Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Article: Twins 2019 Position Analysis: First Base
Completely respect your opinion while also hoping as well that you are, indeed, proved wrong, lol. I think one thing we all have to do is just forget about Morrisson. They may both be power 1B who each played for the Rays, but comparisons should stop there. They are different players, at different points in their careers. Cron has been solid, but bounced in and out of lineups behind other guys, putting up decent but spectacular numbers, never having more than 400 AB until his breakout in 2018. He finally played daily and got 500AB. He reportedly made some adjustments to his approach. You would think Rocco is at least familiar with him also coming over from TB and having some input on his signing. He could, more or less, duplicate his 2018 season. He could regress some and still be a decent hitter with 20+HR power and still be an asset. I doubt he's any sort of long term solution, but he could prove to be a solid short term option until Rooker, Kirilloff, etc, is ready.
-
The Twins Off season Has Been A Success And I'll Tell You Why
Yes I admit it, in all things...Life...or more important things like the Twins...i tend to be an optimist. But I've been through enough and seen enough in life...and the Twins...to also be a realist. I'm also a highly intelligent person. (You will just have to take my word on that last point). I've been described as crazy a few times in my life, by people who know me very well, so any of you who wish to characterize me as such for my opinion here, feel free to do so. But my contention here is that the Twins offseason has been a successful one. Now, I am not saying it's perfect, or exactly to my preference or liking. Nor am I guaranteeing contention for the Central or a potential WS birth. What I am saying is that within context of the Minnesota Twins, who and what they are, and have been for the past several years, the steps that have been taken are good and the right ones. Let us examine first what has NOT been done: 1] The Twins did not acquire a front end starter to team with Berrios and Gibson. 2] They did not acquire a top end bullpen piece to shore the pen as a whole, and thus the entire staff. Either of those moves would be considered major "needle movers" to use standard vonacular. Why not? Now that's a loaded question. I have spent hours of personal reflection and debate, along with debate with an equally passionate Twins fan, my father, as well as doing a great deal of reading articles and opinions both here at TD and elsewhere. In fact, I read a whole lot more than I posted as I was reflecting. So why weren't those two major considerations addressed? To me, the answer is simple. And it has nothing to do with ownership being cheap, which is an ongoing, potential straw-man debate for another time and place other than this article. In fact, money spent last year, and funds paid out so far this year, including the recent Gonzalez signing, vs "pocketing" money could provide context against such an opinion. But again, that is NOT the reflection/debate here. So what is the "simple answer" I mentioned? Answer: From ownership to FO on down, the Twins don't know who they are yet! If you are honest with yourself, I think you have to agree with this basic premise, grudgingly or not. From day one, the FO, still on the job for less than three years, has spoken of building the entire organization, and spoken about "sustainability" which fans...US...have sometimes chastised them for. OUR job is to be fans and support them and debate them and blast them. I mean, we want a winner, rjght? THEIR job is to build an organization to support a winning team for themselves and us. Right? [For haters, do I have to state the obvious that a winning team creates more revenue?] We have seen an ownership and FO that has eaten contracts, spent "free international money", made mid-season trades for prospects like we've never seen before to acquire potential assets, embraced analytics and built up that department, made organizational changes from milb managers and coaches to coordinators to medical staff and anything else you could list. It also appears we've had a couple pretty decent drafts thrown in as well. But all of that is foundation. It has little to do with here and now and the impending 2019 season, and money, potentially, left on the table to add to the Twins themselves. I get it. I really do. Truth? I am pissed Parker is the only real BP addition made despite a plethora of available options available, no matter the volatility of RP in general. I have also been very vocal about the signing of Martin Perez because SOMEONE thinks there is magic there to turnaround vs just auditioning available young pitchers for his spot. The Twins don't know who they are yet! Right or wrong, there has been WAY too much attention and pressure attributed to Sano and Buxton. The Twins not knowing who they are yet is a part 1A and 1B scenario. Like it or not, those two 25yo coming off horrendous 2018 seasons, after exciting 2017 years, is part of the identity crisis. 1B is sustained production from Rosario, the further development of Berrios, Gibson maintaining, Kepler harnessing his ability, Polanco doing the same, etc, etc. The Twins may not know yet who they are, but they like what they see. Pull back the curtain and see what THEY see in regards to 2019. And this is why I say the off season has been a success. 1] The Twins have an exciting new manager that has drawn rave reviews for his ability to know the game and speak to players. He has a new staff that blends different ideas, with a mix of experience, and even a few "old hands" who know the system on hand and the players within. 2] This new manager has taken the time to contact all current players and even spent time visiting both Buxton and Sano in person to speak to them about their future to themselves and the team. From all reports, it meant a lot to both Buxton and Sano. (BTW, the FO has been in contact with both players as well). In fact, Buxton was so juiced after meeting with Rocco, he stated he wished ST was the next day. 3] Despite a gash on Sano's heel, which will slow him down for about a week, he's reportedly in great shape. So is Buxton, strong, stronger, and ready to go and eager. 4] I really wanted McCutchen or Brantley for roster flexibility. But I can't blast them for Cruz due to his production, experience, and ability to help the entire lineup, as well as the young players on the roster. (Hello Sano). This is something Falvey talked about shortly before the signing. 5] In my dream off season blueprint, Gonsalves was part of it after Escobar was gone. I argued and posted about someone being brought on board for depth and roster flexibility. I have always believed in that even before Brian began to bang the drum so loudly. Just always believed we'd have to settle for one of the second tier options. 6] The signings of Kepler and Polanco. The FO obviously believes in these two, as do I. Are Berrios and Rosario far behind? We don't know, as even these were a bit of a surprise, even though there were advanced reports they were looking at extensions. 7] Cron and Schoop. I will miss Mauer for a ton of reasons we won't get in to here. And 1B with 20+HR power are a dime a dozen. Except, with all due respect to Joe, we haven't had that in a while. Was Cron's 2018 an illusion? Or did his adjustments and his first ever 500 AB make a difference? The 2015-16 Schoop was very nice. His 2017 version was awsome. We didn't get a really, really nice bounce back for 2019 here? 8] With health and additions, roster depth looks much better than in 2018. Anyone from Cave, Astudillo, Adrianza, OF newbie Michael Reed, Austin, Torreyes, a healthy Granite and Wade provide potential depth at Rochester we didn't have this time last year. 9] Addison Reed has history, and a solid 6 last season appearances to state he will rebound. Parker should help. May, with great stuff, an acceptance of the bullpen role, should be good to great. I dislike any sort of pigeonhole for Romero or Mejia in the pen vs a rotation option, but they are good arms who could/should help and can still be transitioned if handled correctly. I'm OK without a major SP addition, at this point, waiting to see about prospects and trades for a frontline SP in the future, with Berrios, Gibson, and a rebounding Odorizzi and Pineda, full of potential, leading the way. This is still a team learning who it is. There are holes and questions to be answered. But I have to mention a recent article where Gibson was interviewed and he spoke about Sano and Buxton and commented on their talent and potential and who you would bring in to replace them. (I am paraphrasing here). Now, you'd expect him to be positive about his teammates,of course. But his answers of "no" in regard to brining in someone who is more talented for replacement is hard to argue with. To me, this is a team with vast potential still finding itself. And 2019, right or wrong, may be a make or break season for a few guys. But I feel the off season has been mostly handled well. Feel free to blast me and express your opinions.
-
Grading the Offseason
Well thought out, well written. In brief, I am going to disagree with your grade. I am calling it a solid B to B+ grade. Selfishly, I won't go in to specifics as I have a long explanation why that I any be doing as a post so I can get a lot of people to disagree with me. Lol
-
Two Guys the Twins Should Have Signed
My off season plan was either Iglesias at SS and move Polanco to 2B, OR, keep Polanco at SS and bring in the very best 2B option you could. One way provides a defensive upgrade, the other an offensive one. Honestly, I was OK either way s both approaches made sense to me. Shocked Iglesias ended up on a milb deal! To me, Santana was never a priority. But with continued time to heal and re-gain velocity, I've been saying for months he could be a good milb deal with incentives flier with high upside and zero risk. Maybe I missed it, but I have yet to read a single word about his recovery, velocity, try-outs, etc. Assuming such information isn't of a secretive nature, then either the Twins weren't convinced, or his somewhat negative comments late last season were born out of more than frustration for his poor performance. I still don't like the Perez signing at all! And while a fan, I don't think we are losing anything out on anything regarding Santana.
-
Article: Your Dad Weighing Options For Mispronouncing Marwin Gonzalez
"A person close to the situation said this has the potential to be Your Dad’s greatest Twins-related befuddlement since the Mike Pagliarulo Incident of 1991." Lest we forget the horrifying "Doug Mintcabbage" incident that began in 1998!
-
Article: Top 10 Candidates for 2019 Sire of Fort Myers
Fun discussion with a potential empty premise. But I can't argue with your choices, Tom. Duda seems to be a perfect candidate to show everyone there is gas in the tank still. But I'm split on Collins and Morin. Both could bounce back, and I'm not so sure the Twins won't go north with a trio of LH in the pen. But could Collins rebound enough to pass Moya and Vasquez? I am really hoping for Wade, to show he will be ready at some point, and either Reed or Eades. Reed should have received a shot last year. I had written off Eades until he adapted so well to the pen last season and his various roles. I like Magill's FB and slider if he could just find some damned consistency. I'm not one who believes he's secure at all.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Marwin Gonzalez Fixes A Problem. (We Just Don't Know Which One Yet.)
I think John's headline pretty much says it all. You simply don't know who, when, if someone gets hurt or just has a poor season or stretch. Gonzalez is a great answer for that, as well as being a great fill-in all over the place if and when the roster is healthy. It's also possible we are already seeing an example of this. I don't have any new information, but it was reported/conjectured elsewhere that Adrianza could be an early season DL candidate due to still recovering from the injury to his left shoulder and being limited to swinging from only one side.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Marwin Gonzalez Fixes A Problem. (We Just Don't Know Which One Yet.)
I liked this post and pretty much agree 100%. But I do have a bit of an objection in regard to Astudillo. And yes, I am absolutely a fan, but I'm also a believer. I think the bat is for real, though not to the degree we saw last season. It also seems to me the budding power he showed last season may be for real. While C and 3B may be his best spots, he could be a very valuable bat to have around. I think the biggest question is how well or adequately he plays another position or two or three. ST, for him, may be more of an audition defensively than offensively. FWIW, with options remaining, I think he begins the season at Rochester. But injuries happen, and opportunity arises. Someone like Austin or Duda could force the Twins to take them north, at least initially, to see how things play out. Having too many guys you want to keep is a good problem to have. I feel pretty good about our position player depth at this point.
-
The Twins best Left Fielder in history
In my head, and my personal rankings, I am excluding Harmon for one of the reasons he was so great: he could literally be named the best at 3 different spots. In my head, the HOFer almost needs to be removed from the conversation. Hence, my choice for Mack as best LF.
-
Article: Musical Chairs In The Bullpen
Sorry, I haven't clicked the Magill link as of yet. But from my eye, just way too inconsistent and way too many HR balls. That being said, there were a lot of times I watched him and his mid 90's heat and slider were good to nasty. Can he be taught more consistency at this point? I'm not convinced, even with a 7 man pen, that. 3rd LH won't be kept instead of someone like Magill or Hildenberger.
-
Park: Twins Emphasizing Catcher Defense, Framing
Makes sense to try and have your catchers on the same page, whether it's framing or something else. I agree game calling and overall defense are more important. But as was previously mentioned, framing isn't necessarily trying to "steal" a strike so much as making a close pitch be called a strike. As to the whole umpire scenario, I prefer the human element. But while never perfect, you absolutely can teach, review, grade, promote and denote so there is greater accuracy and consistency behind the plate.
-
Article: BREAKING: Twins to Sign Versatile Marwin Gonzalez
Yes, I absolutely hope we have another pen addition before much longer. But this is smart! I've been strongly advocating a move like this for weeks, just never thought it would be Marwin. I would much rather have a FO, manager and coaching staff trying to figure out how to keep 16 position players they like and want when there is only room for 13, rather than trying to find 13 and praying nobody gets hurt or performs poorly. This same time last year nobody could know or predict the seasons/injuries/suspensions of Sano, Buxton, Polanco and Castro.[not to mention Dozier finally admitting to playing hurt all season]. I feel so much better about roster depth and flexibility now.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Looking For A Bounceback (Part 3)
Schoop had an amazing 2017. Everyone wants to talk about that vs his "collapse" in 2018 due to all the things mentioned above. But his 2 previous seasons to 2017 were really good. I expect a big bounce back season. My only problem is, do we find a way to keep him beyond this season. Gordon has real talent and potential. He's just not fast tracking the way we all hoped. If he needs a full season of AAA, or close to it, should we just dismiss him because he isn't the stud we hoped a 1st round pick should be? Isnt the payoff more important than the original investment?
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Looking For A Bounceback (Part 2)
Liking this post or not...and I do/did...i have NEVER liked the "insanity is doing the same thing over again and expecting different results" comment. That is NOT the definition of insanity, though poignant. Is that comment truly from Einstein? I consider myself to be a pretty smart and intelligent individual, but always wondered where that comment came from. NOT absolving Molitor for limited arms on hand, nor blaming him or injuries, but there were times when you just had to let a game go, or toss someone to the mound and hope for the best, instead of abusing and over using the trusted arms you had. I agree with the recent article by Tom, the bullpen has a low floor but a pretty high ceiling. I still would rather have Romero and Mejia starting, maybe even piggybacking one another, even alternating for the 5th rotation spot. But what do I know? Maybe Romero is destined to be the next great Twins closer. Is that a bad thing? I keep hearing Odorizzi had his worst year. But I also read he was among the top X SP in many categories. Pineda, healthy, could be very good. I hate that there are so many questions. But I'm also excited about so much potential.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Looking For A Bounceback (Part 2)
NOT a fan or apologist of Molitor as a manager. Simply stating that there were games when the Twins seemed to be obviously on the short end of things and he would put out his most trusted RP in hope of a surprising comeback instead of letting a game maybe go by. To his defense, the pen may not have always been as deep as needed. But again, don't you just toss a "someone" out there at times and hope vs riding your best relievers in a possible no win situation? I don't like Romero and Mejia in the pen. Mostly because I think both have real starter potential. But if the FO and Rocco see this as best arms on hand, and not limiting their potential to such, and being fluid in their usage and future roles, then I'm on board with starting 2019 in the pen.
-
Next Man Up on the Bump
23yo now and a successful AAA debut, even in SSS. A history of winning and great numbers posted in his milb career and missing 2 whole seasons. Personally, I'd put him #4 on the prospect list. He doesn't need to be rushed! There is no reason for him not to begin 2019 at Rochester. And there is no reason for him not to be ready by mid season. It's all up to him. As stated, he's not just a soft tossing lefty who tricks batters. Pre and post injury and illness he has shown real ability and real stuff. Just give him a little more time to develop and work on his stuff. You mentioned all of Romero, Mejia and Gonsalves. Romero and Mejia will be in the pen initially as Rocco and his staff prepare for 2019. If they follow development the way the Rays have, and the Cardinals have, and the way the Twins did with Santana and Liriano, both of these guys could figure in the 2019 rotation and beyond. Gonsalves is a classic SP who just needs time to learn and adapt. And when called upon at some point in 2019 we will see a different pitcher than we saw initially in 2018, as a rookie. Thorpe has even better stuff than Gonsalves. Let him blow away AAA and bring him up when needed. Nurture Romero and Gonsalves and Mejia as needed, plug them in where they best fit, but never lose sight of the 2nd half of 2019 and beyond.
-
Article: Catching Up With Ryan Jeffers
Big bat and offensive potential with power and what appears to be decent contact and a decent approach and good eye. All great! But what else could he offer? I mean, a college bat with power and hitting and power potential is NOT some outlier ML teams are oblivious to. Right? But then you mix in high intelligence and genuine WANT to be a catcher and control the game and I think the FO may have quickly gone from a "huh" to very smart selection.
-
The best SS in Twins history?
Hey Mike, just really wanted to thank you for all these greatest/retrospect posts. I have really enjoyed them! I feel a tad guilty as I haven't posted, until now, despite my enjoyment. Been a little more quiet as of late, gearing up for ST I think! LOL But these have been wonderful and very well thought out! For context purposes, I'm 53 and been a Twins fan since my father introduced me them ata be 5. You wouldn't guess my age to look at me, nobody does, and I certainly don't act my age a lot of days, lol. But I've been an avid fan for 48yrs. Wow, how time flies! What I really enjoy is reading about guys that were before my time, and their place in Twins history, as well as reading about some guys I had forgotten about. I find it fun and interesting when I remember someone that you don't. Just brings back a lot of memories scrounging through limited paper information before the internet, and so many years listening to AM radio, sometimes filled with static. I wish I had had the time to comment on each of these posts, but alas, I haven't had the opportunity to do so. And at this point, going back would probably fall on deaf ears. All of this being said I wanted to jump on this positional post. I'm not a big WAR guy for various reasons that are unimportant here. Due to context, I am leaving Cardenas out of the equation. From the history of the Twins, I'd have to place Versalles as the best overall SS. My memories of Smalley are two-fold. His initial time with the Twins and his homecoming. Wondering...in case I missed it somehow...is your WAR ranking skewed because his second time around was more of a DH/utility role? Offense and defense, production and memory, I would make a shorter list of the following: 1] Versalles 2A] Gagne 2B] Smalley 3] Guzman Rea)y torn between Bartlett and Mears limited time.
-
Article: Video: Willians Astudillo Just Took Jose Berrios Deep
Fresh off winter ball, and in a comfort zone the pitchers certainly aren't the first day, his HRs are fun, but meaningless. What is NOT meaningless is his incredible milb career hitting results carrying over to Rochester and Minnesota in 2018, along with increased power, and continuing this trend through the just completed winter season. Just how good he can be is debatable, but there is nothing to indicate he is just a fun story as opposed to a real ballplayer and real find. Early season breaks, I believe the Twins will open with a 12 man staff. Hopefully it will stay that way. The FO has made comments about where they will NOT play him vs all the spots they WILL. That's pretty high praise and a rather telling arguement as to their opinion of him. Other than injury, the only way he doesn't make the opening roster is the fact he has an option. The Twins may simply want more time with Austin or even a resurgent Duda. That wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing. Having too many guys you like, who can help the club, is a good thing. Over/under on Astudillo getting 300 ML/AB? I'm betting the over!
-
Article: TD 2019 Top Minnesota Twins Prospects Recap
I think it's easy to quibble about the order of the rankings, but that has already been expressed previously. Based on early results, potential, and the thoughts of others not involved with TD, I do wonder a bit about Balazovic not appearing in the top 20. I have a feeling that will change come this time next year, if not a mid-season re-shuffle. It may sound strange to say, but one of the things that intrigues me is the listing of prospects that were honorable mention outside the top 20. There are a lot of guys there that have real ML potential in the next couple of years. My greatest "concern" is also the thing that excites me most. There is just so much talent and potential on this top 20 list, despite some question marks. There are a couple guys here rough around the edges with, maybe, lower floors, but with very high ceilings. Alcala and Duran are prime examples. Both have big arms and each could be part of the rotation in the next couple of years, but each has enough to work on to project as quality relievers instead, or wash out as just tantalizing hard throwers. But that's where the new FO, new coaches, and a new way of doing things comes in to play.
-
Twins signing their extension candidates in reverse order?
Exactly. Rosario and Berrios are next. Once you have Polanco and Kepler figured in to the budget, it's giving you a better idea what it takes for the next signings. And offers WILL be made. Makes me feel even better about what the FO sees with talent on hand, and the core in place. We can scream about additions, but they are playing a slow game to the future. They really like what they have and want to lock up what they have. It's a valid argument believing in what you have vs augmenting what you have through FA. I'm at least excited, somewhat, that they are trying up the talent on hand.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
Absolutely! Why I still preach patience at times. I believe in promotions for top talent. And I think thjs FO has been, and will be aggressive. But you also have to knkw when jts prudent to pull the reigns back a bit. For example, they were aggressive with Romero. But he's still a work in progress, especially for his 3rd pitch. But he's also one of the best arms we have. Can we be smart enough to utilize him properly in 2019 and still develop him? Khirilloff is a NATURAL. That doesn't mean he doesn't have things to learn and adjustments to be made. But I think he's ready right now for AA. To rake like he did in a pitcher friendly league tells me he is ready for the next level. Personally, despite his talent and potential, I wouldn't care if he didn't debut until 2020 for various reasons. But I wouldn't be surprised if he forces the issue this year. What a wonderful conundrum it would be to place Khirilloff, Rosario, Buxton, Kepler, Cron, Cruz all in the same lineup with Cave saying....wait a minute, what about me? But I'm OK with stacking talent, end of 2019 and beyond.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #3 Brusdar Graterol
Quoted this even though I also wanted to quote ashburyjohn and nicksaviking. Just easier this WAY. All of you are correct. I mean, if you want to be abstract, a slider is a "change" from a FB, etc. But that is obviously not what we are talking about here. But there are different variations of a "changeup". There is the straight change, the circle change, the palm ball, and some would tell you the splitter was a form of change for a power pitcher. Just...SOMEBODY...grab this kid and teach him SOMETHING in regard to a repeatable 3rd pitch that has speed variation and at least decent control, because his other stuff is outstanding. No rush. Work on the third pitch. Not "babying" him, just working on the 3rd pitch and building up endurance of IP for a full season.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #3 Brusdar Graterol
Sorry Seth, my copy of the Handbook says 6' 1" 247lbs. Did I get a mis-print? Refund! Lol But seriously, I have to wonder how much height really matters. I understand the downward plane concept of course. But not every successful power pitcher has had had a towering frame. I have often mentioned Pedro Martinez when discussing Berrios in the past. I have done so knowing Pedro was more of a slider pitcher while Jose is more of a curveball thrower. And I have little doubt Berrios is larger,overall, than Perez. But live FB, Bulldog mentality and lack of height is why I always grouped them together. HUGE fan and believer in Berrios, and believe we have yet to see the best of him. Graterol seems to have the same "attitude" and work ethic as Berrios...and Perez. The fact that he throws a slider rather than a curve may make him an even better comp to Perez than Berrios. The whole point is, height and length is not always in play. Hard stuff is hard stuff. Big breaking stuff that missing bats is still big breakjng stuff. It still comes down to control and consistency, doesnt it? Yes, to be an effective SP you need at least 1 more pitch. But in today's game, with high K totals, swinging for the fences batters, and the high K looking better and better for smart pitchers who can hit spots, does height and plane even matter as much any longer?
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #5 Wander Javier
I understand and appreciate your consternation. But we DO have those types of prospects. Their names are Lewis and Khirilloff and even Graterol. Before that was Sano and Buxton. And we can all lament the status of those two. I know I do! Only time will tell about Sano and Buck. But consider Sano was an All Star in 2017 before a very significant injury which required surgery. Buxton had a completely messed up 2018. There are HUGE questions surrounding both of these young men. Early reports are good health, both working hard and being fit and ready for 2019. We will see. But we shouldn't be down on Javier at this point. He has shown outstanding ability when healthy. His first injury was a hamstring issue. Just one if those things? Possibly due to still growing in to his body? Who knows? The second was a torn labrum on his left, non-throwing arm. As has been stated, young Khirilloff had an injury just as severe, if not more so, and came back with a vengeance in 2018. If he is fully healthy in 2019, Javier could be following a similar path that Khirilloff and Lewis followed last year.