Everything posted by Deduno Abides
-
What About - Trade Sano, Keep Plouffe?
Was Sano's agent the source for this idea?
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/21): Walker Powers Wings
Agree 100%. Culture starts at the top. If lower levels, less involved with the top, do well, but start falling as they get closer to the top, it's a pretty good sign that the top is setting the wrong tone or direction.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/21): Walker Powers Wings
Let's stop blaming the players. It's clear that some teams do better than others in helping players succeed as they enter the majors. It's why more and more teams have mental counsellors. It doesn't imply some kind of "mental weakness." It simply means that performing in sports is high stress and everything the team can do to improve the environment will be to everyone's benefit. With the Twins, there is little indication of awareness of the mental side and lots of behaviors that would increase a player's stress. What causes stress? Criticism by your GM or manager in the newspaper, not feeling you get a fair shot, the feeling that you're supposed to immediately solve a major problem, believing that you are more capable than the people who got the job. Most mentally tough people will still perform below their abilities in bad environments. Further, players with lower levels of mental toughness might still have great skills. It's a much better investment to figure out to help those players succeed than it is to write them off as not having the mental makeup to succeed.
-
What's Wrong with Brian Dozier?
Last things I'll say on this thread. The book on Dozier was known before last year started. Some writers had him as a top pick to regress. It would have been good to get when the getting was good. Bill Belichek: trades players a year too soon, instead of a year too late; goes to playoffs routinely and wins multiple championships. Twins: generally hang on to players until after their peaks; on a historic run of futility. Keep bringing up that one time 15 years ago when the strategy worked enough to win one playoff series.
-
What's Wrong with Brian Dozier?
In 2015, it was forecastable that Dozier would be on the downside in 2017. If Sano, etc. were two years behind, you're saying it would be a good idea to hang onto someone entering his downside when the other players are ready. The amount of team control matters more for establishing the value you get in return than the value of the player to your team. Arguing about trading "everybody" is a red herring. This discussion is about trading one player when he was at his highest value, who is already in his prime years, when the window of contention is realistically two years away and a younger (and cheaper) replacement is soon to be available. The closest analogy is A.J. Pierzynski. Denard Span is not as good a comparison, because he was traded when his value was low, but even then, right now, I'd rather have an exciting AA pitcher than Dozier.
-
What's Wrong with Brian Dozier?
You also do it with guys who bust out when they are already in their prime years, especially when the rest of the team is a few years behind them and you have an exciting replacement coming. If you don't trade these players, you never get anything good back, especially if you wait until it appears they have lost value. As far as terrible messages go, we're seeing a lot worse, including the messages that veterans with good contracts keep their jobs and better players sit on the bench. At least with trading him and giving the next guy a shot, you're telling someone he can earn a job other than by being a replacement for an injury or a failure.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/21): Walker Powers Wings
Total guess: Berrios has developed some anxiety and resentment this year, which is causing him to try to be perfect and resulting in overthrowing. I also guess that May and Meyer have similar issues. It's not unusual for young talent that knows it's better than people higher on the organization chart to get a little mentally off if they don't think they're given the shot they deserve.
-
What's Wrong with Brian Dozier?
You should sell high when the rest of your team isn't ready when you manage on a cycle, like the Twins do. Playoffs were a stretch goal last year that came in sight due to great "clutch" statistics, which can end as quickly as they start. With the pitching staff last year, the team was, at best, going to go 0-3 in the playoffs. Further, the book on Dozier was known; what remains a mystery is why teams didn't start read it until the All Star game. Nonetheless, he would definitely obtain less value in trade today than he would have 12 months ago. Keeping Dozier shows the long-term cost of getting caught up in short-term excitement.
- What's Wrong with Brian Dozier?
- Game Thread, Blue Jays v. Twins May 22 1:10pm
- Game Thread, Blue Jays v. Twins May 22 1:10pm
- Game Thread, Blue Jays v. Twins May 22 1:10pm
-
Game Thread, Blue Jays v. Twins May 22 1:10pm
What good is an analytics department if they can't understand that a sub .300 OBP makes for a bad lead-off hitter? Look at the Jays. Bautista and Donaldson are not traditional No. 1 and 2 batters, but they are likely to produce the most runs, so they bat first so they will get the most at bats.
-
About time to extend Grossman?
I don't mind a mildly positive comment about any player on the team and I'm definitely not going to get out of shape because TR called Grossman "OK." What I can't stand, however, are the constant public call-outs of developing players, like TR's recent comments in Berardino's Twitter about Kepler and Buxton. No player has ever gotten better because he read a snarky comment from management to Berardino, LEN3, Souhan or anyone else. It has a 100% "not-effective" score, but it seems to be a constant part of the Twins' player development culture.
-
Article: Troubled Youth
You mean "developers" of talent, don't you? Guys leave the Twins and succeed. Neutral evaluators give high marks to the collected talent. They're just not progressing like they would with a league average development team. Wasn't Goins on here about a year ago to explain why they were wise not to implement video review in the minors until last or 2014? As if modern 20-year olds struggle to understand how to use video. They can try to claim credit all they want for being cheap and behind the times, but the proof is on the field.
-
Everyday Joe Hurts Mauer Most
Baggy, great insight that Mauer needs more days off. He'd probably be a lot better if he played 4-5 days a week instead of 6-7.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/19): Walker, Kepler Put On A Show
Some great and tough players used to get hurt all the time. Check out George Brett and Kirk Gibson. My guess is that the pain isn't debilitating, but the annoyance may be enough to possibly cause him to alter something. He needs to perfect his swing. Practicing an imperfect motion would be worse than not practicing at all.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/19): Walker, Kepler Put On A Show
Inconceivable!
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Tomorrow Tyler Duffey pitches. He has options. If he pitches well, he's the new stopper. If he pitches poorly, it's back to Rochester.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
You don't have to feel him, just sign him to play CF.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Willie Norwood might be an upgrade, and he's probably 60 years old.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Nevermind.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Never heard of this Toronto pitcher. Maybe he doesn't know where not to pitch to Dozier.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Suzuki, Santana and Dozier coming up, batting a collective.681. Could we trade them for two guys batting.340?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 5/19 @ 7:10pm CT
Every night, someone steps up to bring the loss in. It's a whole team coming together in pursuit of one goal.