-
Posts
62 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Rod Carews Birthday's Achievements
-
Don't Feed the Greed Guy reacted to a post in a topic: Reflections on the 2023 Twins Season from a Time Traveler
-
miracleb reacted to a post in a topic: Twins Spotlight: LHP Jaylen Nowlin
-
Squirrel reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
DocBauer reacted to a post in a topic: Twins Spotlight: LHP Jaylen Nowlin
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
CarpetGuy reacted to a post in a topic: Twins Spotlight: LHP Jaylen Nowlin
-
tarheeltwinsfan reacted to a post in a topic: Reflections on the 2023 Twins Season from a Time Traveler
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: This is an exceptionally long title to test how various points look on a phone and smaller devices
-
Twins Spotlight: LHP Jaylen Nowlin
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Seth Stohs's topic in Twins Minor League Talk
Great article Seth. While it sounds like he obviously has plenty left to do, he's young and very projectable. You can't really fake a strikeout rate like that - especially as a lefty. He is definitely a player to watch. -
Karbo reacted to a post in a topic: Reflections on the 2023 Twins Season from a Time Traveler
-
DocBauer reacted to a post in a topic: Reflections on the 2023 Twins Season from a Time Traveler
-
Nine of twelve reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
Richie the Rally Goat reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
Rod Carews Birthday changed their profile photo
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
Gilberto Celestino Needs To Catch A Break
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The Twins did him no favors when he was rushed to the majors (out of necessity), and that has slowed his development quite a lot. What they did was find a guy seemed promising but needed two more years of school, hoping he could just skip those classes and succeed anyway. Unfortunately, now it looks like he is being punished and sent back down (after he heals) when he is really just getting in the classes and hopefully finishing the degree before he comes back. I understand why it had to be done, but now they are paying the price. The Celestino situation is EXACTLY why I am NOT clambering for Julien or Lee to be called up to the majors anytime soon. They are both incredibly promising but they need to put in the work and learn in a low pressure situation so that they can be called up, be successful, and stay up in the majors once they get here. Give them time to develop on the farm. Don't waste service time while they try to figure it out on the fly. -
Those would be amazing! I think Gallo and Lopez are most likely to actually happen with the Gallen trade the least likely. Buxton having a real season and finding a gem in Julien would be awesome but I'm not holding my breath. My fingers are crossed.
- 35 replies
-
- joey gallo
- byron buxton
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Ranking the Twins Weakest Positions
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I think it is interesting how much the Twins roster has changed in just the past few years. RF, LF, and 1B are three "power hitter" positions and we only sort of have that covered with Gallo/Kepler. Kiriloff might become that, but he's not there yet. I don't think that relatively a "2 WAR" player is bad, but those are the positions that tend to be occupied by stronger hitters than we currently have in place. So, compared to the rest of the league, we don't look very good here.- 21 replies
-
- alex kirilloff
- joey gallo
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: Twins fans 25th most annoying, 29th worst behaved
-
I have by no means been to every major league ballpark (or city for that matter), but I have been to quite a few. My experience is that fanship at Target Field is definitely among the most "civilized" that I have seen. It's not perfect. . . I'm a realist. . . there are ding dongs all over, but it really is pretty good. I do feel like I have to defend the White Sox fans. I find them to be pretty normal and reasonable people. . . they could be Twins fans. Again, there are a few real ding dongs out there doing really, really dumb stuff so that's not good but that is the exception and not the rule. Unfortunately we all tend to gravitate toward the example of the worst imaginable behavior and assume that it happens all the time. On the other hand, and the other side of town, it is impossible to go to a Cubs game and not experience at least 7 out of 10 of the criteria and sometimes more than that. Insufferable does not even begin to describe the situation, and it is almost always present. Honestly, I have experienced most of these things with Cubs fans without even being at the ballpark. They are a different sort. . .
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: The Twins Dark Horse Designated Hitter
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: The Twins Dark Horse Designated Hitter
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: Your best-case lineup?
-
The Twins Dark Horse Designated Hitter
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Ted Schwerzler's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Julien needs to at least begin the year in the minors. It will be better for his long term development. Playing well in spring training is great and useful but let him go down and rake for at least a half year. That will force the issue and be a wonderful problem to have on our hands. THEN, we can figure out who to trade/release (or who is hurt!) to make that happen. I want him to come up and stay up, not be doing the St. Paul shuffle because he can't figure out how to handle major league pitching.- 34 replies
-
- edouard julien
- kyle farmer
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
The beauty of this lineup is that no one in it is completely irreplaceable. If anyone is out, there is an actual (mostly) qualified major league player able to come in and take their place. In addition, there are going to be capable pieces down in St. Paul able to play before we ever get to some of the guys that we threw to the sharks last year at the end of the season. All of this is to say while I don't love injuries, the floor for this group of position players is pretty good. So. . . Polanco - consistency is key Buxton - get the man some AB's Correa - as Correa goes, so will this lineup Miranda - I think there could be big things in store here (Good) Kiriloff - if healthy. Otherwise Solano? maybe bats seventh Gallo - we're going to smile about this signing by the end of the season DH for the day - This will be a committee, so the lineup position will change all the time. Vasquez - it's a good catcher spot, even when Jeffers plays. (Bad) Kepler - If we get good Kepler, he can bat 5th. Nobody is traded. Nobody not on the 40 man roster. Not the 1927 Yankees, but no black holes either.
-
Ideally, you would like to have the trade work out for both sides, especially if it is in the other league as in this case. That way, when you want to trade again you have some takers, instead of people who run the other way when you are dangling a trade chip. None of these players (Mahle included) have done nearly enough to declare this trade (and a lot of other ones) a success or a failure. As to the Twins getting fleeced all the time, I'm not sure that's really the case. If it were there would be lots of guys around the league that we would say we desperately want back. Historically, the Twins have made some pretty good trades over the years. Trading Pierzynski for Joe Nathan, Francisco Liriano and Boof Bonser. . . now there was a fleecing! Let's do that again.
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: This prospect's loud contact is turning heads - only he is no longer ours.
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: This prospect's loud contact is turning heads - only he is no longer ours.
-
Rod Carews Birthday reacted to a post in a topic: This prospect's loud contact is turning heads - only he is no longer ours.
-
The problem with trading for a “#1/Ace” starter is that aside from a small number of names (probably less than ten - Johan Santana used to be one of those), you don’t really know what is going to happen and you wind up trading for the player that they were the year before . . . for another team. Pitchers are way too unpredictable and variable to bank on one name to do it all. In most cases, these #1 guys have a year or maybe two where they are that good (see Hughes, Phil and Mazda, Kenya) and are otherwise mortals. As I see it, the Twins have one guy in Gray who is going to be pretty good (but likely not an ace) and pretty predictable, one guy in Mazda who is recovering from injury and is a bit of a wildcard but could also be pretty good,, and three guys in Mahle, Lopez, and Ryan who are definite candidates to break out and be more productive than ever before. I prefer that to trading away half of the farm for a year or two of a guy who was previously really good for another team.
-
As a manager, this has got to be the most exciting time for Baldelli. He is comfortably in his role. The team arguably has more talent than he's ever had to work with before. The key leaders are locked up for a few years. Whether that translates into playoff success is a great unknown, but it has to feel good going into the year like this. I don't think he's remotely on the hot seat either, nor should he be, but this really could be a time to create a legacy as manager of the Twins. Best of luck to you Rocco!
- 27 replies
-
- rocco baldelli
- tom kelly
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
The Return of the King
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Lou Hennessy's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Managing his workload will be the key. Obviously we'll be very happy if he gets to 120-150 innings with a reasonable ERA. For starter #5, that's pretty impressive and a lot better than anything that we have gotten from that spot the past few years (decades?). Somewhere along the way, he's going to need a break and a few skipped starts in order to limit his innings (assuming no setbacks/injuries). That will also be a great time to see what some of the starters down at AAA have to offer. -
Who Is the Twins Biggest Rival for 2023?
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Ted Schwerzler's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
In the short term, it would appear that Cleveland is our rival for the division, but don't count out Chicago. They could easily surprise if their young talent stays healthy. I've always felt that Chicago is the more traditional rivalry even though it doesn't really inspire the kind of other team hatred that is prevalent in other rivalries. As someone who lives in the Chicago area, I go to Twins/Sox games every year wearing my Twins jerseys and usually wind up in a really positive discussion with a random Sox fan about the teams this year. They are largely just real baseball fans who even cheer for the other team when something good happens. I guess most of the nastiness gets tied up on the other side of town for the Cubs and Cardinals.- 18 replies
-
- chicago white sox
- luis robert
- (and 3 more)
-
Twins 2023 X-Factors: LHP Jovani Moran
Rod Carews Birthday replied to Adam Friedman's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Thanks for an excellent breakdown. If he can maintain his late season numbers, Moran will indeed be extremely valuable and also be insurance in case there is any fall off from Theilbar from the left side. There are always plenty of innings to be taken care of by the bullpen so we’re going to need many good pitchers to step up and maintain consistency.