Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Report: Twins Willing to Back Out on Blockbuster Deal
Just a complete farce the way this was handled by Boston. Disappointed the trade didn't go through but happy to have Graterol back. Really unfair to the guy the way this was handled. Glad the Twins didn't give in and add more to the deal. Another top 10 prospect when technically the deal went through LA? Please!
-
José Berríos Losing Arbitration Case Provides Reason for Concern Over Long-Term Future with Twins
Honestly, quoted you without remembering who you were speaking to directly, so forgive. Berrios declined an extension last year. OK. As of now he has not declined an extension this year. Maybe he will. "Reports" say talks are amicable and the arbitration process was not contentious. Reports also say talks are ongoing, while apart, which is why I'm not going nuts over this hearing. Maybe, maybe Berrios will follow the Bauer concept of betting on yourself yearly. Personally, I find that ridiculous in regard to guaranteed contracts, but whatever. Maybe, maybe Berrios is banking on being productive and healthy long enough to escape the whole arbitration and year to year process because he wants to escape Minnesota for a big market city. I also find that ridiculous because if I were his agent I'd be looking for at least a little security in case of injury, if nothing else. He is young, and part of a winning team, who has a wide open window. He's seen a few teammates lock up deals. He's seen the team be aggressive with recent contracts and additions to make the best team they can. They just made a major trade following a franchise record FA signing. Personally, I think he's smart enough to bet on himself and his future, while not being short-sighted enough to bet on "what if" tomorrow and is holding out for more but willing to sign. What that magic number is I don't know. Are we talking something like 5yrs and $1M per apart or $5M? None of us knows. But if talks are truly ongoing and cordial, then something will get done. And $3K+ will mean nothing. I feel this FO is smart enough to know what they have that they will be realistic but not be "cheap".
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
I'd really like to post this in about 3 different threads, but will probably just stick with this one. What really irks me is the way this is playing out not just for the organizations,and fans, but for the players themselves. I love baseball! I enjoy the NFL, but not as much as I used to, for various reasons, but that is a different discussion. In MLB, I do not take sides in regard to players vs owners. In the universe that is professional baseball, I side with minor league players, and changes I see as an absolute MUST. We're I an owner, I'd be looking at better treatment, conditions and salary for the lifeblood of my franchise. I would be mkre than willing to thumb my nose at other owners for how I did things because it's not only my franchise, but it's the minors, not MLB. But when it is the BIG STAGE, I don't take sides. I find it oddly curious when others do. We argue about billionaires vs millionaires. We argue about MLB players earning well over 500K per season, with additional perks, and arbitration numbers that go in to the millions. And then we harumph when owners when owners when "only" spend X number of millions. It's really kind of crazy when you step back and look at it all. FWIW, never thought an owner should be an owner if his ego and sense of fun didn't allow him to push the envelope. Otherwise, why own a team in the first place? Ken Rosenthal on MLNetwork commented, as others have, that thjs deal probably still goes through. So my rant may prove worthless. We all know enough to realize there are sometimes questions and delays. But this feels abnormal to me. Maybe it was early reporting? But I'm kind of siding on the retorts from the union on this one. Players are caught in the ceasefire. What if the Twins are dumped out of this? What do they do next? Does Graterol feel welcome comimg back? Is he offered up again in a different deal? The more I look at this, the more frustrated I get at how it has been handled, especially on the Boston end. I feel like some amateurs have been brought in to muck things up.
-
2020 ST Rotation Primer/Falvey and Levine Era
Thank you! I really like the OP by Matt with K%. I concentrated on league and AL WAR. K% would never tell the whole story, of course, because a ton of BB or hits could deflect the results of SO and swing and miss %. Not sure I have the time to re-post the same 4yr time frame and include K%. I'm intrigued now about looking at team WHIP through the same time frame because that may be even more relevant. But then again, as someone still a little outside the analytics fraternity, perhaps WAR accounts for these already???
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: #10 RHP Blayne Enlow
In my own mental handicapping, I've had him ranked lower. Admittedly unfair when I look at his age and reflect on his first half of last season. I see a projected 1st round selection with a major school scholarship offer and the best curveball in his draft class and I just expected/wanted more. Reading this report, his growth physically, increased velocity and better K numbers and I become optomostic. Fair or not, I'm waiting/hoping for a real breakout 2020 where we see dominance across the board before I feel comfortable putting him in the top 10.
-
Twins Trade Suggests More Pieces to Move
This. The Twins don't dislike Graterol. He has a very talented arm with a huge potential future in front of him. And he's still very, very young. He might yet be a fine to great SP if nurtured a bit. But the FO brain trust sees him as a power BP arm. And that is still valuable, to the Twins or Boston. But the prospect cost to bring in a quality starting SP is not some low level flier, or a couple of them.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: #9 Brent Rooker
Absolutely. And I would do nothing to hold back his development. But surely he is the kind of player/prospect who will be in the lineup almost daily. Let him play all 3 spots and see where he settles in, I say. For various reasons, some guys are just better or more comfortable in LF vs RF. The foot placement and action at 1B is different than the OF to be sure. I just hope they don't restrict him too soon.
-
2020 ST Rotation Primer/Falvey and Levine Era
Agree 100%. But when the system hasn't produced, for whatever reason, you have to look and find smart choices. I believe they have done that successfully, which was the point of this OP. Personally, I believe Oddo will be back. And while I love the options brought on board, I am very encouraged by Thorpe and Dobnak. Smeltzer to a lesser degree. The one thing the 30+yr olds do is perform and give time for the youngsters here, and those getting close. When I think about Duran and Balazovic and others rising up over the next couple of seasons I get really excited.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: #9 Brent Rooker
Addition: The one thing about Rooker I don't like us his position use. Milb is for player development. I just can't believe he was never used at 1B last year. Players do tend to gravitate to certain positions and settle in there. But he should be learning both corner spots and 1B for now. Look how much positional flexibility aided the Twins roster last year. In ST last year, the Twins even worked Raley in CF to see what he could do, even on an occasional basis.
-
This Ain't Your Dad's Starting Rotation
Really wish we could combine this thread with the one I wrote a couple days ago. I concentrated on WAR of the past 4 rotation staffs and where they ranked in MLB and the AL each year. Really like the look at K%. Am also wondering now if we should also look closer at WHIP.
-
2020 ST Rotation Primer/Falvey and Levine Era
Indeed it does. While we have a whole season to play and then measure, hard to not be excited about the potential of this rotation, especially with Maeda. I was never as down on Perez as some and was always a Gibson supporter. But the reality is, except for stretches, those two just didn't have great 2019 seasons. It really looks to me as if we are improved. Even if the needle hasn't swung as far as we might have liked.
-
Why all the questions about Twins pitching?
Well done! And I agree 100%. The rotation is as good, probably better, and has more depth. The pen also begins the season stronger and deeper than it began last year.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: #9 Brent Rooker
What I have always appreciated, and where I have found faith/hope with Rooker is he has shown the ability to make adjustments at every level. 2018, IIRC, he started rather abysmal at AA and then flipped a switch. He was OK in 2019 at Rochester and then the same thing happened before his injury. He may not mash immediately at the ML level when he gets a chance, but I believe he will make adjustments, as he's always done, and build from there.
-
Twins drafting strategy: Old And Busted already?
After 3 drafts under the new management, I think it's tough to really make any firm conclusions in regard to any real tendancy or preference, much less if any process is broken or not. There is always your BIG BOARD when drafting and the player rankings on it. Baseball is a little unique as it not only breaks down to 2 essential categories, pitcher and player, but also high school and college. The Twins haven't drafted a college pitcher overly high the past 3 drafts? Perhaps they didn't really like the ones available or simply had someone else ranked considerably higher on their board. And really, from a realistic stance, anybody they have drafted so far is really a year away at this point. I'd say we need at least 1 more year, if not 2, to see if there is a real draft strategy preference, and if what they are doing so far is working.
-
Twins beat Berrios at arb hearing
Or, there was no feeling a settlement needed to be worked out at this time as the Twins FO remains confident they will work out an extension at some point here which very likely raises his 2020 salary anyway.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
Dyson had been pitching hurt, but pitching effectively. And he never informed anyone. The medical reports given to the Twins, reportedly, indicated no issues to be concerned about. It is also my understanding that in deadline deals, especially last minute ones, there is generally no physical involved, only traded medical reports by the teams.
-
The 4 Pitches We Will See From Kenta Maeda
Considering the early results we have seen from Wes Johnson, I wonder just how good Maeda might be if that FB could be tweaked a little bit.
-
Graterol Trade On Hold? Valuing Starters and Relievers
I am about the last person you would ever accuse of being a conspiracy theorist, but I do believe this is, at least mostly, a power play by Boston to get something added to the deal whether that be player or additional $ savings. My hunch? As expected, the deal still goes through with the Dodgers giving in something small. I think they really want this to happen. Despite hopes and dreams of Graterol becoming a top of the rotation SP...and he could still be with some time and development...the Twins FO is having doubts about his long term viability there. Doesn't mean they don't like him, just that they believe the pen is his destination. I doubt Graterol's health is the hold up here. He was just fine after his shoulder impingement and there hasn't been so much as a whisper this off-season about any issues.
-
2020 ST Rotation Primer/Falvey and Levine Era
***Took me a couple hours to put this together after work and I had not yet heard about the trade for Maeda***
-
2020 ST Rotation Primer/Falvey and Levine Era
Spring training is about here, thank the baseball gods! And we have one of the best and most intriguing teams in all of MLB to root for. And while there is much to look forward to, debate and discuss let's be honest that the rotation remains the #1 talking/sticking point. And while I it might be fun/interesting to do something like this for each area of the team...who knows, maybe, time and effort may not be there...I just really wanted to examine the rotation situation since that seems to be at the forefront of so much discussion, hope and angst. Kind of hoping this doesn't lead to an overload of "what if" yet again. But it WILL be a part of any discussion, and that's OK. This post is not just about 2020, but how we have arrived at where we are at this point after 3 1/2 years with Falvey and Levine in charge of the team, albeit with two different managers and pitching coaches involved. But we also need to reflect on how we got here, and to do that, I think it's important to also reflect on the 2016 season before they came on board. Below you will see a listing of every pitcher who started a game for the Twins from 2016 through last season. And while I still believe ERA has value, and I am not a pure WAR believer, I see the value. So I am including ML WAR rankings based on what I found on FanGraphs website. Now, how much you value that site or WAR is not the be all of anything. Just trying to offer up perspectives. Bear with me, I think this is all very interesting. 2016 ROTATION BY GS: Ervin Santana 30 Tyler Duffey 26 Kyle Gibson 25 Jose Berrios 14 Tommy Milone 12 Phil Hughes 11 Hector Santiago 11 Pat Dean 9 Andrew Albers 2 Alex Meyer 1 RANKING BY WAR: 23MLB/13AL/7.6 Notes: Berrios's rookie season. Last year of the old FO. Actually forgot Meyer started a game. 2017 ROTATION BY GS: Ervin Santana 33 Kyle Gibson 29 Jose Berrios 25 Adalberto Mejia 21 Barolo Colon 15 Hector Santiago 14 Phil Hughes 9 Aaron Slegers 3 Nik Gurley 3 Dillon Gee 3 Jaime Garcia 1 Dietrich Enns 1 Adam Wilk 1 Tim Melville 1 Nick Tepesch 1 RANKING BY WAR: 24MLB/ 11AL/ 7.1 Notes: First season with the current FO. Not surprising there were a lot of limited starts due to that fact, plus lack of depth. Colon was not only fun, but he actually produced. Not sure we make a WC without him. Oh what could have been with Mejia, 2018 ROTATION BY GS: Jose Berrios 32 Jake Odorizzi 32 Kyle Gibson 32 Lance Lynn 20 Fernando Romero 11 Gabriel Moya 6 Ervin Santana 5 Kohl Stewart 4 Stephen Gonsalves 4 Adalberto Mejia 4 Chase DeJong 4 Phil Hughes 2 Zach Littell 2 Aaron Slegers 2 Tyler Duffey 1 Trevor May 1 RANKING BY WAR: 17MLB/ 7AL/ 9.1 Notes: Despite a frustrating and disappointing season, you are starting to see some greater stability in the rotation. You also see the Tampa influence as the Twins played some with openers at both the milb and ML level. I admit, I completely forgot about Moya actually starting 6 games. A mistake? I guess, they were at least trying something different. 2019 ROTATION BY GS: Jose Berrios 32 Jake Odorizzi 30 Kyle Gibson 29 Martin Perez 29 Michael Pineda 26 Devin Smeltzer 6 Randy Dobnak 5 Lewis Thorpe 2 Kohl Stewart 2 Cody Stashak 1 RANKING BY WAR: 7MLB/ 4AL/ 16.6 Notes: Really, especially considering the past 10 years plus, unparalleled success from the rotation, overall, even considering Perez being mediocre beyond his first couple of months and the Gibson slide due to weakness, and a so-so start to the season as he built up endurance for a time. Despite success in 2019 from this rotation, it could easily be argued the one flaw was maybe sticking with Perez and Gibson as long as the Twins did vs just letting Dobnak, Smeltzer and Thorpe get their opportunity and let fly. Would that opportunity and experience really impacted the final results? FORWARD TO THE 2020 ROTATION: All of this is context to where we have arrived as to where we have been. Were I a complete nut job vs a partial one, I might have included the top SP prospects over the past 4 year perspective I have written. But I'm just not ready for the straitjacket and padded walls...yet. To at least begin 2020 we have the following: Berrios Odorizzi Pineda Hill Bailey Chacin Dobnak Thorpe Smeltzer Some of these names repeat over the 4 year arc I have presented. And some of the names previously presented were good performers, even on disappointing teams. Some were virtual throw ins, to be honest. While a prospect remains a prospect until proven, when was the last time the Twins had names like this, proven vets, prospects who have shown ability and potential, a flier or two that might actually produce? We're not where we want and need to be just yet. But if you look at where we are now, and where we have been, you have to see changes in the make. But all of this is reflection and perspective to debate. Have at it.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: 16-20
1] No knock on Miranda, and I know he's still really young, but I just sort of keep waiting for that breakthrough season. 2] Really unsure what the ceiling is for Sands, but how could anyone at this point. But could you ever have expected a better debut season? With a couple guys graduating from rookie status and another year this good, top 10 next year??? 3] Like most young pitchers, I have also read the 3rd pitch isn't there yet for Colina. Biggest knock I think I've heard is lack of height in regard to downward plane, etc. Guy can bring it. Really hoping the secondary stuff really settles in soon. 4] Blankenhorn has always reminded me of a great multi sport athlete who goes to college to play football and finally gets to concentrate fully on a single sport. Were that to be true, he would now be physically and mentally ready to make a big push in what would probably be his junior year. In other words, he started to make a move and is now ready to really show off.
-
Taijuan Walker
I wasn't aware he had developed a shoulder issue after his TJ procedure that limited and slowed his rehab. Obviously, full health is the primary concern here, in addition to his velocity returning. But he is young and was quite good as recently as 2018. Not sure how this plays out, but he could be one of the most intriguing additions a team could make.
-
Jhoulys Chacín, Matt Wisler, and Diminishing Returns on Sliders
There is 1 major difference between Chacin and Wisler, however. Despite a few poor and injury affected season's, Chacin has actually produced some solid seasons and OK career numbers while the younger Wisler remains an example of unfulfilled expectation. There are similarities between both of them, as well as vast differences. What they both have in common, IMO, is a need for some kind of successful FB. Whether you throw 90 or 100, you need some kind of FB to make everything work. Sneaky, heavy, tailing, rising, you still need some decent form of the pitch. That would seem to be Johnson's #1 priority/opportunity with both of these guys.
-
Ranking the Top 10 Minnesota Twins Starting Pitching Trade Targets
1] Musgrove and Alcantara might be my top 2 targets based on youth, projectability and availability. Miami and Pittsburgh aren't going anywhere soon. I'm not convinced on Boyd yet, plus there is the whole inter-divisional situation. 2] I fluctuate between Ray and Gray. But I absolutely don't like only 1yr guaranteed on Ray. 3] Boston absolutely has to perform some sort of rebuild/retool. Really not sure they will be ready to move Sale. And if they are, I want to feel confident he is on the rebound, even if that obviously means a higher cost to the Twins. Pretty much how I rank everyone at this time, leaving out Price and just really unsure about Archer. It's interesting to think about this mid-year scenario even before the season begins. And there are a whole of things that can and will change between now and then, not only for the Twins, but for other teams as well. But speaking ONLY about the Twins situation, as it unfolds: 1] What if Berrios, Odorizzi and Pineda pitch just as well as last season? For Berrios in particular, it's not just about improving, but carrying his numbers/ability through the entire season. 2] What if last season, especially his last couple of months, Bailey is 100% healthy finally, and his change in approach is not an iillusion? You might have a really nice and experienced back of the rotation arm. 3] I believe it was Thrylos who recently posted career comparisons between Gibson and Chacin and I was really surprised. What if previous seasons, especially 2017-18 are the real pitcher and he surprises in 2020 by being that guy again, or at least close to it? 4] What if Dobnak and Thorpe just keep getting better and better? 5] What if Hill isn't 100% ready to go until end of June or early July? Do we care? Wasn't he signed, really, to be a 1/2 season SP with the ability to perform well and even dominate for that 1/2 season? 6] Totally forgoing any 2nd half season internal surprise like Duran, Balazovic, Colina, Graterol back in the rotation, etc, what if our bullpen really is as deep and good and most of us believe it is/can be, to offset any "limitations" of the rotation? We can say there are a lot of "what if" possibilities here. But it doesn't take rose-colored glasses to acknowledge that these possibilities are not the least far-fetched. And I am not dismissing a big move of any sort to push the Twins of 2020 over the top. My point is, a big 2nd half trade target, assuming availability, simply may not be the all in necessity that we may believe is needed as we sit here today.
- Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: Honorable Mentions