Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

AlwaysinModeration

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by AlwaysinModeration

  1. According to this Fangraphs article (from one year ago), Granite is the sixth best prospect in the game, projected to amass 10WAR over the first six seasons of his big-league career. Presumably a lot of that value is centered around his defense. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/2018-top-100-katoh-prospects/
  2. How can can you be so....obtuse? .... Nothing stops. We’ll have a little book barbecue in the yard, dancing around it like wild Indians. Do you understand me, or am I being...obtuse?
  3. To draw out the comparisons, let's pull up the minor league numbers for these guys: Player (highest minors level reached) Berrios (AAA) 591IP 2.77ERA 1.07WHIP 7.2H/9 0.5HR/9 2.5BB/9 9.6K/9 Romero (AAA) 394IP 3.02ERA 1.19WHIP 7.9H/9 0.3HR/9 2.8BB/9 8.3K/9 Brusdar (A+) 153IP 2.71ERA 1.10WHIP 7.5H/9 0.3HR/9 2.5BB/9 9.9K/9 Duran (A-) 259IP 4.03ERA 1.32WHIP 8.7H/9 0.6HR/9 3.2BB/9 8.0K/9 Thorpe (AAA) 328IP 3.18ERA 1.21WHIP 7.8H/9 0.8HR/9 3.0BB/9 10.7K/9 Enlow (A-) 114IP 2.91ERA 1.25WHIP 8.2H/9 0.4HR/9 3.1BB/9 7.1K/9 Gonsalves(AAA) 599IP 2.46ERA 1.10WHIP 6.4H/9 0.4HR/9 3.6BB/9 9.5K/9 I get that the lists are based on a combination of stats and stuff. But we also know that numbers generally get worse as players move up to face off against higher competition. Now, maybe the better "stuff" is going to make these guys do the opposite, and post more impressive numbers as they move to higher levels. But to me, I would put my chips on Gonsalves being the better pitcher going forward than Enlow, Thorpe, and Duran. (Brusdar looks like the closest comp, other than Berrios...but he still has a ton to prove.)
  4. I'm trying to see if I have what you are saying right: 1. Gonsalves advanced a level in the middle of every single year of his minor league career, culminating in a promotion to the majors on that same exact path, midway through the season after his midyear promotion to AAA. 2. He blew away the minors at pretty much every level along the way. 3. He should have been moved quicker so that he would have struggled more in the minors, gotten to the majors faster, so that he could be more like....Martin Perez?
  5. Thank you researching this topic. It’s important to have this all documented, and I think you correctly chronicled the chain of events without sugarcoating any of it.
  6. Not bad for the team’s #12 prospect. You know, the guy who in 599 career minor league innings posted: 2.46 ERA 1.10 WHIP 6.4 hits/inning (!) 0.4 hr/9 3.6 bb/9 9.5 k/9 And then was bad for 24 innings in his major league debut in August and September in 2018 (6.57 ERA, 2.02 WHIP) and everyone gave up on him. For comparison’s sake, in 591 career minor league innings, Berrios posted these numbers: 2.77 ERA 1.07 WHIP 7.2 hits/9 0.5 hr/9 2.5 bb/9 9.6 k/9 In Berrios’ mlb debut, he pitched in 14 games/58IP and posted a 8.02 ERA and a 1.87 WHIP. Remind me again why Gonsalves has tumbled from the Twins’ #2 prospect to their #4 prospect to their #12 prospect and how Enlow, Thorpe, Duran and Graterol have gotten better than him?
  7. The irony is that we assume Sano’s reduced plate appearances this offseason is going to lead to an increase in plate appearances this season.
  8. I know that you will be hard to convince otherwise, but arguing for balls and strikes calls to be made correctly is really completely unrelated to the play of pitchers, hitters and fielders on the field. While botched calls can be a cause of intense discussion amongst fans after the game (perhaps years after), I’d rather spend that timing discussing the performance of the players. And I don’t think it takes the human element out of the game at all to ask that all the calls be made as right as possible. It just means the human element is focused on the performance, success and errors of the players, where it should be.
  9. It’s a bit hard to get super-excited about this move after they have added Cruz, Cron, and Schoop, not to mention having Cave, Austin, Duda and Astudillo to sort through / possibly lose. But he’s clearly an upgrade to the overall roster (have to figure he takes Adrianza’s spot), he’s a switch-hitter, and he can play / platoon pretty much anywhere. I like seeing the FO actively trying to improve every spot on the roster. I just hope that they are right that the marginal dollars spent on him are more valuable than anything else they could have done, especially if these are the last FA dollars they spend this year.
  10. I think you are right. Reed at the top. I just thought the board would scoff if I typed that. As for whether it’s a good yardstick....I’d rather look at the whole picture than the last year (or two). Of course, you could weight the last year or two a bit heavier if you want. That might make sense too.
  11. And if I were ranking them with Kimbrel under consideration, it would be: 1. Kimbrel .... 2. Everyone else
  12. Based on their track records across their entire careers, I’d rank the candidates: 1. Romero (hard to judge since he’s been a starter, but I understand the “he could be a weapon” thinking) 2. Rogers (he had a great year, but doesn’t have the track record to back it up) 3. Hildenberger (last year’s HR/9 looks flukey) 4. Parker (last year’s HR/9 looks fluky, this could turn out to be a great signing) 5. Reed (needs to keep homers down, but he has an impeccable track record...big bounce back coming; he could slot in anywhere 1-5...provided he isn’t injured) .... 6. Mejia (sticks as a long man / starter candidate, but numbers don’t stack up as a reliever; I would think Romero should be way ahead of him in the pecking order for SP) 7. May (Ks are great, but too many hits, walks and homers) ... 8. Magill (I don’t get it. Numbers just aren’t impressive).
  13. Yeah, I have no problem with them jettisoning Magill.
  14. Reading the article, I agree with Thrylos that the story here isn’t that they might sign him, but rather that they had made an offer some time in the undefined past (and based on their bad experience with Lynn and Logan as late signees) and won’t wait much longer. Therefore, the real question, in my mind, is whether there are unreported offers on the table for Keuchel and/or Kimbrel, as well?
  15. It’s my George Costanza moment! I’ll see myself out, it’s been good knowing you.
  16. I should also have noted that his quote following this line in the article is “I was keeping myself in shape.” Which, of course, implies that he has been, and continues to be, in EXACTLY the right shape.
  17. For some reason, it is extremely easy to visualize Willians demonstrating how the ball went by his head.
  18. You must have missed it in the Athletic profile by Dan Hayes, the very Willians version of “best shape of his life”: “He lost a little weight this winter.”
  19. Saw Witt at HR Derby. Seems like he might be high on himself. Why is Carroll so good?
  20. So, reading through these materials again, am eager to hear any updates as the spring season gets underway. I’d like to hope that Rutschman or Vaughan have lousy spring seasons and fall down lists (especially Rutschman, seems like than guy does it all). Otherwise Caleb Stewart looks like a potential buy-low (best curve, mid-90s, failed to sign last year) or maybe Misner, given he missed the end of last year including summer with a broken foot.
  21. Actually, I think that is part of the underlying logic of both of these deals. From both Polanco and Kepler’s perspective, as good but maybe not great players, they can clearly see guys who can potentially push them off the field looming behind them (Lewis, Javier; Kiriloff, Larnach). It makes sense, then, to get a team commitment to having them stick around as a long-term piece. Berrios and Buxton don’t have to look over their shoulders, so that might make them less inclined to opt for a deal selling any free agent years. Sano doesn’t either, per se, but we also don’t know how long he will stick at third.
  22. Having E. coli for three weeks with no antibiotics sounds rough. In addition to losing all that weight, he lost a lot of muscle mass and workout time.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.