Everything posted by Dman
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: 11-15
Hard to get too excited about Canterino and Wallner just yet because they haven't even played a full season in pro ball, but I agree they had decent debuts. Also hard to rank them but given their draft postion this seems about right. I know Javier is young and has a lot of potential high end tools but after watching him I really don't think he belongs in the top 20. I didn't see anything that led me to believe he looked better than the worst guy on the Cedar Rapids team. He really needs to up his game this year or I predict he will fall off the prospect map. I like Thorpe and I think he is the best Left handed pitching prospect we have had in a long time. Right now the results don't match the stuff though. He has a tendency to walk guys and allow the big hit far too often. Better control would probably go a long ways toward him reaching his potential. I still like him a lot and have no problem with where he is ranked. Celestino should be higher IMO. After he warmd up last year he was arguably one of the best hitters in the system and for a center fielder he looks like he has all the tools to be a good one. Arm might be a little light but not Ben Revere noodle arm either. I am really excited about this kid. Still needs to continue to do well at the higher levels but I agree with the other poster who said he should be close to untradable as he is starting to realize much of his projected potential. It's another good list just not quite as exciting as the list before it because of Javier and the two players that are so new it is hard to pin down how good they are.
-
Twins Trade Graterol to Dodgers for Kenta Maeda in Blockbuster Deal
I had the same question myself last night. Why didn't Boston just take Maeda from LA. He is a good value for starting pitcher and with Price gone they needed someone decent in the rotation. They still have a shot a world series why go for the prospect? The only thing I could come up with is they really wanted to clear salary more than they let on. The other thought is they don't think Maeda is a needle mover in the AL. It is that aspect of the trade that worries me some. Graterol is only 21 and he makes throwing 100 look incredibly easy. The shoulder impingment last year is worrisome (brings back Alex Meyer anxiety) but hard to say if that means he can't start. At any rate it seems like a good gamble for Boston. His floor is elite reliever and being so young he should be around a good long time in Boston. I was OK with the Twins starting the year with Dobnak, Thorpe and Smeltzer filling in but as many have pointed out that left very little depth if the team encountered injuries and banking on Rich Hills perfect recovery doesn't seem like a leap of faith you take with the kind of team we have right now. Adding Maeda seems like it raises the bar for the rotation and adds depth to the rotation so we should all breath a little easier to start the season. Is this the ace type needle mover we all felt was needed? I don't think so. Was it worth trading Graterol for Meada? If Graterol turns out to only be reliever then I think this is an OK move if he is more than that we lose this trade big time. One last thought. We still have Duran, Balazovic and maybe Colina who are hard throwers with plenty of wild cards in Canterino, Sands, Rijo and Vallimont who could have pretty good stuff. Still plenty of pitching in the system so not the end of the world. I hate losing that big arm (a true 100 mph dream arm) and I hope this works in our favor but I have my doubts.
-
Twins are 3rd team in Betts trade
Not sure what to think just yet. First reaction is I don't like the trade but as it sets in I guess this might not be such a bad deal. We need starting pitching help now and Graterol can't provide that right now. Also there are questions as to whether his arm can hold up to starters innings or not. If his arm can hold up I think we got fleeced if he really is just a reliever then this is not a bad get for a solid to elite reliever when you need a starter really badly. I don't like Meada's age. Can we really get 4 years out of this guy? I know we need help now and I guess if he breaks down the cost in salary is not bad. I guess this comes down to how good Graterol becomes. If he does become that hard throwing ace I think I will be sick to my stomach every time we play Boston. I am trusting the FO on this one and sure hope they got this one right or the fan base will never let them forget it. We wanted a trade for decent starting pitcher we got it. Are we happy?
-
Taijuan Walker
I think Walker is a perfect fit for the Mariners. They should be able to give him a decent offer and if he performs they could net a coveted prospect or two for their system at the deadline. I think if the Twins want him they will have to offer more than other teams would. If he is healthy he is likely smart to wait this out until spring training as he could end up starting for some team as there will likely be injuries or greater concern about rotations as the spring wears on.
-
Twins Daily 2020 Top Prospects: 16-20
On this list I am most excited about Sands. I didn't expect much from a 5th round pick with not particularly great College stats so he has exceeded expectations for me. His numbers from A ball to AA never really wavered which tells me his stuff plays well and he has the control needed to make it in MLB. He goes right after hitters and dares them to hit his stuff. I know most scouts have him as a number 5 but I really think he ends up a three. I know it was just one year but I was really, really impressed with what he was able to do. I had high hopes for Miranda this past year and he really let me down. I know he was very young for the level and high A is tough on hitters but I thought he would at least manage a 700 something OPS the meager 650 he hit left me thinking what happened to that power stroke? He has time to right the ship but he is rule V eligible at the end of this year so he needs to perform like the great player I know he can become. Given the reports I have read I question if Colina is a starter or not. Still love his stuff but it feels like he is missing that quality third pitch he needs to be a starter. Maybe he finds it this year hard to say but without it I think he gets exposed as he moves up. If he does fail as a starter he should be a really good pen arm. He always seem to have good stats it was really just control holding him back but he looked better last year so here's hoping he finds a way to stick in the rotation. It is a very nice 16-20. Hoping to see improvement from these guys this year. We definitely need the pitchers to step up. Right now I am an optimistic believer in these guys.
-
Taijuan Walker
Thought I also read an article that Seattle was interested in bringing him back so not sure if the Twins can get him or not. It does seem curious that he hasn't signed yet though. Is he waiting for the Twins to clear the Rich Hill 40 man spot so they can sign him to a guaranteed contract with a spot on the 40 man? Or since he hasn't pitched in forever are teams not that interested in giving him a 40 man spot? Not sure but he is really the only interesting piece left out there so why not roll the dice.
-
Twins Announce Non-Roster Spring Training Invites
IMO Chacin is the most likely to make it. There will be room on the 40 man for a starting pitcher and we are short on arms to start the year. Unless he looks horrible or the Twins find someone better I think he takes that last spot. Outside chance to make it for me would be Thielbar and Hardy. They are both Lefty arms with bounce back potential. Personally I think they only make it to the 40 man if there are injuries but they have a shot if they pitch well this spring. Everyone else seems like a long shot to me.
-
Do the Minnesota Twins Have a Right-Handedness Problem?
To be honest it was something that had crossed my mind as well but after looking into it, it didn't seem to be much of an issue. I thought you made a good point and one I hadn't considered about the playoff pitchers we will face. That does make it more of an issue when and if we get to that level but it does seem minimal compared to our potential pitching issues. In the end I think there is a healthy balance in this lineup and we might have lefties on the way by the end of this year if things go well on the farm for the top prospects.
-
Twins Trade Ryne Harper to Nationals for minor league pitcher
I have to say it is interesting to me how this board felt about Harper and that the team that won the World Series last year was the high bidder to add his services to their team, lol. For not belonging in a pen with World series aspirations the Nats seem to think otherwise. Not that a 9th round pick is a high price to pay but still interesting how different perceptions can be about players and how they can help a team.
-
Twins Trade Ryne Harper to Nationals for minor league pitcher
Yeah not a lot of 9th rounders make it and his college numbers don't look very impressive but still there was enough there for him to get picked in the top 300 last year. He seems to fit the mold the Twins have been using for later round pitcher picks. They appear to be ignoring stats and looking for certain physical traits as well as how well guys throw certain pitches. Won't know how that turns out for a bit yet but I'm thinking Ober, Sammons and Windor as examples. There are others that have already failed or look like they won't make it but with numbers odds of finding diamonds in the rough are better. Windor was a small school guy with not great numbers who dominated A ball last year. So maybe this is another gamble in that direction. No guarantee it works out but at least we have a lottery ticket instead of nothing at all. Here's hoping the Scouts and FO identified something in McMahon that makes them think he can make it.
-
Twins Trade Ryne Harper to Nationals for minor league pitcher
I was hoping they could manage a trade and they did it! For a guy on an MILB invite last year who helped the MLB pen early in the season we get a guy we can look at for four more years and hopefully he makes it all the way. Definitely better than letting Harper go for nothing. Good job FO.
-
2020 draft class
So finally MLB trade rumors got it right and realized the Comp pick is protected so you are indeed correct we lose our 3rd round pick which is nice because that means we pick at 67 instead of 101 allowing us to pick 34 spots earlier and likely gaining extra cash to spend as well. Sorry I argued your point and have to admit I was confused about a lot of information out there. https://www.mlb.com/draft/2020/order
-
Why hasn't there been a roster move since JD signing is official?
Yeah you look at what he was able to do last year and it was better than a lot of MLB relievers. His stuff is far from elite but you would think he would be worth a GCL or short season guy with upside. Not a top 30 guy or anything just a little something to make sure whatever team wants him can get him. I mean on Fangraphs he was number 57 in WAR for relievers right next to Trevor May. I know he doesn't have the same stuff as May but he should have some value even for a good team.
-
Why hasn't there been a roster move since JD signing is official?
Trade rumors says it is indeed Harper so we have our answer. I wonder if they can work a trade and get a lottery ticket.
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
Gordon always had a slight build and it was always a bit of concern if he would grow into a larger frame. The Twins obviously thought he would and his hit tool, athleticism and makeup were all good as well as bloodlines. So far the projection just hasn't worked out that well IMO. I am still hoping he can fill out a bit more and find some power. I still believe in his hit tool although Fangraphs seems skeptical and they would know more than I do. I still think he can fill out more and regain that prospect status if not he looks like a solid utility guy but that is a tough outcome considering he was taken so high. I agree with you that he still could be a valuable piece for this team as a bench player or hopefully starter at some point. I just think it is going to take a bit longer for him to get there.
-
Why hasn't there been a roster move since JD signing is official?
I would like to know that answer to that question as well. I know that even though Pineda is on the 40 he is also on the restricted list so doesn't count against the 40 man but with the Donaldson signing I thought they had to take someone off. Does Hill not count against the 40 man?
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
Yeah what Bleday did in High A compared to Larnach makes his list a joke. He gives Bleday a 60 power rating and Larnach 50 and Larnach completely outslugged him this year. Yeah I get it is all about potential but they are the same age and Larnach is just better. Hey he can decide potential any way he wants but the list looks biased to me. Given what I have seen the top 10 doesn't really mean much just something to put together and talk about. Winning these lists is nice but doesn't mean much as Garver and Arraez say Hello. They were never on these lists and Garver was one of the best catchers in MLB last year and Arreaz was in rookie of the year conversations. They couldn't have bought there way onto one of these top 10 lists in MILB? The talent experts only can predict so much. I think he is dead wrong not to have Larnach on there though. Kirrilloff had a down year. with only a 750 OPS he is about as high as he could put him in fact statistically I bet there were better options but his stats from last year probably helped him hang on this year. Same for Lewis he had a down year and is living off of last years stats and potential.
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
I honestly didn't realize he did not play first base at all last year. That might impact why he wasn't on this years top 10 list. He was a 1st basemen in college though so he certainly can play that position if needed. I know there was some talk that his defense wasn't that great at first base so maybe the Twins feel outfield is best? Not sure. Thing is breaking into this outfield is no easy task either. I really wonder how all this is going shake out.
-
Donaldson Official Introduction Press Conference (11:00am Jan 22)
While Pineda is suspended he is on the restricted list so won't count against the 40 man until he comes off the restricted list. Counting Pineda the Twins had 39 players on the 40 man and when Baily and Hill signed that went to 41 when including Pineda. Pineda will count eventually but for now he does not. When Donaldson signed it went to 42 so now someone has to come off. By the time Pineda does come off someone els e might be hurt so they might not have to worry about creating a spot. Also when the regular season starts Hill won't count against the. 40 man because he is hurt so they will have that spot back until Hill comes back.
-
Donaldson Official Introduction Press Conference (11:00am Jan 22)
While Pineda is on the 40 man he doesn't count as taking a spot because he is currently suspended. so after the Donaldson signing they just need to remove one guy from the 40 man. They will show 41 but the suspended player doesn't count.
-
3 Twins Prospects Impacted By Josh Donaldson's Signing
Yes that is very true. No one has proven they need to be added yet and we have all year this year to assess value before the outfield could be over crowded and tougher decisions need to be made, Just jumping the gun a little there because I feel over confident that Rooker and Kirrilloff will need to be added and we can't keep all those left fielder\1st basemen on the 40 man. I am still bullish on Rosario too and think that if he performs just a little better this year the Twins will keep him next year as well. We'll have to wait and see what happens. Personally I think Wade and Raley are the ones that need to really perform to keep their 40 man spots. It is gonna be a big year for the boys on the farm. Perform well or get sent packing.
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
I think if Rooker played out the year last year he would have made the top 10 1st baseman. He was just getting hot when he got hurt. He also made teh top 10 last year. Diaz was and is very good but they needed relief help last year and Miami threw in a decent pitching prospect as well. Not sure how many 1st baseman types we need with Rooker, Kirilloff and Larnach potentially there along with Sano who is already in that spot. So trading for pitching there seemed to make sense and that is apparently who Miami wanted.
-
Donaldson Official Introduction Press Conference (11:00am Jan 22)
They are both signed and on the 40 man roster. https://www.mlb.com/news/twins-sign-homer-bailey-rich-hill
-
2020 Baseball America Top 100 Prospects
It's not easy to make the top 100 as a prospect as there is stiff competition so congrats to all the Twins players who made the list. Happy to see some pitcher on the list and they are all hard throwers so greater upside as well. They are also pretty young 22 or under and at AA or higher so plenty of time to refine pitches and still make it. Duran's K9, WHIP and FIP all look really, really good. I am guessing that is why he made it in. ERA was high for a pitcher in the top 100 but in the age of analytics he probably deserves to be at least number 96. Hopefully he improves some more this year and becomes a top of the rotation starter. Balazovic has been solid level to level and I am hoping he handles AA and moves right onto AAA. Nice to have 6 guys on the list. Hopefully some of the lower guys have good seasons and work their way up here as well.
-
3 Twins Prospects Impacted By Josh Donaldson's Signing
Things are definitely crowded in the outfield no question about it. The 40 man is full of talent as well. If you drop some of the younger guys off of it with the exception of Raley and Chalmers you are essentially dropping a top 20 prospect and gifting that player to another organization. Wisler and Harper are about the only true flexibility left IMO. That being said if injury in the outfield or 1st base I have to beliave Raley gets the first shot. He is on the 40 man and they need to see what he can do to either make it or clear a spot. Next in line is probably Rooker he is older and needs to be on the 40 next year anyway to be protected from the Rule V draft. If Rooker is injured or having a down year then Kirilloff would be up as he needs to be added next year as well. Larnach is likely the odd man out unless he is just killing it and doing much better then the players mentioned above. If no injuries it is going to be very tough for anyone from the minors to find a spot on the 40 man. Even with injuries they might get passed over so that we don't lose someone else. Personally I think the FO lets them play this year and try's to decide who to keep and who to trade to strengthen the team around the deadline. They will have more information on the state of the farm to make better decisions by then.