Everything posted by Jham
-
Article: Report: Twins, Kepler Finalizing Extension
I know. I'm just frustrated because I think many of us sense that this core is running out of time. If they fail, we're waiting on the next core with only the remnants of a failed core to build upon. We have no franchise player to build around. 2 players who are already who we were hoping Mauer would be are out there. We have little tied up in future salary. Adding a key stone player gives flexibility, a back up plan, and solidifies plan A all at the same time. With most of the big shooters struggling with cap issues and 2 superstars watering down each other's market, this opportunity just might not come around again. Even if it Josh Hamilton's out, We aren't otherwise over-committed and have a deep enough farm system to weather it if we are smart about it. Now is the time.
-
Article: Report: Twins, Kepler Finalizing Extension
You don't "have" to do anything. You can expand payroll with a pretty darn good excuse: Harper's aren't available for just cash almost ever. Big dogs not hard in pursuit. Controlled core still cheap with another wave coming. Having Harper for 2 waves rather than 1 isn't bad. Imagine if we traded Buxton Rosie AND Kep for prospects. And we started Harper, Cave, and Garver. (for example) Conceivably we upgrade 3 different line up spots. (lose some on d). Then next year we add in AK and Rooker on Rookie deals. And remember, we probably got 5 ot 6 future big leaguers waiting from trading the current OF. Also, we don't have to do all these moves now. We can keep Buxton or Rosie or Kep for another year and You can try to do the math on cost. But which outfield do you like best out of those options?
- Article: Report: Twins, Kepler Finalizing Extension
- Article: Report: Twins, Kepler Finalizing Extension
-
Article: Twins, Jorge Polanco Finalizing Contract Extension
Not a fan of extending a player a positive test away from maybe never playing again. I always like polanco because he swims hard but doesn't have contact issues. But until I can see his slugging isn't PED related (took him 2 months to go yard after his recall) I wouldn't have offered. price was right though.
-
Article: Twins, Jorge Polanco Finalizing Contract Extension
Not a fan of extending a player a positive test away from maybe never playing again. I always like polanco because he swims hard but doesn't have contact issues. But until I can see his slugging isn't PED related (took him 2 months to go yard after his recall) I wouldn't have offered. price was right though.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
I'd personally have AK 1 at this point. He's got the pedigree to go with the gaudy numbers. His bat plays more than Lewis's I think. That said, his Babip was really pretty high last season. He probably needs a few more walks, to turn on a few more pitches, and to turn more of those doubles into HR in order to sustain his momentum. If his value is peaking and we see him as Kepler 2.0, well we've got a lot of tough decisions coming up.
-
Twins stuff from around the Web (Fangraphs, Twitter, Athletic, non-local news sites, etc)
Minnesota is absolutely one of the best places up play in the summer. Cool evenings. Great park. Somewhat loyal fanbase. Fogo. LM bass and hours of additional daylight. I think it's the ownership's reputation. Same as we assume Boras will play hardball. I'm sure other agents assume the Twins will low ball.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #5 Wander Javier
Maybe I'm overly cautious. Or maybe I'm frustrated that we never trade any of our prospects for MLB talent. If more of our guys panned out, perhaps I'd be less cynical. But I've gone on the record that I have reservations on Lewis and Kirolff as well. They're both awesome prospects. Both will have MLB careers if not injured. Both have a shot at stardom. Seth calls AK the most advanced hitter he's ever seen at that stage. Still, it's he a top 12 outfielder in baseball? Is lewis a top 6 ss? That's how fis you have to be to get to all star level. Buxton and Sano didn't hit like MLB Trout and Cabrera in the minors, let alone MiLB versions. Lewis looks like an adequate to good MLB hitter, Kiroloff looks like a good to great MLB hitter which at their positions make them fringe all stars. Not necessarily corner stones. Maybe there's no such thing as "can't miss", but just for example, look at what Vlad Jr has done before 20: https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=guerre002vla and tell me Lewis or AK deserve to be in that category.
-
End of the FA line and ST about to start. Which of these 3 do you want?
As Mike said, it's only a "bad deal" for the Twins. It's a great deal for FSN who get the same broadcast rights for cheaper. I don't buy that theory other than having secure costs. A bad TV deal would hurt the overall value of the team while not likely to benefit the network value unless they were able to maintain viewership despite fielding cheaper teams. On the other hand... I thought I read multiple owners are in on this? Right before a new CBA? What this might allow owners to do is manipulate the amount of "revenue" they kick back to players by diverting profits to the media side of things and away from the team. Although, somehow owners are still allowed to come to the table without actually disclosing their books...
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #5 Wander Javier
Why can't we ever have a Vlad or Tatis? Wander is an ok prospect but I haven't exactly understood the national hype. He signed for big money, so scouts were on him early. They give opinions for a living and aren't likely to change their minds for no reason so it makes sense that everyone is still on him. As I recall he got off to an incredible start then cooled significantly? I was also confused about the projections so early that he'd stay at ss. I haven't heard that he's vizquel or anything. And his frame, age, and bat suggest a possible bulk up power hitter corner type future if he wants it/ grows more. Our writers are all pretty high not only of his abilities and health but of a progression and break out. I'm going to have to see it first, personally.
-
Twins actively discussing locking up parts of young core
So if 2 seasons in a row we've failed to lock up this supposed core... and if they've underperformed for the most part... should we at least be considering other options? Like say... sign a young star FA for (gasp) more than 1 season. And maybe trade some guys you a)won't extend, or might not want to extend. Then make a run with the others taking advantage of their rookie deals while they're still Twins. Thoughts?
-
Article: Starter Or Reliever, That Is The Romero Question
Good pitchers are good pitchers. Failed starters frequently make good relievers. Failed relievers NEVER make goods starters. Start him in the pen. If he dominates and you need rotation help, stretch him out. He'll have more time to develop pitches ot of the pen anyway.
-
Article: Mailbag: Catcher Innings, Bye-Bye Creams, Free Agent Watch
How does adding a "last piece" that would require an 8 year deal make any sense? Now is certainly the time to add a super star. If your window is opening, then why waste half of it waiting to peak? Fling those shudders open and worry about keeping it open down the line. This team's about to get expensive anyway. For years we looked to 2019. No Mauer. No Hughes. No Santana. No Nolasco. Sano, Buck, Rosie, Kep, JO, Polanco, Romero... Come on! Make a move at the deadline? You mean over pay for 2 months of a player? Get guys for a full year and play it out from day 1. Who wants to miss the playoffs by 2 games after taking away prospects when investing in February may have made up those games without losing the future? If you won't get Harper get Kimbrel. This is how we [perpetually rebuild].
-
Twins should be taking advantage of this market
That's not how price fixing works.
-
Article: Derek Falvey Urges Child to Pass on Bryce Harper Card
awesome
-
Article: Show Me the Money (and the Wins)
I need to read more carefully? You didn't even address my post. Just said it was wrong. This is not your normal business where if your margins aren't high enough people lose their jobs and families and investors suffer. The mission of an MLB club in some fashion, is to win games. Bottom line just isn't the concern it is in other industries because they're part of a monopoly where every business is almost automatically profitable. As for market disparity, there are revenue sharing agreements and especially escalating luxury tax penalties that seem to be helping to curb that. Now we need a floor. One thing I agreed with Steinbrenner on was the unfairness of having to pay into a sharing system without requiring the Twins and Pirates to reinvest into the product. You can disagree and keep suggesting they operate like Delta or Best Buy, but there's no need for condescension. We're arguing about how one of the richest families in the world should spend its "going out" money.
- Article: Show Me the Money (and the Wins)
- Article: Show Me the Money (and the Wins)
-
Article: Show Me the Money (and the Wins)
But it is just money. Savings aren't carried over. The team isn't in financial trouble. You talk about the team like it's a normal business which it isn't. It's closer to a non-profit. If you've ever served on a church or charity board you'd understand that the mission guides what you are doing. If you can't fiscally follow your mission, then your organization has no purpose and you dissolve. The Twins have ever stated that their mission is sustainable success, not necessarily championships. But it seems that their real mission is to make money. If that's the case, they aren't good for the sport and they should pick a new business.
-
Twins stuff from around the Web (Fangraphs, Twitter, Athletic, non-local news sites, etc)
Well that's the way it has worked. The league is changing. Maybe after the next CBA it will change again. This isn't that different than the Hicks scenario. We just need a better result. The young controllable and effective player has always mattered to small and mid market teams, but it's even more valuable for teams that plan on exceeding the luxury tax and need to dip down for a year. I'm seeing the same thing happening again. Graterol an "ace". Lewis and Kiroloff are future MVPs. They're all nice prospects. But I don't think Lewis is a Correa or Machado type or that Ak is a Bryce Harper. I'm not saying they should be traded. I'm saying no one is off limits. We need to do a better job of evaluating our own talent. And if we're still committed to the Buck and Sano window, then invest in this team now. Waiting does nothing. We're walking toward a cliff where if they're good they walk and if they're not good we lose trade value by the minute.
-
Twins stuff from around the Web (Fangraphs, Twitter, Athletic, non-local news sites, etc)
So why did we play them into almost no value? Those that suggested that they be traded previously while offering more promise and more cost control were chastised and told that position prospects are too valuable to trade. Well guess what, even if they're all good we won't be able to resign them all. So why not trade at peak value and trust your own scouts and reads? Just like under Ryan. Vastly overrating our own prospects. Also the are significant counterpoints of skepticism as to whether Kepler's "breakout" is sustainable. Swing path, trajectory, and shifting for example.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #9 Blayne Enlow
I don't get the lack of k's with his velocity and breaking ball. control must be pretty inconsistent. His velo and curve are major league level. but control is part of "stuff". a big part.
-
Astudillo best of all time?
They should show his no look pick off too.
-
Article: Mailbag: Buxton’s Leash, Likely Lineup, Ticket Sales
That's precisely what I was saying. We're arguing the same thing. I think many are learning on WAR without considering the fact that it's an estimate of intangible "value". It's most accurate when comparing players of the same position. Posters are using it as proof rather than reference. My only point on Palka was that he was a rookie. I didn't make a point on Buxton at all. Some are saying he can still help the team by being a glove only CF based on WAR. when the correct phrase is "he can still post a positive WAR in cf". similar but different. Literally my only intention was to show where I thought the posters' disagreements might be originating; ie overvalue of cf defense.