Everything posted by Jham
-
Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent or are we all just wasting our time?
Sustained.
-
2017 Staff Compared to 2018
It's not that rookie pitchers can't be good. It's that none of the guys you mention other than Romero are projected to be better than Kyle Gibson at their peaks. Romero should be conserved for innings and probably debut putt of the pen. The only reason this stings is because the opportunity to sign a Darvish doesn't come along very often for a team with our self-imposed budget restraints.
-
2017 Staff Compared to 2018
That's fair, but what are your opinions based on? I've never seen Gonsalves or Romero pitch. Maybe an inning or two last spring training. Mejia peaked at 91 on a BA midseason top 100 list. Gonsalves reached 99. Romero would be higher if more seasoned and durable. Duffy... May is fine but had arm and back problems on top of sporadic command and results. Hughes will either be good again or retire I suspect. I get that you're skeptical of Darish and don't like the years, but the overall contact and aav was very reasonable compared to wishing for lightening in a bottle with 2 rookies and two guys off of surgery.
-
Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent or are we all just wasting our time?
There's a price for not overpaying. Ironically, it's usually overpaying for worse. Ryan frequently put himself in a pinch by low-balling, missing his target and having to sign or trade or of desperation. Put another way, you're going to sign someone anyway. You're going you over-pay anyway. They will be risky anyway, just the risk is production rather than value. We could have paid Darvish's current deal with the money dropped on Hughes, Nolasco, and Pelfrey. To me, that's more wasteful or moronic than paying through a known decline which you can likely trade away anyway (salary dump or eat salary for prospects). It's easy to call a contract moronic if you choose not to analyze the alternatives. It's like low-balling on your dreamhouse. You don't get the house you want. Rent's going out the door. Now you're desperate to buy any house. You spend your money on the value home in need of repairs. Add the roof, kitchen, plumbing, and furnace and you're in almost as much, and now your cars gone because your neighborhood sucks. Move twice more, hire a tutor because the schools are awful and now your behind.
-
2017 Staff Compared to 2018
Do people not get how dramatic a fall off it is from Darvish to whoever we throw out there? Duffy? Gonsalves? Gonsalves profiles almost identically to Mejia no? At least as a prospect? Arguably worse stuff? Romero is most likely a bull pen guy. May couldn't clearly beat out Pelfry. There is some hope there. But realistically no chance in hell any one or combination of those arms can replace the production of a Darvish. I'd actually bet on Hughes to have an impact over any of those other options and I'm not even sure he has any ribs left. Not to mention we'll probably spend that money anyway. On worse components. And if we don't, we're certainly not banking it for next year or for any other signing or extension.
-
Article: The Darvish Contingency Plan
Gonsalves and Romero are nice prospects. They are not Sano, Buxton, or even Berrios or Gibson as prospects. Gonsalves has hardly cracked a top 100 list in his career. Ditto the Romero, although this site seems to hold him in much higher regard than others. These aren't blue chippers. I don't think anyone would bet on either of those two being better than Darvish over the next six years. There's a solid chance that neither of the two will have a season as good as Darvish's worst season over that same stretch. But more to the point, we're trying to win this year. World Series runs take talent and luck. Giving up seasons where you could have enough talent to get lucky is disappointing. I'm concerned that we're gearing up to be sellers at the deadline at this point.
-
Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent or are we all just wasting our time?
To be fair, Mauer and his agent suggested that he would not give a hometown discount. At the time he signed, experts were throwing the $300 mil number around. I'd also say that the Mauer deal should certainly not dissuade anyone from signing a player in his prime to a contract lasting beyond it. Finally, I question how many years we spent rebuilding when we could have been competing. And the years we were competing how many we could have contended. And in the years we could do neither, how much player equity we could have acquired at the trade deadline had we had more than Eduardo Nunez and Kevin Correia to deal. Can't trade a half season of Ardolis Chapman for a ransom if you never sign him in the first place.
-
Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent or are we all just wasting our time?
More affordable to the average middle class family: 15 yr fixed or 30 yr fixed mortgage? 15 yr is a better value (potentially) but not feasible for people on limited incomes (payroll constraints). Doesn't mean you shouldn't buy a house if you can only afford the 30 yr. Might be your only option in fact.
-
Will the Twins ever sign a top free agent or are we all just wasting our time?
As soon as mlb addresses tanking and hording profits/ profit shares maybe.
-
Twins Give Darvish a Formal Offer
That's easy. The price of JD Martinez is dropping. Boston apparently out. Zona low balling. JD considering shorter deals.
-
Twins Give Darvish a Formal Offer
Source? Where'd this come from all the sudden.
-
What is the end game?
Consider the following possibilities based on your observation vis a vis labor sentiment on the site. 1) you, who have bemoaned the current state of affairs but haven't made a single suggestion as how to improve things for anyone but the cost sensitive fan, could be right and everyone wrong. 2) everyone else might be on to a little something that you're failing to grasp. Fixing player salaries is basically socialism. Fixing ticket prices and concessions is socialism. There may be times where human nature (greed) exceeds the balance of free market enterprise, but this hardly seems like that time. Not to say we don't need to be careful, but costs aren't out of control, imo. People need to stop referring to baseball as a kids game. Until I see a runner replaced by a ghost runner at third, I'll go ahead and say the game we played in the back yard is slightly different to the version we watch and post on. By slightly I mean entirely. You're obviously passionate. What is your idea to even out the baseball economy? And you can't say just lower ticket prices. Or that you don't care about owners etc. It seems you care plenty!
-
Ervin Santana had Surgery Today
Pineada threw the other day!! Aren't many vets with minor league contracts given leave from their contracts if a Major league offer comes in and the player isn't likely to make the team? Big Sexy?
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
National debt is roughly equivalent to the yearly Gross National Product. Jham's debt is roughly equivalent to 3-4x his gross annual income. Go to law school and buy a house they said. It'll be fun they said. My mortgage lender has assured me I'm carrying a healthy level of debt given the interest rates. So I'm going to say the US debt isn't the biggest economic issue we're facing. It's all relative. Which is the point of this discussion. I still favor early arbitration. Get rid of the incentive to tank and save money. Small teams can still compete as top salaries should come down (as we're seeing already).
-
Article: The Secret to Ervin Santana’s Success
Correlation and causation. He throws more sliders when ahead in the count. Higher slider usage could also mean better overall command or taking advantage of the larger strike zone. I'd like to see figures regarding control or number of pitches thrown ahead vs behind in the count
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
Agreed. The free market has limitations. It can devolve into a race to the bottom. What's most profitable in the short term is often, perhaps rarely the most sustainable in the long run. Too many decisions which tend toward profits instead of fans and the free agency problem will solve itself because there won't be fans, free agent dollars, or competition.
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
I agree on the disparity aspect. That's why I argued for a revenue share. But rather than a cap which tends to hurt players, a luxury tax and revenue share mandatory spending provisions makes sense to me. Part of what made teams into b Yankee farm systems want that they couldn't compete, but rather they refused to compete. The have not teams engage in a race to the bottom. Fans lose out. Players lose out. Cheap owners pocket extra money and the Yankees who willingly spend don't subsidize the teams that don't. I get that the Yankees can afford to be more aggressive. But they certainly don't have to be. They still push the envelope. And I don't see how arb eligibility changes things for the haves and have nots. Years of control remain the same. It prevents stockpiling of young stars at a discount which is more fair to players, but you can always buy out arb years, and I think it would drive down the price of free agents on the higher side. But I'm not dead set against a cap.
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
This all sounds great, but voluntarily reducing revenue will ultimately destroy the game. You'll attract worse owners. Teams will not have incentive to build beautiful ballparks, provide world class entertainment, or provide safe experiences for players or fans for that matter. Ironically, the issue we're talking about is one predicted by evil empire emperor himself, George Steinbrener. When the Twins were being considered for contraction, revenue sharing was being discussed. Steinbrener was furious, and called out the Twins ownership specifically. His issue wasn't even that he'd have to pay money to his competitors so they could sign away his players through luxury tax and revenue sharing. Even he could see that a level playing field would be beneficial to the game. His anger arose from the fact that he would have to pay money to owners who would NOT be required to invest back into their team and improve the balance in the league. In short, the Polads were pocketing the revenue sharing money. Same as they pocket the added profits they promised they'd reinvest from increased team and stadium revenue. The market between player and owner will balance itself out. The problem is that the market at the ownership level is incredibly slow to react because there is almost no competition. No one is that rich. Public ownership is an idea. Potentially, a team could operate at break even or even at a deficit as long as shareholders allowed. This would force other ownership to have to spend in order to compete. The problem is, that human nature takes over. The desire to make a profit will still be there. Let's say you bought a $5,000 share, and at the end of the season, you could have a $6,000 share plus a $250 dividend, or have your share go down in value (you paid for the team based on profitability, and through payroll, you've made it less profitable) and sign more players/pay your farm system better, etc. Suddenly, you're no better than the Polads. The other option to achieve your goal of lower fan prices is to expand. You'll spread demand by increasing supply. But that's just another word for watered down. We see that even with implementation of a salary cap. You have no super teams in the NFL. Some might say the Patriots disprove that theory. I disagree. I think the Patriots have taken advantage of the watered down league. Ditto the Cavs and Warriors in the NBA. If players take pay cuts to play for one team, no one can break the bank to compete with them. It's not allowed. We could have 60 MLB teams, and we'd have a lot lower ticket and beer prices. Player salaries would come down. Billionaires would dilute their profits. It may be easier for teams to compete. You'd probably only need 2 really good pitchers and a hand full of average roll players. However, how much of a decline in overall product will people be willing to accept before leaving the sport? If allowed the market would adjust, but not for maximum entertainment value, but rather maximum profitability. But since the league can't feasibly grow and shrink with every market change, we may have to just stomach some market inefficiency. In this case, lack of reinvestment by ownership and wage disparity between players (brought about by the artificially low supply of teams and major league roster spots). I'd support some form of revenue sharing and luxury tax over a hard cap, but teams would be required to meet a spending threshold in order to obtain funds. I would also make players arbitration eligible immediately. Why fight paying players what they're worth? It's the 6 years of team control that is valuable. This should combat wage disparity. Tanking would be less advantageous. FA contracts would be balanced by lower payroll pools and a larger FA pool (teams offering FA rather than going to arb) but also by the fact that FA would be relatively more valuable because of larger buyer pools and internal options having less payroll advantage. You'd get truer values for both FA and for younger players. Finally, I'd give teams and players the option of buying out arb years while players are in the farm system. IE, young players often need more money when they're getting started. Then have more money than they need once established. If you want 3 years of league min. salary, with no arb options (current system) you have to buy those years out before the players debuts.
-
Article: MLB Shift Driving Market Realities
Jealous much? I'm guessing you want to be paid what you're worth.
-
Article: Why The Twins May Opt For Short-Term SP Commitment
That's not exactly true. The Indians actually fell to the Yankees who got lucky in the alcs and lucked out again in the world series.
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
You don't need to bow out. You raise good questions. In general, I think finding the gaps and holes in the analytics is one of the most interesting parts of analytics. It's why stats keep getting added and improved upon. It's why analytics staff are numbering along with scouting staffs now. But another interesting part of analytics, testing, and the scientific method in general, is finding out our perceptions or assumptions are wrong. Then trying to figure out why!
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
That's the problem. You don't know it's flawed. You assume it. You have laid out rationale as to why you would expect older players to decline more rapidly. There is rationale that would suggest that that the decline might be less dramatic than average. For instance, players that last that long were probably better players to begin with. Weed out the players barely surviving and flashing in the pan, and you'd expect less variation. Those are both merely hypothesis. Both could be right canceling out. Both could also be wrong! Something else entirely might be driving the rate of decline. But age and prior productivity are only 2 variables. Projections look at far more. You can run regression analysis to see what percentage of variation can be explained by any one variable. Any variable with no predictive value will not be used. You may not like the .5 WAR per season average, but like it or not, the math still backs it up at age 33 or it wouldn't be used.
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
I've never ever seen the Twins dump savings, or even profits for that matter, from one season into the next. They follow their revenue formula each year separately. Regarding WAR, it's a widely debated cumulative stat that probably shouldn't be taken literally. It's still a decent measuring stick for comparing players across varying circumstances without crunching zillions of numbers yourself. I also understand what you're saying about using average war decline as a predictor, or using any average as a predictor in a single circumstance for that matter. What you're calling risk, is actually variation. You hypothesize, perhaps correctly, that older players will have greater variation from the average than younger players, especially at the low end of the curve. And that the prediction for older players should be weighted for age. But WAR is a counting stat relying on health. The risk of going to zero may be elevated for older players, but it would also be higher for players with lower WAR to begin with since many of those players would have low WAR because of injuries. Essentially you have competing theories of what holds more predictive power: age or prior effectiveness. You can run normalcy curves for both and have a ton of data. Then compare standard deviations. And that's what the projections have already presumably done. If age rendered the decline average meaningless, that would almost certainly not factor into projections. I agree it would be interesting to look at the variance and median numbers. But to the extent that you said you have a hard time explaining, at least consider that you may also have a hard time understanding. That's not a knock. You have a good theory that makes sense. It's just that there are other theories that also make sense pointing in the other direction. And those have actually been tested.
-
My prediction for which FA pitcher the Twins pick up is....
A lot of people don't want to be in Minnesota, then they move here and love it. I get that it is clear that Darvish wants to stay in LA, but that in itself would not keep me from trying to get him. That said, Garcia fits this team and it's history.
-
Article: Open Windows
Margin of error. Buxton could go down for a month. Santana for 4 starts and we cam still finish first or second in the division. Rougher to do so in the east.