Everything posted by DocBauer
-
In Appreciation: Jake Odorizzi
Nice write up. And I'm in full agreement on Odorizzi. He doesn't pitch the number of innings you want, but he is borderline dominate for 5+ daily. While the Twins NEED another SP, and there is debate about the whole addition of adding "impact pitching", I don't see how bringing back Odorizzi and Pineda, 2 of the top 12-14 arms available on anyone's list, isn't adding impact pitching. Adding Clippard isn't adding a bum either. They need to add a similar pitcher to Berrios and Odorizzi. Also agree that a flier for depth and competition is an easy must.
-
Lineup Questions/Changes for 2020
Also intrigued by Kepler hitting 3rd and Cruz batting cleanup. Followed by Rosario and then Sano to keep the RH/LH mix going?
-
Lineup Questions/Changes for 2020
While Buxton still has the skill set to be dangerous at the top of the order, I still see him batting 9th because he did so well there last season. Less pressure and he knocked guys in a flipped the order so effectively. I think a "set" lineup won't really exist only because Rocco plays everyone and seems to put together a lineup that works daily. Good players help, lol. But day one, big game lineup, I'm thinking the following: Arraez Polanco Cruz Rosario/Kepler Sano Kepler/Rosario 1B TBD/Garver Garver/1B TBD Buxton If Atlanta doesn't offer a 4th year and Donaldson comes on board (keep those fingers crossed): Arraez Polanco Cruz Donaldson Rosario/Kepler Sano Kepler/Rosario Garver Buxton Great talent and great balance. Very dangerous either way.
-
Lineup Questions/Changes for 2020
Great question and one I've been thinking about. Even without a sudden addition of Donaldson, should he take the Twins 4yr offer, there are a lot of reasons for a potential shakeup here. Kepler was awesome in the #1 spot last year. Would you want to move him lower on the order for his power and production? Why would you even consider doing that? Because Arraez and Polanco could make even more sense setting the table on top. But then again, maybe the BA/OB contact skills of Arraez are better used down lower in the order? If Kepler were to move down, how far? Does he drop to #3 and Cruz becomes your cleanup batter? Or could he supplant Rosario and bump Rosario all the way down to #6 behind Sano, even with the fine year he had? To me it all comes down to who Rocco and his staff truly feel belongs in the top 2 spots.
-
2019/2020 Twins Minor League Signings
FWIW, I am familiar with Asche from his time in college for the Huskers. Not a top prospect, he still had some helium rising through milb. He's had some ML experience and could prove to be a decent, "useful" type of player.
-
Front Page: Here Is What War Projections Say About the Twins and White Sox
While I am not a fan of the Dirty Sox in the least, I appreciate their efforts from afar. And while I can appreciate some of the modern statistical measurements, I remain a huge skeptic. Point in fact, another article, written on another Twins website...though compares to TD...uses the same, or much the same, analytical measurements, using mostly the Pythagorean record...all Greek to me, lol...and WAR, and has them as a .500 team for 2020. As of now, the Twins sit at a minimum of 90 wins using the same analytics. I think there is a big difference between the "analytics" used by beat writers, fans and savants vs the analytics used by progressive FO personnel. Give me the best team you can put on the field. Short in an area? Shore up that area the best you can and build up your strengths to compensate. Then give me the best staff you can to utilize what you have. Then let's play ball and see what we have. Besides, it's not even January 1st yet!
-
Front Page: Nelson Cruz and the Twins' Biggest Mistake in History
Career production, last season production, regression and projection all indicate we should see pretty much the same Cruz, give or take a little, we saw in 2019. Just allowing for father time, I'd expect some regression and a few more games played to see him post very similar numbers next year. Now, Cruz could just decide enough is enough and retire after 2020. Be could also decide he wants to chase some numbers and feel like he's ready to play some more. That would put him in a year to year situation, IMO. Could put he and the Twins in an interesting position come the end of next year. But, that is a discussion for a very distant time and place. I get the Papi reference, and while comparison is natural, the re-tread of a Ryan mistake made 16yrs ago just needs to stop. Whole careers have been made since that time.
-
Front Page: The 12 Free Agents of Twins-mas: Part III - Pitchers
Wanted to make a quick comment about the last OP concerning OF as I wasn't able to. Pretty much no to anyone unless Rosario is moved. Again, unless Cave is moved, per some reports, the only things needed is a smart option to compete with said Cave, and Wadem and Raley who can provide a legitimate, possibly, option in CF so Kepler wouldn't have to slide over. And I don't think Hamilton is that guy. Now...on to the current topic at hand: Really surprised the OP is this short of a list. To bring up Colon, even for the sake of humor, is unforgivable in lieu of arms like Wood and Walker as viable options. Are they not mentioned because they have been brought up in previous articles? Or have I missed something over the last couple of days and they are suddenly gone? At this point they, and even Smyly, would be more viable options than Hernandez, IMO. Every year there is someone, be it an over 30 veteran, or a 27-29yo coming off injury and/or surgery that still offers upside if healthy and with the right fit. How about one of those guys for $5-6M with maybe an option to a potential 4th or 5th rotation slot? Now, Sanchez could be one of those guys at 27 and coming off injury. Everyone wants to talk about Houston and the Astro's approach to things. But the Twins analytics department and Wes Johnson might be new to the scene but we have already seen major changes from the top down. From this list, he could be interesting. Not sure he'd be my first choice, however. Already mentioned a few guys I like as much or more. For 1yr and $4M, I'd be all in on Will Harris. First, especially for $4M, he would do nothing to blow up payroll and trade options or additional signings. You can never have enough pitching, whether rotation or bullpen. But with Romo back, and Clippard, and the rest coming back, and a few other arms on the rise like Alcala, on the rebound like Romero, etc, is there truly room for him? Maybe there is. The rest of this list is a hard pass!
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
I liked your points very much, even though I'm not joining the ongoing debate. I ad to laugh at your typo of "joke grown roster" at the end. I've made a few crazy typos or had weird auto corrects at times but this one made me chuckle. Like you, and most of us I think, home grown is always best. Even the last Yankees dynasty...and I DESPISE giving them credit of any sort...was built on a core of home grown talent. I also believe FA is a tool to augment your roster, not build it. Marwin and Cruz are great examples of that, for us, last season. While this FO has absolutely not ignored the FA route, Castro, Marwin, Cruz and Now Clippard, etc, they've done it smartly. They've also made some signings that were basically waiver wire in Cron and Pineda that were smart. But you are 100% correct that the Twins, HERE AND NOW, are in a unique position. People can call my an apolgist if they choose to do so, but I honestly believe the FO made a real offer to Wheeler...maybe just a 1st offer...but were simply told "no thank you" early on. There have not only been various reports of such, which I find confounding for a 101 win team playing in one of the best ballparks in all of baseball but also a team that is mostly young and on the rise, but he also turned down a better offer to pitch for a far "worse" team in the White Sox. Bumgarner went out and orchestrated his own special deal with Arizona. So what are the Twins to do in those situations? Understand, none of this is pointed at you, just me pointing out the reality of the situation. There is so much clamoring about the Twins missing, or being stingy, but these two examples are real, and seem to be treated as sour grapes and looking for someone to point fingers at. Right now, the Twins continue to look to add. The are one of only two teams...ONE of ONLY TWO TEAMS...who have made a 4yr offer to Donaldson. Unfortunately, speculation is the Braves are his preferred destination and have a sort of "right of first refusal" at their disposal. Despite mass WANT to see something happen, I'm not overly disappointed in not topping offers for Ryu. He COULD surprise us all. And he is very good when available. But odds and past history would lend percentages WAY to the disappointment side of things. You are absolutely right to reference Morris as a big FA signing at the time in '91, though IIRC, he wasn't exactly speculated as being the ACE performer he turned out to be, (more life left in the arm than some gave him credit for). I would go back further to remind that Blyleven was brought back for the first WS team via trade. I really wish we could all concentrate on tomorrow, and not what didn't happen, for various reasons. Seems we're kicking rocks at this point. As you accurately state, the Twins are in a unique position right now. And i apologize after 17+ pages of so much debate and frustration being vented if I missed an opinion, but what would you do at this point?
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
I also prefer more than 1-2yrs. Everyone should. Which makes we wonder all the more about an "under the wire" acquisition like Odorizzi was. I fully confess the FO is a hell of a lot smarter than I am on this. Not crazy about a 1yr unless it comes "cheap" with at least some hope of an extension. 2yr doesn't bother me so much. IMO, Odorizzi is a strong extension possibility. Once we remove the humongous contracts of Cole and Strasburg, his 2020 QO deal of $17.8M is pretty much in line. Adding 2-3yrs for something close to that should be expected and warranted and affordable. And he has already stated he'd like to stay.
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
If you want to debate not signing Ryu for 4yrs and more than $20M considering age and lack of general availability for his career thus far, I can understand. I will disagree, but I understand. The comments about Wheeler and Bumgarner have to stop as they are irrelevant. Sorry, but it's true. Wheeler had a strong preference to stay on the coast and turned down more money from at least one team to stay there. There are various reports that the Twins were NEVER in his plans. If they offered $140M would he have listened? Maybe. None of us knows. But than again, a contract like that is a whole different debate. Bumgarner practically wrote his own deal with Arizona to fit in with their plans and finances. He's taking only $6M this year and deffering another $17M. He left $20-25M to sign where he did. What do we do NOW? The prospect capital is there to bring in a quality SP for the staff. Is that a #2-3 arm and who exactly I don't know. To say there are no possibilities is silly as we have and do see guys move. What if there is another Odorizzi type trade we aren't even thinking about that will pay off just as well? Personally, I'm hoping Donaldson is serious, not playing us, and comes on board. Sign a Wood or Walker for depth. Then go out and cash in a handful of prospect chips, or include Rosario if that is to be, and get that trade arm the FO and Johnson like.
-
Front Page: Projecting Minnesota's 2023 Line-Up
I love this projected lineup and find it plausible, exciting, and even very possible. But I also think 1 or 2 of the guys we are talking about are traded. Remember, this projection is in a vacuum for how things sit today. Could Rosario still be in LF on an extension and Larnach moved in a deal?
-
Front Page: Projecting Minnesota's 2023 Line-Up
I can absolutely see this happening and wouldn't be surprised. But I can also see Javier continuing to mature physically and slide to 3B. Lewis could still wind up at SS, or, possibly CF IF Buxton is gone. Not saying he will be, but it's a possibility.
-
Front Page: Opening Thoughts: Brusdar Graterol (What Would You Do?)
To me the debate isn't traditional SP or primary pitcher following the opener. I do, however, think this could be the perfect example of when and why and how to use an opener. No, to me the decision is ML or AAA to begin the year. He can make the jump and skip AAA. It's been done before. But the combination of losing out on just normal development time last season, including work on his change, might necessitate some time at Rochester to begin the year. If the change looks good in ST, keep him and use him on the rotation as they best see. If the change is lagging, I'd say Rochester initially.
-
Front Page: Twas the Night Before Christmas (Twins Edition)
Had me except for Price and Twitter. Lol WELL DONE! To all a happy Offseason, season, and dreams of playoff wins for our beloved Twins. As you nestle down to sweet dream for Christmas nap, M or TC on your favorite cap Remember all you are blessed with And carefully open those gifts. Merry Twinsmas and God Bless you all!
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
Going to repeat myself briefly here, though I don't want to and shouldn't have to. IMPACT PITCHING: Kind of hard to define what that means. I guess to some, it means spending $ because that will surely make it so, pick your FA option of choice. Depending on which/who's list you look at, Odorizzi was clearly one of the top 6-10 options available. He's back! He has stated he'd like to stay. Forgetting Cole and Strasburg, his 2020 salary is about right on with the other numbers we've seen. So the Twins wouldn't sign him to a similar extension why? The parameters and want are all there. Pineda was in the top 14 on every list. He's also back, for 2yrs. And they have no "impact" why? Just because they were here before? So because they have already pitched for the Twins before, and done well, they lose value? There is much lamenting and gnashing of teeth...WAY too much so...because the Twins "missed out" on guys ranked LOWER than them simply because they didn't make a signing, and didn't get, for various/whatever reasons for a couple of guys ranked higher. I call B.S. I get it. I'm a lifelong Twins fanatic. I want to be excited and pumped! This team needs a starter equal to Berrios and Odorizzi if not better. Better is pretty damn hard as there isn't a store where you can pick someone off the shelf and plug them in. But again, the powers that be can just throw out $ and terms and hope, or they can also be turned down or decide the numbers just don't make sense at some point. Back to the OP... WHAT TO DO NOW: I wasn't initially on this train but find myself buying a ticket now. I'm intrigued and regrettably hopeful Donaldson isn't just playing the Twins and Nats against Atlanta. (I think that might be his long game). He's not exactly a poor consolation prize. But this is about pitching, primarily. Regardless of the Donaldson situation, I'm looking at a trade for Thor, Ray, Gray and maybe Archer. There are others, of course. I'm not convinced the Mets are out on trading Thor. They have done a good job in building depth and may be looking to add via subtraction. Ray and Gray plug right in and offer up differing scenarios based on control. Archer would probably come cheaper, but could be very interesting for a bounce back in the AL again, and with Johnson working with him. I'm fairly certain the Twins braintrust knows a hell of a lot more than I do, so their favorite/preferred target might not be any of these options. But a trade target HAS to be made at this point. Next, I look hard at someone like Wood or Walker and sign them for a 1+1 type of deal for around $5-6M to compete and provide depth and a possible steal. The second year with an acceptable buyout is important as I want options and flexibility if I guess right. There is still ample opportunity for the kids to impress and develop during the season. I'm trading 2 of my top 10, another 1 or 2 in the next 10, possibly replaced by Cave or Rosario depending on the situation, to acquire a top 2-3 SP. I'm signing a flier with an option for depth. If Donaldson is just playing us, I look for the best 1B or 1B convert...think LeMahieu with the Yankees...to add to the lineup and keep the offense rolling.
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
This!! The FO has done so many good things...I'd give them a solid 90% grade so far, or better, from the ML level all the way down...that I think they have earned at least a little trust and patience for their plan/vision.
-
Front Page: Revisiting Falvey and Levine Era Trades: Break in Case of World Series
While the jury is certainly out, I'd say they were good moves overall and potential wins. Even the Pressly deal, which I didn't like then and don't like now, could be a win or at least break even 2 years from now. Still would have rather kept him. Losing Escobar hurt for a few reasons and I think we'd be a better team with him. But if they couldn't agree on an extension and he was going to leave, then they did the right thing at the right time Hindsight is, of course, 20/20. But I wish we could go back, see the future, and play those moves differently.
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
Going to hit a few topics here all at once. Agree with me or blast me, up to you. I will also state again, I am not an apologist for the FO. I am, however a big fan of most of what they have done to this point. And I will freely admit there have been a few times when j have disagreed with what they did, or didn't do, and have been proven wrong. ALL that being said, here we go: 1] There are, of course, exceptions. (There is no need to rebuttle, I've already stated the previous fact). But generally speaking, a true ACE SP is rarely made available unless it is a team in some sort of cost cutting or rebuild mode. They are prized possessions. This FA class was unique in that there 2 available. The final price tag and terms alone, in retrospect if not for thought, eliminates all but a handful of teams in the league. I really wanted Wheeler. I would have liked Bumgarner for various reasons, despite various arguments against, which I get. Wheeler is healthy enough, just young enough, with nice velocity, he could raise his game to another level. But to think he was an ACE SP just waiting to come to anyone is hyperbole at best at this point. That's not a knock. He has a fine arm. He COULD take another step forward. But if he was that good, then why did his cost come at half of the other 2 prizes? Wheeler turned down more money elsewhere, from at least one team. A well placed source with Arizona basically stated Bumgarner and his agent contacted Arizona about playing there. As I have heard reported, he is signed for something around $6M for 2020, and deffered around $16-17M post contract, and left something between $20-25M on the table from other offers to pitch for the Diamondbacks. 2] "Impact pitching" is the catch phrase everyone hangs their hat on. But what does that mean exactly? And that may be the rub that frustrates and disturbs the most. I never heard, "we are going to sign or trade for one of the best SP in the game". When the season ended, Odorizzi and Pineda were on almost every list as 2 of the top 10-12 rotation arms available. The Twins re-signed both. Because they were with us last season somehow diminishes their ability are value? They were part of one of the deepest and best ranked rotations in the AL last season despite Gibson and Perez falling apart. The Twins absolutely NEED another SP to legitimately compete for one of the top 3 spots in the rotation. And we could argue about someone like Bumgarner or Keuchel as being able to be that guy. But what about trading for that guy? How about Gray, or Ray, or a bounce back from Archer, just to toss out 3 names? They will cost a handful of prospects from a deep system, but they all could be as good or better than most or all the FA arms we "missed out" on without the years and $. I remind that Odorizzi and Pineda were surprises with mixed feelings when brought on board, but have proven to be very smart moves. Now, said trade HAS TO HAPPEN, and hasn't happened yet. YET. So let's slow the roll of angst for a moment. Personally, I'd still like a Wood, Walker type of cheap signing also for depth and competition. It would just be smart to do so. This a team well built overall, coming off 101 win season with most everything intact, including a much better and deeper bullpen than when 2019 began. We saw a few pitching prospects get their feet wet and show potential. A few more of equal ability might not be far off. The payroll can easily allow for additions, and prospect capital is high. I'm EAGER for something to happen. Hell, I'm even hoping Donaldson is actually interested and not just playing the Twins and Nationals against one another in order to get a better final offer from the Braves, (which could be reality), and we get him AND make a solid trade. But despite my own anxiousness to see a move, and to see ST and the season start, I'm just not ready to pull some kind of plug on 2020 because we lost out on a collection of over 30, high contract pitchers when I haven't seen the final chapter of this off season yet.
-
Front Page: Twins Need to Make a Splash With the Rain Man: Sign Josh Donaldson
I know I'm repeating myself, but I always felt a "major" FA SP signing was 50-50 vs making a trade acquisition. I felt Wheeler and Bumgarner were the only 2 that really made sense. I didn't think they were serious about moving Sano at this time, but the rumors and links to various 3B and not a peep about a 1B being added in any way has me thinking they are at least fairly serious about this possibility. Now whether it happens or not...
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
As a fan, of course I'm disappointed and frustrated. I was hoping for Wheeler and Bumgarner was my 2nd Choice. I've just never been sold on Ryu, though I would have cheered and hoped. I'm not trying to sound smart, but I've said all along it was 50-50 the Twins would sign a FA vs making a trade. Except for Wheeler and Bumgarner, I didn't see a match that made sense. Now, they still have to make a trade, and I believe they will. Who and what it will cost I don't know. Lastly, there are still a couple guys like Wood and Walker who i think would be smart, inexpensive bounce back candidates to help fill up the rotation. I hope we go get one.
-
Front Page: Internal Reinforcements: Which Twins Prospects Appear to Be Most Prepared to Contribute in 2020?
While I believe there is a very good chance we see both Kirilloff and Larnach at some point in 2020, and with all due respect to Rooker who I have doubts but hopes for, Raley is the position player closest to help IMO. Been banging his drum for some time now so I'm either going to look really smart or really stupid. He seems to be able to hit with some patience and power, runs well enough to even play some CF. I think He gets forgotten about by some because he didn't come up through the Twins system initially. Thorpe, Dobnak, Smeltzer and Graterol have already contributed, at least to some degree, and all 4 will make contributions this year. Unfortunately, despite pure stuff, the time frame for Graterol is a bit up in the air as he needs to remain a starter. But he needs some nurturing. But I believe taking a little time and using him wisely this year will end up paying huge dividends. Really anxious to see what Alcala and Duran do this year. Alcala could be knocking on the door pretty hard really soon. And I believe we have established that Romero does, in fact, have an option left.
-
Front Page: Two Lefty Starters the Twins Could Trade For Right Now
Both 28yo and within 6 months of one another. Matz is LH and throws in the mid 90 range, would love to see what Johnson could do with him. He could be about ready to blossom, but figures to be no worse than a #4. Ray has only 1 season of control but is more proven. What are the odds of a trade and extension rolled in to one? If I'm not mistaken, there is still a QO offer available after next year so that may give a team a little more leverage. I'm willing to pay more in prospect capital for Ray if we can work out some kind of extension. Otherwise, I have to see some "lightening up" of a trade pack for just the 1 year.
-
Taijuan Walker
This is one of the guys I've been nudging for as the "other" pitcher to sign after we get out top new SP, whoever that may be. His 2015-17 seasons were solid, he's still very young, and His arm should be sound now and ready to go. Really like the 2yr or 2yr + idea. I think the first year should be around $5M. This could end up being a very, very smart signing.
-
Front Page: Slinging Frisbees: 3 Reasons Why the Twins Bullpen Will Be Dominant in 2020
Still wondering and holding out hope where Romero fits in at some point.