Everything posted by AlwaysinModeration
- Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #1 Royce Lewis
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
Ok, I’ll bite. Why do you insist on the “h” in Kiriloff?
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
And to bring the conversation back to Kiriloff, as this is in the Kiriloff forum, let me point out the glaringly obvious fact that Kiriloff went from last year being unranked nationally but “he’s a great pure hitter” to this year, after an amazing statistical season, ranked in the top 20 nationally. To me, it looks like it was his stats over the past year that made up 95% of those ranking changes. (94.8%, to be exact.)
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
It seems like there is a big difference between saying stats are “just a piece of the puzzle” and “rankings typically have very little to do with the stats.” I think your latter statement was just hyperbole and we shouldn’t hold you to it, especially in the broader context of all of the great work you do tracking down and writing up all of the Twins prospects that we all like to follow during the dog days of winter (buy the prospect handbook!). All that said, I am still a bit perplexed how you feel like you aren’t considering stats that much when you go from ranking Gonsalves #1 in the system after an amazing statistical season in A+/AA, to #2 in the system after an exceedingly good statistical season in AA/AAA, to #11 after a similarly excellent statistical season in AAA with a 24 bad inning promotion to MLB. To me it looks like stats were a pretty big driver for those rankings.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #2 Alex Kirilloff
Here is what you said, Seth, in the Jhoan Duran forum, when looking at Gonsalves vs Duran: “Prospect rankings, however, typically have very little to do with the stats, though they do obviously factor in. And, I would hope people have not given up on Gonsalves at all. But Duran's upside is top of the rotation starter. That's why I rank him higher. That's'why I have Graterol ranked higher.”
- Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #5 Wander Javier
-
Article: Who's the Fourth Outfielder?
Well that does it, get Granite to the Lasic guy stat!
-
Article: Mailbag: Catcher Innings, Bye-Bye Creams, Free Agent Watch
I somehow read that as “as a late inning pinch runner”, and did a double take.
-
Article: Mailbag: Catcher Innings, Bye-Bye Creams, Free Agent Watch
I like your crowbar metaphor “manny” times more than the fingers metaphor.
- Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #5 Wander Javier
-
Twins Non-Roster Invites, including Lucas Duda
I don’t think I’ve seen you before. However if he somehow sticks with the Twins for two or three years, and the #10 prospect makes his way up to the bigs, there could potentially be a 9-3 double play, with the call: “And a diving catch by Akil “Yabba Dah” Badoo, he gets up and tosses it in to Lucas “Zippety” Duda, this is going to be an easy double play!”
-
Article: Mailbag: Catcher Innings, Bye-Bye Creams, Free Agent Watch
If the Twins have actually offered 3/45 for Kimbrel, that is great news. It would be the highest price paid for a reliever on the market this offseason. Maybe it would take a few more million to get him to sign, but hopefully the Twins’ patience on the market and payroll flexibility will pay off. Aside from shoring up the back of the bullpen, he would be a fine trade piece. The Yankees traded Aroldis and Andrew Miller and got Gleyber Torres, Clint Frazier, and Justus Sheffield (who has turned into James Paxton).
-
Dozier to the Nats
Two questions: 1. Will Schoop insist on batting lead-off? 2. Which player will hit more solo homers this year? That said, I hope both players have nice bounce back seasons, with Schoop bouncing back further than Dozier. I’ll be more than happy to watch Dozier here in DC for the Nats. (It will also make for a nice storyline when he makes the Series for the second year in a row and faces his old team.)
-
HOF: Johan Santana Got Royally Screwed
Thanks for writing this piece. If you compare their stats through age 31, Santana is better. His shredded shoulder, probably exacerbated by pitching the Mets’ lone no-hitter, cost him the HOF for two main reasons, in my opinion: 1) his counting stats, and by that, really, I mean his wins total, fell short. I think the writers see 139 wins, and then they moved on to other players, and 2) he retired a year or two early...if he had gotten on the ballot after the past two years of four guys elected each, he likely would have been able to stay on the ballot, and possibly get some traction over the next few years. Santana was the best pitcher in the game for an extended stretch. His peak can be compared to that of Sandy Koufax. Hell(‘s Bells), he pitched twice as many innings at about the same level of effectiveness as Trevor Hoffman. He absolutely deserved more consideration than one and done.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
It was a little heartless, I have to admit, but I couldn’t resist. I certainly don’t want to have to account for my past assertions! (I seem to recall a strong Tulowitzki post or five). Thanks for taking it in the right spirit. Gonsalves might have a lower upside than people thought a year or two ago, but, I think people are reading too much into 24IP.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
Danchat, I went back to the 2018 write-up of Gonsalves (he was ranked #4 in the system by TD at the time) and I found an interesting comment in the comment section: “I'm hoping to see Gonsalves by July in the majors. From what I've read, it seems he'll slot in as a #3-4 starting pitcher. Having the young core of Berrios (#2), Gonsalves (#3), and Mejia (#4) and seeing them perform up to their talent levels would be huge for this team. Now if they only had a true ace... “I am concerned about the recent trend of rookie starters for the Twins. This includes Kyle Gibson (10 starts, 6.53 ERA), Trevor May (9 starts, 7.88 ERA), Jose Berrios (14 starts, 8.02 ERA). Mejia's first 10 starts were OK (4.93 ERA). The only good recent rookie starter I could find was Tyler Duffey (10 starts, 3.10 ERA) and it's been all downhill from here. “The Twins will have to be patient with Gonsalves... sophomore years have been much better for our starters.” ........ That comment, of course, was by you. I agree with you. Patience!
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #7 Jhoan Duran
Great to see one of trade returns ranked this high, and seems like Duran has great pure stuff that is extremely projectable, which is the basis for a lot of proscpet lists. But let me repost what I posted on the forum when Tom put up spotlight article on Duran, now that we see TD has Gonsalves ranked #11 and Duran at #7: “I looked up Gonsalves’ minor league numbers: 108 games started, 599IP, 2.42ERA, 1.10WHIP, 9.5/3.6 K/BB. Duran’s numbers: 54GS, 259IP, 4.02ERA, 1.32WHIP, 8.0/3.2K/BB. Gonsalves had 4 mediocre starts in the big leagues and people have written him off. Not to throw shade on Duran, like I said I hope he turns into a great prospect for the Twins and sustains the improvement. I would have Gonsalves ahead of Duran on prospect lists, though. He could turn into a mainstay in the rotation for years to come. Duran is a long way from becoming that. I see that you have Gonsalves ahead of Duran, Tom. But two of the four of you have Gonsalves ranked lower than Duran. I think that Gonsalves’ mediocre debut shouldn’t tarnish his outlook. Remember Berrios...”
-
Keith Law Top 100 - no love for Graterol
And I will note that the Twins pick this year (12 or 13?) is a pretty good spot to grab someone who fits this description, that doesn’t seem like a sure bet, but has lots of upside.
-
Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #9 Blayne Enlow
If he posted a 1.33 ERA in 20 GCL innings, and end the season with 53 innings of 2.36ERA in Low A, he must have had a really rough first 21 innings in Cedar Rapids to wind up with a 3.26 ERA overall. In any event, I certainly hope he pans out. For some reason I feel like he’s on the same path as Gonsalves.
-
Keith Law Top 100 - no love for Graterol
Touché! He was definitely billed as a #1 guy. (And Royce Lewis never was).
-
Keith Law Top 100 - no love for Graterol
I know very little about how the top picks of the draft are figured out. But a strategy that seems to work is to find guys that are considered #1 picks and then lost their luster with a bad spring or an injury before the draft. Trea Turner, Sean Manaea, Lucas Giolito, Carlos Rodon, Adrian Peterson types. (If you squint, Kyle Gibson could fit that description.)
- Article: Twins Daily 2019 Top Prospects: #10 Akil Baddoo
-
Twins actively discussing locking up parts of young core
Agreed. As an example, I had hoped the Twins would sign Mauer to an extension after his age 25 season, in which he won his second batting title. Instead, he won the MVP, and became much more expensive. I bet they could have signed him for 7/140, which would have been a LOT better, for several reasons.
-
Article: Who's the Fourth Outfielder?
I plead the fifth on whether I will need a fifth to mull over the fourth.
-
Article: Who's the Fourth Outfielder?
I should have said, in keeping with the spirit of the article, “let me put forth a fourth fourth” in Austin.