Everything posted by Dman
-
Updated Fangraphs ratings
I really like how fangraphs rates players as it usually is more in line with how I think they should be rated. Larnach over Kirilloff is a bold move but I think warranted. They both have great hit tools and their defensive value is about the same as well. I think Larnach has a more diverse approach at the plate so that puts him ahead for me as well. Nice to see Duran, Graterol and Balazovich all with 50 grades and rated 4,5 and 6. These guys are our future we need them to succeed so seeing them rated highly is very encouraging to me. I was surprised they had Celestino at number 10. I know he came along well with the bat this season and is a good defender but I didn't see him jumping up quite that high. Also surprised to see Miranda at 12. He has really good contact skills but seemed to struggle at high A if you ask me. Also not sure he plays great defense. I would have had him lower but might have to rethink that after they put him this high. Nice to see Sands and Colina at 16 and 17. They both have good potential to be 5th starters or good out of the pen. Maybe more if something clicks. Was happy to see Javier and Rooker moved down the list. Rooker is getting older has K issues and is not a great defender. I think is better placed at 18. I mean his power is legit and power rules but he needs to improve his OBP to move up higher on the list if you ask me. Javier had a terrible year and looked lost at the plate. His defense didn't look much better. He needed to be moved down. I am a little surprised they had Raley so low. I know he is older and has his own K issues but he appears to be a good defender and was off to a good start in AAA last year. Fangraphs has never been real high on Raley as they don't like his swing calling it too stiff but he has gotten decent results thus far. I thought he deserved at least a 40 rating. Also surprised by Ober. He has been dominant throughout his entire minors carreer and they barely have him at 41. I get that he doesn't have a big fastball but he has 4 pitches he can use effectively and his results speak for themselves. He is older and been injured a fair bit so maybe that plays into it, but this feels too low for him IMO. Same thing for Vallimont. Granted I don't know a ton about the guy as we just got him, but his K rate has been good and my understanding is he has a good fastball and good movement on his pitches. I though he would be bottom 20's or upper 30's for sure but they barely have him cracking the top 40. Even with some of the surprises it is still a good list. Nice to see some pitchers moving into the upper spots inside the top 10 with a nice group in the top 20. Here's hoping for some break throughs this coming year.
-
MadBaum to the D-Backs
I agree with you. My first reaction was that the money wasn't as bad as i thought it was going to be and if they were in on Bumgarner couldn't they have come up with something slightly better? If Bumgarner didn't really want to come to Minnesota or be a part of an AL team then why are staying in the bidding? This whole thing seems weird to me. I am not a Bumgarner believer so not THAT disappointed we didn't get him but I don't understand why the FO is in on guys they don't really seem to be in on. Is this the same scenario for Josh Donaldson? The FO just wants to hang out with the in crowd but isn't all that serious about stepping up to make a deal? I honestly don't know what they are doing. Maybe they are there hoping the price will drop, lol. At any rate I don't fault the FO on this one as it sounds like he wanted go to Arizona and spurned his own team to do it so good for him. I think he is over rated anyway and we likely dodged a bullet. I just hope our FO has a clue about how to sign a top guy in FA. Given the way things have gone the past few years I have my doubts. If their mentality is give us value or no deal then please just stop pretending to in on guys OK.
-
Front Page: The Twins Should be Dealing With the Marlins
I was trying to find more info on Elieser Hernandez and found the following article. It looks like his slider took off and really helped propel him back to the major leagues. The thing is he has been prone to the long ball and he may be just a two pitch pitcher which might ultimately land him in the pen. If the guy could take the next step he might be a mid rotation starter as he has a good fastball and decent control. He could also regress and end up a AAAA player. Hopefully scouts have a better idea of what he most likely becomes. I know a lot of people on here are not big fans of Jake Cave but his OPS was as good as Rosario's last year and he is an above average defender in left field. He would be a good get for the Marlins especially for a Rule V pick that might not end up a starter. Even in a straight up one for one trade I think the Marlins have less risk for a good outcome than the Twins. For the Twins to make this trade they would have to see Hernandez as an upgrade over the current glut of fifth starter material they already have in Graterol, Thorpe, Smeltzer, Poppin, Dobnak, and Maybe Littel. Not to mention the guys on the way in Balazovich, Duran, Colina, Vallimont and Sands and possibly Enlow if he breaks out. That's a lot of guys with 5th starter potential. If they see him as a dominant reliever as his floor then maybe that changes things. The Twins know what they have in Cave and anything they get in return for him better be better than Luis Gill the guy they gave up to get him. I am not sure Hernandez is. On the other hand we have a glut of outfielders with more likely on the way so maybe this is the best they can get and it helps remove an outfielder from the 40 man and gain what appears to be Hernanadez's floor which is a solid reliever. Tough call for me on this one. Maybe that is what makes it a good trade?
-
Front Page: Getting an “Ace” Easier Said Than Done
I am torn. I do want them to overspend but only for three year deals and that might not get it done. I think they can work in an over pay for three years and not affect the club much especially if ownership is willing to push the budget now that the team is really good. On the flip side I hate to be hindered by an unproductive player and dead money for several years. With a 100 win team sitting there I hate to live on hope with our young pitching but if just a couple of guys out of potentially 7 come through it would sure help us keep this team together longer. It is a tough call for me. I am not sure which way is best to go. However, the FO does need to come through for us this is why they earn the big bucks. They need to be right when they make the tough choices. They cannot stand pat. Be it overpay or trade they need to do something to make this team better. They have the payroll space and the trade capital. They have a good team waiting in the wings they need to make a move. A move that helps this team compete in the playoffs.
-
Front Page: The Twins Should be Dealing With the Marlins
Until I read this I was thinking we don't need another number 5 starter with 5 ERA. I checked and you are correct he did have outstanding year in AAA. I don't think any of our young number 5's posted a 1.13 ERA along with his awesome K rate. So he appears to have the stuff but can he get it to translate? He also doesn't have a track record of being overly dominant from level to level throughout his career so he might be just like the number 5's we already have with a little more potential or he might not have the stamina to be a starter and need to move to the pen. It is a more interesting proposition though now that I dig deeper.
-
Why I think the Twins will end up with Ryu and possibly Donaldson.
I think the Twins have a chance on Donaldson otherwise they wouldn't be mentioned at all. I mean the Twins have to know what the bidding numbers are at this point as the Rangers bowed out knowing that it would likely take 4 years to get him. The Twins haven't bowed out so the money or years must not scare them yet. I am not sure they can get Ryu. I think they will likely need to go 4 years there too and I also think once Bumgarner comes off the board there will be more competition for Ryu as well. Would love to have both but don't see it.
-
Front Page: Let's Talk About Willians Astudillo
I always liked him because he didn't strike out much. I thought with his ability to put the ball in play even if his BABIP number were lower he could still have a decent average. He proved me wrong on that assumption this past year. Maybe it's the cheer for the underdog in me but I still really like the guy. I am hoping for a rebound year at the plate for him.
-
How high and long would you go for Ryu?
Sure teams are signing long term contracts and budgeting them into the future but they are also taking on risk by doing so. The Yankess, Boston, Cubs and Dodgers all have had to sit out FA or in season moves because of the penalties of the cap. How great was there budgeting when their teams were stuck financially? The long contract is a play for today to hell with tomorrow mentality. The more money you have the more risks you can afford to fail but even the top teams have limits. We don't know what contracts Ryu has been offered maybe they are all 3 years deals. Maybe some three year deals are equal too or more than the 4 year deals he is receiving. We have no idea. Lets say the Twins have to go 4\110 to get him. That is nearly 30M a year for four years we have tied up. Lets say he hurts his arms and can't pitch in years 3 and 4. Now you have 30M less to spend the next two years when our core players are at their peak and headed to FA. That would be a bad time to lose pitching production and be 30M short in the budget to make moves. Yes the FO is looking at this year and beyond and what we know is there has never been a budget so far that has been over 130M per year. And if you look at the team salaries in our division every team except Detroit has had about the same budget year in and year out fluctuating from around 90M to 130M. Take 30M out of that budget for future years and you can see why it is a big deal to get production from that player for the full number of years. You can hurt payroll flexibility in a hurry with one big bad deal. Does that mean never take the risk? Of coarse not but with an older player like Ryu you would want to do due diligence. You would want to try and do a three year deal if possible. You are correct pretty much every player takes the most guaranteed money despite the AAV and if I was a pitcher at his age I would as well. The Twins will have to decide if he is worth 4 years or not.
-
Rule V mania
Yeah I have to say I was surprised. Surprised that the other teams didn't value any of the players we had available, Ouch! I also thought more chances might be taken with a 26 man roster but again I was wrong. The FO did a good job of identifying who to put on the 40 man. Honestly I think teams have gotten smarter about the rule V draft. Most players taken are not quite ready for MLB. Teams are better off getting left overs from free agency and signing them to low dollar contracts. I mean the top half dozen teams really bad teams probably have nothing to lose in Rule V so why not pick someone anyone, but after that most teams are better off not wasting the roster spot.
-
How high and long would you go for Ryu?
If owners besides the top revenue producing teams operated that way then I see no issue with what you are saying. But dead money matters, think Phil Hughes. The Twins sold their 2nd round draft choice just to get rid of him and likely felt lucky. The "flexibility" to spend has its limits. Sure with no cap you can spend what you want but most teams don't. Take the Red Sox for instance. They gave long term deals to several players and now they want to get under the cap so that they don't have penalties. If they can't get creative they might not be able to sign their best player. As you say there is no cap so why don't they keep on spending? Probably because there is a limit. You can work the numbers anyway you want to budget for your team. You don't have to do all three years deals but with older players given they can become liabilities at any time it seems to me you mitigate the risk of not having money to spend by limiting the years of the contract. With too many long term deals your team can be bad and you still have to pay a lot of money think the Tigers not that long ago. Ryu is an older player who likely, hopefully is able to give us two decent years. Maybe he gives us three or four hard to say but the odds are not in the teams favor the older he gets therefor it makes sense to play the odds and get out the contract as soon as you can and apply that money to next the guy who can help IMO. It very possible you could tie up 25M for no production in the fourth year and if the budget is essentially 150M that is gonna hurt. If your budget is 300M then maybe not so much. I still think dead money is an issue. If I felt the Twins would spend more then I can agree with you that the total dollars is all that matters but I don't see them doing that.
-
How high and long would you go for Ryu?
I see your point if the higher dollar amount is all that matters sure 4/100 isn't that much different from 3/90. Players don't worry if they can produce in year 4 or not because the money is guaranteed. That is why players\agents always shoot for more years. Odds are there is no contract after this one so get what you can while you can. The AAV is less for the team so they have a few more million to spend per year as well. That is all fine until you get to year 4 when you are still on the hook for 20 some Million instead of zero dollars. For the team having that dead weight in salary year four is a hindrance to signing other FA or extending your own good players (i.e. see the Red Sox dilemma this year) While you say there is not salary cap there is a budget cap that every team has. Staying as agile as possible financially should allow you to have money to spend in FA on a yearly basis. Short term deals help achieve that. The further out in years you go with more players you take on more financial risk. So three years versus four is simply risk management to me. You are hoping to get more efficient production per year from the player and remain financially agile in case that player regresses. It makes sense to me and if I was owner and my front office got me the player for 3/90 instead of 4/100 I would be thanking them for saving me 10M especially if I get to put it back in my pocket.
-
How high and long would you go for Ryu?
Yeah I even upped my estimate on the 3 year. We can handle three years even if it all goes south. We have space this year for sure and likely next year as well. So just year three for a possible pinch and other contracts come off as well so they can still maneuver. They could probably handle a 4th year with likely little to no production from him but it would kind of suck as that would be the time we would need to consider paying some of our younger guys unless they get extended. 3 years is the sweet spot for me. Maybe they do an option year to make the dollar amount sound better?
-
How high and long would you go for Ryu?
3/85 is about as high as I would go. Maybe 3/90 if needed. I would do my best to keep the years down even if I have to go with a higher AAV. Sell him hard on the Manager of the year and good clubhouse. The beautiful Minnesota stadium and all the things our city and state has to offer. If you just had to go four years then 4/110 is the limit and I guess we likely eat one or two years on the end of that contract. We just have to have someone good this year. We really need him. I would not go five years though. With that injury history it could be Phil Hughes II.
-
Front Page: Official Twins Winter Meetings Day 4 Thread
Yeah looks like K rate must be King for these kind of signings. Other teams must have figured Jax's stuff wouldn't play well at the MLB level or he would have been selected. Glad no one Grabbed Rijo that was the only one I thought might kind of hurt. I know Wander and his 4M price tag might have hurt as well but he hasn't shown much to this point yet. Hopefully next year is his breakout year.
-
Front Page: The Pineda Plug: 3 Upside Plays the Twins Could Target
I think he is indicating that these guys could be used in the five spot but you would hope they end up a mid rotation piece in that role instead of staying a five. These types of pickups are always a gamble because you can end up with a pitcher that is worse than a rookie number 5 as well. Not sure if now is the right time for the Twins to take that kind of gamble though as they are trying to improve or at least maintain a 101 win team. The Twins should be shooting for surer production not gambles. I do agree with others that if the coaches are good enough to improve those guys why can't they improve the young guys we already have? Poppen, Smeltzer, Thorpe, and Dobnak, have already done well at the AA levels and pretty well at the AAA levels as well. Aren't they a tweak or two away as well? Not to mention Graterol, Duran, and Balazovich who have heavy fastballs and are set to dominate in AA this coming year. Even Cole or Vallimont could surprise us this year. Let's work some magic with the some of the guys we have.
-
Front Page: Official Twins Winter Meetings Day 3 Thread
I think we are going to miss out on the second tier pitchers this year. They might add some higher end relief pitchers if they can get short term deals. I think they play their typical waiting game now as once the big fish are gone the prices will likely drop for the guys who are left. They will get their bargain 5th starter that way. With the Eddie news it looks like they are going to have to try and find their pitcher upgrade with a trade. I would hate to see Eddie go as he still has All Star upside and is going to be a good hitter for a long time. If a team can teach him patience at the plate he will be a really, really good player for a long time. Guys with great contact skills tend to hang around. I am a little bit surprised at how high the dollar values went for pitching in FA this year. I thought we would better be able to compete. Even the LAD and LAA lost out on getting Cole so they have to be bummed out as well. Teams had to go big or go home empty this year and that is not the Twins MO. I still think the Twins can find a pitcher to upgrade the team out there and I have hope that some of the pitchers in AA step up and become better than 5th starters as well.
-
Gibson says Thank You!
He is a guy that gets it. Always nice to see players be incredibly thoughtful. He will be missed but I still think he needed a fresh start. Hopefully his moving on works out OK for the Twins as well.
-
Front Page: Revisiting Falvey and Levine Era Trades: Jake Odorizzi
I was surprised at the lack of interest in Odo by other teams. Surely another team could have offered Tampa more than Palacios. A straight up one for one trade so that Tampa could dump some salary was a great move by the FO. Everyone on the Twins side liked that trade. I can't think of anyone who didn't like it. Trades like that don't happen often.
-
Front Page: Official Twins Winter Meetings Day 2 Thread
I don't know if it is negativity as much as disappointment. Like expecting or hoping to get an Iphone for Christmas for the last ten years and getting a flip phone every year instead. The flip phone gets the job done but isn't elite like the I-phone. I am not saying the FO is wrong not to take on some of these deals but I really thought given how the market worked out the last few years that we had a really good chance at a decent deal with one of the tier two starters. Given the years and dollars or both plus teams with an inside track to resign those players things look grim for upgrading the rotation IMO. While our pitching might be good enough to win the division or manage a wild card berth it doesn't look capable of handling teams in the playoffs. The window is open and we are close it would have been nice to find a pitcher to give us a chance to get over the hump.
-
Bumgarner or Ryu
Who are the best guys after Ryu and Bumgarner? That should be the question. I just don't see this FO significantly outbidding other teams for these guys. The money they are commanding is starting to get silly. I agree with Kato87 that LA will resign Ryu regardless of what the Twins offer. It was fun to dream while it lasted but now the fallback (reality) plan is in full swing. Find a third tier guy and hope the young guys step up I guess.
-
Front Page: Free Agent Faceoff: Madison Bumgarner Is Not Who You Think He Is Edition
Thanks for this article! My gut just doesn't think Bumgarner will be worth the money he will be getting. At this point I don't think there is a way to get value out of a Bumgarner signing. I like him but if it takes 20M a year AAV for 4 or 5 years I don't see him living up to that. Maybe I am wrong and he will rebound and be great the next couple of years but something tells me he more likely is who he is at this point than who he was before. If he is who he is then our number 5 starters are almost as good.
-
Chasing Madison Bumgarner Thread
I hope you are right as I think 20 per year is the highest they will go as that was AAV they had for Wheeler and obviously they liked him better. We will see they could still surprise me.
-
Chasing Madison Bumgarner Thread
I agree. I don't think the Twins will ultimately like the AAV and the years needed to land him. I think they will look for better value for their money. If that is the case then I agree they would have the money for another tier three guy or reclamation project or two. Could also try and pull off a trade but it would likely be hard to find a team willing to give up young pitching for potential Left fielders and 1st basemen. They already have lots of young 5th starter types so don't need more of those. I don't see the Twins going over 4\80 to sign MadBum and it looks like it will take more than that to get him.
-
Minnesota and Big Contracts
I tend to agree with your analysis here and I think we see it borne out in looking at teams in the bottom half of revenues. Teams like Tampa and Oakland with less money in their budget need to maximize the dollar value per performance a player gives to the team. They have to take more risks on development and sometimes even trade productive players early to get some type of decent return. Granted the Twins revenue is higher and they can take slightly more risk in the FA pool but those parameters and type of thinking still apply IMO. Smaller market teams have a harder time selling out for high priced free agents because it limits what they can do with the rest of the roster and if the that player gets injured or becomes unproductive it really upsets the balance of the team. That being said when a window presents itself it seems best to take advantage of it. I think the Twins will be looking for FA player production that gives them good value for the dollar. Using this mindset i think that with the Bumgarner bidding going up the less likely I see him becoming a Twin. I think they likely drop down to Ryu or Keuchel. I think years and dollars matter more to teams that generate less revenue. Granted there are and can be exceptions I just think the Twins FO will ultimately still look for better value when push come to shove.
-
Front Page: Report: Twins Nearing Multi-Year Deal with Michael Pineda
I am not sure if they have that in mind or not but I do agree that they most likely want to rely on the farm to supply pitching. Falvey will follow the Cleveland blueprint of developing pitching as much as possible. IMO for smaller market teams to be really successful they need to develop at least one top of the rotation starter from their farm system and likely another good mid tier starter. Having top of the line low cost pitching allows the team to spend elsewhere or extend valuable young players to remain competitive. The Twins did this and dominated the division when they had Santana. KC did it when they had Yordano Ventura. Oakland and Tampa do a good job of this as has Cleveland and they are pretty successful small market teams year in and year out. I think the Twins will follow that trend. Granted that doesn't mean the Twins can't take a chance on a good FA starter especially with their window wide open but I can also see where they still might look for the farm to deliver if the money and years for a FA don't make sense to them.