Everything posted by USAFChief
-
Impact of Defense
But this is all supposed to relate to runs, right? And there have been numerous posts in this very thread speculating that the reason, say, Franklin Gutierrez can go from average to spectacular and back again is because of those hard to make plays. 50 one year, 25 the next, etc. I believe you might have even agreed with that. So I'm confused. Although I agree on Span!
-
Impact of Defense
Right, and he was credited with making 97.6% of those 206 chances, or 201. That's 5 plays. Five outs, compared to the leader, Markakis, over the course of a season. Two or three fewer outs than the RFers in the middle of that category. He was rated as average or above average on the other 40 combined, right? So we'll be conservative and give him one out back. That leaves us we a delta of between 4 and 1 outs.
-
Impact of Defense
That list defaults to the last category, the 90-100% list. In which case, Hunter's 97.6% is indeed last of 16, and would be a difference of something like 5 or 6 catches from Nick Markakis' 100%. Maybe 3 catches from being middle of the pack. But if you click on the other categories, Hunter ranges from 5th to 9th. Average to above average everywhere else. He would have an extra catch or so and make up the difference. In total, that seems to indicate to me, average.
-
Impact of Defense
Perhaps I'm mistaken...got a link?
-
Impact of Defense
If we choose Inside Edge Fielding as our metric du jour, Hunter is just fine. Maybe even slightly above average in 2014.
-
Bracket Challenge for TD
Solidly in a tie for 14th currently. I do have the most possible points remaining though, so I got that going for me. Which is nice.
-
Impact of Defense
And therein lies the crux of our discussion. You and many others take your statement as factual. You might very well be proven correct. To me, your statement requires a leap of faith that I'm not ready to make yet. I don't trust the data collection, and I don't fully agree with the design of the measurement systems. I'm troubled by the fact there are multiple measurement systems out there, and they often don't agree. I believe there is more to defense than just range. I doubt the impact on runs from a corner outfielder is as large as a middle infielder at the major league level. And that's fine. We'll both enjoy watching the coming baseball season, and if we end up at a game together I'll buy the first beer*, where we can argue some more in person. *EDIT: and maybe even a hot dog. But no GD sushi. That doesn't belong at a ballpark...can we at least agree on that?
-
"like"
Like!
-
"like"
Test.
-
Impact of Defense
Honest question, because I don't know the answer: Lets say Arcia gets 250 lazy fly balls hit to him in left this year, and every one is hit right to him. He hardly has to move all year, and catches all 250. What would his UZR be?
-
Impact of Defense
Because we can be absolutely positive it's not the measurement system?
-
Impact of Defense
I would, in fact, cite this as a "preconceived notion." The statement is not a "fact." It is the opinion of the author. How does he know this to be factual? He only knows that the measurement system he designed, or advocates, sometimes shows wild fluctuations. It seems to me the default answer for those fluctuations shouldn't be "it can't be the way we're measuring, so defensive performance must vary like offensive performance."
-
Impact of Defense
I think it might be fair to say all sides of this discussion have some preconceived notions about defensive metrics.
-
Article: Sorting Out The Bullpen
That doesn't sound correct to me. For example, a player with 10 and 5 rights cannot be traded, including through a DFA, so I would assume if there's still a rule preventing trading a newly signed FA, that would also prevent a trade through a DFA. I would assume a player can waive that rule if he chooses, though.
-
Impact of Defense
Fair enough. I will wait for something I trust.
-
Impact of Defense
What IS UZR trying to do? By all means, please include all the detailed math you feel necessary. I think it's fair for me to examine the math, though, and if I think it doesn't add up, to ask for clarification. For example, if you try to convince me that there's nothing odd about numbers that appear odd at first blush, I will examine the use of hypotheticals to explain those odd numbers. Particularly when they are not only hypotheticals, but hypotheticals based on numbers that are themselves at best questionable, at worst complete exaggeration s used to make a point seem stronger.
- Article: Sorting Out The Bullpen
-
ST Games #16 & 17 (split squad): Orioles @ Twins, Twins @ Rays, 12:05 CT
Not if they turn two on the grounder to second.
-
Impact of Defense
I don't think it was one error, but whatever. It seems at odds with the whole "it's science' argument to argue "don't let the math cloud the issue," no? "Maybe this" or "possibly that" are at odds with the entire premise of saber metrics.
-
Impact of Defense
I agree judging defense is difficult for fans. Perhaps too difficult. I think it is much less difficult for team officials--managers, GMs, even players--who spend a great deal of time around the game and probably have a pretty good idea of what good defense looks like. I also don't take on faith that UZR is "the best option currently available." Maybe it is, but how would we know that? Compared to what? Even if I grant that UZR is the best option available, then what? What does that tell us? What should it be used for? If I knew that 20 MLB teams were using UZR to make playing time decisions, I'd take it more seriously.
-
Impact of Defense
Your honor, the prosecution will stipulate to the fact the proponents of UZR think its great.
-
Impact of Defense
Help me with the math, please. Which CFers had 500 chances last year? The run value of a single is .75? Where did you get the "opportunity" numbers from? Help me with theory, please. Are we sure a season of Gary Matthews Jr and Vernon Wells can really change the baseline? I thought UZR was based off a rolling average of plays made and not made over 6 years..is that incorrect? If so, a season of those two should have very little impact on Franklin Gutierrez, correct? Maybe no impact at all, unless you believe CF never had players like Matthews and Wells before, and never will again? EDIT: thanks Jimmer, for posting the primer below and confirming the six year rolling data used for comparison. That seems to rule out "other bad CFer" as a possible cause for the wild swings in Gutierrez' UZR, no?
-
Robinson's out-clause
I don't like to compare players using WAR, because I don't think it's very useful, but since you brought it up...as I understand it, about 1/3 of Dyson's WAR is solely due to him standing in CF, right? You don't have him in CF in your above scenario. So wouldn't you need to lop off a good portion of that WAR were he a Twin and standing in LF or RF?
-
Bracket Challenge for TD
Don't feel bad. I had the Gophers into the regional final.
-
Robinson's out-clause
I guess I would rather Arcia and Vargas get full time jobs, or nearly full time jobs, so they get the best chance to develop into something, or play themselves out of the picture. Same with Rosario...wherever he's at, he needs to be playing every day. Mauer would be at first base 155 games, so not much room for Vargas there, either. And Dyson....I think Dyson would be an acceptable 4th outfielder, but he's not someone I'd pursue, nor would he ever take playing time away from any of Rosario, Vargas or Arcia. Or Hicks, for that matter, if Hicks is on the team. He's 30. Can't hit, won't run as fast in the near future.