Everything posted by sthpstm
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
Thanks for getting the thread back on track! 1 year of Howie Kendrick was worth Andrew Heaney who, at the time of the respective trades, was a higher rated prospect than Meyer and had made several starts in the majors already while Meyer had only pitched at High A. I think that's a better trade to set a starting bar for the Twins to get over to trade Dozier. I can't help but wonder if the Twins will get significantly better offers for Dozier centered around top position prospects which would allow them to part with a more desirable MLB piece (Kepler or Sano or Buxton) to get the pitching we all want them to obtain. No, I don't want to trade any of them, but take Kepler for example. I would think the market and demand for someone like him would be far greater than Dozier. I think we could come up with a lot more teams who appear to have outfield needs than second base needs. You might get the teams that you really want to bidding (i.e. the Nationals have incredible quality and depth of young, MLB ready pitching; it's hard to imagine them bidding for Dozier, but Kepler or one of the others seems more likely). I know I'll get a lot of push back for putting these names out there but I think we should all be prepared for some big changes from the next regime. The current roster construction must be altered. We have what appears to be the potential for a solid core of young of position players getting MLB experience. The pitching is years behind it. We can't waste all of these years. I think we need to get some balance between the two. Yes, trading for 2 MLB SP might help next year but look at the price in prospects of the recent trades and consider that with no solid FA SP the price will be costly.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Gonsalves has talked about working on his slider, but BA and now Law have talked about not using it and/or it being below average. I'm curious what the reality is and how much he's actually used it in game situations.
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
Mike, Mike, Mike. How can you make such a grossly inaccurate statement? Meija pitched 2.1 innings in the majors this year.
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
1 year of Howie Kendrick got Andrew Heaney, a top 30 or so prospect just starting in the majors - sadly out for TJ this year. 1 year of Neil Walker brought back 3 years (2 as options) of an established back of the rotation starter, Jon Niese. 2+ months of Ben Zobrist brought back Sean Manea, a top 75 or so prospect close to the majors plus a AAAA player. I can't think of many better comparisons, so I would start there; each trade brought back 1 SP for next year. I would expect more for Dozier than these comps since he is arguable better than all 3, he is younger than all 3 were at the time of those trades. I would expect the first piece to be a Heaney or Manea, not a Niese. You may be right that only a few teams have a glaring hole at second next year, but it only takes one, and you don't know who else might view him as an upgrade. If teams agree with the recent Fangraphs article that his changes to his swing are positive and permanent, you never know.
-
Article: Santana Shines Among Sad Starter Group
Agreed - I don't think people saying trade Santana (and Dozier) expect the return to be players that will make the Twins better next year but rather better in 2018/2019 and beyond. Could everything go well next year with the offense and the pitching is not completely awful and the Twins make a worst to competitive turnaround? I guess stranger things have happened (see the Orioles current team), but i don't see that as a viable strategy. I want a strategy that will build a perennial contender and in my view the offense/defense should be settling in by 2018 and so we need a pitching staff that will coincide with it. Trading Santana and Dozier for SP's to add to Berrios and be around or above Gonsalves/Jay/Mejia is more certain than keeping your currently solid veterans who will not be around or not be as good by that point.
-
Sept Calls / AZ Fall League
Garver and Walker September call ups, with Aaron Slegers, Ryan Eades, Stuart Turner, and Daniel Palka rather than Granite to the AFL since I've seen enough of Granite to know he's going on the 40 man roster but uncertain on Palka. Heck, if Buxton isn't coming back for September (I hope he is) maybe Granite gets a call up and audition in CF.
-
Article: Santana Shines Among Sad Starter Group
Keeping Santana seems like a very TR move - let's keep him and hope 4 other starters exceed any past results and reach their absolute ceilings and the offense maintains or improves slightly we can be a .500 team competing for a wild card spot. I hope the Pohlad's didn't fire TR just to appease fans and just hire someone who will keep the same philosophy. We are going to lose 100 games this year and have been dreadful for most of the past 6 years. We need to rebuild a SP rotation for 2018/2019 that can hopefully coincide with our top hitting prospects developing. Since prospects miss all the time, we need to fill that pipeline with 2-3 more SP's in the AA/AAA range.
-
Article: Santana Shines Among Sad Starter Group
I completely disagree with the idea that no one will give up good, upper level minors, nearly ready for the MLB, players for Santana. We got Adalberto Mejia for the Eduardo Nunez, who has played well for about 1 year. Surely we can do better for Santana. Sell high on an aging player! While I appreciate optimism, the idea that the Twins should be built to compete in 2017 is just unrealistic. Trade Santana for pieces that you believe will help in 2018/2019, and beyond. Yes, you lose a major piece of your current team, but if you're current team is terrible you suck it up and deal him to ensure you have more potential pieces for years that you are building towards.
-
2017 40 man roster additions?
You need to check out this series: http://twinsdaily.com/_/minnesota-twins-news/minnesota-twins/examining-pre-arbitration-players-r5009
-
Article: Arms Race: The Search For Young Starters
I'm on board with filling the pipeline, but we can't ignore catching depth (lack of). I'd be targeting Barnes and Brock Stewart (because I don't think you can get De Leon, but try by all means). I'd also trade Santana - the Rockies seem like a team that could use a veteran that's not De La Rosa to team with their young guys. Maybe we could pry Marquez and Freeland or one of those plus a Castellani. I want to win in 2017, but I just don't see it. All these guys could be up in 2017 and hopefully making positive contributions by 2018/2019.
-
Starting Pitching Remains Twins Biggest Mystery
Do you not consider Duffey an option for the 5th spot next year?
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
I think the 4.2 walk rate they mention for Gonsalves should be understood in the context of 4 starts with a high walk rate of 8.2 (starts 1,2,3, and 6) and the other 6 starts (starts 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10) a rate of 2.25. It seems like a guy working to adjust to his level and showing success in that process. It's hard not to get excited about this guy!
-
Article: Examining Arbitration-Eligible Players
If he is the type that will age well into his low 30's, will deliver good innings consistently, and the options/extra years are affordable, you can take that risk. You mentioning something earlier doesn't make it right. Others can disagree.
-
Article: Examining Arbitration-Eligible Players
But the point of the extension is to give the team an affordable year or two (or options) in his free agent years. If the team can't have the defense improved to good/average by 2019/2020 (preferably 2018) then we have bigger problems.
-
Article: Examining Arbitration-Eligible Players
I agree with trying to extend Gibson while his value may be down. How much more confident would he be and competent would he look with a good defense behind him all year.
-
Why Hasn't Stephen Gonsalves Been Called Up?
Agreed, but on point 5, I think the only reason to call him up is because he needs more starts and more innings. Unless Chattanooga makes the playoffs he will have fewer starts and innings than last year. So they won't call him up to use him in the bullpen. Perhaps he's an AFL candidate?
-
Article: Pitching Pipeline: What's Next?
Does anyone know specifics on Gonsalves? How is his slider/cutter working? Has he added any speed to his fastball? As for Stewart, I think we need to continue being patient. He's only 21, in AA, and unless his stuff has regressed and/or not developed, hopefully he can continue working through becoming a pitcher.
-
Article: Brian Dozier: Powerful Asset
But aren't all of these guys recent acquisitions that they added once their turnaround began. They weren't long time Cubs. If Dozier can bring you core pieces for 2018 and a couple of years after, trade him and then add what you need when you get closer to competing. The Twins have a lot of nice, potential pieces in the low minors. If things go well by 2018 you can look to trade these assets and/or sign FA's to supplement your core. But you have to trade veteran players at peak value, before their decline, if you're not competing and not likely to compete soon.
-
Article: Brian Dozier: Powerful Asset
I actually did not say that everyone who was part of the past 5 years should go; that was someone else. And I think it's wrong thinking as well. I don't care about the past 5 years; they were bad, but they're the past. What's the future? Can it be improved if Dozier is flipped for a valuable, longer term piece? Is he, Ervin Santana, and others going to be at their peak in the offseason and are they likely to be waning by the time we can really compete? 2015 was clearly not the beginning of an upward trend but a blip, some luck, in the midst of lost years.
-
Article: Brian Dozier: Powerful Asset
While very clever, this is a bad baseball team, not a sick body. If you have assets, particularly those that might be replaceable, you have to consider dealing them for the right offer if it helps feel a huge void. I believe most fans would take the tear down efforts of the Cubs, Astros, etc., over the "partial rebuilds" of the Twins, Angels, and others. These now competitive teams didn't hang on to trade-able assets just because they were their good players.
- Article: Twins Trade Nolasco, Meyer, Cash To Angels For Hector Santiago
- Article: Painted Into A Corner (Infield Crunch)
-
Article: Painted Into A Corner (Infield Crunch)
Deal from strength to improve a weakness. The issue is that trading Plouffe, Vargas, and/or Park will not bring much back right now. If you want an ace you have to deal high value back. I would trade Sano, as difficult as it is. My target would be a controllable pitcher such as Steven Matz, Lucas Giolito, Julio Urias, or someone similar. With Matz, I would consider including Kyle Gibson but would need something additional (Rosario is the dream or Cecchini the fall back). You still may need to trade one of Vargas or Park. Next years infield is Mauer/Dozier/Plouffe/Escobar/Polanco/Vargas or Park with Cecchini and Vielma ready in AAA. Your rotation is now Matz/Santana/Berrios/Santiago/Duffy/Meija/May/Wheeler, and the current AA pitchers (Gonsalves) in waiting.
-
Article: Official Trade Deadline Day Thread
Agreed, but I don't think the Twins will/should DFA him. DFA Milone to make room for a young guy (Wheeler). I would consider making Nolasco my long guy for the rest of the year or just September to get a look at Mejia or someone else, but ensuring Nolasco he will get every opportunity to be back in the rotation in 2017 for his walk year. I get it, Nolasco is not good, but you need depth in rotation, young guys are not guaranteed, and at this point in his not trade-able contract, why cut him now. See what he can do in his walk year.
-
Article: Twins Trade Deadline Tidbits
I think we should target Pittsburgh, if they decide to make a push. They need starting pitching and their infield could use some help for this year and the next few. I think Kyle Gibson would be good there, or Ervin Santana with some cash. For infield, I wonder if they would be interested in Dozier or Nunez and Polanco to play second/utility and third base next year. I would be asking for Taillon (dream) and McGuire or Mitch Keller and McGuire depending on the rest of the package and who/how much cash I give up.