Everything posted by Nick Nelson
-
The Widening Search For a New Twins Manager
* ESPN 1500's Darren Wolfson, who has been characteristically active in providing rumors and tidbits gleaned from his various sources, reports that the Twins have interviewed Blue Jays bench coach Demarlo Hale. Hale, 53, has managed at various spots in the minors, and was a member of Terry Francona's staff in Boston before a stint with Baltimore (as third base coach) and his present gig in Toronto. He was rumored to be one of four finalists in 2010 for the Jays managerial job, which ended up going to John Farrell. If it's wide-ranging experience that the Twins are looking for, Hale offers plenty of that. * A day earlier, Wolfson had tweeted that Red Sox bench coach Torey Lovullo "nailed his interview" with the team. Lovullo's name generated some Thursday-morning excitement when his profile page was discovered on the Twins' site, but that buzz was quickly squashed after team employee Andrew Ettel pointed out that any name in the system would show up on a search of the site (including Babe Ruth). Nevertheless, Lovullo appears to have some steam behind him. He was apparently one of the top names considered for the Rangers job, which went to Jeff Banister on Thursday. During just the last two seasons in Boston, Lovullo has experienced the highest of highs (a World Series in 2013) and the lowest of lows (last-place finish in 2014). He also appears to be open to analytics and modernized strategy: It bears noting that Lovullo has interviewed for several managerial openings in the past, including Los Angeles, Cleveland and Boston, and always come up short. But maybe, like Mike Zimmer with the Vikings, this is finally his time. * The Twins also interviewed Sandy Alomar Jr., who has been serving as the bench coach in Cleveland for the past two years. The 48-year-old lacks the depth of experience of the two names mentioned above, and his managerial background amounts to a few days at the end of the 2012 season when he was named as Manny Acta's interim replacement, but it's only a matter of time before Alomar gets a chance somewhere, and he would satisfy calls for a Latin infusion on the Twins' coaching staff. * The Twins became the last team with a managerial vacancy after Texas hired Banister this week. Earlier, the Diamondbacks had hired Chip Hale, who was scheduled for an interview in Minnesota before being swooped away. That means Ron Gardenhire, who expressed interest in managing again, is out of potential destinations for the time being. It seems likely he'll accept a job in the Twins organization.
- Lovullo
-
Article: The Painful Truth?
Terry Ryan has formed a rock-solid reputation during his decades in the game of baseball, in large part because of his integrity and honesty. Say what you will about the man, but he will always give you his sincere opinion. Sometimes, that honesty isn't so refreshing.Here are three quotes that Ryan has provided on three separate occasions since the season ended: “We’re not broke here, we’re bent. We’ve got some issues, and we need to make better decisions. But I feel a heck of a lot better about this club and moving forward than I did a year ago,” Ryan said. “I don’t think we’re all that far away [from contention]. I don’t want to punt on 2015, but it’s still going to be a struggle.” - Conference call with season ticket holders (via Star Tribune) "No one said this is going to be easy. It’s going to take a lot of work and a little time,” Ryan said. “But the worst thing that could happen is, yeah, we’ve had four bad years. I don’t want it to turn into 14 bad years. Sometimes you make decisions that ultimately are going to benefit you down the line that don’t look exactly like what you want right now.” - Phil Miller story from Tuesday's Star Tribune "There isn’t any shortcut to this thing. I’m not going to pretend that this thing’s going to come together in the next six months. We’ve got a lot of work to do, I know it. I’m not going to hide and I’m not going to pretend. … I don’t know how long it’s going to take, but for everybody’s sake the sooner that we get this thing going in the right direction, the better." - Interview with Parker Hageman for the upcoming Offseason Handbook Hey Terry, maybe lighten up a little and leave the doom and gloom to the bloggers, eh? The season ended two weeks ago, for crying out loud! Is there a need to keep not-so-implicitly suggesting that we're likely to be in for another rough one next season when the sting of this year's 92nd loss remains so fresh? On some level, I can appreciate what TR is doing. He's being frank and stern in his assessments of a roster that -- objectively -- still appears to be a ways off from contention. He doesn't want to blow smoke after four straight miserable years. I'll take that over the delusional rah-rah Tim Brewster rhetoric. But while I'm sure Ryan is more hopeful than the above quotes would indicate, it sure seems like I have more faith in the ability of this team to be competitive next year than he does -- and I'm no eternal optimist. Hopefully his actions this offseason don't match his words, but Phil Miller's story in Tuesday's Star Tribune emits little optimism on that front. In the article, Ryan and team president Dave St. Peter share the same sentiment: payroll is likely to remain more or less static heading into 2015. In fact, St. Peter would only go so far as to say "we don't see it going down significantly." Team execs bristle whenever the payroll topic is brought up, and I'm not one to wave the "spend money because you owe the taxpayers!" torch, but they've got to at least acknowledge that they bring this upon themselves. In 2013, the Twins ranked 22nd in the majors with an Opening Day payroll of $76 million. In 2014, thanks to big signings like Ricky Nolasco and Phil Hughes, that number rose to $86 million. But despite the splurge, Minnesota's MLB rank dropped to 24th, because every single team that had sported a lower payroll in 2013 spent even more during the offseason. If the Twins stay at $86 million or drop slightly, they'll likely be passed by a couple more teams, because with substantial new revenues flowing into the game from new TV mega-deals that kicked in this year, small-market franchises are spending more. That said, it's not the payroll rank relative to other teams that bothers me, nor the dubiousness of this supposed "50 percent of revenue" standard. I'm just dispirited by the messages being conveyed. I wouldn't advocate "spending just to spend," and I fully recognize that the Twins are in a position where they basically they have to roll with what they've got, but they have an acute need in left field with no answer in the pipeline. I'd like to think that Ryan will at least aggressively pursue a quality player there to supplement his emerging core, but going after the most highly sought assets -- whether in free agency, or trade, or the international market -- requires a willingness to spend. To see both the general manager and team president downplaying that whole notion so early in the offseason, at a time where fan morale is dreadfully low and the team is hemorrhaging season ticket holders, seems rather bizarre. I'm depressed from reading this stuff as a fan. I can only imagine how the players must feel. A friend reminded me of a quote that Glen Perkins shared back in June, after the Twins signed Kendrys Morales: Hopefully Ryan and the Twins will heed these words from their All-Star closer, and reconsider their stated offseason course. This roster ain't so bad. They need some pitchers to bounce back, but there are some nice young arms ready to make an impact, and the offensive unit is quite strong with elite prospects set to join soon. Youthful teams can emerge from the abyss quite quickly, as the two squads presently facing off in the ALCS can attest. Don't sell these kids short. Give them some help. Or at least feign making an effort. When all you've got to sell is hope, it'd be nice to put a little out on the shelf. Click here to view the article
-
The Painful Truth?
Here are three quotes that Ryan has provided on three separate occasions since the season ended: “We’re not broke here, we’re bent. We’ve got some issues, and we need to make better decisions. But I feel a heck of a lot better about this club and moving forward than I did a year ago,” Ryan said. “I don’t think we’re all that far away [from contention]. I don’t want to punt on 2015, but it’s still going to be a struggle.” - Conference call with season ticket holders (via Star Tribune) "No one said this is going to be easy. It’s going to take a lot of work and a little time,” Ryan said. “But the worst thing that could happen is, yeah, we’ve had four bad years. I don’t want it to turn into 14 bad years. Sometimes you make decisions that ultimately are going to benefit you down the line that don’t look exactly like what you want right now.” - Phil Miller story from Tuesday's Star Tribune "There isn’t any shortcut to this thing. I’m not going to pretend that this thing’s going to come together in the next six months. We’ve got a lot of work to do, I know it. I’m not going to hide and I’m not going to pretend. … I don’t know how long it’s going to take, but for everybody’s sake the sooner that we get this thing going in the right direction, the better." - Interview with Parker Hageman for the upcoming Offseason Handbook Hey Terry, maybe lighten up a little and leave the doom and gloom to the bloggers, eh? The season ended two weeks ago, for crying out loud! Is there a need to keep not-so-implicitly suggesting that we're likely to be in for another rough one next season when the sting of this year's 92nd loss remains so fresh? On some level, I can appreciate what TR is doing. He's being frank and stern in his assessments of a roster that -- objectively -- still appears to be a ways off from contention. He doesn't want to blow smoke after four straight miserable years. I'll take that over the delusional rah-rah Tim Brewster rhetoric. But while I'm sure Ryan is more hopeful than the above quotes would indicate, it sure seems like I have more faith in the ability of this team to be competitive next year than he does -- and I'm no eternal optimist. Hopefully his actions this offseason don't match his words, but Phil Miller's story in Tuesday's Star Tribune emits little optimism on that front. In the article, Ryan and team president Dave St. Peter share the same sentiment: payroll is likely to remain more or less static heading into 2015. In fact, St. Peter would only go so far as to say "we don't see it going down significantly." Team execs bristle whenever the payroll topic is brought up, and I'm not one to wave the "spend money because you owe the taxpayers!" torch, but they've got to at least acknowledge that they bring this upon themselves. In 2013, the Twins ranked 22nd in the majors with an Opening Day payroll of $76 million. In 2014, thanks to big signings like Ricky Nolasco and Phil Hughes, that number rose to $86 million. But despite the splurge, Minnesota's MLB rank dropped to 24th, because every single team that had sported a lower payroll in 2013 spent even more during the offseason. If the Twins stay at $86 million or drop slightly, they'll likely be passed by a couple more teams, because with substantial new revenues flowing into the game from new TV mega-deals that kicked in this year, small-market franchises are spending more. That said, it's not the payroll rank relative to other teams that bothers me, nor the dubiousness of this supposed "50 percent of revenue" standard. I'm just dispirited by the messages being conveyed. I wouldn't advocate "spending just to spend," and I fully recognize that the Twins are in a position where they basically they have to roll with what they've got, but they have an acute need in left field with no answer in the pipeline. I'd like to think that Ryan will at least aggressively pursue a quality player there to supplement his emerging core, but going after the most highly sought assets -- whether in free agency, or trade, or the international market -- requires a willingness to spend. To see both the general manager and team president downplaying that whole notion so early in the offseason, at a time where fan morale is dreadfully low and the team is hemorrhaging season ticket holders, seems rather bizarre. I'm depressed from reading this stuff as a fan. I can only imagine how the players must feel. A friend reminded me of a quote that Glen Perkins shared back in June, after the Twins signed Kendrys Morales: Hopefully Ryan and the Twins will heed these words from their All-Star closer, and reconsider their stated offseason course. This roster ain't so bad. They need some pitchers to bounce back, but there are some nice young arms ready to make an impact, and the offensive unit is quite strong with elite prospects set to join soon. Youthful teams can emerge from the abyss quite quickly, as the two squads presently facing off in the ALCS can attest. Don't sell these kids short. Give them some help. Or at least feign making an effort. When all you've got to sell is hope, it'd be nice to put a little out on the shelf.
-
Article: What Will Be The Twins' Identity?
On Friday, the Baltimore Orioles and Kansas City Royals will kick off the American League Championship Series. Both teams had successful seasons and have had extremely successful postseasons thus far. They've reached a stage that the Twins, obviously, would like to return to, so it makes sense to examine these two clubs for inspiration as the rebuild pushes onward.You can draw some similarities between the Orioles and Royals, but in many ways they are polar opposites. Baltimore is built around power. They led the majors with 211 homers and ranked last with 44 steals. Not one player on the O's roster swiped more than eight bases this season. This is a plodding, station-to-station club whose strategy is very much built around producing runs with bases-clearing hits and homers. Conversely, the Royals are all speed and no power. They ranked last in the majors in home runs (95) but first in steals (153). They barely sneaked into the playoffs but were able to shockingly sweep a 98-win Angels team with a small-ball offensive attack characterized by aggressive base-running and lots (I mean LOTS) of sacrifice bunting. I have little doubt that the Twins, at least under Ron Gardenhire, would have very much aspired to tailor themselves after the Royals. That's a brand of baseball that this organization has constantly held up as the gold standard over the years. However, when you look at the composition of this roster -- and the way it figures to evolve going forward -- there's no denying that the Twins are much more likely to assume Baltimore's profile. By the end of next season, the middle of Minnesota's lineup will likely be anchored by Oswaldo Arcia, Kennys Vargas and Miguel Sano -- slow-footed sluggers. Elsewhere you've got guys like Joe Mauer, Kurt Suzuki and Trevor Plouffe, who also aren't threats with their legs. Sure, there's Brian Dozier and Danny Santana, and eventually Byron Buxton. Maybe they'll add a speedster as a free agent. But barring a major shakeup or trade, the Twins aren't really going to have the personnel to execute the kind of speed-based, small-ball approach that they've so often striven for in the past. Maybe that's not such a bad thing. On the pitching side, there's good news. Neither the Orioles nor Royals have particularly strikeout-heavy staffs. Baltimore ranked 10th in the AL in K/9 rate this year, and Kansas City ranked 12th. The Twins, of course, ranked last with a miserable 6.5 K/9 rate, but the ground they need to make up to reach that level is obviously much smaller than the top tier. Therein lies the rub. The key that allowed these staffs to excel without tons of strikeouts is found in one one clear commonality between the two teams: outstanding defense. Baltimore has several high-end fielders and KC has been hailed by some as the best defensive unit to come along in years. Here's where the Twins are far, far behind. The path to returning to defensive excellence -- a longtime philosophical foundation and clearly a critical component in succeeding as a team -- is murky. As I wrote a month ago, the presence of so many slow power hitters within the offensive core makes it highly difficult to field a defense with great speed and range. To me, this overarching paradox represents the greatest roadblock to a return to contention. The Twins have the offensive pieces to score runs -- albeit more in Baltimore's style than Kansas City's -- but can they create a dynamic with their pitching staff and defense that allows them to prevent scoring in the same way as the Orioles (third-fewest runs allowed in AL) and Royals (fourth-fewest)? You've got to have power pitching or strong defense -- ideally both. But you can't have neither. This is where the identity crisis truly lies. Click here to view the article
-
What Will Be The Twins' Identity?
You can draw some similarities between the Orioles and Royals, but in many ways they are polar opposites. Baltimore is built around power. They led the majors with 211 homers and ranked last with 44 steals. Not one player on the O's roster swiped more than eight bases this season. This is a plodding, station-to-station club whose strategy is very much built around producing runs with bases-clearing hits and homers. Conversely, the Royals are all speed and no power. They ranked last in the majors in home runs (95) but first in steals (153). They barely sneaked into the playoffs but were able to shockingly sweep a 98-win Angels team with a small-ball offensive attack characterized by aggressive base-running and lots (I mean LOTS) of sacrifice bunting. I have little doubt that the Twins, at least under Ron Gardenhire, would have very much aspired to tailor themselves after the Royals. That's a brand of baseball that this organization has constantly held up as the gold standard over the years. However, when you look at the composition of this roster -- and the way it figures to evolve going forward -- there's no denying that the Twins are much more likely to assume Baltimore's profile. By the end of next season, the middle of Minnesota's lineup will likely be anchored by Oswaldo Arcia, Kennys Vargas and Miguel Sano -- slow-footed sluggers. Elsewhere you've got guys like Joe Mauer, Kurt Suzuki and Trevor Plouffe, who also aren't threats with their legs. Sure, there's Brian Dozier and Danny Santana, and eventually Byron Buxton. Maybe they'll add a speedster as a free agent. But barring a major shakeup or trade, the Twins aren't really going to have the personnel to execute the kind of speed-based, small-ball approach that they've so often striven for in the past. Maybe that's not such a bad thing. On the pitching side, there's good news. Neither the Orioles nor Royals have particularly strikeout-heavy staffs. Baltimore ranked 10th in the AL in K/9 rate this year, and Kansas City ranked 12th. The Twins, of course, ranked last with a miserable 6.5 K/9 rate, but the ground they need to make up to reach that level is obviously much smaller than the top tier. Therein lies the rub. The key that allowed these staffs to excel without tons of strikeouts is found in one one clear commonality between the two teams: outstanding defense. Baltimore has several high-end fielders and KC has been hailed by some as the best defensive unit to come along in years. Here's where the Twins are far, far behind. The path to returning to defensive excellence -- a longtime philosophical foundation and clearly a critical component in succeeding as a team -- is murky. As I wrote a month ago, the presence of so many slow power hitters within the offensive core makes it highly difficult to field a defense with great speed and range. To me, this overarching paradox represents the greatest roadblock to a return to contention. The Twins have the offensive pieces to score runs -- albeit more in Baltimore's style than Kansas City's -- but can they create a dynamic with their pitching staff and defense that allows them to prevent scoring in the same way as the Orioles (third-fewest runs allowed in AL) and Royals (fourth-fewest)? You've got to have power pitching or strong defense -- ideally both. But you can't have neither. This is where the identity crisis truly lies.
-
Latest on the Twins Manager Search
* Bob Nightengale of USA Today tweeted on Friday that "Doug Mientkiewicz has emerged as the favorite, ever so slightly over Paul Molitor." Earlier in the week, Nightengale had named Mientkiewicz and Molitor as finalists for the job. Although he's a national reporter, Nightengale has been the first to break Twins news multiple times in the past, leading me to believe he has a pretty good source within the organization. I first brought up Mientkiewicz as a managerial candidate in mid-September and reiterated my support for him last week, so I'd be pleased if they're indeed leaning in his direction. I'd also be extremely surprised, because he'd be a pretty unconventional choice. * Then again, La Velle E. Neal III of the Star Tribune tweeted later on Friday that Molitor "has had multiple interviews with the Twins." If that's true, it's hard not to view the Hall of Famer as clear front-runner. Multiple meetings within a week -- especially when they've only publicly interviewed one other candidate -- suggests aggressive interest. Of course, I believe that Molitor's real interview to be the next manager was the entire 2014 season. Some believe that was implied when he was added to Gardenhire's staff as a seventh coach. He's been in the dugout and in the clubhouse all year, so I think Twins execs have a decent idea of what to expect from him at this point. * Just because Molitor and Mientkiewicz are drawing the early press, we shouldn't assume this is a two-horse race. Jim Mandelaro, who covers the Rochester Red Wings for the Democrat & Chronicle, wrote the following last week: Glynn, like Mientkiewicz, has done an impressive job of turning around a struggling minor-league affiliate, and he worked as a scout for the exemplary Rays in the six years prior to taking over in Rochester. For those reasons, and others, I think he's one of the more intriguing names to be considered, but I wonder if the Twins would view him as a tough sell. He doesn't offer fans the familiarity of a Molitor or Mientkiewicz, nor does he offer the novelty of a name hired from outside the organization. Obviously I don't think the potential for a subdued public reaction should rule out a qualified candidate, but I do wonder how heavily that's being weighed given the waning fan interest. * What about external candidates? Terry Ryan gave his assurance that the team would be casting a wide net in its search for Gardy's replacement, and explicitly stated that they'd look outside the organization as well as within. But we've heard little buzz so far about outside names. Well, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review did report on Sunday that John Russell is expected to interview for the position. Russell (pictured above with former Twin J.J. Hardy) has served as bench coach for the Orioles since 2011, and was manager of the Pirates from 2008 through 2010. He compiled an ugly 186-299 record in his three seasons there, including a 105-loss campaign that led to his removal. Working with catchers is considered to be a speciality for Russell. That could appeal to the Twins, who will be working to determine Joe Mauer's long-term successor behind the plate. The Twins would need to wait for Baltimore's postseason run to end before they can interview Russell. That run will continue for now, after the O's completed a first-round sweep of the Tigers on Sunday. * Stay tuned to Twins Daily all week for the latest news on the Twins' manager search. We'll be on top of each new rumor as it develops.
-
Article: Latest on the Twins Manager Search
It's been less than a week since the Twins announced Ron Gardenhire's dismissal, but already there has been a dizzying whirlwind of reports and rumors regarding who might replace him as manager. Struggling to keep up? No worries. Read on and we'll get you up to speed on all the latest substantive whisperings about the team's search for a skipper successor.* Bob Nightengale of USA Today tweeted on Friday that "Doug Mientkiewicz has emerged as the favorite, ever so slightly over Paul Molitor." Earlier in the week, Nightengale had named Mientkiewicz and Molitor as finalists for the job. Although he's a national reporter, Nightengale has been the first to break Twins news multiple times in the past, leading me to believe he has a pretty good source within the organization. I first brought up Mientkiewicz as a managerial candidate in mid-September and reiterated my support for him last week, so I'd be pleased if they're indeed leaning in his direction. I'd also be extremely surprised, because he'd be a pretty unconventional choice. * Then again, La Velle E. Neal III of the Star Tribune tweeted later on Friday that Molitor "has had multiple interviews with the Twins." If that's true, it's hard not to view the Hall of Famer as clear front-runner. Multiple meetings within a week -- especially when they've only publicly interviewed one other candidate -- suggests aggressive interest. Of course, I believe that Molitor's real interview to be the next manager was the entire 2014 season. Some believe that was implied when he was added to Gardenhire's staff as a seventh coach. He's been in the dugout and in the clubhouse all year, so I think Twins execs have a decent idea of what to expect from him at this point. * Just because Molitor and Mientkiewicz are drawing the early press, we shouldn't assume this is a two-horse race. Jim Mandelaro, who covers the Rochester Red Wings for the Democrat & Chronicle, wrote the following last week: Glynn, like Mientkiewicz, has done an impressive job of turning around a struggling minor-league affiliate, and he worked as a scout for the exemplary Rays in the six years prior to taking over in Rochester. For those reasons, and others, I think he's one of the more intriguing names to be considered, but I wonder if the Twins would view him as a tough sell. He doesn't offer fans the familiarity of a Molitor or Mientkiewicz, nor does he offer the novelty of a name hired from outside the organization. Obviously I don't think the potential for a subdued public reaction should rule out a qualified candidate, but I do wonder how heavily that's being weighed given the waning fan interest. * What about external candidates? Terry Ryan gave his assurance that the team would be casting a wide net in its search for Gardy's replacement, and explicitly stated that they'd look outside the organization as well as within. But we've heard little buzz so far about outside names. Well, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review did report on Sunday that John Russell is expected to interview for the position. Russell (pictured above with former Twin J.J. Hardy) has served as bench coach for the Orioles since 2011, and was manager of the Pirates from 2008 through 2010. He compiled an ugly 186-299 record in his three seasons there, including a 105-loss campaign that led to his removal. Working with catchers is considered to be a speciality for Russell. That could appeal to the Twins, who will be working to determine Joe Mauer's long-term successor behind the plate. The Twins would need to wait for Baltimore's postseason run to end before they can interview Russell. That run will continue for now, after the O's completed a first-round sweep of the Tigers on Sunday. * Stay tuned to Twins Daily all week for the latest news on the Twins' manager search. We'll be on top of each new rumor as it develops. Click here to view the article
- Article: The Merits of Mientkiewicz and Molitor
-
Article: The Merits of Mientkiewicz and Molitor
Good comments so far. I will say that I think the most important part of the article is the last two words: "from afar." I don't know enough about either of these guys to form real strong opinions and I'm mainly just riffing on some of the more outwardly visible differences. I do think that putting tons of stock into quotes about them from minor-league players, or a passing remark about SABR and stats from a radio interview, is a little dubious. Also, personally I think awareness/acceptance of those principles is a lot more important in the process of composing a roster than managing it, but that's just me.
-
Article: The Merits of Mientkiewicz and Molitor
Last month I wrote about the potential benefits Doug Mientkiewicz could provide as the next Twins manager. At the time, I didn't really think Ron Gardenhire would be dismissed, so it was a largely hypothetical piece, but now that Mientkiewicz is actually a legitimate contender -- and maybe even a front-runner -- to lead the club in 2015, I thought I'd revisit the subject.Mientkiewicz had his formal interview for the job on Thursday, one day after Paul Molitor did the same. National ball scribe Bob Nightengale tweeted that the two former first basemen are considered finalists for the position, which isn't surprising given this team's penchant for promoting from within and the high standings of these two in the organization. I'll be honest: I'm not acutely familiar with either individual's tactical approach or managerial style (I don't think anyone is in Molitor's case, since he's never managed). But it's easy to draw some clear distinctions between the two. And as I examine those distinctions, I can't help but feel like Mientkiewicz is the far more interesting and compelling choice. In many ways, there's an old-school versus new-school dynamic at play here. Molitor, at 58, is nearly two decades older. He retired from playing in 1998, the same year Mientkiewicz made his MLB debut. In terms of experience, there's no comparison. Molitor had a much longer career as a player and has been involved in coaching and instructing since Mientkiewicz was first breaking into the league. But Molitor's distance from his playing days could be viewed as a mark against him. Obviously, the Twins' turnaround -- which hopefully will begin to take place next year -- is going to be built around youth. Will these incoming prospects be able to relate and connect with him in the same way as a guy who retired only five years ago, and who has been working directly with many of them in Ft. Myers over the last couple seasons? That's an important question, in my mind, especially when you consider that one of the most common complaints about Gardenhire (and his predecessor, Tom Kelly) was a perceived inability to recognize and maximize the impact of good young talent. Too often, it seemed that Gardy and TK would eschew the excitement and upside of a capable yet inexperienced youth in favor of the established veteran. As I see it, an ability to get the most out of young players, and a willingness to help them through struggles and learning curves, should be the foremost consideration in selecting a new skipper. I'm not saying Molitor can't excel in this area, but on the surface, Mientkiewicz appears more well equipped. There is also the matter of insularity. This is a preeminent concern for many who would like to see the organization break away from its longstanding habit of maintaining continuity and drawing from the same well when it comes to hiring coaches and execs. After four straight miserable years, people want change -- real change. It's not clear that Molitor wouldn't provide that, but he's got deep roots in Minnesota. He was a finalist to take over for Kelly in 2001 before Gardenhire landed the job, and has been involved with the Twins extensively since then. He spent one year in Seattle as a hitting coach in 2004, but then returned as a roving minor-league instructor and filled that role for nine years before being added to the major-league staff in 2014. Molitor has plenty of respect as a baseball mind, around the game and here in Minny especially, but when you look at his track record you can't help but ask questions. Why did he only last one year in Seattle? And in the decade since, how come no other team has lured him away to serve as manager or in some other prominent role? Maybe he never had interest, but why now? Mientkiewicz spent much of his playing career in Minnesota, but after being traded away in 2004, he moved through six different organizations (Red Sox, Yankees, Royals, Mets, Pirates, Dodgers) in six years. He's been around the block, and has been exposed to many different cultures and philosophies. And although he has managed the Twins' Single-A affiliate for the past two years, he hasn't worked on Gardenhire's staff. When the Twins hired Molitor into his new role a year ago, the Hall of Famer said it was possibly his "last opportunity to get back in the game at the major league level." Does a guy who, by his own admission, might be reaching the end of the rope make sense for a team seeking to modernize and break through with a crop of young talent? Even looking beyond his obvious strong points -- his fiery passion, his familiarity with the incoming prospects, his history of winning (a World Series, an Olympic title and most recently a Florida State League Championship) -- Mientkiewicz seems like the better choice for the Twins on a fundamental level. If he and Molitor are indeed the top candidates for the position, I know which one I prefer from afar. Click here to view the article
-
The Merits of Mientkiewicz and Molitor
Mientkiewicz had his formal interview for the job on Thursday, one day after Paul Molitor did the same. National ball scribe Bob Nightengale tweeted that the two former first basemen are considered finalists for the position, which isn't surprising given this team's penchant for promoting from within and the high standings of these two in the organization. I'll be honest: I'm not acutely familiar with either individual's tactical approach or managerial style (I don't think anyone is in Molitor's case, since he's never managed). But it's easy to draw some clear distinctions between the two. And as I examine those distinctions, I can't help but feel like Mientkiewicz is the far more interesting and compelling choice. In many ways, there's an old-school versus new-school dynamic at play here. Molitor, at 58, is nearly two decades older. He retired from playing in 1998, the same year Mientkiewicz made his MLB debut. In terms of experience, there's no comparison. Molitor had a much longer career as a player and has been involved in coaching and instructing since Mientkiewicz was first breaking into the league. But Molitor's distance from his playing days could be viewed as a mark against him. Obviously, the Twins' turnaround -- which hopefully will begin to take place next year -- is going to be built around youth. Will these incoming prospects be able to relate and connect with him in the same way as a guy who retired only five years ago, and who has been working directly with many of them in Ft. Myers over the last couple seasons? That's an important question, in my mind, especially when you consider that one of the most common complaints about Gardenhire (and his predecessor, Tom Kelly) was a perceived inability to recognize and maximize the impact of good young talent. Too often, it seemed that Gardy and TK would eschew the excitement and upside of a capable yet inexperienced youth in favor of the established veteran. As I see it, an ability to get the most out of young players, and a willingness to help them through struggles and learning curves, should be the foremost consideration in selecting a new skipper. I'm not saying Molitor can't excel in this area, but on the surface, Mientkiewicz appears more well equipped. There is also the matter of insularity. This is a preeminent concern for many who would like to see the organization break away from its longstanding habit of maintaining continuity and drawing from the same well when it comes to hiring coaches and execs. After four straight miserable years, people want change -- real change. It's not clear that Molitor wouldn't provide that, but he's got deep roots in Minnesota. He was a finalist to take over for Kelly in 2001 before Gardenhire landed the job, and has been involved with the Twins extensively since then. He spent one year in Seattle as a hitting coach in 2004, but then returned as a roving minor-league instructor and filled that role for nine years before being added to the major-league staff in 2014. Molitor has plenty of respect as a baseball mind, around the game and here in Minny especially, but when you look at his track record you can't help but ask questions. Why did he only last one year in Seattle? And in the decade since, how come no other team has lured him away to serve as manager or in some other prominent role? Maybe he never had interest, but why now? Mientkiewicz spent much of his playing career in Minnesota, but after being traded away in 2004, he moved through six different organizations (Red Sox, Yankees, Royals, Mets, Pirates, Dodgers) in six years. He's been around the block, and has been exposed to many different cultures and philosophies. And although he has managed the Twins' Single-A affiliate for the past two years, he hasn't worked on Gardenhire's staff. When the Twins hired Molitor into his new role a year ago, the Hall of Famer said it was possibly his "last opportunity to get back in the game at the major league level." Does a guy who, by his own admission, might be reaching the end of the rope make sense for a team seeking to modernize and break through with a crop of young talent? Even looking beyond his obvious strong points -- his fiery passion, his familiarity with the incoming prospects, his history of winning (a World Series, an Olympic title and most recently a Florida State League Championship) -- Mientkiewicz seems like the better choice for the Twins on a fundamental level. If he and Molitor are indeed the top candidates for the position, I know which one I prefer from afar.
- Article: Should the Twins Emulate the Royals?
-
Reflecting on the Ron Gardenhire Era
I remember it vividly. The year was 2004 and I was a freshman in college. I had come back to the dorms after a night class, and I parked on a couch in the common room to watch the end of an ALDS game against the Yankees. As was typical of playoff games during that era, the Twins had squandered an early lead and they wilted in the late innings. In this case the management from Gardenhire was especially baffling. You might remember this particular game. A plainly overmatched rookie named Jason Kubel went 0-for-6 while Lew Ford (who was in prime "LEWWW!" form) sat on the bench. Joe Nathan was sent out to pitch a third inning of relief after the Twins had taken a 12th-inning lead, and he coughed up the game while running on fumes. I was so mad at the decision-making that I went back to my dorm and typed out some angry post full of vitriol about Gardy on whatever Blogspot thing I had at the time. I found it cathartic, and some friends seemed to get a kick out reading of it. I was 18 then. It was a decade ago, damn near exactly. The next spring I started an actual blog with a friend, and over the years I stuck with it, continuing to cover the team on a platform that continually evolved into what you read here today. Through all those seasons, the manager of the team I covered was always the same guy. Gardenhire held the position for 13 years. That's pretty crazy. His was the second-longest active tenure in the majors. Across the rest of baseball, only five current managers have had their jobs for more than five years. As I grew from dumb teenager into slightly-less-dumb adult, and developed from amateur blogger dude into occasionally-credentialed pseudo-media member, the lens through which I viewed Gardenhire changed dramatically. Reading his quotes on a screen, I would often perceive an air of smugness, small-mindedness and maybe even pettiness. His snide comments about digital media, in particular, sometimes struck me that way. But when you sit in a room with the man, and you hear him playfully bash "dot-com" along with anything else he can set his sights on, you see it in a different light. He's folksy. He's sarcastic. He's a master of deadpanning. And yeah, he's old school. But while he might not always understand the changing dynamics of the way the game is covered and analyzed, at the end of the day, he gets it. That's the thing that stuck with me on Monday afternoon as I watched the press conference held by the organization to announce Gardenhire's dismissal. He gets it. Despite all the good arguments I've read over the past couple weeks explaining why Gardy might be on the way out, I had a hard time taking them seriously. I just couldn't picture this particular press conference playing out. And how could anyone have pictured what actually ended up transpiring? Here you had Gardenhire, sitting next to the man who had just fired him, cracking jokes and pleasantly answering questions about his termination. It was bizarre. It shouldn't have been bizarre, though. In fact, as I watched it unfold, I found myself wondering why more teams and managers can't part so amiably. Usually the firing of an executive or coach is an awkward and drama-filled affair, but there wasn't a shred of contention in the room Monday. Gardy confessed that he would like to keep managing and would have preferred to do it here, but said he understands the situation and the need to move on. He acknowledged that "sometimes people need to hear a different voice." That's a rare level of self-awareness. People can justifiably complain about the culture of the Twins being overly chummy, and loyal to a fault; in many ways Gardenhire's tenure -- and certainly his departure -- embodied that. But when the team on the other side of downtown is holding bumbling press conferences about child abuse, it's refreshing to watch a strangely amicable presser like the one that took place at Target Field this week. At the end of the day, I think this was the right move, and I agree with Gardy. A different voice is probably needed -- hopefully one that is a little more in-tune with analytics and modern game strategy theory. But I will miss the guy. He's been the skipper ever since I truly started paying attention to the Twins, and it's going to be weird analyzing decisions and dissecting quotes from someone different. Gardenhire represented a longstanding continuity in the organization, one which will be shaken to the very core in the likely event that most of the coaching staff is replaced. I tend to think that a manager's impact on game outcomes is generally overstated, but certainly, the identity of this club is going to change. Maybe for the better. That's intriguing -- not just to me and the hardcores, but to the general public. This is what the Twins needed right now. We'll see where they take it from here.
-
Article: Reflecting on the Ron Gardenhire Era
It's ironic when you consider his views on blogs and online coverage in general, but really, Ron Gardenhire was the one who first inspired me to start writing about the Twins.I remember it vividly. The year was 2004 and I was a freshman in college. I had come back to the dorms after a night class, and I parked on a couch in the common room to watch the end of an ALDS game against the Yankees. As was typical of playoff games during that era, the Twins had squandered an early lead and they wilted in the late innings. In this case the management from Gardenhire was especially baffling. You might remember this particular game. A plainly overmatched rookie named Jason Kubel went 0-for-6 while Lew Ford (who was in prime "LEWWW!" form) sat on the bench. Joe Nathan was sent out to pitch a third inning of relief after the Twins had taken a 12th-inning lead, and he coughed up the game while running on fumes. I was so mad at the decision-making that I went back to my dorm and typed out some angry post full of vitriol about Gardy on whatever Blogspot thing I had at the time. I found it cathartic, and some friends seemed to get a kick out reading of it. I was 18 then. It was a decade ago, damn near exactly. The next spring I started an actual blog with a friend, and over the years I stuck with it, continuing to cover the team on a platform that continually evolved into what you read here today. Through all those seasons, the manager of the team I covered was always the same guy. Gardenhire held the position for 13 years. That's pretty crazy. His was the second-longest active tenure in the majors. Across the rest of baseball, only five current managers have had their jobs for more than five years. As I grew from dumb teenager into slightly-less-dumb adult, and developed from amateur blogger dude into occasionally-credentialed pseudo-media member, the lens through which I viewed Gardenhire changed dramatically. Reading his quotes on a screen, I would often perceive an air of smugness, small-mindedness and maybe even pettiness. His snide comments about digital media, in particular, sometimes struck me that way. But when you sit in a room with the man, and you hear him playfully bash "dot-com" along with anything else he can set his sights on, you see it in a different light. He's folksy. He's sarcastic. He's a master of deadpanning. And yeah, he's old school. But while he might not always understand the changing dynamics of the way the game is covered and analyzed, at the end of the day, he gets it. That's the thing that stuck with me on Monday afternoon as I watched the press conference held by the organization to announce Gardenhire's dismissal. He gets it. Despite all the good arguments I've read over the past couple weeks explaining why Gardy might be on the way out, I had a hard time taking them seriously. I just couldn't picture this particular press conference playing out. And how could anyone have pictured what actually ended up transpiring? Here you had Gardenhire, sitting next to the man who had just fired him, cracking jokes and pleasantly answering questions about his termination. It was bizarre. It shouldn't have been bizarre, though. In fact, as I watched it unfold, I found myself wondering why more teams and managers can't part so amiably. Usually the firing of an executive or coach is an awkward and drama-filled affair, but there wasn't a shred of contention in the room Monday. Gardy confessed that he would like to keep managing and would have preferred to do it here, but said he understands the situation and the need to move on. He acknowledged that "sometimes people need to hear a different voice." That's a rare level of self-awareness. People can justifiably complain about the culture of the Twins being overly chummy, and loyal to a fault; in many ways Gardenhire's tenure -- and certainly his departure -- embodied that. But when the team on the other side of downtown is holding bumbling press conferences about child abuse, it's refreshing to watch a strangely amicable presser like the one that took place at Target Field this week. At the end of the day, I think this was the right move, and I agree with Gardy. A different voice is probably needed -- hopefully one that is a little more in-tune with analytics and modern game strategy theory. But I will miss the guy. He's been the skipper ever since I truly started paying attention to the Twins, and it's going to be weird analyzing decisions and dissecting quotes from someone different. Gardenhire represented a longstanding continuity in the organization, one which will be shaken to the very core in the likely event that most of the coaching staff is replaced. I tend to think that a manager's impact on game outcomes is generally overstated, but certainly, the identity of this club is going to change. Maybe for the better. That's intriguing -- not just to me and the hardcores, but to the general public. This is what the Twins needed right now. We'll see where they take it from here. Click here to view the article
-
Article: Should the Twins Emulate the Royals?
I'm going to say yes. Even if the strategy didn't result in a World Series, or even a deep playoff run, what the Royals have accomplished is a return to relevancy. They've recaptured the interest of fans who had turned away during a decade of losing. They have proven that they're willing to take bold steps to get to the next level rather than constantly playing the safe route. There's value in that. The Twins, at this time, should recognize that as much as anyone.
-
Article: Should the Twins Emulate the Royals?
On Friday night, the Kansas City Royals clinched a playoff spot for the first time in 29 years. It will be a short postseason appearance if they can't beat the Athletics on Tuesday, but finally KC has emerged from the void. The Twins, now coming off their fourth straight "rebuilding year" where little progress was shown in the win/loss column, are becoming familiar with a dynamic that characterized the Royals throughout their lengthy drought: the moving goalpost. A finish line that inches further away as you race toward it.While wallowing near the bottom of the AL Central and perpetually searching for a way out, the Royals often sported an impressive collection of minor-league talent. Understandably, they tended to be protective of those assets, considering them the lifeblood of their rebuilding process. But, as tends to be the case, things didn't always work out. Rising stars fizzled along the way. Injuries struck. Prospects that were expected to be cornerstones ended up being merely 'OK.' A batter is considered successful if he gets a hit three out of every ten trips to the plate. As much as we'd like to believe otherwise, player development isn't a whole lot different. The Twins have a soundly designed plan to return to relevancy, but it is a plan based around uncertainties. I think they were rather unlucky this year with the major injuries to their two best prospects, but setbacks and side-tracks in the minors are nothing out of the norm. No matter what kind of stats and scouting reports you print out, you just never know what you have until a player reaches the majors, and even then it usually takes a while to get a clear picture. At one point it appeared that the Royals would tailor an effective rebuild around Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas, who a few years ago were both considered elite young talents at the level we currently view Byron Buxon and Miguel Sano. Both Hosmer and Moustakas took much longer than anticipated to develop. And this year, while they each contributed in Kansas City's strong season, neither has been all that great. Instead, it is the pitching staff that has been key to the franchise's revival, and leading that staff is the guy who they'll turn to on Tuesday night: James Shields. The Royals, of course, acquired Shields two years ago in a deal that was highly controversial and widely criticized. In order to acquire the frontline starter from Tampa Bay, Kansas City had to part with a premium package of prospects headlined by Wil Myers, who was considered a Top 5 player in the minors. The move was kind of baffling. The Royals were coming off a 90-loss season and hadn't won more than 75 games in a decade. What were they doing trading their best prospect -- a major-league ready star in the making -- for a 30-year-old whose impact figured to be immediate and short-lived? It's worked out well enough. The Royals won 86 games last year and 89 this year, their two highest totals since 1990. And through all of that, Shields has performed exactly as advertised -- a durable, inning-eating ace, setting the example in a rotation that has seen incredible improvement. It's hard to look at Kansas City's reemergence and not wonder about the Twins. Most around here recognize the importance of homegrown talent, and we're reminded of the upside offered by that talent regularly, but there's something to be said about the boldness of Dayton Moore's dramatic shift in approach and the results that have been yielded. Various injury concerns surround some of the top prospects, but Minnesota's system still contains a number of young players that would be highly appealing to other clubs, particularly in this age of skyrocketing free agent salaries. How protective should Terry Ryan be of guys like Sano, Buxton, Alex Meyer and Jose Berrios? For that matter, what about those that have already successfully debuted, like Oswaldo Arcia, Kennys Vargas and Danny Santana? I'm not entirely sure where I fall on the subject. I can see the wisdom of both sides, but as I examine the lengthy stagnant cycles that have plagued organizations like the Royals, and as I size up the marketability problems being faced by the Twins, I must admit that I find myself questioning the conservative route. Click here to view the article
-
Should the Twins Emulate the Royals?
While wallowing near the bottom of the AL Central and perpetually searching for a way out, the Royals often sported an impressive collection of minor-league talent. Understandably, they tended to be protective of those assets, considering them the lifeblood of their rebuilding process. But, as tends to be the case, things didn't always work out. Rising stars fizzled along the way. Injuries struck. Prospects that were expected to be cornerstones ended up being merely 'OK.' A batter is considered successful if he gets a hit three out of every ten trips to the plate. As much as we'd like to believe otherwise, player development isn't a whole lot different. The Twins have a soundly designed plan to return to relevancy, but it is a plan based around uncertainties. I think they were rather unlucky this year with the major injuries to their two best prospects, but setbacks and side-tracks in the minors are nothing out of the norm. No matter what kind of stats and scouting reports you print out, you just never know what you have until a player reaches the majors, and even then it usually takes a while to get a clear picture. At one point it appeared that the Royals would tailor an effective rebuild around Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas, who a few years ago were both considered elite young talents at the level we currently view Byron Buxon and Miguel Sano. Both Hosmer and Moustakas took much longer than anticipated to develop. And this year, while they each contributed in Kansas City's strong season, neither has been all that great. Instead, it is the pitching staff that has been key to the franchise's revival, and leading that staff is the guy who they'll turn to on Tuesday night: James Shields. The Royals, of course, acquired Shields two years ago in a deal that was highly controversial and widely criticized. In order to acquire the frontline starter from Tampa Bay, Kansas City had to part with a premium package of prospects headlined by Wil Myers, who was considered a Top 5 player in the minors. The move was kind of baffling. The Royals were coming off a 90-loss season and hadn't won more than 75 games in a decade. What were they doing trading their best prospect -- a major-league ready star in the making -- for a 30-year-old whose impact figured to be immediate and short-lived? It's worked out well enough. The Royals won 86 games last year and 89 this year, their two highest totals since 1990. And through all of that, Shields has performed exactly as advertised -- a durable, inning-eating ace, setting the example in a rotation that has seen incredible improvement. It's hard to look at Kansas City's reemergence and not wonder about the Twins. Most around here recognize the importance of homegrown talent, and we're reminded of the upside offered by that talent regularly, but there's something to be said about the boldness of Dayton Moore's dramatic shift in approach and the results that have been yielded. Various injury concerns surround some of the top prospects, but Minnesota's system still contains a number of young players that would be highly appealing to other clubs, particularly in this age of skyrocketing free agent salaries. How protective should Terry Ryan be of guys like Sano, Buxton, Alex Meyer and Jose Berrios? For that matter, what about those that have already successfully debuted, like Oswaldo Arcia, Kennys Vargas and Danny Santana? I'm not entirely sure where I fall on the subject. I can see the wisdom of both sides, but as I examine the lengthy stagnant cycles that have plagued organizations like the Royals, and as I size up the marketability problems being faced by the Twins, I must admit that I find myself questioning the conservative route.
-
Article: The Twins Have a Problem
It's not a bad idea in theory but is it actually plausible? Nolasco and Hughes will be there because of contracts and (in Hughes' case) performance. Gibson will be there. So if you sign two more impact pitchers who are highly paid and guaranteed spots, there's no room for May or Meyer, or Berrios when he's ready (maybe as soon as the AS break). The Twins aren't going to spend nine figures to get one of the top starters on the market, so the "impact" arms they'd be adding would probably be in the Nolasco range, and as we know all too well, there's no assurance with those guys. Maybe no more so than Meyer or May.
-
Article: The Twins Have a Problem
This is a great question that is probably worth exploring with a full article. I know exactly what you mean. I went to a game with my mom this summer -- a particularly bad game -- and I was getting so irritated with what was happening on the field that I kinda started snapping at her and acting crabby. The next day I felt horrible about my behavior and had to call her and apologize. But it is tough to continually watch a team you care about play so, so poorly.
-
The Twins Have a Problem
This season ticket group was a bunch of hardcore Twins fans, especially the actual seat-holders. But even they could no longer justify the cost, especially at a time where all games after July consistently carry no level of drama or intrigue. It's a drain. The new ballpark honeymoon period has passed, and now there's going to be a newer stadium over in St. Paul. The All-Star Game has come and gone. The Twins now have to rely more than ever on the quality of their product on the field and, for yet another season, that product has been flat-out lousy. It's not just that this team is bad. They're worse than bad. This is going to be their fourth straight finish with a bottom-five W/L record in the majors. While you can point at several individual positive developments, and numerous unfortunate setbacks that weren't really controllable, the bottom line is that there have been no tangible signs of progress. The Twins will finish with fewer losses than last year, but barely. We've already seen the attendance decline take effect. They're currently at about 2.2 million through the gate this year, so they're going to fall short of their last year at the Metrodome (2.4 million in 2009). If my parents' season ticket group, along with several others I've been hearing about, are any indication, that decline is only going to steepen. The Twins need to do something to jolt the fan base and stir some kind of buzz. But a big roster shakeup doesn't seem to be in the plans; there just aren't many areas where it's realistic to expect major additions. A change in leadership would at least signal a dissatisfaction with the stagnant results and a sense of urgency to get things going, but that also does not seem to be in the plans. Terry Ryan, based on everything I've heard, is entrenched in his position as long as he wants it. Ryan hinted that Ron Gardenhire will also be back next year, and while the team later backed off that statement a bit, it's probably accurate. All the assistant coaches are on one-year deals, and thus facing renewal or removal, so I would guess we'll see some turnover there. It should probably start with Rick Anderson. But the last staff shakeup was little more than a rearrangement. And is the shuffling of assistant coaches really going to strike any skeptical season ticket renewer as a sufficient overhaul? I, personally, can see the light for the Twins. I follow closely enough to know that they were set back by a number of unfortunate events in the minors this year, and that a sizable wave of premium talent is heading this way (or already developing on the field). I do think this young core can succeed with the existing leadership in place, because I mostly trust Ryan and I don't think Gardy matters much one way or the other. But the majority of fans don't follow as closely as I, or most readers of this blog. Most casual fans I talk to can barely identify with the team anymore, and have only faintly heard the names Byron Buxton and Miguel Sano. And right or wrong, this organization's constant commitment to loyalty, promoting from within, and sticking with the guys they like in the face of historically awful results comes off to many as arrogant and insular. There's a reason that a recent rose-colored marketing survey has been nationally criticized as tone-deaf and absurd. The Twins say they get it, but do they? "They're always one year away," my co-worker grumbled over lunch the other day while I was trying to emphasize the quality of the young players who are -- hopefully -- on the verge of arriving and changing this pitiful culture. It's hard to disagree. And in fact "one year away" might seem generous with the complete lack of progress that we've seen in three straight. Until that magical turnaround season finally comes, how many more fans can the team afford to lose to disinterest while steadfastly staying the course? At what point do major changes become a business necessity rather than a strategic decision? I don't know the answer, but what I can say is this: The dwindling crowds at the ballpark, the stagnating traffic and activity on sites like ours, and the increasingly ambivalent attitudes of local baseball fans that I encounter all clearly signify that the Twins are fading from the public sports consciousness to an alarming degree.
-
Article: The Twins Have a Problem
For the past several years, my parents have been part of a season ticket group, buying 10 games from a full 81-game package along with several other parties. The couple running the group has been season ticket holders for a long, long time, and they had worked their way into some pretty prime seats on the lower deck, directly behind home plate and just beneath the overhang. I enjoyed this arrangement because invariably I would be invited to use one or both tickets several times per year. But a couple weeks ago my dad called me with a message that didn't come as a total surprise: "They're not renewing the tickets." When I heard that news, I immediately thought to myself, "This team is in trouble."This season ticket group was a bunch of hardcore Twins fans, especially the actual seat-holders. But even they could no longer justify the cost, especially at a time where all games after July consistently carry no level of drama or intrigue. It's a drain. The new ballpark honeymoon period has passed, and now there's going to be a newer stadium over in St. Paul. The All-Star Game has come and gone. The Twins now have to rely more than ever on the quality of their product on the field and, for yet another season, that product has been flat-out lousy. It's not just that this team is bad. They're worse than bad. This is going to be their fourth straight finish with a bottom-five W/L record in the majors. While you can point at several individual positive developments, and numerous unfortunate setbacks that weren't really controllable, the bottom line is that there have been no tangible signs of progress. The Twins will finish with fewer losses than last year, but barely. We've already seen the attendance decline take effect. They're currently at about 2.2 million through the gate this year, so they're going to fall short of their last year at the Metrodome (2.4 million in 2009). If my parents' season ticket group, along with several others I've been hearing about, are any indication, that decline is only going to steepen. The Twins need to do something to jolt the fan base and stir some kind of buzz. But a big roster shakeup doesn't seem to be in the plans; there just aren't many areas where it's realistic to expect major additions. A change in leadership would at least signal a dissatisfaction with the stagnant results and a sense of urgency to get things going, but that also does not seem to be in the plans. Terry Ryan, based on everything I've heard, is entrenched in his position as long as he wants it. Ryan hinted that Ron Gardenhire will also be back next year, and while the team later backed off that statement a bit, it's probably accurate. All the assistant coaches are on one-year deals, and thus facing renewal or removal, so I would guess we'll see some turnover there. It should probably start with Rick Anderson. But the last staff shakeup was little more than a rearrangement. And is the shuffling of assistant coaches really going to strike any skeptical season ticket renewer as a sufficient overhaul? I, personally, can see the light for the Twins. I follow closely enough to know that they were set back by a number of unfortunate events in the minors this year, and that a sizable wave of premium talent is heading this way (or already developing on the field). I do think this young core can succeed with the existing leadership in place, because I mostly trust Ryan and I don't think Gardy matters much one way or the other. But the majority of fans don't follow as closely as I, or most readers of this blog. Most casual fans I talk to can barely identify with the team anymore, and have only faintly heard the names Byron Buxton and Miguel Sano. And right or wrong, this organization's constant commitment to loyalty, promoting from within, and sticking with the guys they like in the face of historically awful results comes off to many as arrogant and insular. There's a reason that a recent rose-colored marketing survey has been nationally criticized as tone-deaf and absurd. The Twins say they get it, but do they? "They're always one year away," my co-worker grumbled over lunch the other day while I was trying to emphasize the quality of the young players who are -- hopefully -- on the verge of arriving and changing this pitiful culture. It's hard to disagree. And in fact "one year away" might seem generous with the complete lack of progress that we've seen in three straight. Until that magical turnaround season finally comes, how many more fans can the team afford to lose to disinterest while steadfastly staying the course? At what point do major changes become a business necessity rather than a strategic decision? I don't know the answer, but what I can say is this: The dwindling crowds at the ballpark, the stagnating traffic and activity on sites like ours, and the increasingly ambivalent attitudes of local baseball fans that I encounter all clearly signify that the Twins are fading from the public sports consciousness to an alarming degree. Click here to view the article
-
Where Does Pelfrey Fit In?
It's easy to see why Pelfrey isn't popular among the Twins faithful. He was a mediocre pitcher in the National League before being signed. He hasn't pitched well here. He works slowly on the mound and his starts tend to drag on. More than that, the Twins' dealings with him have been emblematic of what frustrates a lot of folks about the way this team operates -- too much of a cater-to-the-player, bargain-seeking approach. When they initially signed him, they got him at a bargain price because he was coming off elbow surgery and few other teams wanted to risk relying on a player who was in recovery mode. His $4 million deal was one of the cheapest guaranteed contracts for a starting pitcher during that offseason, at a time where the Twins desperately needed quality arms. And this past winter, when they re-signed him, it was difficult to view his contract as anything other than a favor to a guy they liked. Who else was going to give Pelfrey multiple years coming off 13 losses and a 5.19 ERA, when he was never that great to begin with? I can certainly agree with those critiques, but at the same time, I think the negativity I see directed toward Pelf is over-the-top. His struggles early on in the 2013 season were completely predictable following his insanely rapid return from Tommy John, but in the final three months of the season he was solid: 4.39 ERA, 2-to-1 K/BB, just six homers allowed in 15 starts. I saw a lot of people using Pelfrey's poor start this year as justification for their complaints about his contract, and it always struck me as disingenuous. He was never healthy. If he was healthy and pitched badly, you could say the Twins screwed up, but I still believe that the guy we saw in the second half last season could be a decent value at $5.5 million as a fifth starter. Whether the Twins should have really been aiming for a fifth starter is another matter, of course, but that's all in the past so there's no use sulking about it now. The question, at this point, is what kind of value he can provide next year. If things proceed as planned, it's tough to see how he fits into the starting rotation. You have to assume that Phil Hughes, Ricky Nolasco and Kyle Gibson will all enter camp as locks. Trevor May should get a spot as long as he's not a mess during spring training. Alex Meyer should be in position to win a spot as well. He'll be 25 with a full year of Triple-A under his belt; it's time to let him roll. Factor in Tommy Milone, who should at least be in the mix, and there doesn't appear to be much room for Mr. Pelfrey. I don't think it's fair to penalize him for getting hurt, but he just hasn't done anything to earn a look over the younger guys. The best route -- and one the Twins have to be considering -- might be moving the 6'7" righty into a relief role. It actually makes a ton of sense. Too much sense. He's basically a one-trick pony, but that fastball he throws 80 percent of the time could be more of weapon with a few extra ticks of velocity. And with the way things have played out late in this season, it looks like the Twins may need some new blood in the bullpen next year. When not injured, Pelfrey has proven to have a durable and resilient arm (he basically never missed a start from 2008 through 2011), so he could turn into a guy they can use for multiple innings, or several days in a row. That has value. If he blossoms in that role, Pelfrey could easily be worth the $5.5 million they pay him next year. And he might uncover a new path for success in the second half of his career.
- Article: Where Does Pelfrey Fit In?
-
Article: Where Does Pelfrey Fit In?
Parker and I participated in a wiffleball tournament at Target Field on Sunday morning, while the Twins were playing out of town, and Pelfrey was out on the field playing long toss while the wiffle games were going on in the outfield. So he's definitely throwing and working out at the stadium. His surgery took place in June and had like a four-month return timetable, so he'd probably be getting pretty close if the season weren't ending. You're not intrigued at all by the thought of Pelfrey in the bullpen? Not enough to even give it a shot? Seems silly to sign him to a two-year deal and then cut him because he got hurt the first year. He should be all systems go next spring.