Everything posted by Dman
- Article: MLB Draft Day 3 Thread
-
Article: MLB Draft Day 3 Thread
I liked that pick where they got him as well. It sounded like he was going to need hit tool work even if he had his expected season and was taken in the lower 1st round. It also looked like he was more power over hit so if he can improve his hit tool he would be a major steal but I still think the odds are long that he hits well enough to make it. I am guessing that is why he lasted that long in the first place.
-
Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
Sure it can if you want to view it that way. I was simply responding to the poster who said who cares if a player has a good swing? It can simply be taught. Yet it is not that simple. Having that skill going in typically translates well to MLB success that is why those players are chosen first in the draft. it doesn't mean they will be successful just that they have a better chance. To the posters point some players do learn and develop that skill but I feel the odds are much steeper for that happening than he does. For the most part I am very happy with what the FO has done. I have been wrong about several picks they have made and I am pleased with the quality of hitters they found deep in the draft. Now if they could do the same with pitchers I will be even more happy. Don't get me wrong as I believe in development but you take on risk when you pick players that can just run fast or throw hard or have good power. They can have those abilities but if they can't hit they are a wasted pick because they will never make it. The upside is huge though because if you can develop their hit tool then you might have an All Star caliber player. IMO you need to balance yourself between the two. At least at the beginning of this draft I felt they were ignoring hit tools which is something they hadn't done in previous drafts. Granted it is hard for me to know much as I am not a scout and only have second hand information to guide me. MLB.com had Jeffers with 40 or 45 hit tool and they are way off. He easily has a 50 hit tool and with development could maybe even get to a 55. I think the FO has I plan I just don't always get it.
-
Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
A good swing is basically all that matters. You can have all the athleticism in the world and if you can't hit the ball you are a black hole on offense. You don't need a ton of athleticism to play 1st, 3rd, Left field, DH and maybe even 2nd Base. You can hide that if you find guys that hit. Arraez is a good example. He has no above average tools except his bat and yet he is more valuable than say a Pedro Floriman type player who has good speed, good arm, good defense but a horrible bat. Arraez can still play decent defense and can help the offense. While I agree you can't teach speed and arm strength teaching someone how to hit is no easy task either. Ask Bechtold, Pearson and Celestino. Lot's of players never learn to do it well enough to make it. Even guys with excellent approaches have trouble I'm thinking Lamonte Wade. I just think that guys with better hit tools have a greater chance to make it because offense is so important. Defense can only take you so far. If you can't hit you can't move up. If you can't move up you can't make it. Hit tool is the most important thing then defense\athleticism.
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
-
Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
Grabbing too many guys with potential hit tool problems. To me that doesn't bode well as those guys typically can't do well enough to make it to MLB. I liked the past two drafts better when they went for players with good hit tools and more average to slightly above average measurables. If you can't hit the best you can be is a utlity player. Not getting a good vibe from this draft so far. Too much risk for me.
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 2 Thread
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
-
Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
I agree with you he was my pick there as well that 60 hit tool just feels like can't miss, and yet how many times do I chastise the FO not taking a risk on guys with high end tools. They look pretty good after taking Jeffers where they did last year. I don't think it was a horrible pick but it was a riskier pick IMO. I am excited about this kid and hope the FO found a diamond in the rough here. Also would be nice if they could save some bonus pool money as well.
-
Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
yeah he recently popped up. He could be better than all of them he might have a higher ceiling than Stott or Carroll but I feel like his floor is much lower with the suspect hit tool. How many times do you see great athletes that just aren't that good at the plate, Kid is young and made strides I just think there is more risk in this than the others.
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
- Article: 2019 MLB Draft Day 1 Thread
-
Article: Twins Daily Staff Predictions for the Twins First Round Pick
I think the Twins go with Langiliers or Carroll if they are still there. With such good hitters likely on the board I don't see them going with a pitcher but since high end pitching is the weakest area in the system maybe they will surprise me. Taking pitchers early has been unkind to the Twins in the past. The only success story I can think of is Kyle Gibson. I take that back they also took Garza in the first but traded him. Also they have been good at finding hitters in the later rounds so maybe they take a chance on high end pitching with the first pick anyway? If Stot or Jung are there I could see them picking one of those two as well. There will be some good players left when we pick I guess it just depends on what kind of deal they cut to get one of the better players in that range.
-
Article: MIN 9, TB 7: Odorizzi Shines In Tampa Return
Call me a worry wart but after we lost that first game big to Tampa I was worried the wheels might come off. I thought Tampa's pitching would slow our offense down and I felt they had the better starting pitching staff going into this series and the better bullpen. Taking three out of four from them really makes me feel better about this team. It was nice to see our offense put lot's of pressure on their pitchers and for the most part continue to do damage all series long. Even going up against good pitching this offense can produce. Also I felt the team played really good defense and did not give Tampa extra outs. At any rate I am really, really happy they took this series to help take some of the worry out of me.
-
Article: MIN 6, TB 2: Marwin Carries May Success Into June, Helps Lead Twins Over Rays
Nice to see the offense have a good day today. Just short on a few fly balls that turned into doubles. Everyone got a hit except the leadoff man Kepler. Can I Just say that I don't have much faith in our pitching and yet they continue to do well. Going into this series I wasn't sure we could play with the big boys but with the win today we have held our own against the good teams we have faced so That bodes well.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Hitter of the Month - May 2019
Yeah I should have said signed but the Twins did PICK him over other IFA's so I used the word pick. He never was fat but I had heard things about him needing to watch his conditioning I assumed that meant not to get too heavy or that there was at least a concern he would get too heavy. As for slow MLB.com had him as a 30 runner to me that is not that fast but maybe they made a typo? Never said he had a bad K rate just that he was under 20 percent with a good eye. Below is MLB's scoutng report on him. Scouting grades: Hit: 50 | Power: 55 | Run: 30 | Arm: 50 | Field: 45 | Overall: 45 The Twins signed Diaz out of the Dominican Republic in 2013 for $1.4 million, then watched him struggle a bit during his pro debut in the Dominican Summer League in 2014 and again in the Gulf Coast League in 2015. Things really started to click in the Appalachian League in 2016 and he made a successful move to full-season ball that included a Midwest League All Star nod in 2017. He didn't back that up with a strong performance in the Florida State League in 2018 and a fractured right thumb sidelined him in late July. Diaz's value lies in his offensive potential from the left side of the plate. Over the past two seasons, he's shown an ability to make consistent contact and drive the ball to all fields. He has tremendous raw power that he is still learning to tap into and it has been really encouraging that he has kept his strikeouts low and hasn't sold out to try to hit the ball over the fence. A below-average runner, Diaz will be a first baseman only and should be capable enough to not be a liability there. As long as Diaz continues to watch his conditioning and continues to refine his approach at the plate, he should fit the profile of a run-producing first baseman in the future. He'll play all of the 2018 season at age 21.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Hitter of the Month - May 2019
I never liked the Diaz pick. Thought he would be a fat, slow, swing and miss 1st baseman. I am very impressed at what great shape he appears to be in and the way he is hitting the ball is even more impressive. HR's are hard to come by in the FS league and he doesn't appear to be having trouble. He has a good eye at the plate as his K rate is just under 20%. He doesn't walk much but making contact is just as important as walk rate and he can barrel up the ball. Congrats to Lewin on proving my assumptions wrong and having a Fantastic month of May.
-
Article: MIN 5, TB 3: Twins Rally, Top Rays Late
I have to say when the Rays were up 3 to 1 I was thinking maybe we just can't compete with the East teams. I was glad when they turned it around and found a way to win. OUr players chased some horrible pitches, looking at you Rosario and Astudillo and yet those two both came through in the clutch. As long as our pitching holds this is going to be a special team. Stinks that Sano got robbed of a Home Run. I think Domes and Baseball don't really go well together.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 MLB Draft Top 50 Prospects: 1-10
I have no idea what the Twins will do this year. After the first ten picks or so though the next 30 players are pretty much rated the same so it just depends on how teams have those players ranked on their board. So we should be able to get two really good players and then some players that hopefully we can develop. I don't think this is a great year to save a ton of money early on if it means taking a lessor player. There are so many teams above us that can cut deals that it might be hard to find a deal anyway. If they can do it and still get the player then great but I wouldn't let that factor in a ton this year. There are going to be good players at 13 and the Twins will be one of the first teams to pick from the second tier of talent. I hope they make the right choice.
-
IT'S TIME TO PANIC!11
You think it is bad losing one game, wait until tonight when we lose another and start a losing streak. Then the other shoe will have dropped and panic can officially set in.
-
Article: TB 14, MIN 3: Well … That Just Happened
Perez seems to play with fire several innings every time he pitches. Lot's of times he has been able to work himself out of it but not tonight. Hoping for a better approach from him in the future. It is a tough way to start the series as you hate to just give a game away but it happens to all teams at some point. I hope we can compete with these guys at some point. If we can't beat the teams in the East then it doesn't really matter what our record is as we will be out in the first round.
-
Article: How the 2018 Twins Draft Looks One Year Later
That Jeffer's pick I didn't like last year seems to be paying off for the Twins. His numbers haven't been too far off of Larnach's this year and he was taken in the second round and plays the valuable catcher position. A bit disappointed in Keirsey and Helman this spring but it has been a down spring for a lot of our prospects. There is still time for these guys to adjust especially the high schoolers but this draft appears weaker than the last couple of years.
-
Article: MIN 5, MIL 3: Smeltzer Shines in Emotional MLB Debut
I am sorry now that I wasn't a believer but I had this game as a loss with Devin on the mound. Of course I couldn't have been more wrong, Devin was brilliant tonight and now we have our best pitchers ready for the Tampa series. He man handled that tough Brewers lineup tonight. I was shocked at the out come. I hope he gets another chance to prove himself. Very happy to grab a split with a tough NL team. Here's to hoping the bats come alive against Tampa.