Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Jham

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Jham

  1. Not what I said, Mike. just the position adjustment seems arbitrary compared to the other factors they're using in calculation. Like you said. It isn't perfect. I simply pointed out 1 way it's not. Doesn't mean we shouldn't use it at all.
  2. I'm not disagreeing with the premise of position adjustment. Merely the execution. You're basically saying you can say who is a more valuable fielder between 2 different players by looking at their uzr then adding the adjustment. I don't think it's that simple. I think the adjustment seems arbitrary. There's enough players like Kep that play multiple spots, it shouldn't be impossible to check. But every team has to field every spot including DH. If you could field 9 Byron Buxtons, they'd all have different WARS with CF Buxton indeed getting an award for showing up. Again, I'm not referring to any specific player. I'm certainly not saying use WAR without the position adjustment. My point as was Ewen's is that WAR itself has some gaps and flaws. CF defense seems to be 1.
  3. Ok. fWAR uses uzr (also positional). I get that. I'm just saying that I've seen no explanation as to how they came up with the positional adjustment that doesn't look arbitrary. I don't see how being bad at your position can be better than being good at another position (other than flexibilty, Riverb). Ball hawks, are also rewarded as I stated. Most outhogs are cf. I'm not suggesting that Palka is better than Hicks. But he hit 27 HR as a rookie. I just don't think WAR is a perfect stat for comparing them.
  4. But defense is also factored in. So you're factoring it twice. Putting Palka in center wouldn't make him more valuable. He'd be a liability there. That's not more value. It's less. The defensive metric would bear that out. Does Kepler really need a different WAR calculation when he plays CF than RF?
  5. Hicks v Palka... Buxton v blackhole all based off the ubiquitous "bwar". Look how it's calculated and you can pretty easily determine where the most likely discrepancy arises. "position adjustment". CF are given a 2.5 runs bump just for showing up. Corners are docked 7.5 runs. (Explains Kepler's elevated war as well). Where's the basis for the adjustment? Not actual defense, since that is calculated separately. If Buck and Kepler traded spots, would Kepler be the more valuable defensive player? No. If Rosie moved to CF instead of Kep last year, what would their WAR have been? The idea that it's harder to put up runs saved in CF than the corners isn't well founded IMO. and neither is the position adjustment. This is compounded by the fact that good cf are ball hawks who run down many balls that the corners might be in perfect position to catch. Thus it is harder for Rosie to increase his radius while Buxtons catch radius looks huge. The actual amount of runs saved is skewed for both. As is their WAR.
  6. Hilde's change up is almost unhittable when he's on. Very few pitchers have a pitch like that. I'd give up on the adding new pitches and deliveries, and work on placement and rest. His MiLB record and MLB success suggests closer upside. We screwed up Duffey having him develop another pitch. How about throw your good pitches more often, to start.
  7. Our cheap controllable talent won't be as cheap and will be losing years of control soon. We don't have much of a choice but to go for things now, imo. Given that this core has made 1 run and we've been building toward this year, that we have the money, that we've added no one for the future, and that we've extended no one either, I don't see how we can give something other than an F at this time. How expensive will an OF of Buck, Rosie, and Kep be in 2 years? Would you rather have that OF or Harper, Garver, and Field then Kiroloff in 2 years? Plus the prospects you get by trading your current OF.
  8. Interesting. How much does revenue increase during our competitive years? If not much, that could explain the reluctance to spend. ROI, as others have pointed out...
  9. I suppose Mauer's publicist was available this off season...
  10. Falvey for sure side-stepped. when asked about the pitching staff he literally skipped over the rotation. Then he raised the A's random gold strike as their plan? That's pretty unlikely. BUT if it were to work, you'd need someone to develope into an untouchable K machine. We have no one that could develop into that. The closest we had was Ryan Pressly who was still under contact and probably extendable. Instead we traded him. A strange move if our plan was to develop a Bull Pen first pitching staff. So they either have no plan, have switched plans and set us back, or are lying about the plan. I think it's 3. Why would they tell fans and media they're not trying to win?
  11. The Mets would not accept a package without Lewis. And that might not be what they want. His timetable means we have to give up more than other teams. He has been really good, a top prospect, but it's hard to protect him as an elite MLB star at this point, although further development is sure possible. I think they want Romero or gonsalves and Taylor Rodgers or hildenberger too. i'd probably do it out of sheer boredom. But it certainly has the opportunity to backfire. Of course, why is Syndegaard even for sale unless something's up...
  12. 4 pages and not 1 poster said they wanted to give up on Buxton. He's never been the site thing his minor league stats implied. Shops still had concerns about the setting and miss to his game and his pitch recognition. His power is natural but his swing never really has been. I'm not against a reasonable extention, but if he says no, I'm not against a reasonable trade package either. More than jrm mind you.
  13. Over the course of 162 games and decades worth of seasons, I like analysts that can teach me something. I've found myself saying, "huh, that was interesting," most often with TK and Torii. But both are on the dry side to listen to. Bremer gets into it. He's using more metrics, but still adds that nostalgia feeling from '91. Baseball has changed the least of all the major sports over time. Listen to James Earl Jones' speech in field of dreams. I defy anyone who grew up in the 80s and 90s to bring up some old Herb Carnile and John Gordon calls (or halsey if you're older) and not feel transported to your youth. That's when I fell in love with the sport. Something will be lost for me, when Bremer retires. So many of my best Twins memories are set to his calls. "Up... back... GONE!! and the cycle is complete." inevitable I guess.
  14. He could never get the job because he couldn't do home games. He tried to walk into Target Field but he missed. Then he'd just talk about how he wish he could play little league as an adult. Who's back up now? Ryan Braun used to do performance enhancing drug. He still does, but he used to too.
  15. How is Kepler's bat even a consideration for first base at this point? Aren't we trying to win? Might as well resign Mauer at that point.
  16. Which part do you disagree with? That we can't get value trading him presumably? I guess it just takes 1. Seems like a guy the Astros, Yankees, or Jays could work with.
  17. I was just repeating the narrative. Oops. But I always thought playing pro at 16 is an advantage. Same with the "Sano is still only __ years old" argument.
  18. The time to trade Kepler was 2 years ago. Now, the value is in keeping or even extending him. He reminds me somewhat of Christian Yelich. But also of David McCarty. Maybe someone will overpay for him, but I doubt it. Better now to play it out and hope his talent comes through. I've always thought he was a little overrated. Started baseball late but started his career early. Wasn't a big time prospect until he developed power which came at the expense of contact and left side splits. Stays closed down on the ball. Needs to open his chest and pull the ball. All of his hard hit balls are pulled anyway. Embrace it.
  19. That's not incorrect. We're looking at the same issue from separate views. I see your argument as a little too "get younger just for the sake of getting younger" for my taste. I happen to think, regardless of league trends, the age aspect, on both ends, is really about maximizing each player's productive window under their rookie contract. This would lend itself to some players, flame throwers, wipe out sliders, elite speed guys to debut sooner. It might also lend itself to a patient approach with fringier types who may develop late. The Twins have just had an abundance of fringe types. The goal is to have the player under control for as many peak years as possible.
  20. You know what a straw man argument is right? I never said the league isn't getting younger. That was in fact the very point of my post. Literally, I said nothing is more valuable in today's game than the young cost-controlled star. These players afford the ability to sign top players and remain out of luxury tax liability. These players also allow small market teams to compete if they can get lucky. Maximizing cost-control, number of prime years vs developmental years, and trade value of guys the league loves more than you do is sound management.
  21. Your path of building from our prospect core is really close to what we've been doing. The facts show that the twins failure to rush players was a mistake? Which players were the Twins too slow with? Everytime fans get angry about not seeing so and so, they finally make it up and we see why they weren't fast tracked. The game has changed so much from the days you refer to. Young talented players could come up with flaws in their game because pitch fx fangraphs and stat casts didn't instantly tell the entire league where the holes in your swing were before you even got the call. Specialty relievers and power pitchers didn't overwhelm young hitters with undeveloped approaches. In today's game, almost nothing is more valuable than the young, talented, and cost-controlled star. If you start the clock early on your stars, you risk burning all your options on the late-bloomers, losing cost control a year early on super 2s, and getting to the trade/ play/extend zone before you have a great idea of the player you have. You risk losing the players peak seasons for no reason other than your own curiosity and impatience. And the ones who bust? How do you even know? Maybe they just weren't ready? But now you've killed the trade value of a nice chip. Look at Gonsalves. If we'd called up Gibby when fans wanted, we'd have traded him or dfad him before ever getting to his potential.
  22. Who is "the young talent" you speak of? The only players in the system who figure to be upgrades are several seasons away. Similarly, rebuild to what end? Our last young core is arb eligible and figures to be down right expensive in a couple years. The pressure to trade or sign will be real in just a year. When you get young you have everyone coming up at the same time, they all get expensive at the same time which limits your ability to add. Rinse repeat. Also, how is anyone untouchable? Lewis and kiriloff are nice players but each have questions still. If Lewis can't stick at short his stock falls quite a bit. Alex may never develope mlb corner position power. Graterol has a short high effort delivery and prior ucl.
  23. Agreed. There is absolutely nothing lucky about getting identifying places where the team can improve, even if not a problem, and upgrading! If anything, the teams that wait for prospects and work on 3 to 5 year contention plans are the team's going to "get lucky". The royals and pirates and Indians have been mostly terrible for decades. 2 of those teams had true contention windows. There's a hindsight bias involved. Adding some veteran pieces generates expectations of contention. Success is expected and goes unnoticed. Building from within with young talent requires that a lot of things outside of your control go right, and when you hit, you look like a genius. In poker, they call it a "hero call". Low percentage play that makes you look good when it works. I've always said a GMs role is to constantly look to improve overall talent of the roster. Then let the chips fall where they may. Not to assume you're going to be good or bad. There is not a single position that can't be upgraded on our roster. Upgrade where it's easiest and cheapest. Don't worry about a plan or a 3 year old prospect report. Suggesting we have to improve "here" but "here" makes no sense. Improve wherever you can! Also, trading Prospect for Value isn't giving up on them.
  24. That's a relief. I hope it's true. He's been coddled at times. If this is a continuation of that, those that think they're helping him are actually hurting him. Glad things seem to be figured out.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.