Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TwinsDr2021

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TwinsDr2021

  1. That isn't at all what I said, Maybe follow along to what I wrote instead of projecting. Berrios made his major league debut at 22, Bumgarner at 19, and Darvish was signed out of Japan, and was not part of the 6 years rookie control. If teams are willing to keep an older prospect in the minors (Winder for example age 25) because they feel the need to make sure that they have him at age 32 instead of just age 31, that seems weird to me. Then I said if poor teams can't afford to sign any 31/32/33 pitcher to a expensive type contract, in theory wouldn't they get a better return for a 29/30 pitcher than a 31/32 year old pitcher? Lets use a few pitchers as example, which pitcher do people think will cost the most in prospect capital? ( Bassitt, Montas) Now it is not apples to apples because Montas has an extra year, so lets ask it this way which A's pitcher would return the best prospects, trading Montas (28) before this year or Bassitt (32) before last year.
  2. I agree with that, I guess the rule makes sense when you are bringing up younger prospects (20,21,22) but when the prospects are older the rule or teams keeping them in the minors seems weird, Winder is 25 for example, are teams really worried about that extra year when they are over 30? I have read people say we should be trading Garver since he is already 31, and he won't hit FA until 2024. Also if the poor teams really want to trade guys to get prospects, wouldn't it make sense to trade them during their prime to get better prospects in return?
  3. I guess what I was saying, no matter the 3/3 or 4/4, if the first pitcher doesn't do the required 3 or 4, you are playing two ends of the relief pitcher game. In the 3/3 if the first pitcher goes 1, then you to use RP pitcher(s) just to get to the 4th, you aren't bringing in the second guy early because that isn't the strategy, then at the end you are doing the same to get to the end of the game. Or lets say they are doing the 4/4 and the first guys does great for 3 innings and the Twins are up 1 -0 or 2-0, and in the 4th the starter gets an out but a couple of guys get on, don't they have to play that 2/3 like it is the end of the game and bring in a good RP to get the last two outs and not the last pitcher off the bench? I don't know the answers to these that is why I am asking. As for trusting young pitchers have the Twins shown at all that they do? Who is the last young pitcher that has gotten more than a couple hold opportunities in the last few years? So in a 4/4 the second guy is almost never going to get 4 innings in. So what we are really talking about is a 3/3 or more of a hybrid model like Major League Ready has talked about. Also I think it is different than the normal starter, in that if your starter had a short start you hopefully have a long guy that can go 3 or more innings if they were having a good day, you don't have to play every inning like it is the playoffs. I will repeat I am not against this idea, I am just bringing up scenarios that might make it hard to stick to it and thus make it look like the FO doesn't really have a plan. If you stack you stack, you tell the second pitcher what inning they will be starting and let them prepare for that inning like it is the start of a game for them, you don't jack these pitchers around and say OK, your up second be prepared for it to be at anytime, that is what relief pitchers are for. Unless the plan is to put the second tier guys in the second spot, the ones they don't think will ever be starters anyway, Dobnak, Jax, Strotman or whoever they think they are, because in all reality they are just trying to get the studs some innings without blowing up their arms or confidence. I pitched in high school and college and I can tell you, starting pitchers and relief pitchers have different routines to get ready. One more reason I think it will be hard to fully stick to this strategy is if they truly want to get a few of these pitchers to 120 or so innings, that is 30 starts of 4 innings, or less starts and more innings a start, thus making it hard to stick to this strategy. They can't let guys that are being Ober type successful not pitch; and go out and make 20 starts and pitch 60 innings, if these rookies are pitching like Ober did last year they have to let them get to the amount of innings they are hoping that get to. (I am guessing each pitcher will be different) Sorry to be long winded, but it seems that maybe the Twins let Bundy, Ober, and Ryan be more of a traditional 5,6 innings starters, and start the season with the other two spots doing a 3/3 with a Winder/Jax and Sands or Strotman/Dobnak, and the ones that do well you move to 4 inning type start, the others either go to the bullpen or down to the minors to get their innings.
  4. That is super easy to do when things go as planned, but what happens if they Twins are consistently giving up 3,4,5 inning in a 4 inning or less start? (That happened in a 1/3 of Ober's start for example, only one of Ryan's to be fair.) I am not saying this isn't the right or possibly the only strategy the Twins have. Plus the team might have to come out and say this is the plan and why (the people on this site understand) but there are way more fans of the Twins not on a site like this then there are on it. They will look genius if they do this and it works, but man if it doesn't there will be call for their heads on a plate.
  5. Kinda agree with fans showing up for wins, if the opening day line up is what some are suggesting, fans and wins might be hard to come by. And with the restrictions currently in MPLS there may be less fans than ever. I know plenty of people that are vaccinated that won't go any place they have to show their card (now if the Twins are winning and looking good I bet they might change their mind, but if they are losing they will probably even be more adamant) The strategy of stacking isn't a bad one, but can go bad quickly if both of the starters are bad and you tax the bullpen, and it if starts happening more than expected things could go real bad. They will have to be prepared almost every game a young guy goes out there to bridge the gap. Also, I don't see the Twins doing a 4/4/1 strategy, there is no way they are leaving a rookie pitcher out there in the 7th or 8th in a one run game when they have Duffey, Rogers or whoever else might be pitching really well. So it may have to be highly thought of prospect starting going 4 and a lesser one starting the 5th and 6th and possibly 7th if there are pitching well, or it isn't a tight game.
  6. I don't disagree with what you are saying at all and to be honest I don't know how they would do something different. (other then signing a couple of vets that they have go 4-6 innings regardless of how they are doing, I am not for that) With that being said sometimes doing what is right for the team doesn't translate well to watching/viewing a game. If your choice is going to watch Ryan pitch on Saturday or going to a stacked or bullpen game on Sunday, which choice do you think most fans would make? Also I think the fans could sour very quickly if Winder for example has a no hitter though 3, gets taken out and Jax comes in and gives up 4 in the 4th. Also it could make Rocco's job almost impossible, again for example the plan is for Winder to go three and Balazovic to go three. What if Winder is finishes his 3 innings with 36 pitches, does he stick to the plan or let him go another. Or maybe they are stacking 4/4/1 and the Twins are winning 5 - 0, Winder has 48 pitches after 4, what does Rocco do? He is in a no win situation, he leaves him in Winder does bad in the 5th, that is on him, he takes him out and Balazovic doesn't do good, also on him. IMO it is so hard to manage a team this way, and probably is why they didn't do it last year, when they absolutely could have with way lesser prospects than they have this year. Bullpen games are much easier, you are asking bullpen guys to do what they normally do, but stacking is asking pitchers to do something they don't normally do.
  7. I personally don't think we will see any prospect currently not on the 40 man until they figure out if Dobnak, Jax, Sands, Strotman, Winder and Vallimont are worthy of continuing to be kept on the 40 man. So it would not surprise me to see a starting 5 of Bundy, Ryan, Ober, Dobnak and Jax. And if Ryan or Ober struggle they could get sent down and replaced with one of the above, but if Dobnak or Jax struggle the could get released, opening up 40 man spots for others. Now if that is how the season starts, I personally won't have to worry about watching crappy baseball, because I won't pay to see that disgusting staff and I stream so currently can't watch on TV as far as I know. I will sit on the side and complain how bad this FO is and Rocco should be fired, OR I will be in the backyard grilling crow (and still complaining about Rocco because I don't like him as a manager)
  8. I guess it depends on the definition of helpful. Does getting to play because there are no other options count as helpful. At this point all three are on the 40 man, so if something happens to somebody they should get a chance, Combined last year they played in 135 for a negative WAR, but it seemed helpful because the Twins had nobody else. Based on the lineup MikeLink45 above these 3 are or should be counted as plan B for injuries or being terrible. The sad part is I don't see a plan C. The Twins can't trade Kepler until AK, Larnach or Celestino prove they are capable otherwise the Twins could have the worst OF in the majors no matter how good Buxton is, Can't trade Garver until you know Jeffers has it figured out, because that turns what is considered a strength into a hole in the lineup. Can't trade Donaldson because if Miranda doesn't pan out, they have no back up 3B, unless you want an infield with Arraez at 3B, Gordon at SS and Polanco at 2b, and Sano at first. And the biggest problem of all is there isn't much if any room on the 40 to replace offense. In the end I will say Gordon he seems like the most likely to be on the Twins opening day.
  9. In my personal opinion teams are teaching the younger kids to go all out for as long as they can, because the stats say that getting though a lineup a 3rd time is hard to do. So again in my opinion and I have no data to back this up pitch counts and limiting innings might actually be hurting these pitchers. Obviously while trying to stretch somebody out and coming back from injury these are good tools to use. I believe I remember reading that huge jumps in innings from year to year isn't a good thing on a arm, but maybe teaching pitches to actually pitch and no always have to go all out might be good as well. But I don't think the way teams are using pitchers is going to change until it starts actually affecting the salaries of starting pitchers and the union steps up.
  10. Sorry if you assumed I meant starters were going to complete every game. I meant there is about 1458 innings in a season. The Twins have 3 starters, and Alcala, Cotton, Duffey, Garza Jr, Jax, Rogers, Stashak, Theilbar, Throrpe, if they each pitch 75 (675), they are still short quite a bit of innings.
  11. What if only two of those pitchers are successful in that role next year, heck even 3, what does 2023 look like? I am in no way going to be happy if 22 goes the way of 21 and we are looking at 23 like we are 22. I do want to see as many of these prospects as possible this year, but I don't want to see 14 starts from them if they are pitching like Jax or Barnes did in 21. This is on this FO to figure out, but I am in no way waiting around to 24 after being promised sustained success.
  12. Agreed, the real question is how are the Twins going to fill ~1458 (162*9) innings this year? Bundy - 120 Ober - 150 Ryan - 140 Only 1000 left to fill.
  13. Haven't all or most of the prospects been hurt as well? I will add giving up a major league catcher for one year is too much, the second trade seems high as well. To me this is the kind of trade you make for a Rooker, Cavaco, and some arm in low A.
  14. From what I remember about Law (haven't read him for a while) he likes is prospects on the younger side which I agree with, most of the Twins prospects are getting older. IMO it is hard to call a 25 year old man a high end prospects compared to an 18 year old. (doesn't mean the 25 year old won't have a better career, but getting your feet wet in the majors at 25 is quite a bit different than getting them wet at 21/22) A ways back I went though the top 50 guys in ERA in 2021 and just about all of them were guys that made their major league debut at age 23/24 or younger. (with a Covid that may change in the future) Which means guys like SWR, Balazovic and Petty will probably be rated higher over the other Twins prospects, because they rest are all 24 or older. I think if Steve Hajjar has a big year, he could be in the top 100 next year?
  15. He will be 23 this year, so he isn't old yet, but taking a college guy in the first round, you would hope for better results in year one, With that said, if he can duplicate what he did in A+ at AA this year, he will moving up the prospect list. And to piggy back on terrydactlys he seems like the perfect type of guy to include in a trade, while he may be a decent major league player for a long time he doesn't seem like the type that you will look back on and say, darn he was the wrong guy to trade.
  16. For those thinking they should have spent money on pitching instead of Donaldson (which I tend to agree with but not sure who those pitchers are?), which pitcher haven't they been able to afford because of him and what pitchers should they have signed instead of him? The Twins aren't trading Donaldson any time soon, if they do it shows they are rebuilding again after saying that wasn't the case, they aren't eating the amount that would be needed to get anything decent back. (Imagine for a minute they trade him and have to eat 10 million for a couple of really young prospects, if they Twins have 10 million to spend on prospects I would prefer that would be on international ones), and finally because it makes the FO looks stupid for signing him in the first place. The front office pretty much got screwed because of all the injuries to to the pitching prospects, then decided it would be better to let vets pitch at the end of the season instead of putting the prospects on the 40 man or using service time without knowing how the labor dispute would go. (that may turn out to be a great decision because they can be working with a few of them in the mean time), but the problem is and was why are all of their prospects getting hurt?
  17. Always exciting getting a 27 year old with an ERA north of 4 in AA.
  18. Just to play devils advocate (because I wasn't really in the boat to sign Bumgarner, at least to 5 years, and it seems like they really didn't have a chance for him even if they wanted him) but with that said, would the Twins be in any different of spot today if they signed him, Maybe they don't sign Pineda (he made 5 good starts in 2020) or maybe the do and don't sign Bailey, Hill, Happ and Shoemaker, but anyway Madison would have quickly moved down the rotation hierarchy in 2020 because he was mostly to very bad in just about all of his starts. 2021 he was decent, not as good as Pineda, but 2021 was terrible all around. The first two years would have cost the Twins about 5 million more for Madison, the next three years are where Madison's contract gets real expensive. But with the way he finished the year last year giving Diamondbacks 5 to 7 innings with decent results, there would be hope he figured something out and instead of looking for 3 starters the Twins are looking at two, and it isn't like his contract (at this time) would have hindered them from signing somebody, because as of yet they have signed anybody anyway. Again, signing 30 year over used pitchers to 5 years contracts probably (and very likely) isn't the best way for a lower revenue team to go about business, but if the Twins aren't going to spend on FA just to keep payroll lower, well then screw them, I have better places to spend money then target field in MPLS.
  19. For the most part I like analytics, but I hate watching baseball shifts, It makes me sick to stomach watching a player like Kepler pull the ball to the 2nd basemen with the whole left side of the field open, or watching Mauer at the end of his career continue to hit line drives up the middle that are just easy plays for the SS standing right there. Nobody wants a math lesson when watching baseball except the middle age men/women that post on boards like this; and then just maybe. Baseball analytics are so over the top complex nobody wants to hear how FIP is figured it or how how WAR is figured out and different depending on what sites you go to. People love easy math, how exciting is it when you can help a middle school or younger child solve math problems? That is why people loved ERA, W/L, BA, OBP, SLG, stuff that makes sense and you can see with your eyes, and know are being told by a few people they are wrong or worse yet stupid for thinking those things matter anymore . For example the NFL will throw out QB rating and everybody pretty much understands completion percentage, yards and TD's good, in-completions and INT's bad. The announcer doesn't need to explain well it is high because it was bad luck that WR dropped a pass, or ran the wrong route, or the defense showed zone but switched to man to man at the last second, and the QB actually had a good game but just unlucky. You know how many times I have watched a game and seen a pitcher get hit fairly hard, throw in some bloppers and maybe a Texas leaguer or two and gives up multiple runs in a few innings and was explained to how well he actually pitched and was just unlucky. Nobody wants to watch their favorite teams pitcher go 3 innings give up 5 runs and be told to their face, he was actually pretty good today just unlucky and I use analytics to prove what you saw with your own eyes is wrong. I am not an NBA fan but I know looking at PER and comparing players by it will give me a pretty good idea how good a player is compared to another. Baseball doesn't have that one stat, if you have to explain why Nicky Lopez was the 36th best non-pitcher in baseball while hitting .300, 21 2B, 2 HR, 43 RBI, 22 SB, and SLG .378, that is a huge problem. (I am not saying he wasn't the 36th best, but how many baseball fans have even heard of him or said oh yea he is one of the top players in the game) I guess what I am really trying to say is there is fine line between boring the tv fans and entertaining them and baseball probably has the hardest of all sports, they play a ton of games so how many times do you want to hear the same thing over and over? and the Analytics are so important to building a franchise from the bottom (minor leagues) up and projecting what might happen going forward, but who want to hear about spin rate? Certainly not my teen age son. He want to here how hard and how far his favorite player just hit that homer, or how fast his favorite pitcher is throwing and what is his pitch count so he know many innings he has left, so he tell his friends when he will be available because he doesn't want to watch the end of the game and all the commercials (I mean pitching changes)
  20. After looking more closely the Twins from 2001 to 2010, probably fit both of our definitions. Made the playoffs 6 times, with never missing more than two years in a row. Only once with less than 80 wins, and only twice not finishing in the top two in the division. The last five years of the Twins have been close but two of the years were down and this year looks the same.
  21. I am guessing demanding the bottom 11 teams (Milwaukee was at 99 million last year) to spend more will do less for the overall players then allowing the top 18 teams to spend more. (that was by 2021 salaries) In 2019 only 6 teams were below 100 million
  22. Wow, project much? I haven't claimed to figured out anything, you are the one that has said that. I said low revenue teams haven't sustained success over an extended period, and you proved that pointing out low revenue teams that have went in cycles. I am not and I believe nobody else has ever said the core of a team isn't based on what comes up though the farm. I have said when your window opens take advantage because it will close again fairly soon. Since 2002 the Cleveland (been in one world series since the Twins last been in one, and 4 of their main starting pitchers didn't start in their organization) team has 7 90 wins season. (and 4 of them were in a row between 16 and 19) Tampa Bay has 8 in their history - and they basically came in two 4 year runs (two world series and in their last one 2020, 3 of their main starters didn't start in their organization). Oakland (who hasn't been to a world series since the Twins were last in one)has 10 since 2000, and 6 of them game between 2000-2006, which my math tells me they had 4 others, and both of them came back to back with 4 years between them. This is the kind of success you are claiming? The Twins have 6 since 2002. My point was when the Twins were in their cycle they should have done more to put them over the edge, not having Lewis, Duran, or another prospect or two wouldn't change much as of today (well except maybe hope) probably the 2022 season, and maybe 2023 we have no idea.
  23. I guess mine is pretty much being in the playoffs almost every year for a decade or so, but never missing more than one year in a row or having a run of 5 or 6 missing two years and rattling off another run. Having a bad year here and there happens, but sustained success IMO means you are right back the next year.
  24. What happened in the last 2,3,4 years is how the twins got to were they are today. 0 playoff wins, and terrible 2021 season and a 2022 that looks like a rebuild season and huge question marks on 2023 at this point. You have asked over and over again, and there are no examples, why because NO below average revenue team has ever sustained any success for more than a few years. Milwaukee has been to 4 in a row, but only 2 others since 1983 Cleveland has been to 4 of the last 6 and 2 others since 2002 Tampa Bay as been to the playoffs 3 years in a row but missed the 5 previous years. Oakland 3 of the last 5, after missing 3 years, after making it 3 years after missing 5 years. The Twins have been in 3 of the last 5. All this building though the draft not signing FA or not trading prospects is recency basis. What people are trying to say is that the Twins will be the first team in history to have sustained playoff success doing it this.
  25. That doesn't make sense if winning 72 instead of 70, hurts you don't the line. And teams in MLB don't tank in the true sense of the word. They are building for the future knowing there will be rough times, IMO real tanking would be sending out AA type pitchers that have no real change and no future and trying to lose, I don't see that happening. Also a floor isn't going to do what everybody wants, unless the goal is take money from the owners and give it to the players.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.