October 14, 201511 yr I came across this article that discusses the Twins futility in obtaining talent from outside the organization. I have not seen it referenced here. There have been a number of threads this years that touched on a similar theme. "There are two ways to build a baseball team, and the Twins are not good at one of them" written by Bryan Grosnick on SB Nation http://www.beyondtheboxscore.com/2015/10/9/9337965/minnesota-twins-good-at-drafting-and-developing-bad-at-everything-else
October 14, 201511 yr Yeah other than the lucky Liriano/Nathan/Boof trade the Twins have been quite poor at acquiring talent from other teams, they had an awesome talent in Gomez but foolishly gave him up because he didn't fit the "twins way" which 1 year later turned into Jim Hooey. In the meantime we gave up guys like Span, Gomez, Ortiz, Garza, Santana all with plenty of time left in the org for the cheap and got back a combined: 1 year of good play by Delmon Young, one average year of JJ Hardy and the only guy still around is Meyer who if he becomes an average bullpen arm it will be a "success" at this point.
October 14, 201511 yr Good read. I just hope the Twins failure at trade doesn't dissuade them trading in the future.
October 14, 201511 yr In the meantime we gave up guys like Span, Gomez, Ortiz, Garza, Santana all with plenty of time left in the org for the cheap and got back a combined: 1 year of good play by Delmon Young, one average year of JJ Hardy and the only guy still around is Meyer who if he becomes an average bullpen arm it will be a "success" at this point.Yeah, leaving out one guy like those, Revere, who brought back one guy, May*, who might yet spoil this narrative to any degree. * Also Worley, so, well, yeah.
October 14, 201511 yr Might be hard to spin this sow's ear into a silk purse. Rather damning for the front office and scouting department.
October 14, 201511 yr The luster of the aj trade wore off over 5 years ago for me. It's plain to see to everyone is outside of MN where they lack is evolution. It seems there has been an increasing amount of negative ink about the fundamental flaws of twins organization. I wonder if the right people will begin to take notice?
October 14, 201511 yr Well, nice to see a critique that says the Twins are good at drafting and developing talent. I thought that was the reason the Twins were bad. We'll be fine. Besides the AJ trade, Ryan collected Milton, Silva, Punto, Ortiz, Bartlett, Lohse, Guerrier, Stewart, Guzman, Ford, Liriano, Castillo and Casilla.
October 14, 201511 yr Well, nice to see a critique that says the Twins are good at drafting and developing talent. I thought that was the reason the Twins were bad. We'll be fine. Besides the AJ trade, Ryan collected Milton, Silva, Punto, Ortiz, Bartlett, Lohse, Guerrier, Stewart, Guzman, Ford, Liriano, Castillo and Casilla. Did you even read the article, where it compares to how OTHER teams did? Because it clearly states they aren't good at acquiring outside talent relative to other teams.
October 14, 201511 yr Did you even read the article, where it compares to how OTHER teams did? Because it clearly states they aren't good at acquiring outside talent relative to other teams.Yeah, I read it but it's dubious. We'll be fine.
October 14, 201511 yr It wasn't the greatest study, but you seem to be dismissing it because it doesn't fit your beliefs, not because it is invalid.
October 14, 201511 yr It wasn't the greatest study, but you seem to be dismissing it because it doesn't fit your beliefs, not because it is invalid.How much weight should I give it? We have past history that shows our GM has been pretty good about this. The team's clearly on the right track and seems to be doing things correctly. I'm not sure what to do with a piece like that. We'll be fine.
October 14, 201511 yr Or be like Boston: Crawford, Sandoval, Ramirez.Break the bank and it doesn't always yield gold."Homegrown is good," Neil Young.
October 14, 201511 yr I came across this article that discusses the Twins futility in obtaining talent from outside the organization. I have not seen it referenced here. There have been a number of threads this years that touched on a similar theme. "There are two ways to build a baseball team, and the Twins are not good at one of them" written by Bryan Grosnick on SB Nation http://www.beyondtheboxscore.com/2015/10/9/9337965/minnesota-twins-good-at-drafting-and-developing-bad-at-everything-else This makes total sense from experience. Completely agree. Terry Ryan et al are great at drafting and developing, and mostly horrible at trading/FA. All the more reason to put the thumb on the scale in NOT trading our prospects for established players. Edited October 14, 201511 yr by nytwinsfan
October 14, 201511 yr Well, nice to see a critique that says the Twins are good at drafting and developing talent. I thought that was the reason the Twins were bad. We'll be fine. Besides the AJ trade, Ryan collected Milton, Silva, Punto, Ortiz, Bartlett, Lohse, Guerrier, Stewart, Guzman, Ford, Liriano, Castillo and Casilla. Guerrier was a waiver claim. That list was compiled over 20 years, back to when Rule 5 and draft compensation rules were different. Ortiz was going to be Rule 5 eligible a year earlier than he would now. When we dealt Greg Swindell, he returned draft pick compensation to Boston a few months later. And with only 12 guys on your list, over 20 years, you're still reaching down to the Ford/Casilla level of useful spare parts for a couple seasons. Plus 5 of those guys came directly or indirectly thanks to the trade of a 29 year old star as we were slashing payroll preparing for a franchise sale/move/contraction -- think TR will get that opportunity again?
October 14, 201511 yr TR will get that opportunity again?I think Ryan will get the opportunity to make this a pretty successful team. Again.
October 14, 201511 yr Guerrier was a waiver claim. That list was compiled over 20 years, back to when Rule 5 and draft compensation rules were different. Ortiz was going to be Rule 5 eligible a year earlier than he would now. When we dealt Greg Swindell, he returned draft pick compensation to Boston a few months later. And with only 12 guys on your list, over 20 years, you're still reaching down to the Ford/Casilla level of useful spare parts for a couple seasons. Plus 5 of those guys came directly or indirectly thanks to the trade of a 29 year old star as we were slashing payroll preparing for a franchise sale/move/contraction -- think TR will get that opportunity again?Plus a nitpic: Liriano was not "besides the AJ trade." He came in the AJ trade.
October 14, 201511 yr I think Ryan will get the opportunity to make this a pretty successful team. Again. Was that the question?
October 16, 201511 yr I disagree with the article. When Terry Ryan makes a trade, They usually turn out in our favor. Getting Escobar for 2 months of Liriano was a heist. May for Revere is turning into a good one. Most of the acquisition the article laments were actually good lower cost moves that worked out. From using the Stat lines from the article is that we don't trade for core players and so what if we don't do that.
October 16, 201511 yr I disagree with the article. When Terry Ryan makes a trade, They usually turn out in our favor. Getting Escobar for 2 months of Liriano was a heist. May for Revere is turning into a good one. Most of the acquisition the article laments were actually good lower cost moves that worked out. From using the Stat lines from the article is that we don't trade for core players and so what if we don't do that. Isn't that the point of the article? They don't build well from trades compared to other teams?
October 16, 201511 yr I think Ryan will get the opportunity to make this a pretty successful team. Again.Since he is GM, he gets that opportunity every day
October 16, 201511 yr I thinks trades have been TRs strength over the years so I disagree with the premise of the article. He doesn't trade that much but that is not necessarily a bad thing.
October 16, 201511 yr Judging a GM only on trades or only on free agent signing or only on draft picks, does not make any sense. If there were a singular thing a GM chould be judged on is World Championships and World Series appearances. Ryan is oh for 17 in those metrics. But there is isn't. Ryan did make a couple of good trades, did botch a couple of others, did sign a couple of decent free agents and did sign a bunch of bad ones and let a future hall of famer go. The thing with Ryan is risk adversity. And it shows in many ways: Will not make a blockbuster, will not trade players and prospects at the peak of their value and will not sign top of the line free agents. Instead he will make small, corrective type of moves of medium risk, medium reward. That's ok if you have a team like the Yankees had a decade ago. Not ok for the 2010s Twins... Got to risk something to get a high reward. Too bad that this piece does not get this and does not look at the big picture here... Cannot look at trades in a vacuum Edited October 16, 201511 yr by Thrylos
October 16, 201511 yr The article doesn't judge him solely on that. It clearly states they are good at drafting and developing players. It is an article about trading, how well the Twins do at adding impact players from trades. It is not a 1000 page treatise on Ryan's record overall.
October 16, 201511 yr Judging a GM only on trades or only on free agent signing or only on draft picks, does not make any sense. If there were a singular thing a GM chould be judged on is World Championships and World Series appearances. Ryan is oh for 17 in those metrics. But there is isn't. Ryan did make a couple of good trades, did botch a couple of others, did sign a couple of decent free agents and did sign a bunch of bad ones and let a future hall of famer go. The thing with Ryan is risk adversity. And it shows in many ways: Will not make a blockbuster, will not trade players and prospects at the peak of their value and will not sign top of the line free agents. Instead he will make small, corrective type of moves of medium risk, medium reward. That's ok if you have a team like the Yankees had a decade ago. Not ok for the 2010s Twins... Got to risk something to get a high reward. Too bad that this piece does not get this and does not look at the big picture here... Cannot look at trades in a vacuumYou say this with such conviction. The Minnesota Twins organization is a business. I could come up with a half dozen things would without question be more important to judging a GM than World Series Appearances.1. Leadership2. Financial Performance3. Managing / Elevating the Twins Brand4. Risk Mitigation5. Asset Management – Primarily related to minor league development given the Twins revenue relative to the top markets.6. Developing methodologies that provide competitive advantage (Saber Metrics / Scouting, etc)T The exact six measures are debatable but this is a business and the people who run them measure success differently than fans. Edited October 16, 201511 yr by Major Leauge Ready
October 16, 201511 yr You say this with such conviction. The Minnesota Twins organization is a business. I could come up with a half dozen things would without question be more important to judging a GM than World Series Appearances.1. Leadership2. Financial Performance3. Managing / Elevating the Twins Brand4. Risk Mitigation5. Asset Management – Primarily related to minor league development given the Twins revenue relative to the top markets.6. Developing methodologies that provide competitive advantage (Saber Metrics / Scouting, etc)T The exact six measures are debatable but this is a business and the people who run them measure success differently than fans. In your list, isn't 2 really the end and the rest the means towards that end? And wouldn't making to and winning world series be the biggest driver for number 2? Lots of data on that. On field performance translates to financial performance in professional sports. Edited October 16, 201511 yr by Thrylos
October 16, 201511 yr Yeah other than the lucky Liriano/Nathan/Boof trade the Twins have been quite poor at acquiring talent from other teams, they had an awesome talent in Gomez but foolishly gave him up because he didn't fit the "twins way" which 1 year later turned into Jim Hooey. In the meantime we gave up guys like Span, Gomez, Ortiz, Garza, Santana all with plenty of time left in the org for the cheap and got back a combined: 1 year of good play by Delmon Young, one average year of JJ Hardy and the only guy still around is Meyer who if he becomes an average bullpen arm it will be a "success" at this point.Of course you fail to factor in the fact that Gomez, Ortiz & Santana were also all acquired from other organizations.
October 16, 201511 yr Of course you fail to factor in the fact that Gomez, Ortiz & Santana were also all acquired from other organizations. I try every day not to raise the fact the Twins gave up on Gomez and Hardy, but we can go there if people want....
Create an account or sign in to comment