts are published and preserved forever. But that doesn't mean that you should be forever judged by them.
-
Article: No Suspension For Miguel Sano
But it's not like the victim's testimony is the first and last thing that happens at a rape trial and jurors are required to assess it in a vacuum. Plenty of other types of evidence are introduced: eyewitnesses who saw either the accuser or the defendant after the alleged incident, witnesses who knew both parties to describe their relationship, alibi witnesses for the defendant if the defendant is claiming it wasn't him, surveillance video if they were together in a public police before it happened, credit card receipts, medical records, expert testimony, social media posts, text messages, and phone records for starters (Even in this incident, which happened 2 years ago and was not reported to anyone at the time, the MLB found 20 witnesses to interview.) It may well be that none of the other evidence corroborates the accuser's account, making it hard to get a conviction, but that's why the constitutional presumption of innocence exists - so that the state can't rip you from your home and lock you in a cage without proof you did anything wrong; it's a feature, not a bug.
-
Article: No Suspension For Miguel Sano
The problem with law enforcement's approach to sex crimes is one of perverse incentives. Thanks to a flow of federal money and asset forfeiture laws that allow local police departments to enrich themselves with what they seize from drug investigation, they tend to put most of their resources into drug enforcement. They'll send out teams of guys to raid pot dealers while rape kits sit untested for months, even years, if they are ever tested at all. They don't get any money for solving rapes, but they do for going after drug dealers. As far as defense attorneys go, they should not be shamed for "victim blaming" because they raise a consent defense on behalf of their client when there is evidence to support it. Everyone charged with a crime is entitled to a vigorous defense. (I see this narrative about defense attorneys raised frequently, I swear they must teach kids in school these days that Atticus Finch was the bad guy in To Kill a Mockingbird because he questioned a rape accuser.)
-
Article: No Suspension For Miguel Sano
Sufficient evidence for what - a conviction? Yes, if the jury believes it, the victim's testimony alone could be enough. But that doesn't really mean much because the alleged victim's testimony is not the only evidence presented at a trial. Whether the jury believes the victim will often hinge on how well it matches the other evidence presented. In this case, given that there was no independent evidence to substantiate the allegations, and possibly evidence to contradict them, it would be pretty tough to sell a jury on proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
-
Article: No Suspension For Miguel Sano
It's not going to satisfy everyone, but based on the evidence this strikes me as the correct result. At the end of the day, what you had was a Twitter accusation that Sano committed a serious crime in a public place 2 years ago. The MLB investigated and found no evidence to corroborate it, and apparently, perhaps some evidence to contradict it. I have a hard time seeing how punishing Sano would be fair in this situation. Maybe there's temptation to do so to show support for #metoo, but I think we also need to be mindful of the fact that this country also has a history of punishing black men for allegations of sexual misconduct against a white woman based on flimsy evidence. It's interesting to me that so many seem to be so quick to assume that Sano is guilty here - would the reaction be the same if a black woman made the same accusation 2 years later, giving a reason for waiting that is demonstrably false, against Mauer or Dozier?
-
Miguel Sano accused of assault by photographer
That's correct in a strict legal sense, however there are legitimate reasons to be concerned about too many people picking up their torches and pitchforks based on unsubstantiated allegations on social media. You are entitled to due process in a court of law. In the court of public opinion, the Twitter Mob can be judge, jury and executioner, fairness and truth be damned. And while judgments of the Twitter mob have no legal force, they can certainly have consequences to the people they are handed down against. (The professor who was falsely identified as one of the Charlottesville marchers for example). So no, it's not illegal to believe or disbelieve whatever tweets you want. But that doesn't mean rushing to join the mob is the right thing to do.
-
OFFICIAL (UNOFFICIAL) OFFICIAL PHILLY MINNESOTA VIKINGS PRE GAME MEET UP
Tearing it down would be drastic, but the fact that they got steamrolled for 6 consecutive quarters in the playoffs cannot be casually dismissed as an anomaly either. There are issues to be addressed here. It's one thing to get shredded by Brees, but another to get shredded by Nick Foles.
-
OFFICIAL (UNOFFICIAL) OFFICIAL PHILLY MINNESOTA VIKINGS PRE GAME MEET UP
Yeah I was kinda expecting a loss. But I did not expect the D to get humiliated and make Nick Foles look like Joe Montana at the height of his powers. A Patriots-Eagles Super Bowl? Puke.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
To your last point, this is a perfect example of what we've been talking about when we say that it's important to distinguish between criminal and boorish behavior, and how damaging it is to conflate them. And it refutes the claim of those pushing back at the point that "nobody is saying those are the same thing". Well, look at all the "Ansari accused of sexual assault" headlines. I think another way this happens is that there are these non-specific terms like "sexual misconduct" and "inappropriate behavior" thrown around. "Sexual harassment", "assault" and "rape" are legal terms with specific definitions. There may be arguments in a given case whether the conduct at issue falls into those definitions, but they are clearly defined. But "sexual misconduct" is a vague term used to encompass all sorts of bad behavior of vastly varying degrees by men towards women. So when an article talks about the number of the men in the entertainment industry that have been accused of "sexual misconduct", then lists Weinsten and Ansari as examples, it creates a false impression of equivalency between them.
-
Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
Yeah I'm kinda uneasy about this one too. That statement does make you wonder. Also the way she went to a publication about this a year later with every lurid detail of the evening, after changing her mind that this was not just an awkward encounter but an assault. It does seem like this was a lot more about getting revenge on Ansari than on getting justice or changing the culture. Also, neither gender should have to do the 'vast majority of putting on the brakes'. Both parties should have the same responsibility for clear, open communication and respecting what the other person tells them. This woman admits she was a willing participant in sexual activity with Ansari, but complains that he did not pick up on her "non-verbal cues" that she wasn't enthusiastic about it. I don't know what non-verbal cues she gave off, but his failure to read them does not make him a criminal.
-
Most disappointing playoff losses by team
Definitely have to play a better overall game Philly. D needs to play better too - after not giving up more than 19 points at home all year, they gave up 24 in the second half. Granted the interception and blocked punt gave NO generous field position, but still. You'd expect a low scoring game, but that was the expectation for Jax/Pitt and they scored a combined 87 points, so who knows. Whoever jumps out to a lead in that game is going to have a huge advantage, because neither team has a Drew Brees.
- Article: Photographer Accuses Miguel Sano Of Assault
-
Most disappointing playoff losses by team
I've been thinking to myself "So do they rip our hearts out next week in Philly, or do they wait until they are on the world's biggest stage on their home field for maximum effect?"
-
Most disappointing playoff losses by team
Yeah I know what you mean. But it's fun! I wonder what it's like for Pats fans. Do they enjoy the divisional round victories? Or do they get bored watching the Pats beat up on some crappy team in what is effectively a scrimmage every year?
-
Most disappointing playoff losses by team
It still feels too good to be true. I keep bracing myself for the league to pull a post-game Tuck Rule and give the win to the Saints by invalidating the walk-off touchdown based on some obscure provision of the rulebook that has never been invoked in the history off the sport. But until that happens, onto Philly, that's a game we should win.
-
Catch rule
I'm bracing myself for one of these stupid rulings to kill the Vikes tomorrow. I'm hoping the NFL addresses this mess in the offseason. it could happen, the NFL hates it when the post-Sunday conversation is dominated by officiating controversies, and that happened a lot this year. I think there 2 main problems with the Catch Rule. First of all, it's unnecessarily complex. As this piece points point out, while the rule defining a catch at the high school level is 51 words, the version in the NFL's rule book "contains 649 words with three lettered subsections, six numbered items, and two notes". It's silly. They added some things a while ago in an attempt to alleviate confusion, but those additions only added confusion. Then, in their typical arrogant fashion, instead of removing the confusing additions, they kept doubling down, and tried to clarify and justify them with even more additions, thus the mess we have today. They finally got it of the impossibly stupid Tuck Rule after years of defending it, so hopefully they see the light here. The other problem is the overuse of replay. It's now taken to CSI levels where plays are reversed due to movements that could never be detected in real time. Replay was supposed to be limited to overturning obvious mistakes like when a receiver clearly landed out of bounds. It was not meant to be used to make fans wait 10 minutes while every touchdown catch is reviewed in slow motion from every possible angle so there could be the opportunity for a hypertechnical analysis of whether the receiver met every single one of a list of requirements. Replay should be limited to objective determinations - in or out of bounds, did the ball hit the ground before it was caught - things like that. And if you can't tell within a minute or two of review if the call on the field as wrong - it stands. Maybe the results would be less consistent, but right now, they are consistently stupid, and they suck all the fun and flow out of games.