Everything posted by Dman
-
Trade Retrospective: How Did the Twins Do in the Ryan Pressly Trade?
I think that is an interesting thought. I know it is a bit out there but if that was the case the trade ends up being Pressly, Outfielder Jaylin Davis and pitchers Prelander Berroa and Kai-Wei Teng for Alcala, Celestino and Dyson. Dyson ends up actually hurting the team in 2019 and is no longer with the team so if the subtraction of Presley could be linked to the needed adding of Dyson then the Presley trade does look a lot worse. Granted the Dyson deal was an odd and unforeseen case of bad luck but still if you taking everything into consideration that would be a high price to pay for losing Presley and only gaining Alcala and Celestino. Personally I think there is some merit to thinking this way but there is no way to prove they would or wouldn't have made those moves if they still had Presley.
-
Trade Retrospective: How Did the Twins Do in the Ryan Pressly Trade?
I like your analysis here. I think they still make the Romo Trade even if they had Pressly as it freed up a spot for 1st base prospects (Lewin Diaz who would need to be added to the 40 man) and added a pitcher that didn't need to be added to the 40 man while also netting Romo. At that time we felt we needed two or three options so I think that Romo deal happens regardless. I wonder though if we had Pressly if we could have avoided the horrible Dyson trade. So that is something to consider. My thinking at the time was the year we traded him he wasn't going to help us. We were not going to make the playoffs. The next year we certainly could have used him but in the end I don't see him as someone who would have been a difference maker as we won 100 games without him and the issues we had in the playoffs were soooo numerous even if we had him he wouldn't have made a difference. So while we missed a year and a half of a fairly elite reliever I think the return works in our favor assuming of course the players received make it to MLB. I too don't think he would have signed an extension with the Twins and I don't think the Twins would have offered the money that he ultimately received as they seem to have a philosophy of not investing high dollar amounts in the pen. Hard to say for sure though maybe he would have taken a discount to stay on the Team he came up with and maybe they could have gotten a deal done but I don't think you can take that to the bank in fact the odds seem low to me that he would have stayed. Assuming they were not going to be willing to pay market value to sign him I think the trade looks really good for the Twins right now. They have 5 or 6 years of Control of Alcala who will never be quite Pressly like but still very good and a potential productive center fielder that could give them a lot of future flexibility. It is early but I don't see Celestino as an All Star type player but a very good player certainly better than 4th outfielder if he continues to hit. If both those players do hit MLB then IMO the Twins win this trade handily. If only Alcala makes it having him for 6 years versus the 1 and a half we didn't really need Pressly it is still a win in my mind. Even if neither player made it at this point I don't think I would be that disappointed in the effort to get better given where the team was at that time. Still too early to say how this all turns out but I still like this move.
- Game-Thread 8/5: Minnesota Twins (9-2) @ Pittsburgh Pirates (2-9) 6:05pmCT
- Game-Thread 8/5: Minnesota Twins (9-2) @ Pittsburgh Pirates (2-9) 6:05pmCT
-
Mechanical Adjustments Make for Wicked Matt Wisler
I believe I called Wisler a Clown when we moved to get him as his stat profile was bad. He had the one good pitch and a fastball that guys hit over the fence. I was definitely not on board with the pickup at the time. So far this season I am the one looking like a clown. Hope he keeps it up. Getting a guys for free that performs like that really helps a team out.
-
MLB Pipeline's Updated Top 100
The Twins list is pretty much as expected. I would have liked to see Duran in there but all these guys are good so likely comes down to preference. It looks like Chicago's rebuild is pretty much complete. Robert and Madrigal will graduate off of this list and Kopek will likely follow next year so they will have their young lineup and rotation pretty much set for years to come. Looks like they will be a tough team for quite a while now but after this year not as much for top tier prospects in the system anymore. Detroit has a ton of pitching coming I presume soon in Mize, Manning, and Skubal but not much in the way of elite hitters ready anytime soon as Green is likely a ways a away and they just drafted Torkelson. They could use some more elite bats but could have an elite pitching staff if things go their way. Kansas City has elite pitching coming up as well with Lacy, Singer and Lynch but virtually nothing for hitters either. I think they might have an unbalanced rebuild but I guess trades and FA could turn that around. Cleveland has virtually no top 100 talent but I guess when you can find under the radar Ace pitchers who needs top 100 lists. Clevland could use hitters though and I would suggest they trade some of that pitching to get some as the cupboard looks a little bare there. Top 100 lists are not the be all end all for good to elite talent and the Shane Bieber and Randy Dobnaks of the world can attest to that but it sure is helpful to have guys in that range to predict future success. Looking at where teams are IMO Chicago looks like a team with all around young players that project as high performers. If the pitching side works out for them in time I think they will be an elite team. Their lineup will be brutal so if the pitching comes around look out. The Twins simply need elite good young pitching and they have the hitters in the wings to compete for a long time as well. The central is going to be very competitive very soon. I think the next two to three years a World series team will come from the central.
-
Has a Change in Pitch Usage Ascended Kenta Maeda to the Next Level?
Too small of a sample size for me but the trend is still worth pointing out. TIme will tell if you are a soothsayer or not.
-
MIN 7, PIT 3: José Berríos Overcomes Command, Drone
Happy to get the win today but things didn't go as well as I had hoped against a hittable pitcher. For as great as Berrios's line was (only 1 earned through 6 innings) He was getting close to 50 pitches after two innings. For a while there it looked like he might only go 4 innings 5 max and these were the pirates not the Yankee's. It feels like he has a lot of things to work out. In the end he made it 6 innings so I guess I can't complain too much but it was pretty brutal to watch IMO. It was nice they got 2.1 innings out of Thielbar so the pen could rest a day. He doesn't look like someone to rely on just yet but a guy who could eat innings when games are out of hand. He looked OK out there to me but not overly dominant. At least he doesn't walk guys like Poppen does, but that is the only reliever I would say Thielbar might be better than in our current pen. Where would this team be at the start of this season without Cruz? Probably in about the same place as the Indians and Chicago. He has been a true difference maker early and yet teams keep challenging him. I see a fair number of walks and hit by pitch in Cruz's future. 4 walks for Kepler bodes well. Pitchers will have to give stuff to hit or put him on 1st for free. Good to see that good eye at the plate and solid contact. He should be a tough out if he keeps this up. Also nice to see Rosario beat the shift taking the ball to left. Beat it a few more times and they might have to play him more straight up again. We don't seem to have the homer magic we had last year but with the improved pitching we are still a tough team to beat. Here's hoping for a few more HR's in the next few games. Go Twins!
-
GAME THREAD: 8/4/20 Minnesota Twins vs. Pittsburgh Pirates 1:10 CDT
Nice to see Eddie beat the shift. They will have to think about how they want to play him.
-
GAME THREAD: 8/4/20 Minnesota Twins vs. Pittsburgh Pirates 1:10 CDT
Ump is not giving that low strike like yesterday to either side.
-
GAME THREAD: 8/4/20 Minnesota Twins vs. Pittsburgh Pirates 1:10 CDT
Man 45 pitches through two innings I thought this was our ace. Looks more like a number 5 right now. Lucky to go 4 innings at this rate, 5 max. Hope the bullpen is ready.
-
GAME THREAD: 8/4/20 Minnesota Twins vs. Pittsburgh Pirates 1:10 CDT
According to the MLB pitch tracker it looks like he just struck that guy out but they were called balls instead. Not that the tracker is perfect either. Still tight zone hopefully for both sides thten.
-
Twins 3, Cleveland 1: Bullpen Dominates as Twins Take Series
I am just not used to us pitching this well and having virtually no weak links in the rotation or the pen. The way they have pitched this year gives me hope that this team can do great things. Very happy we took 3 out of 4 from Cleveland as they are a very god team and I don't see them losing a series or much at all with the pitching they are getting. Essentially shutting our lineup down which is one of the deepest in Baseball is no easy task so other teams will likely have a difficult time scoring runs against them as well. Great series and am happy we came out on top and didn't split it. Really excited about this team. Go Twins!
-
CLE 2, MIN 0: Shane Bieber is a Cheat Code
The Twins hitters just couldn't tell if\when the ball was going to break or not and he often didn't throw strikes when they were lucky enough to work the count 3-2. He was going to bury the ball and not throw strikes in that situation until they figured it out. They never did. He was definitely a mind reader last night sensing the Twins would be aggressive when they were and throwing down the middle when he felt they would take. Honestly I think they solve him the next time out. At least draw more walks and bring his pitch count up. I don't see him ever giving up a ton of runs but I think they can make him work even harder and get him out of the game earlier. He had a great night and is going to be good pitcher for a long time. Here's hoping we can find pitchers that are just as good and soon.
-
Early Report on Eddie Rosario's Plate Discipline
I can see he understands his weakness and is trying and that is awesome, but as you can see by his chase rate he just doesn't have a great sense of the zone. Guy has amazing hand eye coordination and can turn on pitches that no other hitter I have seen can. He can hit balls hard that are out the of strike zone, but mainly makes weak contact there. Personally I think pitchers drool over getting to face him because there is little reason to throw strikes or quality pitches just let Rosario get himself out. Hopefully he improves because if he does look out he could be one of the most dangerous hitters in baseball.
-
Opinion - Is the way to fix baseball implementing a 60 game season?
You could have two season like in the minors. The first half division winners would automatically have a spot in the playoffs. This accomplishes a couple of things. It means that the first 80 games have more meaning and it allows all teams to start fresh for the second half so you can keep all around fan interest higher. Nothing worse than having a young team flounder in the first half never quite able to make up the ground needed the rest of the way or devastating injuries early and the team can't make up those games the rest of the way. Splitting the season would give improving teams a chance to make the playoffs in the second half. IMO I think splitting the season could solve a lot of problems talked about in this article and mute the main comments against the shorter season.
-
GAME THREAD: 7/29/20 Minnesota Twins VS St. Louis Cardinals, 7:10 CDT
Yep really nice to see a solid at bat like that for Eddie. He got fooled on ball 4 but still he made the pitcher work so that helps.
-
Twins Select Alerick Soularie with the 59th Overall Pick
Hate to sound like a broken record but pitchers were coming off the board like crazy in the second round. Seemed like a good time to grab one there. Grabbing another position-less player in a system full of them seems well down right wasteful to me. The positives appear to be that he does have a good eye and hit tool so a decent chance to make it to MLB. Also seems to have some power as well. With not a ton of picks this year I thought that maybe they would take more chances on pitching in the draft but I guess it is the same old same old. Not a bad pick but not what I was hoping for either.
-
Top 20 Twins Prospects
Really like the write ups and the list I could quibble about the order but I think all these guys are in range of your projections. I too am not a Lewis fan mainly because of the bat but he looked very good yesterday with a Home Run and defensive gem that made me think why would anyone say he might not be able to play shortstop. It was an amazing play very few shortstops in MLB could make IMO. Anyway like you secretly I have Lewis at number three until the bat comes around. If that bat produces at AA then he truly does belong at number one because no one in the system has close to the athleticism he has. Also I give him props for bulking up. Dude looks huge this year, like he belongs in MLB. Just needs that hit tool to work and he has All Star written all over him.
-
Two Wild Cards: Luis Gil and Dakota Chalmers
At this point in time I like Chalmers better. He looks like he might be able to control his pitches and striking out the side the other day means he has swing and miss stuff as well as good velocity. I think if our pen was a little weaker Chalmers would be a candidate for a pen spot this year. Gill is younger and still has potential to start. He got his WHIP down to 1.19 last year in A ball not great but doable for a reliever. It's a tough choice between the two right now, but as I stated earlier right now today I like Chalmers better. If Gill manages better control and a more advanced approach he could be much better than Chalmers who I only see as a reliever. The Twins getting Cave who looks MLB ready for Gill also complicates this analysis for me as Cave has already been a timely asset as he helped last years team to 101 wins when most of the starting outfield was injured. Not having him might have impacted that effort.
-
Twins option 7 players to minor league camp
Thorpe was a surprise but there must be a reason. Gordon, Blankenhorn and Celestino all looked a bit over matched at the plate so probably not a bad idea to have them move over. Alcala looked a little shaky to me as well. Duran and Chalmers pitched well so no reason to be sent down other than they just are not going to start the year with the big club. Was nice to get to see some of these young guys get a chance and see how they perform.
-
Twins option 7 players to minor league camp
Agreed. Is Thorpe just not in game shape or do they feel Dobnak had that 5th spot pretty much locked up at this point? Also can someone explain to me why it makes sense to put Romero on the restricted list? I would think he would be back not long after the season starts or is that process going to take longer? Also even though he doesn't take a 40 man spot while on the list can the Twins really afford to use that spot on someone else when they would likely only have spot for short period of time and then need to be optioned? I guess I don't see the advantage unless he isn't coming back anytime soon.
-
The Twins 2018 Draft Class is Loaded with Talent
Thanks for this article I remember being very worried that we might not have a good draft after we sold our 2nd round pick and lost our third for signing Lance Lynn. We weren't picking high in the draft and it didn't appear we would have much money to move around in the draft. After the draft I did not feel like they had a "good" draft. I was just hoping Larnach would turn out OK so that the draft wouldn't be a complete loss. I guess I was wrong about a lot of these guys. As I've said many times I bought into the pundits view of Jeffers and didn't like the pick at the time. He made me eat crow from Elizabethton to Pensicola. Seeing where he is right now I think that was an outstanding pick. Sands number from college didn't give me much hope that he would be anything better than reliever and probably take a long time to get there. Again I couldn't have been more wrong as he has really been dominant to this point in his professional career. I didn't even know who Windor was and given he came from a small school didn't give him much of a chance to be successful. I liked his frame and could see potential there but he didn't throw throw real hard and he was in need of third pitch if I remember correctly. Not bad for 7th round pick but certainly no guarantee to work out either. I really didn't care for the Willie Joe Garry pick either. He didn't have a good hit tool and it I thought most of his other tools were average. He started the year out pretty hot and it looks like he has 5 tool potential although the bat could hold him back. Still a good grab at 9 where the Twins always seem to find a little something. I actually liked the Reggie Grace pick at 10 better. He has had control issue's but hoping he come around this year. Anything after 10 is crap shoot but I have to say I definitely didn't see Zach Neff moving as fast as he did. It is going to be a fun class to watch and hopefully the Twins can find a way to replicate that success as they again are without there 2nd and 3rd round picks this year.
- Moncada and White Sox Reportedly Agree to Extension
-
Keith Law's top 100 prospects
I think that sounds about right to me. I would obviously have us a tick or two higher but we don't have a ton of high end guys so we might be just out of the top 10. Still is a solid system and again I am biased but I think our system will outperform the analysts predictions. Just need some of those guys in the 12 to 25 to up their game and I think we are top ten again. I can see why he has us at 15 though.