Everything posted by KScott
-
Realistic trade return ideas
My last comment shouldn't be construed as hating on Mauer. Just a statement of preferring Plouffe. Mauer is still better than many of the other possible options.
-
Realistic trade return ideas
I think you have to in order to make a comparison. I mean Sano's production isn't going to suddenly get better because he moves to first from third. So the comparison then becomes who would Sano provide a bigger upgrade to on the roster. So, you are finding the difference between Sano and Plouffe, and Sano and Mauer then comparing the difference. You take the one with the bigger difference. The rank of Mauer and Plouffe at their respective positions is irrelevant. It comes down to how much improvement would happen. For that reason you have to compare how the 3rd baseman is hitting compared to the 1st baseman. There is no way around it. That said, I would prefer Plouffe to Mauer. Plouffe is cheaper, younger, more flexible where he can play, with similar stats over the last two years -- oh and Plouffe is the better of the two this year. Plouffe has more/higher: Runs RBIs HRs OBP SLG OPS So yes, I would much rather have Plouffe to Mauer.
-
Realistic trade return ideas
I agree 100% with that list of players that should be on the Twins trading block. But I would add to that a few of the guys in the bullpen: Pressly, Thielbar, Thompson and Graham, given how many relievers we have in the works. Also, I would add to the list--- NVM A better way to phrase this: The fielders I wouldn't be open to trading: Hicks, Dozier, Plouffe, Suzuki. The rest have quality alternatives coming up in the minors, and if they can net valuable pieces for later I would take it. Granted some of them won't be traded because of contract and home town status (Mauer and Hunter). But they would be worth it. 1b Has Plouffe, Vargas, Kepler as replacements (assuming Sano is at 3) 2nd is Dozier SS has Gordon and Polanco 3rd has Sano and Plouffe CF: Buxton then Hicks Corner OF: Hicks, Rosario, Hunter, Arcia, Walker, Kepler (and a host more in the minors, not to mention its not hard to pick up a corner outfielder) I am not saying the Twins should be sellers because they are out of it. I am suggesting they should sell big league talent move the log jam forward, but probably not make it any better-- I mean who are you going to get back, all of the positions at the big league club are filled or will be soon. The other question I don't see being talked about: If the Twins are buyers with the aim of taking a run into the playoffs, what do you see as the playoff rotation, given that Santana will not be able to participate. If that is your idea or philosophy, are you going to hold off on trading out starting pitching?
-
The Twins Depth Is Turning Into A Tightrope
That is an impressive list. I am torn I want the winning to continue. However, in terms of having a better team down the road and allowing players to develop, I think the twins should be sellers come time for the trade deadline. It scares me to think that I may be suggesting that the twins trade away the pieces that have giving the twins success this season, but I do. I want the twins to trade Nolasco and Pelfrey. Let Milone come up and pitch, and bite the bullet on who the 5th man in the rotation would be for the rest of the season. (next year it'll be Santana, but he's unavailable come playoffs, so I am ignoring him this season as an option). I want the Twins to trade Arcia and Vargas. Plouffe, Sano and Mauer can cover DH 1st and 3rd. The outfield is easily covered with Hicks, Buxton and Rosario--completely ignoring Hunter as an option. Adam Brett Walker, and Max Kepler need to get moved up among others. Trade as much of the bullpen as you can, that isn't named Perkins, Fien, or Boyer. Not because the others are necessarily horrible, but because there is a log jam. The Twins will be a very good team in a year or two, and I want to still have a strong farm system when that happens. Trade the mid tier guys that are performing a little better than they ought to be, stock up for the future and let the guys come up that are really going to be the team to watch from 2017-2025.
-
Article: Minnesota Twins Minor League Leader Board (Through 5/22)
Just to give a little more insight as to how unbelievable that is. Last year's MLB triples leader hit 12. The guy in second hit 10. ALL SEASON. Sure, that's he majors though, the defenses are better there you say. Okay, the same league Buxton is in now, the league leader hit 14, the guy in second hit 11 and Buxton would be in 3rd. (Both of those guys spent the entire season a AA) Bottom line: Buxtons triples total in 1/4 of the season are enough to put him in the top 5 no matter the league, over the course of full season. I can't wait to see him up with Twins flying around the bases.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/8): Pitching, Big Homers And Leaders
Looking at the leaders there are a couple names standing out, that make me wonder what more those players need to do to be called up to either the next level or the twins. Those players in particular being: Aaron Hicks, Josmil Pinto, James Beresford, and D.J Bauxendale. Hicks and Pinto, are probably working on other things like being a professional baseball player and defense respectively. But Beresford, and Bauxendale, I know nothing about these players. What do they need to be working on and What is the hold up in their progression?