Everything posted by Platoon
-
Article: Center Of Attention
Two phrases stand out>>>>. "A perceived lack of range at the corners". And >>>> Santana played an adequate CF! This is a team with offense as its strength. While I don't believe the offense will be as good as last year it's still the Twins current boasting point. As to CF, the only criteria at the beginning of the season is how fast you can get between the gaps, with a glove on your hand, and catch the ball while dodging the corner OF's.
-
Souhan: Ryan in for the long haul
Agree. Ryan has made it clear more than once that he is not that interested in the numbers crunching side of the game. He enjoys the game more than the business. My biggest complaint is he seems afraid to "roll the dice"! He is painstakingly slow bringing up top prospects. He seems to put more weight on rewarding loyalty than talent. But it's talent that wins games.
-
Souhan: Ryan in for the long haul
There is a difference between building a good farm system, and knowing when to use it. Also, losing in MLB is inevitable. But if you lose with a plan, and a purpose, at least it's palitable.
-
Is this anything? Josmil Pinto not coming to TwinsFest?
Maybe they will trade him for another RH starting pitcher with fastball in the low 90's, a solid 4 pitch mix, and good command of all 4 pitches. Someone has to fill that 5th spot in the rotation!
-
Vargas shut down as PR Winter League final series begins... Bigger plans for him in Minnesota?
I've always thought that some of the things TD members , myself included, post read like they are translated from a foreign language. This makes us look virtually eloquent! Never has the term "I think something was lost in the translation" been more appropo!
-
Meyer listed as 10th best RH pitching prospect
Maybe they have the Twins confused with one of the other 27 teams in the league. In just a few years Meyer will shoot up to #1 on the top prospect list of RH SP over 30!
-
Article: How Secure Is Suzuki's Starting Job?
I totally agree. I have nothing against him whatsoever. I would taken every penny and a little more. To me he would be a great back up, even on a contender. Maybe more so on a contender. My position relates to his being extended and hindering the evaluation of a Pinto. To me it is symptomatic of many other Twins decisions. When you are where they are, a bird in the hand is not necessarily as good as two in the bush.
-
Article: How Secure Is Suzuki's Starting Job?
I agree with Jokin on this. It was a time to cash in on Suzuki's aberration of a half season and sell high. Then use the last half of yet another lost year to evaluate and educate Pinto. If it works, great, if not what's the worst that can happen. The Twins were in a relatively unique place in their baseball existence. And I have never been sure, or understood who exactly they thought they were fooling by pretending that some of the moves they made were important to their future. The only person with a defensible argument for these moves was Gardy. He needed to squeeze out every win he could in 2014 to keep his job. He can hardly be blamed for making some short term decisions. But for the FO to do so is a troubling sign.
-
Article: How Secure Is Suzuki's Starting Job?
But one of the problems is that it's not all about the money. Once you sign a guy like Suzuki to an extension, his playing time becomes a gauge on commentary on your decision making. I would not only have never extended him last year, I would have sold high. I don't know if the manager change will alleviate the problem/perception that I and I think some others have. And that is the Twins put an inordinate amount of weight to the character and likability of a player, in relation to other teams.
-
Rockies seek pitching for Outfielder
Shafer can cover ground and catch the ball. That is priority número uno for theTwins in CF. I dont care if he will not hit .275, someone HAS to fill in the gaps between Hunter and Arcia. And these gaps may be worse than thought because of the inexplicable decision to move Arcia to left. If that came from the FO, and it seems it did, the only rationale is to make the acquision seem more palatable!
-
Rockies seek pitching for Outfielder
If they had not signed Hunter, this discussion would be more pertinent. But he and Arcia will keep the corners filled and Hicks or Shafer will hold down center. And you have Rosario in the wings. Then we get to the pitching! We have had the worst SP in MLB for 4 years running. We have 2 seemingly distinct groups: veteran run of the mill types (Hughes a possible exception TBD) and promising youth with big arms. The veterans will never yield a satisfactory return, and this is a team which really should not at this stage even consider trading a young pitching prospect. I know it makes for a boring "hot stove" season, but the Twins should stand pat, let ST play itself out, and by June set their final course for 2016. Despite an unfortunate sequence of variables,I had hoped that this would have been done a year ago. Better late than never!
-
share of full season ticket package
I have a 1987 Yugo for sale, which my mother only drove on days that ended with the letter "y"! Actually none of this is true, but I could not help myself. It's Friday and I am in a weird mood. It must be the polar eclipse!
-
Is Brian Dozier Underrated?
"He's not good enough to build around". My point is that he is good enough to be part of a legitimate contender. I would take him any day. This is not a knock on "The Hair God". This is an observation that a team buit of 8 BD level players would not be successful. He quit hitting home runs the minute they figured out that almost everyone he hit was off a high, almost out of, or out the strike zone pitch. Besides the obvious fact that pitching rules, you need a couple position studs. BD is a very nice ball player. But he is not in the stud category. (Hair comments will not be tolerated). . I agree with the first part of your last sentence, he is good enough to build with. But not the around part.
-
Is Brian Dozier Underrated?
I think it's sad, not because of Dozier, but because if he is our BEST position player, that leaves the rest of them behind. You could easily win a World Series with Brian Dozier in your lineup. You cannot win the World Series with 7 other Dozier level players on the field. He is over rated in Twins Land because we have become very used to mediocrity in this market. And that extends to virtually every statewide sports entity that has a MN zip code. In any other market, a manager who said the boys were "battlin their tails off" after yet another loss, would have been gone long before this. Sorry to have wandered slightly off topic, but it goes to the heart of over/under rating.
-
Article: How Secure Is Suzuki's Starting Job?
I don't know about other years, or other pitchers, but pitch framing statistics when catching Samuel Deduno might be one of the most overrated metrics of all time. It's just another mystifying case of Gardy's mentality. You put your "worst" catcher in to catch your hardest to catch pitcher. And you put your "best" catcher in to sit in a rocking chair, catching the guy who has the lowest walk rate in MLB history. Perhaps that's why my driver training school for NASCAR drivers is off to such a slow start?
-
Articles
As my 4 yr old granddaughter is fond of saying when asked, "how did that work for you?" NOT VERY GOOD lol
-
Outfield Depth Reality in Minors
OR, is Chattanooga to hard tho spell? (Thanks auto correct)
-
Unofficial Contest! Torii's Return To CF
You could, if Hunter had been signed by the Rockies!
-
Unofficial Contest! Torii's Return To CF
Be nice, that was not Minnesota Nice!
-
Unofficial Contest! Torii's Return To CF
4/29..... Afternoon game against the Tigers. A chance to show Detroit what a huge mistake they made!
-
Rules for contests?
I love it. But there is no need for a prize. Just the acknowledgement and accolades from TD readers will be enough for me. I did think it was kind of funny that Brock thought Kirby etc might offer cash! . A Pa Pa Johns Pizza would have been more appropriate. It's a good thing Gardy is in Florida taking the year off otherwise there would have been an awful lot of pizzas handed out due to the massive tie that would exist when everyone took the same day. Opening day, 2015!
-
15 Optimistic Twins Predictions for 2015
If I could choreograph the season, it would go pretty much like you have predicted. Not to be a wet blanket, but our main choreographer is TR. He is not noted for being agressively innovative. If he had been in charge of Riverdance, they would have not been allowed to wear those noisy metal tips on their shoes!
-
Does everyone think the Twins are going about this right?
If Nolasco starts hot, does anyone really think the Twins will trade him? That is not the "twins way".
-
OF Defense. Thoughts and community Poll ?
As bad as the pitching was last year, the overall D was worse, and will be no better to start the year. You compound Hunter by moving an unsure Arcia move to LF. The jury is out on Santana at SS, but it will by default improve the CF glove work. I think there was a rating on here the other day of Twins defenders by position, and it was not a pretty sight. So far the only improvement will be probably in CF. There is an old saying, "throw it and duck"! It might have to be changed to "throw it and don't trun around and watch"!
-
The trade that is coming
I agree on the bullpen. I am positive Pelfry will go to the pen. I am not sure how much upgrade OF defense can get. That went out the door with the latest reunion. From just a defensive standpoint Shafer and Hicks can be more than adequate, not sure you will be able to improve the defense there. And the corners are locked. That was the folly in signing Hunter to appease the casual fan. If I was Nunez or Hermann I would keep a travel bag packed, and not sign any long term leases!