Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
3 Twins Players Set to Bounce Back in 2022
I just threw up in my mouth a little bit with those options at short. A 32 year old, who has never played in the bigs, Gordon who they don't trust there in a lost season. Palacios a 25 year old in AA, Polanco who should be a second baseman and a Lewis who hasn't played a game in two years coming off an ACL.
-
Who is your top position player FA target?
Chris Taylor, he can play just about anywhere on defense, he would be a good guy to have start the year in LF, and if Larnach forces his way up, he can become a super utility guy. ( he basically has played every where for the Dodgers this year) Plus he strikes out quite a bit, and the FO seems to love guys that that.
-
How quickly we Forget
My guess is that because he is 25 years old, they thought he only had two good or better pitches, had to be put on the 40 this off season, he wasn't even in their top 10 prospects and most importantly wanted the best hitting guy available on the market so they over paid a bit. Also and I could be wrong with this, they don't seem to load up their 40 man with aging prospects.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
I like your thinking, what in your opinion would be the back up old fielder plan? Celestino seems obvious, and maybe Rooker? So do they load up AAA with minor league vets? IMO they start somebody like a Garlick (right handed fairly cheap guy) for left field, and have Larnach as the back up plan waiting in the wings in AAA.
-
Trade Retrospective: Who Won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil Trade?
If you want to say the front office has done a terrible job in general with trades, you will not get an argument from me. I was just looking at this trade by itself, because the topic was who won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil trade, and IMO I can't say how any trade where one teams gets more major league WAR over the other team getting 25 innings pitched years later goes to the 25 innings pitched team, not at this point anyway, maybe next year Gil turns into a reliable relief pitcher or even better than that, then the Yanks probably win the trade, but I would make that type of trade every time, The twins signed him in 2015 and they just now would be getting a guy to the majors that twice hasn't been drafted in rule 5. compared to a guy that has already had two decent or better years in the majors, a OK year, and a terrible year.
-
Trade Retrospective: Who Won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil Trade?
Because for every Gil or Ynoa, there are dozens of others that fail, Stewart, Jay, Gonzo, Romero, Meyer, and on and on and on. If you are a contending team and there is a player you think could help you win, you can trade those young pitchers because the odds of them becoming even a fairly reliable relief pitcher so super low. Now I am not saying you trade a Chase Perry to another team because they are having a hard time finding a 40 man spot for, but do I trade Perry for the right controllable pitcher, yup. Remember when people on here were complaining or worried about trading Chih-Wei Hu after his first 10 innings in TB?
- One Buy Low Candidate to Solve Minnesota’s Shortstop Need
-
Trade Retrospective: Who Won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil Trade?
So only trade minor league pitchers that have proven they aren't what you are looking for (not sure that is how to get decent players from other team trading for your garbage) Not sure what Ynoa has to do with a Gil/Cave trade, unless your are saying this FO shouldn't have a job, there are a bunch of other threads complaining about them. (also Littell was a huge part of a division championship, Ynoa has less than 100 MLB innings, lets see how that works out) I will say this is the kind of trade the Twins need to do the opposite way, when you have a 40 man crunch you trade for a young high end prospect. (That is one of the reasons the Rays gave up Strotman) I wasn't afraid when the Twins traded Gil, and I am not worried going forward they traded him, if he turns out to be a star, good for him, the FO did something they needed to do, and that was upgrade the major league team.
-
Trade Retrospective: Who Won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil Trade?
The Cave that had a WAR of 1.5 in 2018 in 91 games, the Cave that had a .9 WAR in 72 games, even last year had a .3 in 42 games. That is better than replacement level. Wade played some in 19 and 20 in was negative in the WAR or 0. I am not a really a fan of Cave, but he played a role in two divisions champions that was statistically better than replacement. From what I can tell I can't find a prospect list that had him even in the top 50 for the Twins prior to being traded. He has walked 165 guys in 284 minor league innings, he has walked 15 in his first 25 major league innings. This year e pitched in AA started 7 games for 30 innings with 13 walks, lots of K's and a decent 3.23 ERA. He started in AAA 10 times and pitched in 11 games, 46.1, 28 walks with a 4.66 ERA. If these aren't the type of pitchers you trade, who the heck can you trade and expect to get anything back for.
-
Trade Retrospective: Who Won the Jake Cave/Luis Gil Trade?
The Twins got 3 years of plus WAR, while winning two Division titles. The Yanks have gotten 25 MLB innings. As of today it isn't even close the Twins have won the first 3 years, this year is a draw unless Gill continues to pitch well. Going forward is more than likely the Yanks, but it is the kind of trade you do when you are trying to win.
-
Game Score: Royals 5, Twins 3
I was surprised to see that Do-Hyoung Park didn't tweet out that Ober extended his less than 3 earned runs to 10 games. But the writer of the article did and he actually got the number wrong. I will say this again, I like Ober and think he has a real chance to be a major league starter but saying he had a strong performance is ridiculous, his ERA for this game was 6.24 and you don't get to take out the first six batters There were definitely things to like in his last two starts, 0 walks, 10 K's in 8 innings, and 11 hits in those innings are good as well. Hopefully next year he can deeper into games and these results translate in another inning or three. IMO any starting pitcher that pitches 5 or less innings and gives up more than 2 earned runs should not be considered a good start.
-
OPINION: The ‘Fire Falvine’ talk should stop (for now)
Seems pretty simple to me, if they have that record, and Winder, Duran, Balazovic, Ryan, Ober or at least two of them look like 2/3 starters going into 2023, Larnach figures it out and Lewis returns and it really good (whatever level that is) and Miranda and Martin are at least respectable and look like they have a future they keep their job. But if it looks like they are going into 2023 with the same question marks at pitching like they are going into 2022 they gone.
-
Which Prospect Anchors 2022's Rotation?
Winder has pitched 72 innings this yer, 0 in 2020, 125.2 in 2019, and a combined 123.2 in 2018. Expecting him next year to pitch anything more than about 100 is unrealistic, plus the odds are he will start in AAA next year, so my expectation of him are hopefully next year will be this years Ober. 20 -25 starts combined averaging 5 innings per start.
-
Game Score: Minnesota 5, Cleveland 2
Man it is sad how far the Twins have fallen that actual reportrts find this to be big news "Bailey Ober has now allowed 3 or fewer earned runs in 9 consecutive starts." When out of those 9 starts, twice were 4 innings starts, and has averaged 5.07 innings in those starts, don't get me wrong I love what he has done, and I totally get the inning and pitch count stuff, but come on. Compare what he has done to say Robby Ray in the last 8 games, Never more than 2 earned runs, while never pitching less than 6 innings, once finishing 8, 3 times finishing 7, three 6, and lastly 6.2. It is sad we have this to get excited about.
-
Did the FO misevaluate their pitching additions?
I don't think they missed as much on the Free agents, as they did on the the internal options being ready and/or not injured. Sure Shoemaker sucked but everybody had to be thinking there was better than a 50% chance of that happening .Happ was a little worse than expected, but they had to no back up plan if that happened, (I assume it was WInder and Duran, but that didn't work out well), then they were onto plan C,D,E,etc... Imagine next year pitching if they have to moved onto plan C,D,E.....
-
Minor League Report 9/4 Simeon Woods Richardson Debuts
I was hoping Winder would get up this year, so maybe he could help next year, but I don't see him being a very viable option for next year (at least the first half) if he doesn't pitch again this year.
-
The Twins Shouldn't Spend (Much) On Starting Pitching This Offseason
Personally if they want to go young pitchers, they for sure will have to sign some one year vets to fill innings, currently I have seen the names of around 15 rookie (or Jax, Ober, Dodnak) names mentioned, can a major league team really carry 15 rookie type starting pitchers on their 40 man? Seems unlikely, sure some will get hurt, but that mean other retreads or rookies filling in. And then why sign Buxton over the winter, because if these pitchers don't pan out, what good is he to have around on a rebuild? what if the likes of Balazovi,c, Duran, Strotman, Ryan, etc.. have years like Ober had this year, does that guarantee anything for 2023? To me, it means we have some good depth and can sign a high end Free Agent but it kind of makes 2023 a crap shoot also, but I think they can sign a free agent this year. To me this off season and 2022 will show if this FO is around in 2023, I hope Rocco is gone after this season, but that is another topic.
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
If the FO feels 2022 is a development year, what good is paying Donaldson 21 million each of the next two years, Sano 9.25 next year with an option for 14 million in 2023 which it sounds like there is no chance of picking up. Also we love to talk about trading people at their peak on TD, Will Polanco's peak be any higher than this off season? Also, I say good luck to the Pohlad's with fans in the stands next year, especially if Buxton is not extended.
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
The question I would have and you didn't address, was. You have told us your plan the last few years was sustained success, now you are coming to me with a plan for sustained success in the future. You asked us to spend 92 million on Donaldson, 6.25 on Colume, 30 million on Sano, 2 on Shoemaker and 8 on Happ to get us though this year, and you traded our best pitching prospect (Graterol) for a veteran pitcher. The only unexpected things that happened this year that affects next year are: Maeda is lost for next year and some of the prospects got hurt that you thought MIGHT be able to help us next year. What happens next year if Winder, Duran, Balazovic, Strotman, Woods Richardson, Ober and others get hurt again or aren't as good as you are expecting? Are you going to come to me next year and tell me you need punt on 2023? If 2022 is a more than likely a lost year and 2023 is based on prospects, why not cut my loses and trade Donaldson, Sano, Kepler and Polanco. The only one of that group that has a contract for 2024 is Kepler?
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
Did you see the post I was responding to? It said "it's going to be a lost year. " And I said "If the FO thinks this way", I didn't say I thought it was a lost year and I don't believe it should be. And if they think 2022 is a lost year and time to get all the prospects up, then they wouldn't have sustained success, that would be two lost years, and if those prospects don't turn out as advertised, 2023 and beyond could be lost as well. But if your opinion is go cheap next year because the year is lost, and don't think they should trade everybody, that's great because it is your opinion, I wouldn't call you simplistic or crude. Missed this the first time I posted. I said "put a contending team on the field consistently" and you turned that into "put a contending team on the field every year". In my simplistic/crude mind: put a contending team on the field consistently = sustained success
-
Envisioning a Good Twins Rotation in 2022 (For Real!)
If the FO thinks this way, they should trade everybody possible on the team. Kepler, Garver, Sano, Donaldson, Polanco, Arreaz, all of them and start over, second they should come out publicly and admit they were wrong in their ability to put a contending team on the field consistently (that is what they promised was it not?)
-
Who Will Be the Twins Top Prospect in 2023?
I thought AK had his surgery in 17, spent 18 in A and A+, 19 in AA, and was called up 9/2020? Sano had his in 14 and was called up from AA in 15, after 66 games and hitting .269, with 18 doubles and 15 homers with a .918 OPS. Sano and AK were far superior hitting prospects to Lewis, Lewis career minor league OPS is .740, Sano's .932, and AK .869. So unless Royce comes back and does stuff he never has done in the minors or continues to absolutely rake like he did in the fall league I don't see he coming up next year, on top of playing great defense, which could be hard playing SS after coming back from TJ. IMO I guess if the FO totally blows a back up plan for the outfield, Lewis could be forced to come up and play OF since his will be on the 40.
-
Twins Daily Minnesota Twins Starting Pitcher of the Month - August 2021
To me it is Ober and it really isn't close. 5 starts, 3 of them he started pitching the 6th inning, two of them he completed the 6th, and all of them finished 5 innings. Something he has not been able to prior to August. He has learned to get more out of his 70/80 pitches as the season has went on.
- Who Will Be the Twins Top Prospect in 2023?
-
Who Will Be the Twins Top Prospect in 2023?
Canterino will turn 25 December 14 2022, I really like him and think he has a to be a shut down relief pitcher, or maybe a really good starter, but if the #1 prospect in the organization is a 25 year old (3 year college draft pick) that to me throws up huge red flags for an organization. I personally see it being Royce Lewis, IMO I find it hard to believe he is going to come back next year and be so amazing after all that time off that he forces the Twins to call him up, or he is good and the team is terrible again. I really hope it is either Simeon Woods Richardson or Chase Petty. Or maybe Urbina, I personally like to see the top guys being around age 20/21, meaning they have done great prior and are projected to make an impact in the next year or two.