Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dman

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dman

  1. It doesn't make a ton of sense to trade Kepler to me. He is on a team friendly contract, has a better OBP and OPS than Rosario, and he is a top of the line defender in right field. It would take a Chris Sale type pitcher and then some to pry him a way IMO. The other thing is we don't really have a great replacement for what Kepler does. I mean you could throw Cave over there but long term I am not sure we have a good replacement for Kepler in the system. At least not from a defensive standpoint. He is also a nice backup for Buxton as he graded pretty well in center when he played there. I guess if the right deal came along he could be traded but it would have to be for some very good assets IMO.
  2. Way too young to be gone already. Just doesn't seem possible to die of natural causes at 23. RIP Ryan.
  3. I think it has to do with his ability to be aggressive in big moments and make something happen, whether that be running through a stop sign to score, Making an incredible throw to home that won a game, or coming up with big home runs. A risk taker by nature Rosario is not afraid to fail, in fact he is prone to be even more aggressive when something needs to happen. That being said it also backfires on him as well. Running through stop signs to create outs, missing the cut off man allowing runners to move up, and striking out by swinging at balls out of the zone in big moments when getting on base via walk would have helped hurt the team as well. I guess it depends on what you want to see. The player that is clutch in some situations or the player who produces more outs than he should. The aggregate when added up though points to the WAR he received and thus his perceived value by the important decision makers in baseball (GM's). If he can change a couple of things I still think he could be an all star caliber player but he just wants to swing and his defense isn't exactly elite so if he stays who he is I think we can find better options for that spot. I still think the Twins keep him this coming year, but if wants to stay beyond that his OBP has to change and his defense needs to improve. There are three or four guys in our system that could be ready to take that spot if he doesn't improve.
  4. I am happy we have another pitcher in the stable. Just need at least two more really good arms. Kind of hoping they can bring back Pineda and then get a top guy in free agency. Need two more solid arms to be able to compete would be nice if one was as a top of the rotation starter.
  5. MIke I see this the same way. This isn't about bashing Eddie it is simply logical numbers based decision making. I love Rosario as much as the next guy but when looking at our farm system and payroll Eddie looks like the most likely to go at this point. Don't get me wrong I am pretty sure the Twins are keeping Rosario this year as they need the proven outfield depth so unless some team wants to overpay he will be around next year. Look the guy was almost an All Star in the first half but teams made changes just before the break and they seemed effective. They played Eddie to his pull side on defense and they kept pitching him low and away out of the zone and after two strikes they threw him junk and he swung at almost anything with two strikes. Granted he was also injured and that affected him as well but he needs to better understand when to swing and when not to swing if he ever wants to be that All Star player he wants to become. Given what I have seen I don't think he can change and if he can't then he is replaceable IMO.
  6. Small sample size but Cave has the same OPS as Eddie and is probably a better defender in left than Eddie. Cave also had 8 dingers in his small number of a bats as well so he has some power. Not a great stretch for him to replace Eddie with those numbers.
  7. I wouldn't mind seeing extensions for any of those layers with exception of Rosario. Granted I love Rosario passion but the lack of discipline and the fact we have some young guys ready for that spot it seems like it would be a mistake to extend him at this point. I hope the Twins can find a way to get a couple more extensions done this year. Berrios would be key as hanging onto pitching is always important. If Sano has finally put things together I would love to have him an extra a year or two. Same with Buxton.
  8. I think Duran is the only lock on this list. While I am not a believer in protecting position players in the rule V I would protect Raley for sure as he is almost MLB ready and with rosters expanding makes sense to be poached by teams not planning to compete next year. Blankenhorn might get poached as well as he reminds me of Niko Goodrum to some extent without the speed and maybe a better bat. He might not get taken but would hate to lose him at this point. He might be a tough add though because if he regresses he might be hard to get off the 40 man. Celestino is pretty young I agree with the poster who said a team could take him as 4th outfielder as his defense is good and then hope the bat plays. Pretty big gamble at this stage though and you don’t see many or any teams really try that in Rule V, but with roster expanding and some teams not competing you never know. I would not protect Wander. His defense is poor and his bat didn’t even play in A ball. He might have potential but appears to be years away at this point. I don’t know why a team would saddle themselves with a player like that on their 40 man. For pitcher’s I am torn on Chalmers. He still has control problems although they have gotten better and should get better the further removed from surgery he is. I just don’t think he is ready for MLB right now and I am not sold yet that he ever will be. The K rate looks good though and he is a hard thrower so probably needs to be added. Also torn on Jax. I love that he just goes after hitters but the WHIP is a little high and without the K’s 5th starter is likely the best he can do at the MLB level. Still would hate to lose him and I think he could work in someone’s pen right now so might have to add him. Tough call there though as we have some higher quality guys not too far off. I was pretty high on Wells but coming off surgery he might be a really big gamble for a team to take but his K 9 is good and I have always liked him for a spot in the pen. Unless he doesn’t come back well I think he will be a guy that makes it. Not sure if needs protection this year or not but he would be guy I would hate to see leave. I also like Moran better than most on this site. He had a K 9 last year of 13 but a horrible WHIP. He doesn’t throw real hard but he gets such good movement he K’s a lot of guys. Personally I would rather have Moran on the 40 man than Wisler. Wisler has one great pitch is 27 and has no options. Moran has two good pitches is 22 and has a full set of options. If they think they can fix Wisler why can’t they fix Moran? I don’t get it. I think Jovani is underrated but I guess we will see how this plays out soon enough.
  9. They gave Stewart every possible opportunity to succeed and he just never quite made it. I still think he could be a decent reliever in MLB but I guess the Twins don't think so. This was coming two years ago it was time for both the player and the organization to move on.
  10. First let me say I always loved Stephen as a draft pick and his stats coming through MiLB. However, given what I have seen of him MLB so far he looks like a 5th starter similar to Popen, Smeltzer, Littel, and Thorpe. In fact I think all those guys except maybe Smeltzer throw harder than Stephen. His control issues plus lack of velocity was always going to be tough to overcome IMO. Honestly I don't hate this move. I was hoping we could get one last look at him to see if he could improve an make the jump but with so many other arms in the system that appear to have more upside I can see why the Twins tried to move him off the 40 man. I will say I was surprised by the move especially this early but looking at it harder can understand them taking the risk. I wish Stephen well and I still believe he can be a solid major league pitcher it doesn't look like it going to be with Twins though.
  11. You are right my rhetoric was too harsh. I just never liked the Tyler Kinley signing and my emotions got the better of me. Thanks for calling me out. I agree with you no need to degrade. I removed the post since it serves no good purpose with that content in it.
  12. While I agree I am being a little bit harsh my main criticism is their infatuation with rule V pickups or guys with no options who have to remain on the 25(6) man roster which can allow other teams to pick up our home grown guys via rule V. Last year the guys that mainly ended up working out the best were guys that were in OUR system (home grown) not someone else's. Guys that had options remaining so that they could move them up and down. This pickup doesn't allow for any of that and smells a bit like their rule V pick failure Tyler Kinley. Not saying you can't find diamonds in the rough in rule V but unless they are certain they can fix this guy it seems like a waste to me. I am fine with guys they sign that start at AAA with the potential to be added later like they did last year I just don't like these types of moves where they have to roster a guy who has been historically bad and is now 27 with no options. I would rather they use that spot to get someone with a proven MLB track record in free agency or keep one of their own players form being poached.
  13. Travis maybe I am being mean for asking this but I am curious so here goes. Toward the end of your minor league career did you see the writing on the wall that you might not achieve your dream of playing MLB and how did you feel once the Twins let you go? Maybe I am a creep for asking that but I am curious about your mindset during that process. If you don't want to answer this one that is fine. FYI I followed you (i.e. your stats) throughout your minor league career. Kept hoping you would take off and there were times when it looked like you might. Anyway I wish you well and am glad that you appear to be in a good place in your life right now. Thanks for giving this a shot.
  14. Totally love your take here as it is pretty the same as my own. Gordan has been doing OK. His OPS is nothing to write home about but having a young solid Utility depth guy is not a bad thing to have in your pocket. He can be this years Torreyes for us. A guy who can help us if multiple infield injuries come up. I agree with your premise of why sell low. He appears to be a solid player with the potential to get better. To be a Marwin or Escobar like player down the road. Unless we are dying for that 40 man spot for some reason I think it makes sense to keep him around. If someone wants to over pay for him in a trade then that works for me too. I just don't feel like he is throw in materiel but that's me. He has value and given time and opportunity I think will provide more value than most people think. No one thought Arraez provided much value before this year and Gordon has greater speed and a better arm than Arraez. They are fairly similar players with the exception of Arraez's amazing eye at the plate which very few in baseball can match. I agree with others that it would be nice to see greater durability. He was out early this year and then late with a HBP injury. He still had decent numbers at AAA .298/..342 with and .800 OPS. A little more muscle another year of experience should serve him well. He might not be the All-Star he should have been being drafted that high but I see a guy who can still be very valuable down the road.
  15. I think the Twins will have to add him if they want to keep him. He has already had success in AAA and teams like the Orioles and Tigers would love to grab a guy like that for free. He is too close to ready to not be added IMO. If he is added though the Twins would need to think about moving another outfielder via Trade. Not sure how many of these guys we can keep on the 40 man. Somebody might have to get moved at some point. Personally I think Wade is the most likely trade candidate. He hasn't shown much power and his batting average in AAA has not been that stellar either. I know he has a good eye but that might not be enough in today's game. Will be interesting to see how it plays out.
  16. I really like your analysis but I am going to go the other direction and say Buxton is the most valuable. I am going to base that on the fact he has elite speed and defense in center field coupled with the fact he has very good power for a center fielder. While Max might have more power he isn't the same threat to steal bases and play gold glove D in center. I admit that Buxtons health is a real concern and you would have to see past that to give him most valuable but I think he has more elite skills so I would give it to him. Based on what both of them have done so far I would give it to Kepler for the reasons you mention above. Kepler is a good defender in center and elite in right field. He has the power to play the corners and a good eye at the plate. He is a very valuable player on a team friendly contract. He has generally been pretty healthy in MLB ball. It is a tough choice to be sure and personally I would keep both of them.
  17. I agree with you. There are a lot of things to like\love about Rosario but patience is not one of them and it makes him far more average than people realize. Kepler has a worse average and his OBP is .36 points higher and OPS .55 points higher than Rosario and thus more valuable. Max also plays some of the best right field in the league and Eddie not so much. There is a fatal flaw in Eddies game and if he can't fix it then Larnach or Kirilof will be better options either later this year or next for sure. Granted the young guys won't likely hit 32 home runs but they still could end up with an OPS similar to Rosario. They would cost less and production even it went it went down slightly likely wouldn't hurt the team that much. I mean even Jake Cave has a better OBP than Rosario and his OPS is essentially the same and he would play better defense in left than Rosario. Granted it is a small sample size but our 4th outfielder can essentially play to Rosario's level right now. Look I Like Rosario and I don't think the Twins will trade him this year, but if he doesn't improve his OBP and OPS then next year is another story. I think at least one of Larnach or Kirolloff will likely be ready to go by then or as noted above Cave could step in.. He needs to learn to play cat and mouse with the pitcher or his value will never be that high. He is a good trade candidate simply because we have minor league depth at the position not because of hate. The numbers simply show he needs to be better or the competition will take his place.
  18. I didn't think we would beat the Yankee's in HR's after they caught us so I am surprised but really happy we get bragging rights for at least a year. I think the way the game is going there will be more lineups like the Twins with power throughout the lineup. What a year just can't believe how well the team did this year. Such a fun season to follow. Ups downs but we came out on top. Now lets hope for a little more magic in the playoffs.
  19. I never thought Dobnak would have had a chance to be anything other than possibly a low level MLB reliever. I never had him as a top prospect and figured that he most likely would end up a AAAA pitcher. I guess I could not have been more wrong about him. Only having numbers to rely on I always liked his WHIP but the K9 numbers didn't seem to be there so I never considered he could even be a dominant pitcher. This year he really had a great ERA and WHIP no matter what level they had him at. While his K9 numbers are not fantastic it isn't at Kohl Stewart levels either. He seems pretty solid attacking the zone and getting good results. I am surprised but happy to be wrong as we need some guys to step in and step for us soon. Sorry I doubted you Randy I wish you continued domination and success.
  20. Very, very happy that in a very special season the Twins took the division. The beginning of the year was heaven with all the long ball action. The middle of the year was torture as the huge division lead was whittled away to nothing and eventually knocked out of first place. The end of the year was a grind but even with all the injuries, the Pineda suspension and our main rotation in shambles this team never quit. They kept fighting. They kept winning and they held off the Indians to take the Central division crown. Unbelievable and fantastic. Here's hoping for a little more Twins magic in the post season.
  21. Very, very happy that in a very special season the Twins took the division. The beginning of the year was heaven with all the long ball action. The middle of the year was torture as the huge division lead was whittled away to nothing and eventually knocked out of first place. The end of the year was a grind but even with all the injuries, the Pineda suspension and our main rotation in shambles this team never quit. They kept fighting. They kept winning and they held off the Indians to take the Central division crown. Unbelievable and fantastic. Here's hoping for a little more Twins magic in the post season.
  22. While I agree with you that he has as much or more potential to improve than regress I still don't buy the sign right now scenario. So many things can go wrong it doesn't make much sense to sign him long term this early. What if he blows out his knee again and is never the same player again? What if he gets concussed and isn't the same player again? What if he does regress? What if he never develops much power? Then you are stuck paying for a guy you may not even want on your 40 man. There is a reason teams typically don't extend players this early and that is they don't want to take on that kind of risk. Give him a full year and see what things look like. There really is no hurry to make these deals until players are close to arbitration. Most deals are only adding a year or two tops anyway. Under the current rules If I was in the FO I would wait even for a sure thing I would wait. I will say that I agree that barring injury I think Arraez will get better as he ages. I think he will selectively add power to his game in the next couple of years and with his great eye at the plate I don't think there will be much regression because he will force pitchers to pitch in the zone and that should allow for better outcomes. If he stays healthy I believe this guy is the real deal and a big asset to this team now and moving forward.
  23. I agree but I bet they keep him down next year until he proves he can be consistently productive at a high level. Since he doesn't have to be added to the 40 man he will have to force their hand to make it IMO.
  24. Nice to see we have 5 players in the top 100 which is more than any team in our division. The position players are going to have a tough time breaking in as there are good players at pretty much every position now. I wouldn't move Kepler for Larnach. I wouldn't move Polanco for Lewis right now either so those guys will have to be really good in AAA to earn a shot. I wish we had more high end pitching than we do but hopefully Graterol and Balazovic work out well for us. There are some guys further down with a chance to move up if they can take the next step. So things still look good down on the farm.
  25. I have always liked Arraez's bat but I am still not a big fan of his defense. I think he can probably play close to average at 2nd base and that is where he should stay. I really don't like his arm at third at all. When he throws the ball over I swear it looks like it is going in slow motion. When Sano throws a ball over it gets to first in a hurry. I really believe that on a close play the throw from Arraez would be just late instead of just in time. I don't like him in left field either as he isn't real fast and again doesn't have a real strong arm. Is he better than Josh Willingham, sure but you still lose defensive value when he is out there IMO. I can see why fangraphs and other scouts are somewhat down on him as he lacks power and at his best is average at 2nd base defensively. The hit tool is as good or better than most all the rookie prospects IMO it is an elite tool. I keep expecting him to regress with the bat and he just keeps on hitting. With the great approach at the plate he has I think Francona is right he looks like someone who will challenge for batting titles in the future. Like many have already said I like him a lot as our future 2nd baseman. I think he will grow into some power and round out the hit tool and make it to some All Star games. I think his future is bright and am happy the Twins found an under rated player that has the best hit tool on the team.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.