Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. I think the article referenced Hunter's decision as saving the Twins from themselves. But who am I to quibble, I withdraw the comment in an attempt to promote harmony and good will!
  2. I was never sure which Hunter was the real one. The one with the views I don't agree with and the accompanying attitude displayed to Bernadino, or the smiley friendly one displayed on the field? Likely a composite of the two. Whichever, it's mostly irrelevant as he is not paid to be my ideal male sports personality, he was paid to play baseball. Which I think he can still do to some degree. So did he retire because it was time, because he thought it best to go out on the higher note? Or because the Twins would not guarantee him a full time gig? If the Twins truly wanted him back with a regular lineup spot, it speaks reams about FO decision making, and the likelihood that any significant improvement is forthcoming. That said, while it can be argued pro or con that Hunter helped the Twins on the field in 2015, his biggest contribution will likely be his retirement, saving the Twins from yet another mind boggling roster decision!
  3. Yes, but it is a well known fact that consistency is one of the hallmarks of any great orginisation.
  4. I would agree with trading Plouffe and Dozier to get a catcher, and maybe even a young defensive middle infielder. I really hate the thought of trading Gibson. It would have to be for the proverbial "I made him an offer he couldn't refuse" in reverse deal. So why trade Plouffe and Dozier? Plouffe because he's in the wrong place at the wrong time. Sano has to play third, as first is unavailable for 3 yrs, for this whole rebuild to work. It's one of the starting pieces to the whole project. Dozier, while a slightly above average defender, has shown no inclination to adjust to the way he is being pitched. Once teams got really serious about avoiding fastballs up in the zone to him, he became virtually an offensive liability, especially that high in the order. It's a rare chance to sell somewhat on the high side. The reason I advocate some of these moves is I don't believe this team, as constructed, can do anything better than compete for the second WC spot. If that's sufficient, then stay the course. Otherwise something out of the ordinary TW should be attempted. Do I think it will? Not a chance in hell. But it's nice to consider. Ryan said he needs a catcher to "take some of the load" of Kurt. Sounds like he has an agrssive plan for the off season in place already.
  5. Hoping for the Royals to win it. But the Mets starting pitching is a great equalizer. The Royals bullpen is minimized if the Mets SP keeps it very close. But Royals in 7, just by the hair on my chinny chin chin!
  6. If you think she would be upset over your lack of knowledge regarding alphabetical order, that would pale in comparison to the venom she would spew over your posting on TD!
  7. I don't know if it's apples and oranges, but last year the Twins had a chance to "save" something like a half mil by sitting Kurt a few games at the end of a lost year, and didn't. So will they get another catcher solely to platoon for monetary reasons or on field reasons? As for just plain getting help, it it was I, and Turner was as advanced defensively as advertised, I would look at him as an option. I know his bat is short, but he also has had some offensive success. The bottom line is AJ does nothing to advance the Twins in the right direction. It's just a complete meh move!
  8. [Not sure this is how I wanted to use my 1000th post. I was hoping to save that for when we won the World Series.] You might have to add another zero, and several years to reach that goal!
  9. We would finally get a throw out % in the 30's! 15 for Kurt, and 16 for AJ.
  10. I agree St. Peter is not the go to guy for roster decisions. It was the eeery similarity to Molitors views that made me mention it. And since they were so in tune, I used the term "company line". And if reading between the lines is required, this is what I read. Only Hunter can save the Twins from Hunter. Our starting pitching will not include Berrios, i.e., it will remain static due to long term contracts. Plouffe ain't going nowhere. Our first decision on the pen affirms our long term belief in low SO rates. If Sano is the DH, Arcia is gone. If Arcia is the DH, and Buxton is wowing the norther NY fans, Hunter or Sano will roam RF. (At least Sano can still run) That's just a few of the lines, but the last one is: We still think we can get people to buy tickets by working feverishly to acquire that last WC spot. To some this may sound sarcastic? Sadly it was not meant that way!
  11. Most of this thinking does not seem as much Molitors, as the "company line". A post on TD referenced Dave St. Peter telling season ticket holders much of the same things. An interview with Ryan would likely sound like a replay of talking points. Is it just me, or does this sound like Gardy never left? Keep Cotts? Agonize over whether Torii returns? Worry about a roster spot for Nunez? Don't trust Hicks? Sano to the OF, having to the best of my knowledge never playing an inning there? The only one I can agree with is Berrios and Buxton, and that only if someone just plain says that it's service time. Which I imagine they can't, even though it is. So you keep Cotts, you have Sano stumble around the OF, but ditch Arcia because he couldn't field, you bring up Berrios and Buxton in late June, and waste a month or two on ML acclimation, and then at the end of the year, bemoan how very close you were to that one and down WC game. Now that truly is the "Twins Way".
  12. . I think the "take charge" aspect. Another way of putting it would be baseball sense. Where to throw that cutoff, when to go to the plate with the infield in, etc. metrics does not measure those things. I think metrics are a tool, and a good one. But there is still a reason scouts are sent to games, and GM make decisions, and mangers make out lineups.
  13. I don't know anything about Vielma except what I have read, so this is not specifically about him. But given a choice I like a SS who can field better than one who can hit. And I like a SS who can field better than one who can hit "a little" and field "a little". I don't think there are metrics that can measure the value of a slick fielding, take charge SS.
  14. Extra years of rebuilding are the cost of leaving your youth in the minors to marinate to a level past what others might. After 4 yrs of 90+ losses, most teams would have started the rebuild in earnest in Nov of 2014. Are we in rebuild mode? I would like to think so. But does the FO? Either way, the question of whether they should sign a $?00,000,000 ace to a ? Yr contract is a moot point. It ain't ever gonna happen.
  15. The conflict of opinions in this post point out one inescapable truth. The Twins roster situation is an incredible mess. Way to much money tied up in contracts to mid to low level 30+ yr old pitchers. And a batting order that lacks a clear #1 or #3 stick. Throw in a soft tossing bull pen, and you complete the picture. The Twins will not and cannot acquire a Price level FA pitcher. There is no reason for them to come here. Market size and chances of winning "now" are not a match. And the thought of the FO going in search of yet another tier 3 type pitcher is scary enough to be featured as this years Halloween theme.
  16. And not to pile on, but the Twins hitters were CONSISTENT! They were consistently poor! As an aside, I have no problem with an umpire being termed consistent. I have done it, and if you are behind the plate, and call the same pitches the same way every time, you stay out of trouble. Even if you are "consistently" a little low. It's the moving target that gets you in trouble.
  17. The Twins just spent 10M to bring back a 40 yr old former Twin OF, and want him back next year. They are likely exploring signing a 39 yr old FA catcher, another former Twin. What makes you think in 3 yrs it will be all over? :) I am sure in 3 yrs we will hear that Vargas still needs some seasoning in Rocherster!
  18. I really was not comparing AJ to Hunter as to talent or disposition. I was strictly referring to the Twins status as a team that should be rebuilding from within via youth. As to Turner specifically, I like most others here have not seen him play. All I can go by is that more than one analysis has his defense as major league ready, and his offense as not. Based on that, as long as Suzuki is in the mix, having a good defensive catcher a couple times a week would not hurt. Having an AJ/Kurt kombo should not preclude a younger catcher surfacing, but it will in effect do just that for the duration of their contracts. I base that opinion on what the Twins history of dealing with veteran FA has been, not what I, or anyone else, thinks it should be. There are a few rare rentals they have been let go in mid season, but as a rule a winter FA is here for the duration. Ryan has made his position clear on that quite often. I agree totally that catching is a problem, but would prefer that we keep the number of veteran catchers well below 2!
  19. I think this decision would depend on whether one thinks the team is going to proceed as a legitimate contender next year, or still be in a youth/rebuilding mode. Some will say both. IMHO they are still strictly in a youth movement. Adding yet another 40 yr old seems a step backward. And it will effectively block a Turner for coming up in mid season. The Twons just do not acquire a FA and then move him in season. Trade Kurt in mid season? Possible, but it would be out of the norm. I have no idea what the real status of Pinto is. But it seems the Twins have catchers who can either catch, or hit, but not both. While AJ can do some of each, this team does not need to delve further into the geriatric ward for players. I would rather a Turner gets his feet wet, or a Pinto be able to return to catching than sign yet another stopgap.
  20. You may have overlooked solid prediction #1, or silly prediction #3! Mays professed hip problem associated with pitching in the bull pen will flair up again. The Twins will waffle for 14 days trying to decide if a few days rest will improve it. They will then announce they can't play short handed anymore, will put May on the 15 day DL, retroactive of course. They will call up Tonkin, who will pitch that day, and they will then send Tonkin back to Rochester, (unknown to Tonkin his ticket was round trip) and reactivate May!
  21. The Twins 30 yr old + SP reminds me of buying something on CL that you thought would work perfectly for a task at hand. So you paid the asking price. You get it home and find out it worked, but not as well as you thought it would. When you try to get rid of it, you find that you cannot recoup your cost. And you either sell it for a loss, or are stuck with a "tool" that does work, but not at the level needed to get the project finished. Sooner or later a shop with too many underperforming "tools" has to get cleaned out.
  22. You (they) forgot #7. Winning baseball games. The Twins are a business, and are run like one. But if you don't include #7, then everyone who goes to the games, buys merchandise, and follows the team must be basically rubes! Or worse! i know it sounds/seems cynical but looking at the last 20 years seems make one wonder.
  23. Great post. After reading some of the comments, I am so glad I did not pay attention in Mr. Jensens English class. Not knowing the difference between a participle, a preposition, or a proposition, has made my life easier, and in some cases much more exciting! Btw, thanks for not writing this in Canadian! Adding, eh, to the end of each sentence would have driven the word count above TD maximum levels.
  24. I would think that Gardy, after all these years in baseball, can handle NL rules. If I had to make a decision on Gardy as a manager, it would be based on my roster. Is it stable? Veteran? Huge egos? Yes to the first two questions and no to the third, would be more important to me than the league rules.
  25. Little known fact: Chief was the prototype on which Dickens based Scrooge! Although Chief was still a young man at the time Charles saw his potential!

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.