Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Article: Twins 2015 Minor League Relief Pitcher of the Year - Trevor Hildenberger
1* a nice list and some impressive numbers and performances. (Minus a couple high BB totals) Overall depth is even more impressive when you notice some talented arms that aren't on the list. Plus the hopeful return of Melotakis. (?) 2* no question JT is a great story! But how about Bard? Low A or not, his coming back and performing so well might be a better one. 3* these guys plus others not listed, and several milb SP options should bode well for the Twins bullpen in the immediate as well as the future. I just hope they don't get complacent and choose to do nothing this offseason. Another good arm or two could really set the Twins bullpen up for a strong 2016.
-
Article: Twins 2015 Minor League Starting Pitcher Of The Year- Jose Berrios
Been a huge fan and believer in Berrios since day one. From the very start there's just been something tough and determined about him. My fear isn't whether or not he breaks camp with the Twins or not. No. Day one or a month in, he'll be up...he'll contribute...and he'll be important. My fear is that with what the Twins have on roster now, plus the addition of Berrios, they might be tempted to keep May in the bullpen rather than look for an addition from elsewhere. And that would be a cry in' shame. Next to Berrios...and possibly right beside him...he's arguably the team's top young SP...at least from the RH side...major or milb level.
- Article: Twins 2015 Minor League Starting Pitcher Of The Year- Jose Berrios
-
Escobar's slash line since the Santana demotion
Look, I'm not dismissing other people's opinions...nor am I comparing two gentlemen as being equals necessarily...but...remember when rumors of the Twins trading for Tulo ran rampant? I was against such a move due to the cost of prospects as well as years and dollars owed financially. And I was, originally, in the Santana camp to open the season based on potential, overall athleticism and what he did last season. But I was also in full agreement that Escobar should be the guy, and should have been the guy sooner than the move was made. And now where are we today? Toronto gave up prospects and is on the hook for an over 30 veteran who has struggled past his initial appearances, has struggled with injury, and is still owed multiple years at $20M per. Meanwhile, Escobar is years younger, multiple millions of dollars cheaper, is playing quality defense, providing above average offense, and is proving 2014 and his ST of this season weren't a fluke. What I'm saying is, sometimes the smart play isn't the big gamble or big move. Rather, it can sometimes be patience and just plugging the right man in the right job.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/12): Polanco Blast Not Enough
-
What a James Shields Trade Could Look Like
Ok....take Nolasco completely out of the equation. Traded, released, whatever. Your SP rotation going in to ST 2016: Hughes Santana Gibson May Milone Duffey Berrios Argue and debat as you will concerning a rebounded Hughes, (I think it happens), be ticked off about Santana missing 50 games and a recent rough patch he already seems over...there are no deadbeats there. There are no hanging on by a thread retread "was's" there or AAAA hanging on "never were's". Only 1 of those guys is over 30. That is depth and talent and even youth we haven't had for a long time. An expensive, 34 yo veteran pitcher, showing possible decline, undoubtedly declining sometime soon if not now, and replacing one of these doesn't sound like a lot of help or an upgrade.
-
What does a Plouffe extension look like?
Been saying for a while now I can see he and Sano and Mauer moving around. I think if Plouffe were a FA a few of you might be surprised what kind of offers he would receive. An available 3B who plays above average to good defense? Hit .250-.260 ish with 30 doubles and high teens low HR? There are a lot of teams that could use that. I don't have a problem with trading him though, IF it's a smart deal with a solid and fair return. Sano can play 3rd, just probably not as well right away. That's normal and called a learning curve. But without Plouffe, unless you really believe in someone else internally, I think you look for a vet DH Extension? With 2 more years of control, I just don't think I would. But I wonder, if you were a team trading for him, would you feel better if he was "cost controlled" for the next 3-4 years? As in, you knew what he would cost ahead of time due to said extension.
-
Free Agent Pipe Dream - Matt Wieters
Maybe. Tempting. Orioles might let him walk. But a 29 yo catcher coming off injury no less, is not the same as a 29 yo OF or 2B. Down year, recovering from injury, how much and for how long? If he and his agent are thinking high and long I'm out. I just wouldn't take the chance of paying big bucks to a guy who might be out behind the plate soon and/or regress.
-
What a James Shields Trade Could Look Like
I like Shields. But he's going to start a decline soon, and it might be in early stages already this season. He's also more expensive and for a year longer than Nolasco. Only 2 ways I'd do it. 1) part of a 3 way in some fashion and Shields moves on. 2) if we could trade Nolasco and Santana both. Baseball Christmas is finally arriving. And underneath the tree are a bunch of shiny new pitchers. I don't want to block them with older veterans and huge contracts.
- Article: Twins Minor League Playoff Report (9/9): Kernels Pop Quad Cities in Opener
-
Eddie Rosario's Gold Glove Chances
Yep. Been a hopeful fan, love watching him play, love his potential, but felt he burned his 2014 season and chances for 2015 other than as a late season option. Boy has he proved me wrong! I don't believe the Gold Glove or Silver Slugger awards are as arbitrary as say an All Star appearance. But these awards, even with merit, are still dependent on things such as production and reputation. Rosario, with very little exception, has been nothing but good to excellent defensively thus far. But he doesn't have the rep yet. And despite a 3/4 season that is/should be a quad double in doubles/triples/homers/SB with outstanding defense and a boatload of assists, he hasn't had the big season to garner attention. So not now. Not yet. But I have to disagree with Nick on this one. I don't believe weak-armed guys get a lot of assists because people run on them. I believe it's guys that haven't received the rep yet than get run on...and thus often get assists. Then comes the rep. Then, often but not always, the assists will begin to drop as the rep grows.
-
Gonsalves vs Berrios
First of all, this is not intended to be another debate about Berrios and should he have been brought up and extended, or, should he have been brought up earlier, (which means he'd be at an IP limit now anyway), or, should he have been limited to relief innings in order to save him for the majors, (which I also find severely debatable as it seems to me a top SP prospect should actually be a starter, IMHO). And while we still have the AFL to look forward to, as well as a pair of teams in the milb playoffs...(BTW, is there something wrong with the system when top winning teams don't qualify for the post season because they didn't "win" a first or second half of the season?)...we no longer have our wonderful morning reports to the milb season which is, unfortunately, ended. So I felt it was a good time to bring this subject up. As I stated the other day in another thread, Berrios seems to be something special. I think it's ridiculous to attempt to pronounce him as a future ACE or future #1 because that's just so damn hard to predict or expect. And Berrios IS ahead of Gonsalves right now on prospect lists, as well as higher up in the system, but I have felt since he was drafted that Gonsalves was a potential steal. And despite strong conversation, I also think he's been rather overlooked, at times, because of Berrios' season. Consider the following numbers: 13 W - 3 L 134.1 IP 95 Hits 53 BB. 132 SO 2.01 ERA. .198 AVG 1.10 WHIP WOW! This was at low A and high A for a split season...but...WOW. If not for Berrios, this our top SP prospect and probably milb SP of the year. Berrios and Gonsalves are both 21, relative pups, with Berrios only 6 weeks older. However, professionally, though Berrios is a couple levels higher currently than Gonsalves, he was drafted a year before and has an additional year of pro instruction and experience. And for whatever reason, Gonsalves' second pro season, 2014, was only 14 GS as he spent a bulk of the year in EST for reasons I'm unaware of, or don't recall. These two factors could easily wedge a year and a half discrepancy between the two in regard to level advancement. These two do not have a season that compares directly. HOWEVER, we can, somewhat, compare their third seasons, a full season for both, a split season for both. 2014 for Berrios and the previously listed '15 for Gonsalves. And while it was Berrios' second full season, it was Gonsalves' first, and the levels were slightly different: Berrios at A and AA, Gonsalves A- and A+. Close enough, under all circumstances, to at least pause and compare, I believe. So...Berrios in 2014: 12 W 8 L 140 IP 118 Hits 38 BB. 140 SO .2.76 ERA. 227 AVG 1.11 WHIP Right now, Berrios is further up the ladder rung, with the extra year of pro ball contingency. Whether or not he breaks camp with the Twins to begin next season is debatable, but he will be in the majors in 2016. It is also debatable as to whether Gonsalves will break camp with AA Chattanooga, or begin the season at high A initially before moving up. If it's AA, there's a very good chance he sees Rochester at some point. If it's Ft Myers, his shot at AAA becomes smaller. Or, another way of putting it, Berrios reaches the majors at the ripe old age of 22, while Gonsalves probably doesn't get his first taste of ML Java until he's an ancient 23. Now, the proverbial monkey wrench. Not only is Gonsalves, almost the same age as Berrios, a year to arguably a year and a half behind in professional game experience, but he is also listed as 5" taller, presumably with room to grow and fill out a bit more than the 6' Berrios...(though we know size vs velocity is not a pure correlation, much less pure pitch ability, but it is a factor to consider)...but he is also, of course, left handed. And not only is a LH of quality harder to find, but it has long been believed, and seemingly true, that they take longer to develop. So all things factored, and no disrespect to either extremely talented and important young man...long term...which do you feel may ultimately be the best and most prized, and ultimately, most successful pitcher?
-
Apologize to Bill Smith Thread
This is tough for me to debate, even though a part of me wants to. The problem is, I really didn't know anything about Jepsen before we got him. He kind of slipped under my radar. I liked Hu, and he's a great story. But a top 20 milb, probably after this season anyway, in A ball for a still young-ish reliever like Jepsen who has done what he's done thus far...especially if he can maintain it...I feel pretty good about the trade is all I can say.
-
Apologize to Bill Smith Thread
I'm sorry, home has been erratic since I got home so I don't have time to confirm, so forgive me if I'm off a bit here. But wasn't Young the second pick of his draft, rushed quickly to the majors, (where he still produced) and runner up for ROY? I think the Twins blew the Harris part of the deal. I believe they were short-sighted in regard to how good a player Barlett was going to be, and their lack of a suitable replacement. But Young was a decent young athlete with decent speed, strong arm, and big time potential power. Flaws? Yeah, there probably were some flaws and red flags, (potentially), but there are a lot of rough edges on most youngsters. Especially those who get rushed a bit. I think Smith felt he was getting on on the ground floor of a prospect with a ton of potential. I can't fault him for that.
-
Apologize to Bill Smith Thread
I was excited, at least initially, by Smith as he was less conservative in his approach. He was more aggressive in signing current players, (though that didn't always work out so well) And he didn't seem as "timid" towards making a trade. (though I think he acted or over-reacted too quickly at times) If the Young trade had worked out, (and let's be honest, all signs pointed initially to his being a very, very good player), and if Nishioka had either worked out, or at least not just stunk up a 5 mile radius, Smith's entire tenure might be much better remembered. (and might have even lasted longer)
-
Can Alex Meyer help the pen?
This! A few positive, successful ML appearances to close out this season, and a much more positive second half overall, could give Meyer that much more of a boost of confidence going in to next season, regardless of what his role is intended to be.
-
Pelfrey: his days as a Minnesota starter should be over
Honestly, there are very few moves made by the Twins this season...or not made...that I can take much umbrage with. But May to the bullpen instead of Pelfrey is one move where I have a Paul Bunyan size axe to grind. Every season, on just about every team...even losing ones...there is someone who steps up unexpectedly to help their club, maybe even carry them for a short time. But it's always for the short term. And everyone knows and expects this. To think Pelfrey was going to take a stretch, even one a couple months long, and suddenly transform it in to a full season was a fools wish. For a rebuilding, rebounding team to have a top young SP like May and move him to the bullpen to accommodate and appease a poor to mediocre career veteran pitcher who doesn't fit into your future plans...including next season...is short-sighted and irresponsible. Without being dramatic, even us armchair GM's new what to expect. How could the professionals not know as much?
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/4): Pitching, Pitching And More Pitching
I believe Berrios is special. I'm not going to declare him an ACE or future HOFer yet, but there is something special about the young man. I felt when the Twins drafted Gonsalves they may have gotten one of the real steals in the draft that year. While it may seem strange at first to attempt to compare the two of them...RH vs LH and 6' (maybe) vs a listed 6' 5"...there are some correlations that are at least interesting to consider. Both are 21, Berrios about 6 weeks older, both are coming off big years at two different levels...though Berrios was a full step higher...but Berrios has also been in professional ball, and the Twins system, a year longer. Berrios' age 20 season, last year in '14 at A+ and AA, is probably the closest comp you could make. No matter how you slice it, Berrios has advanced further, faster, than Gonsalves. But again, there is the advantage of the extra professional season. And for whatever reason, Gonsalves was held back in 2014 in EST. but both young men have some tremendous milb numbers, both are very young, and both have at least one big year of split level results to reflect on, if not compare. The whole point being...WOW. Go back and take a look. You'll be glad you did! The one thing I'd question and be interested in knowing is whether the taller Gonsalves is really his listed weight of 190lbs. If accurate, you'd have to expect another 15-20lbs of bulk and muscle yet to come wouldn't you? That could lead to even more endurance and velocity out of Gonsalves.
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/3): Solid Granite
- Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/3): Solid Granite
-
The Unloading of Ricky Nolasco's Contract
I thought if claimed off waivers the team claiming was responsible for the balance of the contract. If signed after clearing waivers, he could be signed for the minimum. But I think there are different regulations and different procedures and I may be mixing them up.
-
The Unloading of Ricky Nolasco's Contract
Nothing wrong with your trade idea at all. But I think you still need a third team in there somewhere as the Padres wouldn't take on Nolasco, IMHO, unless getting rid of Shields somehow. I think they went all in, as a mistake, and would really, really like to find a way to get rid of Shields in whatever they do.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Starting Pitcher Of The Month - August 2015
While pure stuff and potential would probably have Gonsalves and a healthy and fully re-habed Thorpe as easily the top LHSP options in the organization, it does seem as though there are a number of other, decent LH options in the organization. Sure would be nice if at least one of them could make the transition to reliable LH bullpen arm.
-
The Unloading of Ricky Nolasco's Contract
We could just dump him and move on, hoping with absolutely no hope, that some desperate team would claim him and thus pick up his remaining contract. But despite two disappointing seasons with our Twins, Nolasco does have value. His career numbers are solid. His best years are with better/winning teams. That may sound like an odd comment, but the ability to rise to the occassion is something not every player has. And he has been sturdy...up until his Twins tenure. But his injuries have been as nagging as they are unfortunate and they have not been debilitating. No torn up knees. No torn up arm. No blown back. There is every reason to believe that he will come in to next season healthy, ready to go, ready for 32 starts, 188-190 IP, 12-14 wins. All career norms. But no-one is going to just take him off the Twins hands and pay his final two seasons, after the two he's had, and turn over a high quality player. More than likely, we are talking cash thrown in, possibly another decent prospect, and a limited return. San Diego, to me, still sounds like a nice option, as long as you can involve another team to move Shields too. Dodgers? They have tons of money, and need pitching depth behind their big two.
-
Burdi, Reed, And The Pass Less Traveled
I think you'd have to add Jones to the list, though he was already in the organization before 2014. No question Ryan was counting on at least one of these three to make a positive impact on the season. Good chance one of them does next season. But in no way, no how, should he plan on one or more of them and not make a move to bring in at least one additional re-enforcement from outside the organization.