Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Robinson, Thompson, Fryer Outrighted
Professionally speaking, there is nothing special about Robinson to afford him a spot on the 40 man. I don't know that a 4th/5th OF who can actually play and hit above the Mendoza is truly a "dime a dozen", but they sure are easier to find than a lot of positions. I could have seen keeping him if the team really was unsure about Buxton beginning the season in AAA, but there's just too much fodder taking up spots now as is. On topic but a very different question...could the Twins simply remove someone like, say, Nolasco from the 40 man? I confess to not knowing enough about certain parameters within the rules, but if a team just decided to remove him, he could obviously be claimed and the Twins are off the hook for his remaining contract terms. Of course, this would almost assuredly not happen. Now, I know it's not as simply as just removing him. But in theory, even being the veteran he is, and under contract, you aren't forced to keep him. But does said contract require him to be kept on the 40? Could he be optioned to Rochester? Would he instead have to pass through waivers? I'm just curious as to the details of a veteran player in his situation that might not fit in any longer.
-
Lucroy Available
I get this. But his age doesn't bother me. Especially being a catcher, and the contract he's sitting at. Offense from the catcher position is great to have, and he, potentially, should provide a nice upgrade there for us. But at the end of the day, it is still a defense first position. If Mauer were fully healthy and able to still catch, but simply had regressed due to age and wear and tear to the hitter he is now, he would STILL be a valuable asset. And not just for his defense and game calling, but for being the hitter he has become. As long as Lucroy is healthy, (including his head), there is no immediate reason to expect sudden regression. But as long as any regression wasn't to Butera levels, he would still be an asset and upgrade over the current situation. Further, in a season or two. either or both Turner and Garver should be ready in at least some capacity.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 6 (11-15)
Because of his age and size, and he need to "muscle up" some more over the next couple of years, I think I would downgrade Vielma a few spots. But despite being younger than average for his level, he seems to have a hit tool and the ability to take a few walks. He has certainly shown speed and SB ability as well. If his defense is as good as advertised...well...he's someone you absolutely have to have at least a little excitement about! Now...a few extra protein shakes to get him to 180lbs.... I understand the idea that Javier is a huge signing, so you assume the Twins knew what they were getting, and therefor he ranks high based on young, raw athleticism and the such. But 16 and having never played...mmm...I think I'd knock him down a couple spots just for so many unknowns at this point. But I can't say either of these kids is ranked vastly out of place. ALL prospects are just that, prospects. Projectability is difficult to fully quantify. What's so interesting about this group of 5 is that there are legitimate questions, of differing sorts, for all of them; age, injury, no experience, bad 2015, etc. But all 5 of them have some really, really nice potential. As much as anyone in the entire Twins milb system.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 6 (11-15)
Thorpe and Meyer. With Rosario, Sano, Buxton, May and even Duffey arriving...and the huge seasons by Berrios and Kepler, along with speculation about them...it might be easy to forget about Thorpe and Meyer. Meyer is former top 10, and still haas the big atmosphere and potential. A healthy Thorpe in 2015 would have him also in the top 10. These two are very intriguing, and maybe the top two guys to watch in 2016, story wise.
-
Article: Torii Hunter To Retire
This is the perfect ending. I felt and stated I thought he had that one special season left in him. That "coming home" season to close out a career and show you can still do it. Now, bash him, his August, his OPS, he defense, whatever you want to say. But he brought an energy to the team along with 22HR and 80 RBI. And those are all things not be ignored. I've always had respect for Torii, even if I didn't always agree with his words or stance on things. The way he played the game, and the way he has tried to bring the game back to kids in the inner cities are the two things I probably respect him most for. I don't know if you remember or not, but about a year ago I wrote a half serious, half tongue-in-cheek article about how the loss of Torii Hunter lead to the eventual downfall of the Twins through a large affecting domino effect with his FA loss. (OK, it was probably 70-30 serious vs not) His coming home to help the Twins jump start their rebuild, especially with Rosario, Buxton and Hicks patrolling the OF with him is a full-circle, baseball gods kind of justice. I'd call this a happy ending. Thank you Torii.
-
Article: Ryan On Suzuki: He Took The Post
Oh, and I get this! But if someone offers their AA or AAA catcher who hasn't reached the majors yet in any capacity and they want Berrios and Kepler....I'm thinking NO. So the deal...any deal...just has to make sense. And if it doesn't, you move on to the next option. Possibly the one after that. We don't have a Sano-Buxton-Rosario-Kepler quality catching prospect ready to graduate. At least, not right now. And I'd sure love one! But I also don't want to pay someone $100 for the privilege of having $50.
-
Article: Ryan On Suzuki: He Took The Post
Oh the heck with it....once again...a trade for Lucroy would be great! A trade for a talented young catcher with some real potential would be as good in some ways, better in others, not as good in other ways. The problem with any trade...obviously... is what does it cost you? I like the idea of signing AJ as an alternative. He helps. He and Suzuki are better than Suzuki and Herrmann/Fryer. I would rather go this route than pay through the nose for a deal that doesn't make sense. Then next year...with another season to monitor the progress/development/potential of Turner and Garver...we can re-visit both the FA and trade market.
-
Lucroy Available
1* Make this trade as long as it's something similar to what we are saying here. 2* Sign Chris Davis to DH and share 1B. 3* Trade Plouffe, move Nolasco with cash and probably a lower prospect. Try to come away with one top RP in one of these moves, LH or RH. If you can somehow come up with one of each, you just hit a bit-time double! 4* Sign a veteran LH bat for the bench. I'm intrigued by Murphy of the Angels. Solid career triple slash. Rosario-Buxton-Hicks with Murphy in the OF Sano-Escobar-Dozier-Mauer/Davis with Nunez and Santana in the INF Lucroy-Suzuki at C I'd go to war with that roster, though the exact order of the lineup is hard to predict right now. Too many variables until we get to ST and begin to play games.
-
Lucroy Available
Stewart, Polanco and Arcia?
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
Assuming you are referring to Wilson Contreras and Reese McGuire? McGuire hits LH, which is a lot more rare, but Contreras looks to be the better hitter and played at AA I believe, so he's closer. So I'd have to say Contreras at this point, but would have to do more research. While Stewart is still rated higher and seems to have the highest upside potential, I think I'd rather trade him than the top LHSP prospect in my system, Gonsalves. But would either of these two really provide an upgrade over Turner and Garver at this point?
-
Article: Chasing An Ace
I really like this post! My one concern with moving Plouffe is the high potential but tenuous OF situation for 2016. Like Leviathan, I believe Buxton should be in CF. Great defense, tremendous tools and potential...he can learn a bit on the fly. (I believe his 2015 experience and talent will allow him to do so) Rosario is obviously in left. And until Kepler is ready, Hicks, or possibly Hicks/Arcia can man RF. I still wouldn't mind a veteran LH bat for a bench role, but that's a rather small piece vs a larger discussion here. But if the Twins are truly intent in their belief of placing Buxton in Rochester to begin the year, and Plouffe IS traded, then DH and RF becomes a whole lot more tenuous. A Davis signing provides another high quality hitter for the DH spot, improves and deepens the lineup, and you mow don't miss Plouffe. (Or Hunter's 22 HR for that matter) Add a reliever from both sides of the mound, and this team looks really good to me for 2016 with some very talented milb depth in the wings.
-
AFL Recap Week 2: Bullpen Promise
Except for Rogers past the 3rd inning, another very good week for our AFL prospects! On a downer note...I think losing out on Cody this past draft is going to come back to bite us in the posterior.
-
Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now
I agree 100%. Shop him. See if you can get something good that helps the club. Otherwise...keep him. But yes, I do think he's insurance, and valuable insurance. And not due to anything negative about Sano. I believe can play 3B just fine, though not as well as Plouffe at this point, nor would I expect him too. But he would be OK and get better and better at it, just like Plouffe did. Just like Koskie and Gaetti before him. To me, the insurance factor is the lineup in general, as I feel we enter 2016 with the potential for a young and amazing OF, but one with some initial questions that we don't have the answers to yet. Will Buxton be ready for day one even if he's not a complete stud yet? (I think yes, but we don't know) Can Hicks hold down RF on a daily basis? Maybe. I hope so. I really do think he's begun to round the corner. What about Arcia? Can he rebound? He could DH or platoon with Hicks in RF maybe. What if the Twins decide to open with Buxton at AAA, now how does the OF stack up? Keeping Plouffe, at least initially, keeps the 3B/1B/DH rotation with Sano and Mauer that we saw last year. It keeps another OK and 20 HR bat in the lineup.
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
Look, I'd love to see the Twins find the right deal, for the right price, and acquire a young catcher who can hit, provide some pop, not be a windmill at the plate, and play solid defense, call a nice game and throw. But I'm not interested in Berrios and Kepler for some young prospect. We're not going to trade for Mauer. But I don't want to trade for Butera either. (Or Walbeck, the last catcher I can recall the Twins calling for) If the right deal isn't there, the question I ask myself is; "are we a better team with AJ on board sharing time with Suzuki, (probably as the primary), providing experience and a solid bat with some power vs Herrmann or Fryer?" The answer is YES, we are a better team with AJ than without him.
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
Absolutely. Totally agree. Which is why I like percentages, and numbers, but also recognize flaws in relying too much on them. Hence the ongoing debates in regard to defensive metrics.
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
I stand corrected. 24% for his career. The numbers I looked up originally must have been incorrect. If that is the case, then I will freely admit my error. But still better than Suzuki and again, a far better offensive producer than most.
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
1* Some people actually want to call out or hint at a lack of integrity by the TD staff because they deleted a posting at the Twins request because the information came from a situation that was, more or less, considered off the record? And TD did so with an explanation and apologies? That's called integrity. Look it up. The Yankees could always use more fans I guess. 2* And now for something completely different.....the actual content of the post! 3* I'm going to do a Colonel Sherman T Potter on this post and call "horse hockey". Lol But in fact, I'd call it and donkey donuts on a few of the posts here. I did not, repeat, did not spend hours poring over articles and new age stats regarding defensive metrics for ML catchers. I didn't have time. But we have also been down that path enough times to realize the only thing we will all agree on is that we won't all agree. But Brayan Pena 260/ 300/ 352/ 651 for career George Kottaras 215/ 326/ 411/ 737 for career These guys as better options than AJ? Saltalamacchia had a couple decent years before falling off the proverbial edge. But his career is 240/ 311/ 419/ 730. Don't like or believe in AJ if you want. Totally cool. But at least be realistic if you bash him or the idea of him joining the Twins again. He would absolutely overtake Zuke as the principal catcher. His career slash line 282/ 321/ 424/ 745. His "washed up" 2015 numbers were 300/ 339/ 430/ 769. In other words, not only are his career slash numbers very good, and above average for a catcher, but he actually produced better than his own career average numbers last season. All of his numbers could drop 20 points and he would still be a productive offense player from the catcher position. (Further, Zuke may be more productive facing fewer RH pitchers) AJ can't throw? He has thrown out a career average of 32% of base stealers and 31% in 2015. Whether total surprise by what happened to Mauer or bad planning, the Twins are short on catching in the minors. This is the reason Turner skipped low A, and Navarreto has been played at three different levels in three years despite being at least a year younger than the competition and with sub-par offensive numbers at each level. Turner, Garver and Navarreto may all make it and provide a happy ending. (I just wish any of them could hit like Swim) And a move for a talented young catcher would be a great move, should said player and move be recognized and made successfully. But don't pretend AJ can't play or hit or help. Because he could.
-
Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion
Are you speaking of an African swallow or a European swallow?
-
We have really bad mods or ones who just miss BYTO
I didn't read the original discussion/post, but I certainly get the gist of this conversation. I'm also dense enough or lost enough that I'm uncertain of the BYTO reference. But I really like this post from Goat! Hunter has always been one of my favorite all time players, and I was heartbroken when he left the Twins. He's said some thing that disappointed me or ticked me off over the years, but always liked and respected him. And I have always applauded his efforts to bring baseball back to the inner cities. I know this thread isn't about that, but I just wanted to say it. As to the mods on here, I think they do a tremendous job! They are part of the community and discussions while "moderating" without "policing". In fact, the harshness of any action they partake in involves little more than a hand slap and reminder to be civil.
-
Weeding Through Molitor's Messages
Nothing too surprising in all of this. Once again, I think Buxton builds on this past season and shouldn't be counted out of his spot with the Twins right out of camp so soon. Sano to the OF makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. It's totally counter productive and counter intuitive to his entire baseball career. Arcia would probably be a better option! And no pun intended, but he's out of options, and needs a spot, even as a role player to begin the season. Cotts? Meh. It could be a good signing. But I think there are a couple of better options out there. Santana really isn't much of an issue either. The Twins will keep 2 catcher, 4 or 5 OF's, 3 middle INF's, 2 or 3 corner INF's. In most any way you configure the 13 man player roster, there is room for a 13th player who could fill almost any role. In this case, Santana as an INF/OF utility type. I don't know...I didn't listen to the interview so I may be missing something...but I'd like to hear a little more imagination and a little more aggressiveness in the Twins thinking. I'm not say go hog wild and blow up the roster with major moves, but, it's not the time to just limit yourself either.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 5: (16-20)
Hmmm....I see your point here but I am going to disagree. Big and strong with a big arm, it appears to me he's been promoted very aggressively despite being a little young for his level, and while his bat is behind, he hasn't been allowed to repeat a year, or part of a year, to let his bat catch up. (The same arguement could be made for Turner as well I think) Without getting a true fix on his hitting potential, I'd say speculation puts him pretty close to where he is.
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 5: (16-20)
Sooner or later, don't the Twins have to slow Navaretto down and let him spend a second year at a level to let his bat catch up a bit?1
-
Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now
Personally, I believe Dozier's only problem is getting worn out by the second half of the past couple of seasons. I know he's very good and we rely on him, and at times he has practically carried the offense each of the past 2 first halves, but can't the guy get a day off once in a while? Hey, I'm intrigued by Polanco and I think he's going to be good...versatile...and clutch. But I don't believe he's ready to replace Dozier yet. I have maintained that you trade Plouffe for the right deal, and that deal might just be that young catcher if you can find him. But my problem with trading him is the OF. Example: Buxton begins the season in the minors. Hicks begins the season in CF. Who is in RF? Arcia? Then who is the DH? With Plouffe around, there is just less un-certainty with the lineup as you still have the Plouffe/Sano/Mauer 3B/1B/DH rotation.
-
Questions For Terry Ryan?
With little exception, each of the Twins milb affiliates ranked among the top 5-ish in their respective leagues in ERA, SO's and CG's. Also, recent drafts have the seen the Twins seemingly changing direction in regard to the type of pitcher drafted. I'd like to hear more about the changes and concentration of new philosophy, and how things are stacking up at this point. Also, with the fairly decent success of 40 yo Torii Hunter this past season, any thought to persuade Mark DeRosa to join the team for a World Series push in 2016?
-
Minnesota's Next Free Agent Arm?
This would be the FA I would target and persue IF I were to persue one. But in addition to getting Nolasco off the books, I now need to get Santana or Hughes off the books. Or, move Hughes to the bullpen as some have suggested. But I am not fully convinced he would be an upgrade over a healthy Hughes or Santana. Or enough of one to warrant the investments when I have Berrios, May and Duffey plus Gibson.