Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Jham

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Jham

  1. The pot is 4 months of games and 100 mil payroll. Many are ignoring the point of comparison. Any team at that point of the season is below 30% to win it all. Maybe less. Successful seasons don't always end in world series championships. I think the odds that prospect x or y contribute in a meaningful way to get us to a even the same position we were in at 5% with Kintzler or Garcia.
  2. Ok, it's just an analogy, but your logic is slightly off. You can't just say the odds say to fold because the odds were 5%. You left out the size of the pot and the size of the bet. If there's a $100 pot and its $1 to stay in, by all means call with a 5% chance. 4.5 months of baseball and $100 million payroll, to throw away your 5% chance for a prospect that probably won't improve your chances in total over his career by as much as he damaged their chances (admittedly small) this year. I don't necessarily see it that way, but that's how it should be analyzed. I do not see either trade as a clear error or success.
  3. His upside is R.A. Dicky. Learn a knuckle ball stat.
  4. Update: According to Wikipedia, a study had rWAR as explaining 83% of the variance between expected wins and actual wins. (retroactively. 5 random teams from 5 years, SSS of large sample sizes). As a predictor it accounted for 35% of variance between expected to actual wins. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wins_Above_Replacement
  5. Are we talking bWAR or fWAR? Or is that the point? People forget that the variables we can measure are vastly outnumbered by the ones we can't. Try to figure out at your own job why you are more productive one day versus another. One week versus another. Then ask whether those things that effect your performance, a poor night's sleep, a sick child, an especially entertaining TD game thread could be measured if you were a baseball player. We hope that those other variables balance out over a season, but again the things we can measure offer only a glimpse. Statisticians use regression analysis to estimate how much variance within one statistic can be explained by a certain measured variable. Presumably they've run regressions on WAR factors in order to apply proper weight. Regardless, if we were able to get an actual measurement of what contributes to actual wins and put them in a pie chart, WAR factors would take up maybe 25% of the with things like luck, sequencing, umpires, and non-WAR factors dominating the pie. I'm no stats expert. I took one course in business stats and one in research stats. Hated them. Wish they would have had baseball stats back then.
  6. To those who inquired as to my questioning whether he has a sense of entitlement, it's only based from the very unique position he's in. (In some sense, entitlement might be an issue for this whole generation of non-impoverished prospects). I've just never heard of a free agent or draft pick asking for recruitment letters. It's different. People questioned the Rays pick for allegedly telling teams not to pick him if they weren't on board with 2 way status. I get that Ohtani is the prettiest girl at the dance. It just seems that a 22 year old kid calling all the shots even in regard to his future boss doesn't fit the humble narrative. Of course is possible to be a humble diva. LeBron is one. Let's hope he's LeBron. Eventually he'll struggle. This is a big step, and it doesn't seem like he expects any struggle. When it happens and he's in a strange country with media and fan pressure and older players who he might take at bats from... how will he handle that? He is asking teams to evaluate how he'll fit. That shows self awareness. But if he doesn't see that his attitude and recruitment might well effect how he's received by his new teammates, that shows lack of awareness. It's refreshing to see a kid who loves the game more than the money. How will those values play in club house filled with very diverse financial backgrounds? Many players grew up poor. Money matters to them. Vets don't like being showed up. Many feel that they earned their big bucks and the right to enjoy that guilt free. He's just a different kind of kid. It could make him special. It could make him am easy target.
  7. Personally, I have a few reservations regarding Ohtani. The guy seems to have a huge sense of entitlement. It makes me wonder how coachable he'll be, and what sort of a team mate. I have huge concerns about how he'll deal with adversity and real struggle. It seems like he's coming in expecting things to be easy. $20 million is a relatively small investment for a talent with that upside. At the same time, we're entering an important stretch for our organization. $20 mil can go to a big FA, a number of useful pieces, absorbing a contract in a beneficial trade, or extending a current or potential trade piece. I'd be looking hard right now while everyone else is chasing the hype train. BTW, asking teams to write you love letters does not scream, "I want the small market and quiet life." But I will say, he'd instantly be one of the biggest and most loved celebrities in Minnesota if he came here.
  8. I was just going to say, it looks like the gophers are suddenly in the market for a qb!
  9. Genetics (metabolism, hormones, etc) certainly play a role. For the record, the rumors I've heard about his work ethic have been more regarding his dedication to right field before 2016 season and his willingness to work on his game during batting practice more than working out. I've heard general concerns about his weight, rumors about his eating, and the one comment I related regarding loving to eat. Some of the questioning, I think, regarding the BP HR Derbies and the preparation for playing 9 seemed somewhat fair. Bottom line, whether he has an eating problem, a gland problem, or an elliptical aversion, the undiscriminating and sometimes cruel equalizer of Major League level competition will identify the weakness, highlight, and attack it. The end result, weight, may well be a limitation for Sano, whether in terms of productivity, longevity, or durability. I suggested that if some organizations still think he's the next Miggy Cabrera, Giancarlo, or Pujols, we should work a trade. Ultimately, I really like the kid, and I hope he does get to that level wherever he is. Especially if it's with us!!
  10. Nick, I think we've all heard the allusions to weight. Weight is pretty universally related to activity and diet. He's a pro-athlete. Activity isn't the problem. He's also at an age where this shouldn't be a problem. If there is an issue, it will only get worse without change. Your asking for specific sources is fair, but the posters are just the messengers. You've read the numerous vague accounts same as everyone else. You can say there is reason for concern without having 100% proof. For instance, I remember distinctly reading an article on the team website a few years back where he started his interests are fishing and eating. It made me nervous. Don't know if it's an issue or not, but my concern is real, and it's based on my wanting to see him succeed. Not because I want to pile on or shame. Lastly, what if... our expectations were skewed from the beginning. His k's and contact never suggested Cab or Pujols. He's put up great power numbers but not elite. And his k's and contact are where you'd expect given his history. I think it's far more likely that a player will gain power with age than contact and average. This limits his potential and has been a limit from day 1. I'll still cheer for the guy. I still love the guy. He just makes me nervous!
  11. That's my thought as well. You should be able to purchase a solid prospect for $4 mil plus a legitimate starting pitcher from the team you ultimately battled for a home wild card game. In retrospect, international signing pool money may have been better than the prospect if we were set on trading Garcia to the Yankees.
  12. Shaw and Kintzler for me. I think Shaw's weight and build and Kintzler's K rate keep people away from these very effective and mentally tough arms.
  13. I get what you're saying. I'm not even sure we disagree on anything except team expectations. We're in agreement that May shouldn't be inked in to the rotation. The plan should be to get him back in at some point if he's ready and we feel he can make a difference. Regarding the World Series, I'm not sure we are title contenders either. But we can win the division. That's a reasonable goal considering that this group will probably NEVER be good enough to be World Series favorites on par with last year's Indians, Astros, and Dodgers. You have to get incrementally better. The Astros weren't true contenders the last couple years, but they came close enough to see what more they had to do. The Yankees this year got that experience. A lot does have to go right for us to be World Series contenders this year. But if you break it down over the next few years, and take some steps each year, it's not so intimidating. We have to start putting the pieces together now including, most likely, a division title and/or playoff run in order to set us up for a WS run. We only have so many years of this core remaining. I'll say the same thing I said last year. If this core in its prime is not able to contend, then what's the point of building around this core? Trade Sano for a haul and point to 2021. They showed they're good enough, imo. Push now. If it doesn't work, and the core flops, they should still have enough trade value to start again.
  14. See, you're depending on peripherals turning into results. That's my problem with depending on May as a starter. He had decent FIP but his xFIP wasn't as nice because he wasn't giving up HR despite lots of hard contact which could have driven the high BABIP. I'm fine with letting him compete. I'm saying I don't plan around him in a year we should contend.
  15. It did make sense. Expecting him to produce for a season as a 3ish starter did not.
  16. I thought it was foolish to depend on May last season. He's never shown sustained success as a starter. His peripherals were nice but rarely transferred to on field results. Similar to Mejia, his swing and miss stuff was offset by erratic control, inability to get deep into games and in May's case, some very hard contact mixed in. He also has a bad back. I like the guy. I think he's going to be successful in either the pen or starting rotation. But in a competitive year, his production should certainly not be relied upon.
  17. I think your probably right. I think the issue Cheif and I have is that a bad day can really skew the metrics. I think Rosario had that this year. A few bad throws and drops negated a lot of solid play. If hee caught a few of the balls that he clamored after a long run, his metrics probably look much better. Sort of like a bad inning to a reliever.
  18. Moreland and Santana had better numbers. Hosmer has the reputation. Defensive metrics are interesting in that even over a season, we're largely dealing with small sample sizes. It really doesn't make sense that Hos would be elite 1 year and not the next. That said, Mauer passed the eye test over the course of the season, but any single game, he rarely made spectacular plays. He was average chasing down foul pops. Often took safe routes on ground balls and took safe outs over double plays or getting the lead runner. I believe Mauer has gotten better across the board at first base with the exception of chasing down fly balls. But I don't consider it robbery that he wasn't a finalist.
  19. Of course it is. But then how can you also be arguing that Dozier should have been used to get an ace or something that substantially improves a rotation that made the playoffs? Just for now, it certainly appears the twins made the right decision by holding dozier. That's not really debateable. In fact, regardless of the outcome, retaining him was at least, not a mistake.
  20. I advocated for keeping Dozier last off season and trading one of Kepler, Sano, or Buxton for a true ace. I also advocated for trading Dozier at the deadline in order to galvanize the team. The shed Kintzler instead. I see both sides on this one. But I don't really see how anyone can argue we should habe done the deal on DeLeon alone. That was so far below our asking price. He wasn't even their top pitching prospect or the arm we wanted.
  21. I was following the tigers forums pretty hard toward the waiver deadline, and their fans didn't even bring up the twins let alone twins prospect packages in their discussions. We were excited when the media speculated verlander could be had for free Alex Rios style on waiver claims. In reality the tigers demanded a premium prospect package. We were never close. There's risk either way. He could turn into a pumpkin, conversely we may end up am elite arm short and end up signing worse guys for more, or trading top prospects for less.
  22. A couple things. First, we need to stop pretending that people are that calling out "warning signs" is a media-driven witch hunt. Concerns about Sano's work ethic stem from real evidence. First, his public struggle with weight leads people to questioning his conditioning and effort. His refusal to play winter ball after his rookie year begged the question. There was that weird spring training story where the twins reported he was taking extra fly balls to prepare for right field, but it turned out he want even back in the US yet. Right field was a stupid experiment in hindsight, but if he didn't prepare, it's partly on him. I think it's fair to question his work ethic based on facts alone. I don't think anyone has said he's lazy. But concern is prudent at this stage. As his k-rate and good to great, but not elite production and peripherals at each stage. My guess is that he'll want to be paid like an elite player, even if he's simply a star slugger. $100 mil minimum. Regarding NYC, his agency is a sports and entertainment agency owned by the owner of the Brooklyn Nets who raps that he makes a Yankees cap more famous than a Yankee can and gets Alicia Keyes to sing the virtues of the city that never sleeps. If we're going to extend, I'd weight the front end. Your budget isn't as ham-strung that way, Sano "needs"/ would appreciate more money earlier in his career and thus be more likely to agree to a discount, and his contract is more liquid as a trade asset vs. possibility of being completely immovable later (his contract, not his size).
  23. I'm not 100% sure he's done. His velocity was starting to creep ball up, and might not have topped out. His feel was certainly off, but in general it seems like he was rushing back in case this season was his last shot. His role may be more loogy going forward, but I wouldn't be surprised if he succeeded in that capacity if he wanted to put in the work for 1 more reinvention. If this was it, the thing I always loved about perk was his willingness to pitch up in the zone and challenge hitters at a time when the twins philosophy was "keep the ball down and pitch to contact.
  24. I think the difficulty is, as usual, the framing of the question. When we say "we wouldn't be here without..." That's true of pretty much everyone. When Jason Bartlett went to the Rays, he put up modest numbers but was team MVP because he knew what it took to win and convinced a young team that they were at least as good as the perennial playoff team he'd just left. Chris Giminez convinced the team to believe in themselves. As others have mentioned, James Rowsan's work with Mauer, Buxton, rosario, adrianza, and Dozier has been borderline unbelievable. And those players suggest that they didn't even trust him at first. Overall, if I have to pick one, it has to be Dozier. I suggested we trade him to shake things up. He shook things up himself. Well done Brian.
  25. I've been impressed with Dillon Gee. I would like to see what he can do in higher leverage 1 inning stints. He's certainly been a fantastic long man. May have found something there.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.