Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Blake Parker Signs Officially; John Curtiss DFAd
I have seen enough good done to not bash this move. For whatever reason, they felt thjs was the guy to let go. More moves yet to come? A strong belief in the other arms on hand and how the pen will be managed going forward? Who knows. But while Curtiss looked wild at times, you could see the potential. Just not sure i understand this move.
-
Article: Can the Twins Be Competitive With Their Current Bullpen?
Agree with the pen addition. Not as concerned with an infielder that hits LH or switches, just an option for depth and versatility. What happens if someone goes down or just stinks? I like Adrianza, just not as an extended option. There ARE infield options out there, even on the cheap, to provide depth, versatility, a bat and some production, even if their last name is not Gonzalez. And while I would LOVE the FO to just GO FOR IT with Marwin, there are other interesting options. Biggest bite is, I hate an 8 man pen and a short bench, but think we are headed that way. Hope I am wrong. I think your LHSP is Mejia and Gonsalves and Thorpe coming up.
-
Article: Can the Twins Be Competitive With Their Current Bullpen?
I think a healthy Castro helps this team in a variety of ways. But I am not convinced he starts. Garver showed defensive improvement and offers quality offense. He's also a part of the future.
-
Article: Can the Twins Be Competitive With Their Current Bullpen?
I have to echo this! A few weeks back. Falvey was on local radio with Judd in the TC and the question/comment posed to him was the potential of a 10-12 game swing upward in 2019 if a few things broke right. Falvey agreed, of course. But the central point of the question was how much went wrong in 2018. No need to re-hash all of that. But I am in agreement with that assessment, and Brock here. I also agree with a "trickle down" effect in the pen if you add one more quality arm. To me, the obvious choice is Allen. You create depth, and you gain experience. Now Reed, who finished well, does not have to be the closer. Nor does May. Nor does anyone else from Parker on down. You are building depth. Good guys, a deep bullpen, is what you want. Not relying on just a few arms, or using them in obvious loss situations as Molitor did too often. (As if hoping for a comeback win). And the season is long and you need depth. Give me what we have, add one more veteran guy like Allen, and this bullpen, talent, depth, numbers, etc, I feel SO MUCH BETTER. Everything that went wrong last season, 23/24+ 1 run losses, and a better pen to reverse that horrible number...yea...I see a potential 90ish win team.
-
Article: Best Remaining No-Risk Starters on the Free Agent Market
Ash and Nick pretty much answered, but my take is simple. If the guy rebounds and looks surprisingly good, you've added another solid option for the rotation and you've added depth, depth to the pen where Mejia and Romero could both help. If said guy doesn't flash, he goes to Rochester to continue to work while off the 40 man. He can still be released or opt out. If, at whatever point, said signee looks good, there is the option to trade him, or anyone else, to bring in another asset or two. All you are doing is bringing in a flier to see if you get lucky and build depth and possibilities.
-
Article: Best Remaining No-Risk Starters on the Free Agent Market
Barring a trade for an absolute, top of the rotation arm...which is not going to happen at this point...I am 100% all in on who we have, auditioning the kids for now and 2020, etc. But why on earth would you turn down a veteran arm on a MILB deal with no guarantees and no 40 man spot just to see if you get lucky?
-
Article: Solving Stephen Gonsalves
Right with you there on Thorpe. Everything from his early performance to post injury/illness performance and pure stuff tells me he is for real. But if his debut stinks, do we proclaim he was over-hyped? Remember, Gibson had a bad debut. Then he had 2 really solid seasons on bad teams. Then he really found himself after a season and a half. Berrios really struggled on his initiation to MLB and now looks like a true #1-2 with time. Gonsalves has done nothing but adapt and produce at every level. He even adapted and produced his last few "primary starts" in 2018. He is long, lanky, LH, and has struggled with repeated delivery at times. He has also shown adaptability and pitchability at every level. So a so-so ROOKIE appearance at the ML level has convinced some he doesn't have the stuff to make it? My goodness, can't we just let time, experience and new pitching coach Johnson just work through some things before we just say he can't make it? Ridiculous to dismiss Gonsalves at this point after a brief so-so debu6 simply because he doesn't have some singular dominating pitch. Tweaks and experience along with opportunity, it's not hard to see Gonsalves, Thorpe and Berrios as part of the 2020 staff along with Romero and Mejia, even though a pen option remains.
-
Article: Solving Stephen Gonsalves
Very salient points all the way around! My only disagreement is your comment on 2-3yrs before he steps to the forefront. He has learned and made adjustments at every level he has been at. Yes, there have been hiccups, and the BB for a time last season was alarming. But what did he do yet again? He made adjustments and found himself. I often find it amusing when a pitching prospect reaches the ML level, like Berrios as an example, and struggles initially, and some claim he's automatically a bust of some sort. I think Gonsalves will be up in 2019, will improve, and could be a fixture by 2020. That being said, I honestly think Thorpe is an even better option. Here's hoping both are part of the 2020 roation.
-
Article: Prospect Spotlight Series: Royce Lewis
As stated, just no way to predict his defense definitively at this point, in A+ and only 19. All the tools seem to be there. I agree with the "unorthodox" look. He just looks "longer" than a typical SS and his throwing motion looks a little more over the top. It also appears he is graceful, but needing a little more polish in his footwork. Nothing here to indicate he can't and won't continue to improve and smooth things out.
-
Is the FO "blowing it" in regard to the bench?
Let me begin by stating I am using the term "bench" rather loosely. I have always believed in constructing the deepest and most versatile club you can. Use the term "reserve" if you prefer that designation. In building any ballclub, even the best and deepest you can, there will always be a number of players who will see the majority of playing time. "Starters", if you will. Days off, injuries, even in regard to some situational matchups, I have always held the belief your "non starters" should be players you can count on to perform at a quality level. What they may bring to the table as their best assets is arguable, but I've never been in favor of a glove only, Mendoza hitting reserve, or a bat only slugger who couldn't play catch in a weekend softball league. In fact, I've never been big on a DH-only player unless he was special. (Yes, Cruz applies here). So all that being said, I'm perplexed and frustrated with the current construction of the roster. There is time to address this issue, but I'm wondering if the current braintrust is making a mistake here. Let's examine the depth as it stands currently, assuming everyone is healthy and ready to go. OF: We are discussing depth and options, not simply continuing arguments about "will he or won't he". Rosario, Buxton, Kepler and Cave offer 4 guys who could, potentially, make up one of the better OF in all of MLB, even if ceilings aren't hit in 2019. I was in favor of McCutchen or Brantley over Cruz for versatility, but that ship has sailed. Wade is a comer who could make his presence felt at some point in 2019 and offers a slightly different skill set than those above him. A fully healthy Granite does the same. (Don't dismiss him). I believe the Twins see Michael Reed as a RH version of Cave, a guy with some skills who may be looking for an opportunity, and may be a bit of a late bloomer. Astudillo could be a corner OF option. And while I just don't see room for him, unless he would pass through waivers, perhaps Austin as well. C: Garver and Castro should man this position well. Astudillo would seem to be the #3 option here. Call me worried for anything beyond those three. INF: Just like the OF, there are questions to be answered, but we are seemingly set with Sano, Polanco, Schoop and Cron. Adrianza seems scheduled to make the club. Austin has a shot, but again, I don't see room for him. Once again, Austudillo could provide depth at 3B. Maybe 1B despite a lack of desired height/length. Can he really play 2B? I know he DID, but can he? As has been hotly discussed, Kepler has the potential to play some 1B and SHOULD. Hell, I'd try Cave there too and have Rosario play some 2B and 3B just to see if he can perform there in a crunch! He's done it before. But it's the infield where I'm really concerned. What else is there? Frankly, Adrianza has played good to excellent defense most of the time, even filled in "capably" at 1B and OF in brief appearances. He's hit far better than he did with the Giants in his limited opportunity with them. He's even shown a little power at times. I'm a big fan and believer in Austudillo, but are we really banking on him as a key reserve at this point? No matter how much you like, or believe in, the primary, starting alignment of the infield, where is the depth? Where are the options if someone gets hurt or goes south? While we are all banging the drum for another quality back of the pen arm, I think we are losing sight of a an opportunity here to create depth and versatility to the roster. While this 3/4-1/4 German/Norweigan would somehow figure out how to dance a jig were we to sign Gonzalez or Lowrie, I believe the roster could be upgraded even with setting our sites lower. I give you three names to consider: Wilmer Flores, 27yo Tim Beckham, 28yo Yangervis Solarte, 31yo Flores: Career .262BA/.727OPS with 4 consecutive seasons with double digit HR totals. He also has more than 100 career appearances at all 4 infield positions. Beckham: Career .252BA/ .728OPS with 2 consecutive seasons with double digit HR totals, (22 in 2017). He has over 220 games at SS, 80 at 2B, and 49 at 3B. Solarte: Career .259BA/ .728OPS with 5 consecutive double digit HR seasons. He has made more than 400 appearances at 3B, has 168 at 2B, 43 at SS, 42 at 1B, and 7 games played in OF. None of these 3 are anything approaching a Gold Glove defender. But each offers a solid ML bat with acceptable/decent OPS with some power and a lot of various positional flexibility. Is it even practical the Twins could add a Gonzalez or Lowrie, each of whom remains un-signed? Are we comfortable with what we have at the ML level and at Rochester? Do you like the addition of one of these 3 names to finish the roster? Or do you have someone else in mind via FA or trade? I really think we are missing the boat here. What do you say?
-
Article: Mailbox: Openers, Trading Buxton, Kirilloff’s Debut
Nice mailbag and responses Cody! But I take issue with May as a possible opener, despite his previous starter experience. I see him as a valuable back of the pen option with not only his stuff and his finish to 2018, but also his embracing of his role as a reliever now. Just my opinion.
-
Article: Solving Stephen Gonsalves
I remain very high on Gonsalves for all the reasons stated in the OP. His BB jumped in 2018 to be sure. But if I may quote directly from the 2019 Handbook: "He pitched masterfully in his first two starts for the Red Wings and only gave up two walks. Over his next nine starts, however, he battled command issues and walked 36 batters over a 38-inning stretch. As soon as the calendar flipped to July, Gonsalves appeared to regain his feel. Over his final eight starts for Rochester, he had a 1.50 ERA, 0.94 WHIP and only walked 17 batters over 48 innings." An uneven season, to be sure. But one in which he did what he has always done, which is make adjustments and "pitch". He's never been a thrower with a wipe-out slider or mid 90's FB. Primary starter or not, he did the same thing to end his 2018 season with the Twins, though in SSS. While I believe Thorpe has better pure stuff, I think Gonsalves will be fine as a back end SP with a ceiling of a quality #3. But I agree I think he begins 2019 at Rochester.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins Finalizing Deal With Blake Parker
I was also really hoping for Familia, Soria or Robertson. Still kinda upset about Robertson in particular after what he signed for. Would have taken any of those three and been pretty darn happy. I'm pretty high on Cody Allen despite a down 2018. He just turned 30 in November. Career ERA of 2.98, (5 straight season's previously of an ERA under 3.00), career AVG of .217, career WHIP of 1.19, 3.26 career K/BB. Six straight season's of 67 or more appearances and IP. And those numbers include a down 2018. I just think he's a perfect fit unless there is some health or sudden velocity concern I am unaware of. Holland has been mentioned, but he's 3 years older than Allen, their career numbers and quite close, but Holland seems to be on a 3 year downward trend except for his late seaskn surge with the Nationals last season. I'm fine with Parker as a piece. Now give me Allen with all of the other pieces on hand and I'm actually pretty optimistic.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins Finalizing Deal With Blake Parker
I would have to say Moya has a leg...errr...arm up on the competition unless Mejia isn't in the rotation. In that case Mejia to the pen, Moya to Rochester to begin the year. But to further complicate the issue, if Mejia isn't in the rotation, then I'm betting Romero is. Then we open up the discussion yet again.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins Finalizing Deal With Blake Parker
I hear ya but cant look at those 4 in a vacuum. Schoop is coming off a down but injured season. He was outstanding the year before and had a pair of quality seasons before that. Cron got more than 409AB for the first time and Rocco is familiar with the adjustments he made. Torreys is depth and will almost assuredly be in Rochester. I think the arguement can be made Parker is a better arm than a couple guys still on the 40 man. I still want and think we need another arm and I'd like to see another quality "utility" or "flex" player added. But I cant disagree with these 4 signings for their individual purposes.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins Finalizing Deal With Blake Parker
I really want/wanted one proven guy for the back end. Then, I thought a solid flier, and there have been a ton of interesting options, would make sense for depth and competition. This is the flier. Considering his past success, relatively young age and familiarity with the FO, is there something about Allen that we are just missing here? He should be signed within the next 48hrs if you ask me.
-
Article: How the Twins Reshaped Their Identity in a Half-Decade
You had me at, "Five weeks until pitchers and catchers report".
-
2019 Minnesota Twins TV Analyst Conundrum
Jim Thome
-
Opening / Everyday Batting Order
I admit to not following the Rays too closely. I was unaware Cron hit in the 2 hole often. I wonder at the reasoning. Power but not a great OB, was this to sandwich him between two other guys with better OB? I agree Rocco could carry on a similar idea now that he's in charge. And if so, your lineup makes sense. And I do like Kepler/Cave lower in the order to break up RH/LH batters and deepen the lineup more.
-
Article: The Top 20 Minnesota Twins Assets of 2019: Part 4 (1-5)
Nick, I actually get what it is you are doing here. And I appreciate your efforts tremendously. And I have held off commenting until I saw your final results. The absolute best part was where and how you broke down all options and evaluations at the end. Like any ranking, you can argue about a placement here or there and it doesn't really matter when you are talking about a spot or two. But a couple of qualms: 1] Sano should be ranked higher, or Buxton lower. The potential for these two is still tremendous! And each have issues and questions and each have issues and questions that are both similar and different. 2] Considering he was just drafted, I get leaving Larnach out of the equation. Not sure I'd leave Rooker out. 3] I have read and re-read your listings over and over again. Just to make sure i haven't missed anything. And nowhere is Lewis Thorpe mentioned. I think you are missing something there my friend.
- Opening / Everyday Batting Order
-
How Do You Spell R-E-L-I-E-F?
Absolutely sick about Robertson! His contract is so manageable! Why didn't we do this? Maybe we contacted him, and maybe we didn't. Maybe he wanted to stay on the east coast, liked what the Phillies were doing, hates Minnesota, whatever. Just sick about what he signed for. On the positive side, there are still arms out there. Does this move the needle downward for terms, but upward for opportunity and expediency for Allen and Ottavino and others? Come on Twins! Bring in an arm and a flier and then add another quality "utility" player that is out there!
-
Opening / Everyday Batting Order
An exercise in futility because who knows how well each guy will perform, much less what Rocco has in mind. But a fun exercise! Actually was thinking about this today before I even saw the thread. My first, initial thoughts: 1] Polanco 2] Kepler 3] Cruz 4] Rosario 5] Sano 6] Cron 7] Schoop 8] Garver/Castro 9] Buxton Initially, makes the most sense to me, though I dislike to man RH hitters in a row.
-
Making the Most of Max
I'm with you! There is just so much potential there, and we've seen a mixed bag of flashes of what he can do and what he could be. We're I another team calling the Twins about trade possibilities, he'd be at the top of my list because what he might become in the next year to year and a half with experience and a more even, "locked in" approach.
-
How Do You Spell R-E-L-I-E-F?
Mike, as you have intelligently stated, there are reasons why all 3 options could work. But if forced to choose, I'm going with option #3, the pair of RP coming in around the $20M mark. Maybe I'm wrong, but Red's history, age, and a few, solid late season performances indicate to me it was just his turn to have an off season due to injury or a tired arm. Personally, I think May is for real, especially now that he has fully embraced his role as a reliever. Even if Rogers isn't as good as 2018, he's NICE. With his milb history and first 1 1/2 years of performance I'm betting on Hildenberger. Now, let's add in Moya, Mejia and Romero for their contributions...do be determined...as SP, RP, designated/primary SP, and we start to see a lot of arms an inventive coaching staff has to work with. Some may say I'm crazy, but if this staff can find greater consistency from Magill, his mid 90's FB and wicked slider could play a part as well. Can Reed and especially Curtiss finally show the consistency to make a real contribution? But I believe in depth and options. There are still a handful of quality guys with late inning stuff and history available to make a difference without making that HUGE commitment to that "one guy". I think Allen is one of those real opportunities. Then you could bring in a flier like Herrera, or someone else, coming off injury or a down season, to increase that depth and your options. I actually like a lot of what is on hand. But I really want that depth to work with.