Everything posted by Platoon
-
Front Page: A Three-Step Plan to Drastically Improve the Twins' Infield Defense in 2020
I like the idea overall. I don't think that throwing from third is any farther than from SS in many instances. And less in some. Also, it seems to me that the harder the ball is hit and the less time Polanco has to react to it the better he plays. The 3 hoppers eat him up, as do the tag plays at second base. Bottom line, he is a good hitter and a lousy SS. Whether this particular move is a good idea, or is made, I hope the day does not come when MLB becomes an all bat game, and defense is simply something to do before your next AB!
-
Trivia
Why would he introduce Bert to his wife? Shouldn't he have already known who she was?
-
Planning the Twins Winter Moves
Briefly, I am all in on doing the best we can to get some quality SP. at least one who precedes Berrios. I think two is asking a lot. After that, don't spend money on pitchers, just to spend money on pitchers. I do think the offense should be fine, but it's at the expense of the defense, with the exception of the outfield. But since every position from the OF grass to the backstop is so defensively challenged, I am not sure how one can correct that without massive trades? But without dominant pitching, mediocre defense is more problematic than it should be.
-
Front Page: "Robot Umpires" Coming to Some Affiliated Parks Next Season
Well if they are I feel Mitch Garver will be one of the lower paid catchers in baseball year after year. I wish that we would put as much expectation on the players as we do on the officials. Don't get me wrong, I have barked at many an umpire in my life, way many. But that does not change the fact that we expect perfection from them, and at the same time seem quite enthralled with an entire infield that can do only one half of their proscribed duties, the offensive half, with any apparent proficiency. We are enthralled with a catcher who can hit, but couldn't block a four year old from getting into the candy drawer. A cleanup hitter who swings at pitches in a different zip code. But have an umpire miss some close pitches, even say 10 out of 250, and we want to mechanize it? For the players we cheer lustily for their successes and excuse their faults. For the officials we ignore their abilities, and demean their mistakes.
-
Front Page: "Robot Umpires" Coming to Some Affiliated Parks Next Season
I am sick of lots of stats........ Why? Because they are simply new ways to emphasize, and yes account for, things that have been baseball staples for years. And I imagine a lot of fans enjoy fine tuning the numbers. Anyone who has ever played, umpired, or even watched with attentiveness has known for years the value of framing. And it doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that some catchers just aren't good at it. Nor do I need exit velocity, launch angle, and spin rate to know that the harder you hit the ball, in the air the further it will go. And the more revolutions you can impact unto a baseball the quicker and further it will change course. Oh, btw, just to be clear none of the above causes me to change my dislike of the Robo ump possibility.
-
Front Page: "Robot Umpires" Coming to Some Affiliated Parks Next Season
In RU3 a RoboNator comes back from the future to kill a 14 year old Manfred before he can start his insidious destruction of baseball with replays of shoelaces still touching the bag, a helium filled baseball in 2019, and instigating the original Robo Ump 1. It all started innocently. Simple fair or foul. Then everything was up for review by some faceless nameless and apparently AI dimished human bot in NY. Soon the sight of two guys listening on headsets next to the dugout with a quizzical look on there face caused mass confusion. What took so long? It couldn't be the Nixon tapes, the missing gap was only 18 seconds. The newest long lost Elvis release? The audio book of War and Peace? (I date myself) Eventually as is now obvious Rob survives and RU3 is taken out by by his own lack of awareness. Having transformed himself into a beer vendor on opening day, RU3 discovered what all TD readers and posters already know. Beer, especially spilt beer and electronics don't mix! One slip pouring a double 12 oz. cup ($24.00 at Twins games) was all it took. Once the smoke from the short circuit cleared there was nothing left but a small puddle of warm, stale PBR. And Manfreds campaign to destroy our National Pastime moved forward, unabated by common sense, or the AI it spawned!
-
Front Page: "Robot Umpires" Coming to Some Affiliated Parks Next Season
The NFL also replays whether balls are catches, or ground assisted. Or whether both feet touched down inside the line? And you still cannot get total agreement on some of those calls. I dont know is some of the pro Robo crowd are expecting controversy to end due to electronic balls and strikes. If so, they will be sorely disappointed.
-
Front Page: "Robot Umpires" Coming to Some Affiliated Parks Next Season
IIRC in the Atlantic league the plate umpire could overrule a "mistake" by the bot? Seems odd that such perfection would need correction by a mere mortal? I imagine Robo umps are coming. I really do not think they will improve the game. Something will be lost. That said, I will gladly be on board with Robo perfection once the players all play and the managers all manage to perfection, and the vendors don't spill any beer. Why do we expect perfection from 4 guys on the field, and not from the other 30,000 in the stadium? I would think that the fiascos the NFL is going through attempting to perfect football officiating would be enough forewarning?
-
Front Page: A Case for Signing Yasmani Grandal
I could easily get behind this idea.......
-
Twins hitting over 300 HRs
Since numerous teams hit more home runs than usual the most obvious reason is the Titleist 3 that replaced the normal MLB baseball. It's true that the odd part is that the Twins hit the most. There is no doubt the maturation of some younger players also contributed. And, there is no doubt that there are players who hit HR's way above their pay scale this year. I didn't do the math, but I think Garver, for example, would extrapolate into a 50 HR hitter given a full season of AB's. I can't really believe anyone thinks he is that level power hitter. Castro and Kepler were over their heads also.Edit: I just did the math. Garver hit .33 HR per game, which in a full season = 54. This year he played in 93 games and hit 31 Bombas. Last year he played in 102 games and hit SEVEN. While he actually had 24 fewer plate appearances in 2018, that doe not account for the difference whatsoever.
-
Thoughts on Robo Umps by the people most affected!
Interesting article in Wapo about the plate umpiring, the players and managers thoughts on it, and some comparisons to the unintended consequences the NFL is dealing with due to an expansion of electronic officiating. https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2019/10/28/game-umpire-controversy-raises-question-should-mlb-use-an-electronic-system-make-calls/?wpisrc=nl_most&wpmm=1
-
Front Page: The Uncertain Future Of Nick Gordon
That they did. It's sort of a shame they couldn't have made it 104 games. Or maybe 103? Or even 102? They had a great offensive year, along with something like 20 other teams and the company that makes MLB baseballs. But that does not hide the fact that this isn't a good defensive baseball team. Those flaws were painfully exposed in the playoffs. Those deficiencies coupled with more or less the same level pitching, and one had better hope that the Bombas continue at a high level.
-
Front Page: Statcast Wants C.J. Cron Back – Do You?
There were lots of stats explaining how well Cron hit the ball and wasn't rewarded for his above league average efforts. There was little mention of how his defensive shortcomings contribute to the less than stellar performance of he other three infielders. I realize that 1B is a bat first postion. But considering the question marks surrounding the pitching staff, some consideration has to be given to improving the teams defense. Somewhere! Since we seem locked in on Sano, Polanco, and Arrez it doesn't seem that defense will be addressed next year, yet again
-
Front Page: The Uncertain Future Of Nick Gordon
If I was a MLB FA pitcher and someone offered me a chance to pitch in front of the Twins IF, and frankly their catchers, I would have to give serious thought to the wisdom of that idea. Oh they can hit, but that is one awful looking IF. It's almost inconceivable that this orginisation cannot draft and develop a SS who doesn't need his offensive prowess to justify his playing that position?
-
WHAT IF: George Springer had signed with the Twins
I think George Springer is a wonderful ball player. But WHAT IF George Springer had ran out of the box on that double instead or posing for 40'? WHAT IF he had ended up at third and scored on that one out FB to RF? Springer would still look good in a Twins uni, but that was a mistake. I wonder what TD would look like today if it had been a Twins WS and it had been Eddie?
-
Moving Eddie Rosario, but Where?
I have been an Edde fan, but this year his play and his seeming blasé attitude have been sometimes confounding. But to really know what's up one would need to know the answers to two questions, the true answers which we will never find out. First is how his legs really were. Season long nagging injury? Or not? Second was his apparent non chalance driven by a dislike for being forced to RF? This questions isn't in defense of such dislike, it's meant to analyze his actual behavior and results.
-
Front Page: Hot Corner Consideration: Potential Third Base Alternatives to Miguel Sano
IF the rest of the infield wasn't so god awful lousy you could probably do what has been done for ages in baseball at all levels. Good defense in the middle, and offense on the corners. I know the shifts change the dynamics to an extent, but the fundamental still is applicable. If Polanco and Arrez weren't so glove challenged I imagine Sano wouldn't be such a problem defensively at third. That and the fact that Mauers glove is missed far more than many had anticipated at the top of the year. Those who had salivated for years wishing for more power at 1B now have comparison to judge the benefits of someone who can catch a baseball at the at position v someone who will hit a few more HR's.
-
Front Page: ALDS Takeaways, Part 5: How Does Anyone Hit Anything These Days?
The Twins had a wonderful season hitting the ball. Those numbers were accumulated over 162 games, many of which were played against the KC, Chicago, Detroit, and Blatimores of the world. Last time I looked those teams weren't in the playofs. In playoff baseball defense is likely the easiest to replicate from the regular season. Then likely pitching. By far the least likely tool to duplicate into the post season is offense. I really don't think the Twins diminished output should have surprised anyone.
-
Front Page: Can the Twins Become the New Astros? Part 1
Well once the last Trogosaurus has been turned into crude oil, everyone really won't be in the same place. The "haves" will be more likely to add depth and talent to their teams via free agency and expensive extensions. The "have nots" will not. While everyone may be in the same place in the future, they may not be able to remain there.
-
Front Page: ALDS Takeaways, Part 4: Sluggers Go Close Together
Putting your top three hitters in a bunch near the top of the order is something I wish the 1965 Twins had thought of. . I always see mentions of where players hit in the order makes no difference? But actually it does. Which is why playing the regular season in one manner and the playoff batting order in another is puzzling. There will be two other factors in place next year. The afore posted three hitter minimum somewhat mitigates the need for LRLR. And of course which baseball will MLB dig out of the closet next year. In principle I don't disagree with the OP, but I would prefer two OB guys up first. Say Averrez (sp) and Polanco. Then probably Cruz, Garver, and Sano. Or switch Garver and Cruz. Sano IMHO remains the power hitter I would most like to oppose in a big situation. He is 5 times more likely to SO than homer. And he still has not been able to calm himself in big situations. A 5 run HR often seems his thought process. Those are odds I can work with. The Twins didn't lose only because the wind blew more into LF, or the RF porch in Yankee stadium is ridiculously close to home plate. They lost because the Yankees had a better pen, one better SP at least and a far superior defense. The defensive gap alone was enough to turn the series their way.
-
Front Page: ALDS Takeaways, Part 3: Rocco Baldelli and His Security Blankets
I would have used Duffy the same way I did during the season. I say this even though I was concerned he might revert to his "deer in the headlights" look of previous years. But he had earned the chance this year, and one has to have someone to fill that spot. On this team that was him. As for Dobnak and Littel? No way that Dobnak starts in NY. FB v GB ratio be damned. He had no chance in those bright lights. Put him in the friendly confines of Target Field. Zach Littel was not the man for that slot either. May preferably and Romo if I didn't trust May. But that screws up the game in later innings.
-
Minnesota Twins Off-Season Timeline Fortune Telling
10/14: Jim Pohlad quoted in a Sid Hartman column "there will be no restrictions on payroll">>>>>>>> For some reason I thought I had read this quote from one of Sid's previous columns, so I looked back. I found it in 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015............................... 1964, 1963, 1962, and 1961. While I assme it was Calvin and Carl who issued the earlier quotes, the fact that the Twins have always been a family run enterprise may explain the fact that Sid has never quoted ownership in full. The words "to family members" was either consciously omitted, or in a more likely scenario Sid didn't have his hearing aid turned all the way up? .
-
Postseason Perils Provide Reality for Twins
As Derek Falvey and Thad Levine look to build a consistent winner, their goal will be in the form of projectable success. While owning one of the best farm systems in baseball, and now having a Major League roster flush with controllable talent, they’ll look to stack the deck in their favor for years to come. Rather than sacrificing high level assets for a fleeting hope or additional percentage points, they’ll be calculated and well thought out in pushing for consistency.>>>>>>>> This. The Twins will have to and should build from within. They don't have the money to instantly "buy" a winner. But good scouting, good coaching, and good orginisational structure can make the a Twins consistently competitive. Thinking the Twins can or will match the Yankess and Dodgers spending are ignoring math and history. As I noted in another post, this roster is far from one SP and one RP away from the top bracket.
-
The DJ At Target Field
I have first hand experience in this matter. While coaching a youth team in the championship game for our local league. Apparently the game coincided with a local town celebration, and the Over 60 municipal band decided to play at the park. They chose as their location the bleachers behind the third base bench. Apparently unawares of baseball etiquette they would play during an ongoing at bat, or any other action that got in their way. You could not hear the umpires balls and strikes, you could not hear the ball hit the bat, and you could not converse with your players. I finally asked the home town, plate ump to see if they could restrict their talents to between innings. Which he did, and they agreed to. I on the other hand was roundly booed but the locals, which at that level I imagine was some sort of first. maybe that's why to this day I absolutely abhor loud grating music at sporting events. IF you have to make artificial noise to excite your fans, maybe you should consider the fact that your team isn't very entertaining on its own.
-
Rocco: "I'm not frustrated at all"
Like everybody, I like managers who let it all hang out at pressers. And pregame interviews. Let's the fans and players know exactly where they stand. The White Sox had one a few years ago, he was really forthright. But I think he retired or something, haven't seen him in quite awhile?