Everything posted by sthpstm
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
I'm a little behind on this thread, but has anyone brought up Wolfson's mentioning the Phillies as having interest in Dozier? Initially, I found this quite perplexing, but then I thought a little more. The Dodgers need a leadoff hitter, someone with good OBP and some speed, probably more than they need a slugger, particularly if they bring back Turner. Howie Kendrick (.255/.326/.366) and Chase Utley (.252/.319/.396) were their lead off hitters last year. Kendrick is now gone; Utley is a free agent. Maybe the Phillies trade Cesar Hernandez (.294/.371/.393) to the Dodgers, opening up second base to trade for Dozier.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
I don't think it's wise to expect a 28 and 32 year old suddenly learned to hit and that they won't dive back down offensively next year. If nothing else, check out their jumps in BABIP. And as others have stated or inferred, Castro needs to be employed on a fairly strict platoon against RH pitchers; his stats against LH pitchers were brutal (.478 OPS vs .757 against RH). You guys are right, his overall numbers are terrible, but get a guy who hits LH pitchers (Murphy, or maybe Chris Gimenez), and you have solid numbers against both LH and RH pitchers. By Baseball Prospectus numbers, their pitch framing stats are not close, at all. And their improvements over him in the other areas, were not as great as you imagine them to be. FRAA Adj is Baseball Prospectus's measurement for catchers using Fielding Runs Above Average (FRAA) that "is augmented with framing, throwing and blocking contribution" and "is then added to the 'normal' FRAA components, such as fielding ground balls, to generate a total FRAA for the catcher." By FRAA Adj, these 2 are not even close to Castro. Butera is at .8, Herrmann at -4.9 (MLB only), and Castro at 16.8. In other words, average, poor and excellent. Falvey, Levine, and Baseball Prospectus disagree with you and laloesch and others here on your assessment. Perhaps we all, myself included, would benefit from a great understanding of BP's catching analytics. And maybe we can give the new guys a chance to install their systems and players before announcing we know better than they and some statistical organizations do.
- Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
- Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
-
Dozier for Giolito?
Surprisingly he's not even the first writer to mention it. I stumbled across this a few days ago: http://fansided.com/2016/09/19/5-potential-trade-destinations-brian-dozier/
- Dodgers make inquiry on Dozier
-
Article: A Look At The Free Agent Catcher Market
He's not a free agent, but I think Derek Norris is still worth a look, particularly if you think Garver can be effective by mid-season. He gets good defensive ratings, but what little I can find on framing is mixed. He used to be okay, then took at dive in early 2015 before climbing back up. I would be curious how he rated in 2016. If it is okay, he may be worth a try.
-
Cory's 2017 Blueprint, 2.0
Berrios is in the bullpen because you think he belongs there long term or something else?
-
A's misusing revenue sharing?
I have to assume that people saying the Giants and the A's are in the same market aren't from the area or California. As a California transplant I may have a little more knowledge, and for the people I know, they aren't, they aren't in the same market. Most San Franciscans wouldn't make the trek to Oakland for a game even if the A's were great and the Giants were in a Twins-like slump. Oakland and it's areas are generally lower income and industrial.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Cleveland connection...could it be the Twins? Until it's not, I can hope.
-
Setting the framework for a potential Dozier trade
Personally, I would think that the risk with that package is too high, in combination because they are too far away, too new to professional baseball, have had injuries, and/or have too big of question marks. I could see a couple of them in the trade, but I think we should expect at least a piece or probably two that are either near MLB ready and/or have a high floor and high ceiling.
-
Norge Ruiz
I think those are comps from people on this thread based off of the Prospect Pipeline scouting report. Amazing that they can comp him from that, eh? In 2015 Badler tagged him as having potential for 3 above average pitches (fastball, + change up, slider) and that a splitter that was more like a change up. He describes him as a strikeout pitcher who gets a lot of ground balls. He listed no comps. He goes in depth on him here (paywall): http://www.baseballamerica.com/international/top-20-prospects-cuba-1-10/#T4KpWZObKh8hR4VR.97 Badler also had him well above Perez who didn't make the top 20 and was going to get $5M+ from the Astros till the recent rescinding of that offer. While that may have changed, $500k is not going to get it done. And if being under 23 and subject to the pool hurts his market that much, I imagine he would hold out until 3/15/17 when he turns 23. Now that he's more easily viewed by scouts I imagine we will hear more.
-
An Argument for the Twins to NOT do too much to fix their 2017 rotation
I don't want a GM to have to come in and press too hard to make moves and make bad moves to try to improve a team. SD and Arizona tried this and I don't think anyone wants those situations. I agree with the original premise of this thread overall. Falvey needs to build up a system of coaches and personnel first, and there is only so much that can be taken on when starting anew. I expect this to be more like Milwaukee when Stearns took over last year. The coaching staff will be revamped and the player development process will be reviewed and a system put in place. It seems to me, the only difference is it being more likely Falvey makes a trade in his first offseason (Dozier and/or Santana) due to a player being at peak value instead of waiting for the value to go back up (Lucroy) and trading at midseason. Next offseason or the trade deadline is, in my opinion, when Falvey would make more drastic moves to shift players out and bring those into the system that fit the system, if necessary. At that point, you have to hope that your process and coaching staff have caused the Gibsons, Santiagos, etc. to have built up trade value that you can turn into long term assets.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 6 (11-15)
I think the Stewart is washed up crowd forgets that he may very well be a late bloomer in honing his craft. He didn't focus on baseball as much as most top draft picks do and so, as I recall, patience was preached. But everyone seems to have forgotten it. There are examples of pitchers with low strikeout rates in the minors becoming productive major league starters who improve their strikeout rates over time. I know it's neither typical nor what we would like but it happens. With his stuff, Stewart seems as likely a candidate to turn it around as Keuchel, or anyone before him who has.
-
Sickels: End of 2016 Top 100 Prospects
Oh my, has Stewart really dropped so far as to be out of the top 10?
-
Article: Can Derek Falvey Be The New Andy MacPhail?
First and foremost, Falvey will change the philosophy of drafting, developing, and working with minor league and major league pitchers. Who he determines to fit into that philosophy, I couldn't guess, but my point is this will be less about the pieces changes and more about the system that produces and works with those pieces changing.
- Article: Reports: Twins Leaning Toward Falvey As Baseball Ops Chief
-
Derek Falvey PBO?
No one is exactly like those under whom they learned their positions, but Mark Shapiro and Chris Antonetti have seemed quite aggressive in their moves. Shapiro was not afraid to trade off the best players and fan favorites for young pieces when expedient and we've seen Antonetti be fairly aggressive in acquiring/attempting to acquire talent to help their post season run this year.
-
Derek Falvey PBO?
Here's a brief article on Falvey's previous promotion along with the David Stearns hiring in 2011: http://m.mlb.com/news/article/26174134// And I believe someone has already posted this or a similar interview with Falvey at the beginning of the year: http://cleveland.cbslocal.com/2016/04/04/indians-assistant-general-manager-derek-falvey-says-the-off-season-goal-was-to-supplement-the-core-pieces/
-
Derek Falvey PBO?
I'm curious where these rumors are as I haven't seen, or looked for, them yet. Interested that David Stearns and Falvey shared the director of baseball operations role in Cleveland before Stearns left for the GM post in Milwaukee. IF it is Falvey, it would seem as though he may lack the contract negotiations and external analysis needed, but certainly the Twins could hire a GM to balance that out. And, if that is Antony, I personally won't complain
-
Article: Penciling A 2017 Bullpen
Baxendale is a near lock for me in the same way Rogers was going into 2016. Thanks to being a starter for most of his time in the minors, he's had plenty of experience and has very little to nothing left to prove. His 35 innings in AAA have been very good. He was sufficient as a minors starter but his stuff can play up in the bullpen. He can start as a long reliever or a 6th/7th inning guy depending the other bullpen pieces.
-
Article: Updates On The Front Office Search
I think I have more reasons to cheer for the Cubs to win the World Series. I like McLeod. The Dodgers will become more desperate and may make a trade favorable to us depending on what weaknesses show up in their post season performance.
-
Article: Penciling A 2017 Bullpen
Hard to disagree with the general sentiment here. Assuming Baxendale's move to the bullpen was permanent, I see no reason he shouldn't be a near lock. He's had plenty of minors experience and likely would have moved quickly if he wasn't starting. So, Kintzler (you need a little experience in this pen/won't cost much), Chargois, Rogers, Boshers (outside of ERA, his numbers are solid), Baxendale, Duffey, and two of Pressley, Wimmers, Light, Dean, Hildenberger. And since we're not signing a top FA, I wouldn't do too much in the way of FA signings as we should have plenty of young depth behind these.
-
So let's say the Twins are trading Brian Dozier
I am all for trading Dozier, but I agree that one of those three seems unlikely. I continue to believe that a trade for Dozier may be more likely to get back higher valued position players, which would allow us trade a more valuable piece (Sano, Kepler, Buxton) that could fetch the pitching we need.
-
Bates: Trade Dozier? History suggests really hard to get good return.
I'm curious why he didn't include the Howie Kendrick for Andrew Heaney trade (I know, I keep banging that drum). It's not a perfect comparison since there was only 1 year left on Kendrick's deal and Kendrick was older but not of these are perfect comparisons as others have stated. If we need ML ready starting pitching, it seems like there may be no better trade comparison.