Everything posted by shimrod
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
I believe the contention that the Twins offer for JD was not competitive. What to do next? We still need to improve the starting pitching. If we wind up with more than we need they're trade bait, that simple. Twins should target a salary dump pitcher that comes with minimal cost in prospects. Demonstrate the talk about spending to improve wasn't BS. Will they do this? Hell no, I think they were lying. I am coming to think the FO expected they'd never have to make good on that promise. By the time the "window opened" the base salary would be higher through arbitration and perhaps an extension or two. FO would point at that and say the impact spending window had passed. Unfortunately the team got ahead of the expected schedule. 101 wins later the fan base is expecting action to back up the talk. So spend the money on pitching. It's not too late to trade and there are teams looking to dump expensive pitchers. The pitchers may not play to the contract but even if they don't they're better than what we've already got. This team can and should be improved, it will only cost money, and at the end of the season the owners will still have made millions in profit. It may be a few millions less than desired but hey, if the team excels and goes deep in the playoffs it may even be a profit booster. Do it.
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
"but I am fine with not breaking the bank to sign a 34 y.o. 3rd baseman for 25 mil a year for 4 years." So am I. But only if that money is spent to improve the team somewhere else. If the alternative is ownership pocketing that money, screw it. Sign the man up. The FO needs to understand (and probably does), the more you upgrade the talent the higher the cost of improvement. Improving the bottom-feeding team we fielded in the 90's was easy. As the talent level rises the price of improvement grows, and it's not a linear function. The FO had multiple options to improve this team at the beginning of free agency. One by one we've seen those options go to other clubs while we sign cheap, aging and injured lottery tickets. Now we're in a position where improvement will cost us prospects instead of dollars, which is antithetical to the stated desire to obtain sustainable success through internal development. The FO said when the window opened they'd spend on impact talent. The failure to do so either marks a failure of the FO to perform or admission the FO was lying when they said they'd spend. Based upon the history of this team and the known proclivities of ownership I expect the latter explanation is correct.
-
Front Page: Rich Hill: A 40-Year Old Mr. October?
Amazing to me the club won't sign top tier players to multi-year contracts because they're in their low to mid thirties. Might decline by the last year of the contract, you know. Meanwhile, we're happy to give multi-million dollar contracts to late thirties and forty year old vets (Cruz, Hill). Neither of whom are top tier talents. The excuses are just that, excuses. This club is cheap.
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
"It is frustrating to me when so many people seem to think that the only thing that matters all winter is how many dollars they are spending." That's not what we're saying. The point is, money is the one thing this team has in abundance that can be used to add talent without a negative impact to the rest of the team. Why trade prospects when you can spend money while keeping and developing said prospects? It's not a choice between spending in free agency OR internal development. The team can and should do both. As someone pointed out earlier, Cole didn't cost more than this team is spending on has-been's and injured veterans. Adding one or two top-tier FAs while aggressively promoting internal prospects seems preferable to buying a truck load of damaged goods hoping for a couple diamonds in the rough.
-
Front Page: With Twins Likely Out on Donaldson, So What's the Plan Now?
If I recall correctly the Twins were headed for contraction until a judge made opening the books to public scrutiny a condition for breaking their Metrodome lease. That brought the contraction move to a screeching halt. I expect a look at the books would have revealed that ownership was raking in a fat profit and the payroll limitations were completely self-inflicted. That was before the taxpayers built Target field. There is no excuse, none, for not spending to improve this team. The "impact" FAs are gone. It's time to trade for a salary dump starting pitcher. I'm all on board with hoarding prospects and internal development. If we take on enough salary we may even get prospects back. The Twins owe the fanbase an "impact" move and it doesn't have to cost anything in prospects or prohibit future growth. I don't begrudge ownership a return on their investment. I expect ownership receives a solid return on investment even if payroll spending goes substantially higher than current levels. And considering the taxpayer money provided to this franchise a substantial profit should be enough.
-
Front Page: Twins Front Office Testing Fate in Waiting
Romo was on the team at the end of the year. Just as with signing Pineda and Odo, that's simply staying even. Clippard remains our only improvement.
-
Front Page: Twins Front Office Testing Fate in Waiting
"and have added to the point they are better now than when the season ended." A few days ago you asked why there was so much pessimism about the Twins off-season. This may be where the disparity lies. I for one do not agree the Twins have improved the team (yet) this off-season. We replaced a decent catcher with a backup catcher. Added an aged, injured, pitcher who may or may not produce and is guaranteed to miss the first couple months. Swapped back-end starters (Gibson for Bailey). Added a reliever (reminiscent of last years Blake Parker signing). Where have we improved? The only thing we have going for us is the vaunted "payroll flexibility". Absent at least one more significant move we're no better off than last year and arguably worse.
-
Donaldson contract discussion - 4/100? 4/110?
I'd rather see us obtain starting pitching from a club shedding payroll. (absorb the expense rather than giving up prospects). If we're not going that route, by all means give it to Donaldson. If the team had a policy of making unspent funds available for use in future years I'd be okay with accumulating the financial assets to make a splash in 2021. As long as the owners continue pocketing any unspent money I'd rather see us spending to the max allocated. Pitching's the need but another bat won't hurt either, much less improved D. Signing Donaldson would be the first move that actually looks like an improvement rather than just treading water. I think this team needs to send a signal, both to the league and to the players, that we will use all available resources to win. Right now we don't have that. I think it impacts our ability to obtain extensions and hurts us in the FA market. It will probably take an overpay or two to send that message.
-
Front Page: A Decade of Greener Grass Ahead for Twins
Rose colored glasses indeed.
-
Front Page: Hayes: Twins To Sign Rich Hill & Homer Bailey
"All the talk of 'aggressive' pursuit of 'impact pitching' was, to this point, a blatant lie." Now you're catching on. To quote "Animal House" (minus the expletive), "you (screwed) up... you trusted us" Not the first time either. Remember how increased Target Field revenue would go to payroll? That was a good one.
-
Front Page: Starting Pitching Plan B: Snatching Lottery Tickets in Bulk
They won't pay the rate for proven talent and they don't seem comfortable trading prospects. As a plan C this doesn't look bad. Sign all the damaged goods and hope that 1 or 2 pan out. We may still have a shot at contending for the central division title. This plan also maintains the organization's premier goal, "financial flexibility". We've learned this vaunted flexibility is far more likely to be diverted to the owner's bank accounts than used to add talent and wins, but that's the way ownership rolls. I expect they're still trying to recoup the small portion of the stadium that wasn't bankrolled by the taxpayers.
-
Front Page: Here Is What War Projections Say About the Twins and White Sox
We entered the off-season anticipating the FO making moves to support a deep playoff run. Now we're supposed to be happy the Twins are still in contention for the division? Congratulations. I believe you've just set a new land-speed record for goalposts.
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
"What disappoints me is the idea that we were told the Twins will aggressively pursue impact pitching, and be aggressive with the payroll, when in reality it seemingly was blown smoke" I wouldn't call it blowing smoke. Speaking for myself, I'm aggressively pursuing the acquisition of a 2019 Range Rover as soon as I find someone who will sell it to me for less than 20K. That's not blowing smoke. Seriously, 2019 Range Rover for 20K I'll pay you straight cash. I'm in this to win.
-
Front Page: Ryu To Sign with Toronto. Now What?
"The consternation over the lack of free agent signings seems to be bigger than when we got swept in the first round." Maybe because it looks like we plan to run out the same team that got swept, minus several occasional contributors and a whole lot of salary. I'm beginning to think the front office signed on expecting to execute the complete tear down/rebuild only to be thwarted by on-field success. Every free agent they've signed has been added with the intention they'd build value and trade for prospects. That's not a bad strategy but it's hard to execute when the team insists on winning enough to keep the post-season in play. Perhaps this will be the year the FO gets to finally gut the team of veterans and acquire the minor league talent that will eventually lead the organization back to the promised land.
-
Front Page: Passan: Twins to Sign Catcher Alex Avila
"The answer is money, right?" I expect that is so. We're saving up for the big free agent investment that, when all is said and done, we won't make. Not that management didn't try to spend that money; they just couldn't find anyone to take it. Look on the bright side, though. Money unspent at the end of the season goes into the owners pockets, never to be seen again by the team or fans. That will provide fodder for another long offseason of fan vs pocket protector commentary on these boards.
-
Front Page: Twins' Payroll Analysis: Three Pitchers, $70M
"Can we get rid of this perceived reputation?" That reputation didn't come from nowhere, it was earned. And when I say rookies and castoffs I'm not referring to the 2019 team. The Twins spent big on Mauer and what did they put around him? Little to nothing, certainly nothing in free agency. What assurance does a top free agent have that the owners won't revert to form? My point is that adding long-term assets via trade first may make it easier to convince potential free agents that the team is committed to winning, not simply being competitive enough to maintain ticket sales.
-
Front Page: Twins' Payroll Analysis: Three Pitchers, $70M
I expect the Twins reputation as cheapskates will scare off free agent pitchers, even if offered a premium salary. Players will want to play for a good team - I can't imagine anyone wants to sign a big dollar contract and find it offset by filling the roster with rookies and cast-offs. If you're going to convince a top free agent to come to MN I think you need to start by trading for premium talent. Bump Berrios back to number 3 by trade and you might have a chance to bump him back to number 4 via free agency. Yes, it's expensive in both prospects and dollars, but I think it's the only way we sign a top free agent pitcher. My personal expectation is that the Twins are "in on" everyone, fail to sign a difference maker, and next year's rotation is no better than the crew that got blown out this fall.
-
Playoff Game Thread: Twins @ Yankees 4:07 PM CT, 10/5/19
Just tossing some nitro on the bonfire, think it's possible the Yankee hitters are comfortable laying off close pitches because they know they'll get the call? History shows they don't even have to play to cover the foul lines...if it lands within 3 feet of the foul line they'll get that call too.
- Playoff Game Thread: Twins @ Yankees 4:07 PM CT, 10/5/19
-
Front Page: Twins Game Recap (9/7): Odorizzi, Garver Power the Twins to Victory
"He was pitched 6 "Balls..." I agree Eddie swings at too many pitches off the plate, but to be fair the home plate umpire didn't seem to much care where the pitches were thrown. His strike zone could be charitably described as erratic.
-
Front Page: Twins Game Recap (8/1): Dyson Implodes In Twins Debut
Sam Dyson is a grown ass man who I'm sure is very capable of jumping on a plane and pitching the same day... It's my understanding our players prepare for the games by studying their opponents...tendencies, weaknesses, strengths... and pro ball requires more work than just showing up and throwing. Unless Dyson spent his plane ride watching video and studying Miami batters, he wasn't prepared and shouldn't have been playing. Or maybe all that talk about analytics and film study is BS and the players actually spend their pre-game playing cards and getting pedicures. In that case, grown-ass man just had a bad day.
-
Craig Kimbrel Tracker
Hadn't you heard? Management's still waiting for the window to open.
-
Article: DET 9, MIN 3: Third Out Eludes Gibson, Eades Debuts
Correlation is not causation. Your post says a whole lot about you and virtually nothing about Kyle Gibson. How does noting the pitcher didn't follow his normal routine and then pitched poorly reflect on the commenter? Perhaps you interpreted the statement as a dig at religion but I didn't read it that way. Not that Gibson cost us the game. The bats and the bullpen deserve more opprobrium.
- Article: Miguel Sano: A Fading Superstar
-
Article: DET 5, MIN 3: Tigers Out-Tater Twins, Gardy Gets Tossed
'