Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dman

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dman

  1. I get what everyone is saying and the Twins likely will send Winder down but you have to look at the risk of piggy backing versus the risk of a traditional pen IMO. If one part of your piggy back can't make their 3 to 4 innings that is going to decimate a pen only 6 arms deep. If you piggy back Archer\Winder and Gray\Paddack and they pitch into the 8th inning together a pen 6 arms deep is more than enough. Here is the thing though, instead of Winder would you prefer Stashak, Coulombe or Jax? Yeah now you have 7 relievers but Stashak and Coulombe would be lucky to go 1 inning let alone two and Jax can go multiple innings but has he been better than Winder to this point. It feels like this pen stalls out at Duran, Pagan, Smith, Thielbar and maybe Duffy. 3 pretty strong arms and the next three are anybody's guess. Is that really better than keeping Winder around? Also how many innings are we thinking Winder is going to pitch this year anyway 100 or so? Having him piggy back might be a way to use him all year instead of shutting him down later in the year. Until Winder struggles more and proves he doesn't belong I think there is less risk in keeping him up than sending him down at least IMO.
  2. I tend to agree with you. Not sure why they wouldn't piggy back more and if they did what you suggest with Winder then they could reset the pen every 5th day to some degree (that is if Winder continues to pitch well). And this pen isn't exactly the teams strong suite to begin with. Given how well Winder has been doing I kind of hate to see them send him down. He is 25 already so no service time concerns and they should be using him in his prime years. He has been holding his own to this point. He needs the MLB experience. Keep him up at least until he implodes or has a couple of bad games.
  3. With all the dings and bruises catchers have it is no wonder they can easily slump at the plate. While I miss Garvers bat (even though he off to a slow start for Texas) he had his fair share of injuries in Minnesota as well. I think you pretty much have to plan on needing three catchers to get through a season minimum. I think most of the board was surprised the Twins went with just 2 to start the season but given their plan to limit starting pitcher innings they probably had no choice. I don't see Godoy as much different than Rortvedt and Cisco might be even better with the bat than Ben as well hard to say at this point. Would I rather have Garver as a replacement sure but I think the Twins have OK options for the moment. Lot's of teams have black hole bats for catchers. While not ideal it can be a postion where you can get away with less than ideal offensive production. I assume the reason they brought Godoy up instead of Cisco is that Godoy passed through waivers once already and they might not want to risk losing Cisco if they needed more room for another player. Cisco looks like he has the better record with the bat. I hope Jeffers stays healthy he is the best catcher we have on the team right now.
  4. Actually to this point in the season Sanchez's OPS is higher than Garvers and Urshela's is higher than Donaldson's. So to your point those guys would only be hurting us more than their replacements are at least to this point in the season. Garver always was a slow starter IMO. He will mash eventually. Donaldson no idea how he will do but have to believe he will warm up with the weather as well. At least for the first two weeks the Twins are winning those trades.
  5. First let me say I am sad to see Thorpe go. He brought a lot of hope with him at the lower levels that we might have a strong lefty starter. He piled up the K's and kept the velocity up through 2019 and then things started to fall a part. Whether it was injury or that he just peaked is hard to say. His velocity was down from when he was younger and he started giving up too much hard contact. The Twins gave him a long time to try and get things right even keeping him on the 40 man all winter but he never quite found the stuff he once had. I wish him well and hope things still work out well for him. Smeltzer appears to back to his old self. At some point the Twins will need to put him back on the 40 man. He was great this spring and has been very good at AAA as well. At the very least they could use him as a long man lefty reliever. The way the season started I thought the AA lineup was going to be the weak link. With the weather warming so have the bats warmed up and Martin is now closing in on an 800 OPS after a brutal start to the season. Steer is still the best bat at least for the moment. Everyone up and down the lineup is hitting except Wallner who has a .073 batting average and 47% K rate. He can't hit a slow pitch softball right now and has been a rally killer automatic out so far this season. Vallimont still looks Shaky out there to me. 3 hits and 3 walks in 4 innings is not ideal. Hoping he can straighten things out as the weather warms up. The pitching is good and the hitting is good at High A so it is no wonder that they are 10-2 at this point. It is a tough lineup with Prato and CES at the top. Sawyer Gipson-Long and Povich are two best pitchers and Headrick has been right there with them to this point. Still Mooney, Legumina and Laweryson are pretty solid as well. As long as this team stays together they should be tough to beat. The muscles need to find their bats if they want to win more games. With Rodriguez in an 0 for 9 slump the other bats need to heat up. The only consistent bat in that lineup seems to be Fedko. Varland at AA and Headrick and High A should be more must watch Twins affiliate baseball.
  6. Jeremy was pretty close to nailing this one. Actually he didn't think quite big enough. Susana was rated slightly lower than Medina in the Padres system. Susana is big 6'6" compared to the 6'1" Medina but right now given what we know it looks like Medina has the better secondary's. It will be interesting to see how Medina does as I think he is rule V eligible in 2023 and it looks like he will be in short season ball this year as he hasn't pitched yet. Kind of nice to replace the loss of Petty with another fairly high octane arm that is only 19 years old. Hard to say what the outcomes will be, but on the surface it looks like the Twins did well in this deal. 3 years of Paddack, 2 years of Pagan, if he makes it 6 years of Medina for one year of Rogers, and 5 years of Rooker if he makes it, who might have been lost for nothing. Oh and the Twins had to pay 7M of Rogers salary. I hope this is an arm that works out. I will be watching to see how he does this year. If he gets the walks under control and maintains that K rate I have to believe he will make it as at least a reliever.
  7. He might be Petty like in the end hard to say with both of them so young. I think I like Petty's chances better though. However, I also don't know much about Medina either. Good Velo with a good slider should keep him moving through the system with decent results. Hoping that changeup keeps him a starter but if he ticks up in the pen he could be a hard throwing pen arm as well. Pretty good get (nice potential) for a PTBNL.
  8. I am getting a little scared we might just miss out on the elite hitters in this draft. Hopefully more guys bubble up especially pitchers so we can snag a good hitter.
  9. That seems high considering the Padres only got one year of Rogers. The only way I can see that it justifies a return this high to me is if I guess they believe Rooker is going to turn out in time Or is this the extra money they kicked in? Not sure but a pretty good get considering what else the Twins got in trade. Kid has a live arm but hasn't pitched this year yet. Lot's of walks so plenty of control issue but he is only 19. It is just that looking at Cruz and the good velocity and poor control this looks like a boom or bust deal IMO. Always nice to have young arms with great potential in the system. Not quite a Petty replacement but seems better than normal for a PTBNL.
  10. Camargo's K rate is problematic but anything he hits seems to go for extra bases. I am starting to wonder if approaches like that lead to generally higher BABIP's with the extra K's offsetting that approach. At any rate I think he needs to take more walks to be successful. Being overly aggressive only takes you so far. I like call out on the Cedar Rapids staff and honestly Mooney and Legumina could be added to that list. SGL has been good at getting K's but always had trouble giving up runs as well. If that issue is better resolved he looks like a good prospect to me. I expect him to be in the top 30 this year. Headrick is probably the biggest surprise for me on your list. He was very hittable last year and gave up plenty of walks as well. If he keeps this K rate up and WHIP down he looks like a good lefty reliever to me. Possibly he could start but I am not sure the velocity is there. At any rate he moves from bust to possibility now in my book. Povich is too good to be at High A, but it is what it is. I always wondered how Stankiewicz would do as an after thought in the 2020 draft. He bet on himself coming out that year and it looks like that is going to pay off. I don't know a ton about him and I hope they allow him to be a fast mover. Especially if he continues to dominate like he has. He could be sneaky good but will just have to wait and see. Prato is a nice underdog pick. I think if he can hit he makes it. If not with the Twins then somewhere else as a utility option. He has a good eye, good speed and a solid glove. Just needs to prove he can continue hit on his way up because he lacks "special" skills and is more average except for Onbase skills which could be above average if he keep the batting average up.
  11. Nice to continue to see Royce Lewis getting hits and doing his thing. Miranda needed a multi-hit game and got one as well. Both Cano and Minaya had good relief outings and look like potential big league pen options if needed. SWR has defeinately righted the ship to start the year. No earned runs over 16 innings and very little hard contact made from what I have seen. He has been very efficient getting guys out only giving up 5 hits and 4 walks for a .54 WHIP. The K rate is little low for him compared to last year but still close to a K an inning. He looks really. really good right now. If he can continue to keep the walks down he looks ready for the next step. His outing was even more impressive than normal because the team he faced had 6 guys batting over .300 and pretty much every guy in their lineup had an OPS over .750. That is a tough lineup to hold to 2 hits and no walks. Was pretty much the same old Cruz. When he starts walking guys bad things happen. The guy does throw very hard though so I guess we hope for better days ahead. Happy to see the bats have heated up at AA. Everyone except Wallner with at least one hit last night. Emmanual Rodriguez is on a KKKKKK Kold streak after being rested last Sunday. I don't think he has a hit yet this week and is back to striking out a lot. Fedko remain hot with a 432 batting average and two more hits last night. he looks like he wants to get promoted. Hajjar with an impressive outing this time out. Gave up no hits this time out and 10 K's. He has the K touch.
  12. Falvey turned us into the Indians alright. We can pitch now but no hitters to be found and the 30 Million dollar man has been less than clutch to this point. These guys need to find themselves and fast if they want to save the season.
  13. If we can't even beat the Royals I don't really know who we plan to beat. Maybe once they get Buck back they do something but this lineup is thin on hitters right now. Can't win any games if you score no runs. Gotta say the hitters look horrible, just horrible to start the season. Hopefully they take extra batting practice because they need it.
  14. Kind of shocked Cotton made it through waivers. I really thought Baltimore or maybe even Texas would pick him up again. I guess he isn't as well thought of as I thought he might be. Honestly I think this is good news for the Twins. Get Cotton back to throwing strikes and trusting his stuff and they can think about re-adding him again if needed.
  15. Yeah I would give you ten likes for this if I could. I think you hit the nail on the head. He is not the strongest in game manager IMO. He does excel on the relationship end though. Also he can only play the hand he is dealt. The FO did him no favors when it came to the pen.
  16. Pagan was more of a throw in type veteran replacement for Rogers than a real solution IMO. We all knew he was headed in the wrong direction sans the trade and yet given the state of our pen he looks like one of the few arms trusted in high leverage situations. So I am hoping the Twins can find something to make sure he can be a solution and not another problem.
  17. I am trying to avoid thinking another veteran reliever could sink this team early. The numbers on Duffy look even worse than I initially thought. Still he got better last year as the season wore on. Certainly not a guy you want working high leverage situations unless things change for the better. We are only ten games in though and it seems way too early to give up on him as well. I hope he can figure things out but if he is this hittable he isn't just done with the Twins he is done completely.
  18. I wouldn't say that was a good matchup. Thielbar has had a lot of trouble getting righties out IIRC. If I had to guess I would say he had too much confidence in Thielbar in that situation. When Caleb is on he can be tough on both sides but I do find that an odd situation to put him in early in the season. Would love to know the thought process on that one. Going with the gut instead of the numbers? Or the numbers told him something about those matchups? I will agree with you that on the surface that one doesn't look good.
  19. I think I am with Ashbury on this for the most part. To start the season Rocco hasn't had a ton of consistency from his pen arms. In many ways Baseball is a confidence game. When players are doing their jobs and playing well they seem to have more belief that their outcomes will be positive. When in a slump confidence in what they are doing wains and they seem more prone to stay in a slump until extra coaching and or practice get them back on track. That being said Managers\coaches have to have confidence in their players and give confidence to their players. I think Rocco does a really good job in that regard. We have heard Cruz talk about the positive atmosphere in the club house and Buxton wanting to stay a Twin (look at all the adversity he faced and always had Rocco's support). Correa and Buxton were just talking about the "positive" vibes in the clubhouse. So you know that is important to players. Knowing your manager has your back allows you to stay focused and on track IMO. If I were the manager and I have a bunch of unknowns in the pen am I going to lean on less experienced guys or more experienced guys? For me I am going to put my trust in the guys that have been there and done it before. Guys like Duffey and Theilbar have good track records. Does that mean they are going to be successful every time they go out there no it doesn't. I feel the angst everyone else does about Duffey and Thielbar being Colome killers. They collectively sunk several promising games this season. Possibly three games lost by their collective failures. Still it is too early to throw them in the trash heap. Rocco still has to have confidence they can do the job and needs to give them the confidence they need to be successful again. Right now it is a bit of a waiting game IMO. Could both players be washed up and not going to get back on track or better until it is too late. That is one possibility. Odds are though it is early and they just need to settle into what works and what doesn't right now. The manager has to believe every player is going to pull their weight and be able to do their job. While he can create matchups to help them be more successful in the end the players have to perform and the manager has to keep his players in a good state of mind to create as much consistency as possible. I think Rocco does a decent job of that.
  20. Sands with one of those games that make me worried about him staying a starter. I wonder if he is going to show up on the injured list as usually when he has one of these games something isn't quite right. St. Paul was brutal in pretty much every way possible last night. Pretty much total system failure. Nice to see Canterino get some of his groove back but his control problems continue. He has been less than efficient on the mound. Hoping this is where he gets things going again. The bats were better for Wichita but still several hitters struggling there namely Wallner. Martin knows how to steal bases and seems to be back to his OnBase ways with little to no power. Looking fairly Arraez like with speed right now. Povich wasn't as efficient as he has been but still K'ing nearly two guys per inning. He has been pretty dominant for a level that should be challenging him. If he can stay healthy looks like he will move up to AA mid season. CES with 2 more hits and 2 more Strike outs. That K rate is starting to climb and I always say his .500 BABIP has to come down but it didn't last year. Will just have to wait and see what that looks like through a full season but right now he looks like the best hitter on the Cedar Rapids squad. Camargo has had a hot bat to start the season as well. He generally is a K machine with good power will have to see if he can keep things going and find better plate discipline. Raya looked shaky his first time out to me and then he goes out and nearly throws 6 perfect innings with 10 K's. He had a lot of hype coming into the season and I wasn't so sure he would stand up to it, but he has me believing now. 1 hit and no walks through 6 is really hard to do unless you are throwing really, really well. A dominant performance like that puts him on the must watch list. Fedko came through the big hit and 2 RBI's but it was a tough night for the bats on both sides. The walks were the difference in the game IMO. Lot's of really good starting pitching with the exception of Sands. Keep that pipeline coming. We are going to need the arms.
  21. I agree with you. I don't know what it is but this team feels like it will be competitive this year. Maybe my rose colored glasses are bit too tinted but if the pen can pull things together and the starters stay this hot I am pretty sure the bats will come around they always seem to every year. Even if the starting pitching falls off a bit I feel good about this team this year. The 6,7,8,9 spots in the lineup are in flux right now but once Correa gets going and Buxton is back and the warmer weather warms Sano's bat things will likely change for the better. I like this team and the young players that are close to ready that can make a difference later in the year. If nothing else we should have good depth.
  22. I am going to highlight a few guys myself. Seth already stole my under the radar Stankiewicz pick, but Brent Headrick has been awefully dominant to start the year. I know it is only 9 innings but he has 16 K's 3 hits and 0 walks for a .33 WHIP. That is crazy, crazy good. This from a guy who last year gave up more hits than innings pitched and has a fairly high walk rate. After last year I was kind of wondering if he had peaked at the college level. I know he cannot maintain that pace but if he can miss more bats and keep plugging the zone with strikes he looks like a lefty reliever at worst and number 4 or 5 at best. For hitter I am going to go with Charles Mack. He started hitting the ball better at the end of last year but he looks even better to start the year this year. He always was supposed to have good power and he does. He started as a third baseman but moved to catcher and his brother was taken in the first round last year so he has ability to be a good one I think. If his hit tool is for real, and there is a ways to go yet, he could be a solution at catcher for the Twins. He has a decent eye at the plate with 52 walks versus 72 K's last year. He just needed to make more contact. All these sample sizes are too small to have any real value but I think he could be a breakout candidate this year. Catcher is a tough position with injuries easily affecting at bats but I will be watching him closely this year. Also going to highlight Prato. So far this year he is finally the player I thought we were getting when he was drafted. A pest at the plate and on the bases. A solid defender with decent range. A good eye at the plate and someone who can put the ball in play. Might not have great power but can move the ball around. If he keeps playing this well his future looks bright IMO. Lot's of under the radar guys are off to good starts this year. Hopefully they maintain that level throughout the year with the ups and downs that come with a long season.
  23. It was big to get the split with Boston. Only series loss was to the Dodgers and just two games. We need to be the better team in the division if we are going to go anywhere so those games will have added importance. I have to say Bundy has been much better than I thought he would be to this point. He has been an efficient strike throwing machine and very SSS but keeping the ball in the park to this point. I may be eating a fair bit of crow given my dismissal of his potential contributions to this team. Celestino had a huge at bat for essentially a Rookie. Getting behind in the count and battling back to draw that walk was huge. Polanco got the big hit but not making an out there saved the rally. Given his lack of experience I was happy he found his way on base. OK I am going to monologue a bit here. When the Twins sent Jax out for 8th inning after the big rally I thought that was a huge mistake. I thought for sure he would get lit up and either lose the lead or at the very least lose the cushion we had with the runs scored. I mean this is a guy who got pounded in his last spring training game and wasn't even added to the 28 man roster to start the season and this is the guy they run out there to protect the lead in an almost must win situation? In fact you run your weakest essentially last man out there not just for the 8th but the 9th as well? I get that we had a 6 run lead but with the lineup the Sox have no lead is safe with 6 outs left. Let alone against a pitcher who has been prone to give up big innings. Why allow for such great potential to give the lead back? Maybe he was on a fairly short leash but at the time I thought it was an unnecessary risk. In hindsight it worked out great for Jax's confidence and the team win. I just didn't have a good feeling about it though. This was an important win. If the starting pitching holds up you have to like this teams chances. Lineup still could use some help but they usually turn things around once the weather warms up. Very happy they got the win.
  24. Your list of DFA candidates is spot on. It just seems a little early in the year to give up on Strotman and Vallimont IMO. Honestly i think they both would get snagged by another team and although I am low on both of them mainly because of their WHIP's. They both have the ability to K guys as well. Like the OP said they are getting older and still haven't made it out of the minors but I think you would want to give both one more try before losing them for good. Strotman's delivery looks really good to me but he needs to get better results with his stuff. I am kind of ready to give up on Vallimont. The lack of feel for finding the zone is almost comical as he has a 4.33 WHIP in his SSS this year and honestly struggled with walks last year as well. It is the elite K rate though that keeps you hanging on. Both those guys need to show something this year or they are gone IMO. Stashak hasn't been good in a while and doesn't have "great" stuff so he might make it through. Romero is a bit of a wild card guy for me. He has strike out stuff and can throw strikes but he seems hittable as well. Just don't know enough about the guy but my feeling is another team might be willing to give him a try. They are both borderline 28/40 man adds though so I think they would be the first ones to go. They could be replaced by another waiver claim or the farm IMO.
  25. Interesting to me that both Rodriguez and CES were rested going into the day off. I guess they want to keep those two in tip top shape? Fort Meyers could have used Rodriguez's bat as they looked a little anemic without him in the lineup. Adams had a nice night on the hill. 7 K's in 5 innings keeping that ERA at a cool .90 with an even better WHIP to match at .60. I wasn't a fan of the pick when the Twins made it. Kind of thought he might be the weak link in their draft but he is off to a great start. When Prato is healthy he is a pest in the box and on the bases. His over 1.000 OPS is nice and it almost seems like it should be higher as it feels like he is on base all time. Mack is finally finding more contact and his 1,469 OPS puts him right there with Emmanual Rodriguez and CES. There are some Pretty impressive hitters at High A right now. Lewis with another multi-hit game keeping that OPS above 1.000 along with Contreras, Cave and surprisingly Baneulos. Miranda continues his slow start. Might have to wait for the weather to warm up before he gets going.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.