Everything posted by Dman
-
No, Top FA Starters Are Not Risky
I like the analysis and it makes sense but not every team is going to be able to sign the three to four elite pitchers that come out every year so 27 teams are going to miss out that is the math of supply and demand. If it is worth it for the Twins why wouldn't it be worth it for the Yankee's, Dodgers etc? Teams that can up the anti until they can't. Maybe it is the owner but Falvey came from Cleveland and they never bought an ace in fact they seem to get rid of their guys once they get too expensive. I think it will be the same mentality for the Twins. They are going to do it from within and hope those one year deals work out more often than not. If they get to a Cleveland like pitching pipeline then they won't spend big on pitching at all. It will all come from the farm. I'm not saying your analysis is wrong but it seems like most teams in the Twins payroll range don't buy into your premise. They seem to feel or have analysis that arms are too volatile to bank on and that on average younger arms are better than older ones. Thus the home grown and one year prove it deals for Oakland, Tampa, KC, Cleveland, Miami, Pittsburg, Milwaukee etc.. None of those teams do what you are suggesting in fact they all avoid it. Most all of those teams are banking on building a staff of young arms and supplementing with a reasonably priced veteran on a shorter term deal. I like the go big or go home approach but for small market it has to hurt and mean losing other valuable players at some point. There is more to your analysis than meets the eye IMO. Else everyone would\could do it.
-
Twins Minor League Report (9/8): Wallner Grand Slams, Saints Walk-Off
Hopefully he is Albert Pujols light or something but more likely the scouting reports catch up to him. In the report I read one of the concerns was that aggressiveness at the plate was part of his success but the higher you go that can and usually does become a liability as pitchers exploit that. K rate is important because there is a certain point where it is so much of a liability that even when a player generates positive outcomes they cannot overcome the negatives of non contact outs. Walk rate is key because it forces pitchers to pitch and put balls over the plate. Given what you have there his BABIP looks similar to how Wallner started his season. So he is due for regression with nothing in the numbers to make it appear he can sustain this for long and could drop precipitously once pitchers exploit his weaknesses. Still it is always fun to watch guys do well and give us hope and I do have hope that he will be better than his current numbers indicate.
-
Twins Minor League Report (9/8): Wallner Grand Slams, Saints Walk-Off
Nice to see Sands have a really good game against good competition. I really like his stuff I just hope he stays healthy. The Wichita bats have gone cold recently. Without Boyd they seem lost and or they have faced better teams lately as well. Whatever the case I hope they find their Mojo again. Encarnacion-Strand is having quite the debut. I was a little nervous about that pick when the Twins made it as he looked like another slow footed power only guy but if he can hit like that all the way up then, Wow. Looks like a good pick right now but the knock on him was his stroke might not hold up against higher velocity pitching. I guess we will find out before too long because if he keeps hitting like this he is going to move up fast.
-
Game Score: Twins 3, Cleveland 0
Yeah I tend to agree with you. I had been thinking about this more as he has been pretty good recently but he has such a bad rap due to his historically bad start that anytime he struggles at all the fans are all over him. It just feels like it would be best to have a fresh start for both the team and especially the player. He needs a do over and I just don't think he will get that in Minnesota. I know his recent results don't agree with me but I find his pitch mix too predictable. If I am at the plate I wouldn't swing at anything and take my free pass. He is rarely in the zone now and that appears to be how he needs to pitch to survive. It is the cutter diving under the zone for a swinging strike or a ball way off the plate that is an easy take. Last night he did throw a couple of fool me pitches in there so maybe he is working on that but as I said not sure I love the mix in general. Given his recent results, the Twins familiarity with him and everything he has gone through only to get better I would not be surprised if the Twins did pick up the option. Not to lean on him as the closer necessarily but as a middle relief or setup man that they feel they can use multiple days in a row. Seems like a Twins thing to do but I guess we will find out what happens soon enough.
-
Game Score: Twins 3, Cleveland 0
I like what Gant has been doing the last couple of games but if he can't get those walks under control he is still destined for the pen. Was awesome to see him strike out the side but this is Cleveland not the best offensive club out there. I hope he can take the next steps and be a starting pitcher but he still has a ways to go IMO.
-
Did the Twins Fleece Tampa Twice?
The Odo trade needs some context. As per usual the ever payroll conscious Rays needed to move Odo and his market wasn't good. I think we all were surprised the Twins were getting two years of Odo for a single player in A ball. Still Palacios had potential and he is showing now what the Rays thought they were getting. A player with a good eye at the plate who also is hitting for power that can play short. It didn't work out for Tampa but it had decent potential IMO. Tampa achieved what they wanted though which was getting rid of salary so in my mind they weren't really trying to "win" that trade just achieve an objective. So it depends on how you look at these deals IMO. Way too early to assess the Cruz trade and again context is needed. Tampa wasn't worried about winning the Cruz trade long term as they needed a difference maker bat for this postseason and Cruz was the best available that wouldn't hurt them salary wise long term. Strotman was a player likely not good enough to make their 40 man next year and Ryan looks good but is a one trick pony unless his secondary's improve. It is quite the haul for half a year of Cruz but again Tampa needed a short term asset to help them in the playoffs and they got the guy they wanted. If he helps them win the world series then in my mind Tampa wins this trade or you could say both teams won depending on how Ryan and Strotman work out. If Cruz fails to be the difference maker they paid for then it seems hard to see how they could "win" that trade but sometimes you have to take calculated risks and I think theirs was a good one.
-
Randy Dobnak and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Season
His magic when he first came up was batter's hit most of his stuff on the ground and he didn't give up many HR's. Seems like teams might have caught onto his stuff, he is too predictable or he isn't throwing the same way. Not sure which one it is but teams are having a little too much success against him this year. He has the rest of this year and this offseason to figure things out. If he doesn't I think he gets passed by. We will see what happens but I am still on the Dobnak bandwagon. He kept the ball on the ground and in the park before I believe he can do it again once healthy.
-
Is it too early to call Cavaco a bust?
Yeah Carroll was touted as an almost sure thing with the bat which is why I thought the Twins would grab him for sure. I think there were questions about his power but that hasn't seemed to be a problem in the minors so far. They had the perfect player fall into their lap IMO but they chose to go the risky route. Will have to wait and see if it bites them or not.
-
Is it too early to call Cavaco a bust?
Cavaceo was doing well to start the season in fact he looked like he might be the best hitter on the team for a while. It seemed like he got hurt because he didn't play for a few weeks and he hasn't been quite the same since. Also it seemed like pitchers got better after the first month and lots of guy at FM started slumping. He has good speed and is a good athlete. The Twins loved him and bet on his bat coming around. I don't like it when they pick guys high with unknown hit tools. Way too much bust potential for me. Way too early to write him off though this is really his first full year in pro ball and guys much older than him have had issue's hitting in A ball as well. He is far from alone as most of that team has been poor hitters. My pick was Corbin Carrol I was hoping and hoping that he would fall to us and when he did I thought for sure they would take him. At that time we had a lot of outfield depth and had taken outfielders in multiple drafts so I have to assume they were looking for an up the middle infield player and he looked like the best bet to them. Sometimes I think the FO outsmarts themselves. Anyway don't give up on the kid after his first full year he has plenty of time to get significantly better and I think he will.
-
The Twins Shouldn't Spend (Much) On Starting Pitching This Offseason
Assuming Ober and Pineda are penciled in next year. I am still not sure how many young pitchers that we have that will make it through an entire season as so many were hurt this year but I think Winder, Ryan, Strotman, Balazovich can be options with maybe Sands and SWR with an outside chance as well. I can't see Duran making it and Canterino seems like a long shot with the tendinitis issue (Maybe it clears up maybe it doesn't). Beyond those arms you likely have Dobnak and Jax to work in as needed as well. That seems like a fair bit of depth and they all are young arms as well. The Twins could still add one more vet if desired but I think that's a good group to start with. I am probably in the minority but I still think Dobnak and Jax can make it as starters. Hoping they just find an out pitch of some kind. Randy still makes guys hit the ball into the ground if he can just get that K rate up I still think he can be a mid rotation arm. If he can't get the K rate up then he is who he is and Bullpen would be the ceiling and if the K rate isn't there we might have better guys in the pen anyway. I am still a believer that both those arms can make it if they can improve just a little bit. I have to believe someone or two of Winder, Ryan, Balazovich, Strotman, SWR etc. make it and then we can build from there.
-
The Twins Shouldn't Spend (Much) On Starting Pitching This Offseason
I hate to say it but in many ways I agree with this article. Until we develop at least three solid young arms we are destined to not be able to compete at the playoff level. It takes MLB experience to develop young pitching and if you are always filling it with one year arms I think you are on a treadmill trying to get somewhere. The Twins have a lot of young pitching ready to come up and they don't have a ton of 40 man space to waste so they need to know who can make it and who can't. Once you have that base of young pitching established then you can top it off with a proven vet or a one year contract on a guy trying to come back. We aren't going to compete in the market for an ace level pitcher so we have to develop our own. They have finally built up enough volume of good to great potential arms that they should find out what they can do. Maybe we get lucky and as those guys develop they hold their own and we have good season to boot. Maybe they all fail and we have to start over but best to find out what guys stuff translates to MLB and whose doesn't.
-
Oakland as a Trading Partner
It is is a possibility but I would guess the cost would be heavy as like Tampa they like overpays to rebuild.
-
Johnson: Sabato concentrating on contact
I get that it is a process I really do and his eye seems better than most but you have to make contact and he just hasn't been able to until recently. It just is disconcerting that a guy whose bat most scouts thought was MLB ready couldn't make contact when push came to shove. It feels like a fatal flaw. He has the right attitude though. You have to keep trying and better understand what pitchers are trying to do to you and find a swing path to match what they are throwing at you. He has a lot of work to do but the good eye should help him have a chance to succeed without that I would say he is lost.
-
Twins Minor League Starting Pitcher of the Month - August 2021
I had Gipson-Long as my Winder pick for this year as they were drafted in the same range, had solid builds and were strike throwers with Higher ERA's at lower level schools. While Gipson-Long K'd lot's of guys early he was very hittable and his WHIP wasn't that great to start the year. So I started to sour on him a little bit as Winder was pretty dominant start to finish his year in A ball. Still as the OP said he has been even better after moving up a level and seems to have really refined his pitch mix in a good way, I am starting to get excited about him again. That 2019 draft has some pretty interesting arms that were picked late in Gipson-Long, Gross, Mooney and Varland and at the top they took Canterino. So several guys that look to make a difference down the road. If the Twins can keep finding solid arms that late it would really help.
-
Finding the Next Bailey Ober
I really like Sands too I just worry about his durability. He does seem to get hurt each year he has been in the minors. He looks the most Oberesque to me as well as he likes the top of the zone and his stuff plays well at the top of the zone as well. Hopefully his arm can take the load otherwise I see him in the pen.
-
Twins Daily Minnesota Twins Starting Pitcher of the Month - August 2021
I get that with a pool of just 5 starters it hardly makes sense to split this in two groups of reliever or starter as your top 5 starters would likely have to include poor performer's but starter versus reliever seems like compering apples and oranges to me. So IMO this really should be parsed out as separate for reliever and Starter. The more innings pitched the better the sample size even if a month is a SSS on its own. Relievers with so few innings pitched and such a SSSS tells us very little other than they held their own for a few innings. Hands down just value wise this belongs to Ober as he pitched more innings almost as effectively as a reliever.
-
Trade Retrospective: Which Team Won the Kenta Maeda Trade?
I tend to agree with Mike that the Twins got what they needed when they needed it with Maeda in 2020. I don't think they win the division without him so that was a big get. As always trades like this take so much time to evaluate for overall value and sometimes a team is willing to lose a trade to try and win a championship so trades can be looked at from different perspectives as to who won and who lost. That being said short term the Twins already got what they needed out of the Maeda trade. He was instrumental in helping them win the division in 2020 and with the performance based salary can't hurt them into the future financially even if he never returns. When he does return he just adds more value. Camargo has been OK at High A but his K rate is a killer. He is also only 22 so has time to straighten that approach out but the bat needs some work and he looks like a backup catcher at this point if he makes it so not much there if you ask me. For the Dodgers Graterol has been nothing special to this point certainly not the dominant reliever we thought he would be. Luke Raley who I thought might be better than Rooker, certainly better in the field, currently has a 483 OPS at the MLB level granted a very SSS but still so far nothing that great. The Dodgers look like they might have gotten a good pitcher with the 2nd round supplemental pick though as Clayton Beeter has a really nice K rate and has pitched himself up to AA already. So that could still turn the tide of this trade. Based on pure value I have the Twins winning this trade at least short term. Graterol still could be a dominant reliever and Beeter could end up being better than Maeda with more years of control so there is still future value out there to be counted. With Maeda hurt and in need of TJ it feels like the Dodgers have a good chance to win this trade on pure player value long term IMO. The Twins needed another starter badly in 2020 and found a way to get one so even if they do ultimately lose the total player value of this trade they got the immediate return they needed to make a difference in 2020 with a team whose window was wide open at the time. I think that is a trade you have to make every time as a team in that position. So I can't fault them even if they might lose out on future value.
-
Twins Minor League Hitter of the Month- August 2021
Personally I thought Cabrera had the better line but he might not have had as many at bats. Twins scouts did a good job picking up Cabrera. When I watched him earlier this year I was wishing they had someone better for that position and why grab a washed up 23 year old? I guess this is why. If there is one thing the Twins system seems to be good at it is developing power. HIs K rate is high for the level but walk rate and BABIP are solid so this could be who he is at the plate. A little less swing and miss and he looks MLB bound to me. I still like Boyd better but Cabrera is right there as well in the good finds department. I love the power Cabbage has but the K's and BABIP don't look sustainable so he has work to do. HIs 391 BABIP has fueled his top hitter award but he looks like a big regression candidate to me. Hoping he can bring those K's down. Almost forgot. Nice to see Sabato's name in the honorable mentions. I have noted my disappointment many times so want to point out I can acknowledge when he does well. It just has taken some time to have something good to say.
-
Minor League Report (8/31): Wichita Whacks, Louie Lights it Up
Yeah if the Twins don't add Palacios to the 40 man if I were him I would look at one of the rebuilding teams that need shortstop help. Odds are he might get a shot at MLB in 2022 with one of those clubs. He doesn't look like he will be an All Star at Short but he looks like he could be solid there and certainly a great utility player to have around especially since he has power.
-
Minor League Report (8/31): Wichita Whacks, Louie Lights it Up
Might be coincidence but he started playing less when they acquired Martin IIRC. That certainly doesn't mean he might not be injured but it seemed like around that time he was only playing part time. With his slump and OPS at 823 not sure he makes the 40 man roster this coming year. He does look like he is going to have 20 HR's so they might need to add him if they want to keep him. My guess is the Tigers take him in Rule V just to mess with the Twins FO and get the fans to revolt.
-
Minor League Report (8/31): Wichita Whacks, Louie Lights it Up
Yeah I don't understand these types of trades for most teams not just the Twins. Often the other team just takes cash and calls it good. In fact I would have thought the Twins would have taken cash considering the year they are having attendance wise. Spit balling but maybe the Dodgers felt they got the short end of the stick on the Graterol trade and the Twins are trying to stay in good with Friedman? Or maybe they just think that they won't be adding Vasquez to the 40 man and will likely lose him in the offseason to Rule V or free agency so why not get something instead of nothing. Berman did have a pretty good 2019 but I think I like all the catchers we currently have better but then I don't know a lot about Berman. Most of these trades never amount to much of anything but I do think Vasquez has potential. When he is on he is unhittable but he has lacked consistency. Friedman has a good eye for these types of players I wouldn't be surprised to see him have success with the Dodgers.
-
Twins to Promote Olympic Medalist Joe Ryan, Slated to Start Wednesday
Yeah you did not specifically state service time was an issue in your article but you did ask the question\wondering why the Twins weren't making a move after Ryans two excellent starts in AAA which was an impetus for looking for reasons why. While I agree service time as an answer was likely premature (especially because roster expansion hadn't happened yet) it would be a reason because we all know it happens. With no CBA next year it could be even more of a reason because maybe teams only get 4 years of control and starting him early counts as a full year. No one knows how it will work out so a team might want to be overly conservative. I just think it was a fair question and wanted to state it as such.
-
Twins to Promote Olympic Medalist Joe Ryan, Slated to Start Wednesday
Right and Mike said gee whiz why would people think this might be a service time issue and I said golly gee whiz we all were wondering why they weren't calling him up. So I am simply stating I can see why people would think that since you literally put the same thing out like a day or two ago. That's it. Nothing that controversial I don't think.
-
Twins to Promote Olympic Medalist Joe Ryan, Slated to Start Wednesday
I don't know You tell me isn't this the statement that got some of us wondering if service time might be an issue? Joe Ryan was in Tokyo pitching for Team USA until... he wasn't. And while I supported the logical step of letting him have a few starts in the Twins organization to re-acclimate himself to the cycles of American baseball and familiarize himself with his new organization, this season isn't going to last forever. Every start the Twins give to the likes of Andrew Albers into September is one fewer start they can use to evaluate the likes of Joe Ryan. The Twins were put into a really bad situation with Strotman struggling, Ryan in Tokyo, and seemingly half their minor leagues injured. I'm willing to be patient when things spiral out of the team's control and they're forced to run Charlie Barnes out there every fifth day. Except my patience runs out when other, vastly superior options become available. And as of about 8pm yesterday, a *very* attractive option became available and the Uber ride to Target Field won't even cost the team $30. Two games and this is what he has done. Never mind that he pitched to a 1.50 ERA in the Olympics, including a 4.1 IP with 1 ER in the silver medal game against Team Japan.
- Twins to Promote Olympic Medalist Joe Ryan, Slated to Start Wednesday