Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Rocco, Usage, and the Twins Bullpen
If the Twins are not bombing home runs all over the place, Rocco pretty much fails as a manager, IMO. for full disclosure I didn't see the game last night, but my goodness Archer is a 33 year old man with over 1200 MLB innings and Rocco doesn't have the confidence in him to pitch to a rookie hitting around .150? If that is the kind of confidence you have in your starter you might as well tell him sorry Chris, but your now a bullpen guy because unless if you are absolutely perfect after the third inning I am going to pull you from the game.
-
Your Most Controversial Baseball Opinion
Allow a 25 year old to pitch between 90 - 115 pitches.
-
Twins catchers, SS, and trades. A quick reflection
Completely agree with all this, which is why I only said I didn't agree with #2, because there were multiple paths of keeping both.
-
Game Score: Red Sox 8, Twins, 1
And (not sure if this is true or not) Rocco seems to pick the wrong relievers to bring him.
-
Game Score: Red Sox 8, Twins, 1
Ober was pitching what I call a unicorn game, less than 12 pitches per inning and the Twins still wouldn't let him go out in the 7th. If he takes 12-18 pitches in the 7th that still leaves him at 82-88 for the game, is that too many pitches for somebody that has given up 4 base runs in 6 innings? Doesn't this seem like the perfect type of game to see how he does in the 7th? But instead they turn to the game over to inferior pitchers and get blown out, now I get the Twins offense was horrible and with that had no chance of winning, but isn't there a time and place to see if you starting pitcher has the ability to pitch in the 7th? There is a decent enough chance they will let him go 80 pitches in less innings in his next start. This game is a bit different than Ryan on Friday, because Ryan was already at 82 pitches, and if he is brought back he is likely to end up very close to 100 and the expectation is Duran might be an upgrade on him at this point.
-
Twins catchers, SS, and trades. A quick reflection
Not sure I agree with number two, per spotrac the twins current payroll is sitting at 132.6 million. if you remove Urshela (6.5), Sanchez(7.5), and Gray (10.6) that comes to 24.9. Donaldson (23), and Garver (3.35) and , so the twins could have signed Correa and still had about the same payroll if they wouldn't have traded for Gray.. So IMO you could say the twins wouldn't have been able to trade for Gray without getting rid of Donaldson or you could say they turned Donaldson and Garver into Urshela, Sanchez, and Gray, but tying the Correa signing to Donaldson is Twins fans running cover for the FO and owners. I am not arguing it was the right or wrong move, everybody can have their own opinion on that, I am saying their was a path to signing Correa that didn't include trading Donaldson and left the twins in about the same spot (1.5) payroll.
-
Twins catchers, SS, and trades. A quick reflection
And they traded two pitchers on the 40 for 3 months of Nelson Cruz. Cleaning theirs up a bit and hindering the Twins. Ryan being as good as he has been has helped, but having a 25 year old holding down a 40 man spot that really never has been a great minor league pitcher hasn't helped the Twins.
-
Twins catchers, SS, and trades. A quick reflection
Remind me again who signed Donaldson to a contract that would need to be cleared after two years?
- Game Thread: Twins @ Red Sox 1:10 PM 4/15/2022
-
Beating the Shift
100% agree it isn't on easy, but with some practice is it really harder than trying to take a full all out swing to hit (with 6 guys and a pitcher on the right side of the field)? IMO the hitters don't actually have to be that successful doing it, they just have to show the other team they are willing. In the Kepler scenario above the Twins scored zero runs, but if tried to bunt and failed they still score zero runs but the other team(s) have to take note he will try and if that brings over the fielders even a little bit, that should help when they are hitting away. Kepler is 3 for 18 so his current approach hasn't worked, give it a try, Kirby used to bunt when he was in a slump to help him get out of it, I remember back in the day Hrbek trying the bunt down the third base line a couple of times a year. I will add trying to inside out a pitch or go the other way is IMO way more difficult than bunting and I wouldn't want a batter trying without really practicing it.
-
Sherry's Series Takes: Twins vs. Dodgers
Super happy as a Twins fan that Dereck Rodriguez has pitched 3 more innings than Josh Winder this year. I 100% agreed with him starting in the majors because I thought there was a plan for him to pitch, but since there really didn't seem like there was one, I would rather have had him in St. Paul starting a game or two by now.
-
Kirilloff's cold start
You sound like the Major league guy changing the argument to make yourself look smart. The Mariners are starting one rookie in the field and he is hitting .071. ( in this case the pitcher is not relevant because this wasn't about pitching). Houston is starting one rookie (.300) and like the twins one younger guy (McCormick). Tampa is starting 1 rookie Lowe(.118) and like the Twins one younger guy (Franco) . TB last year started no-rookies and a young guy Arozarena) The White sox have one young guy (vaughn), I also looked at a few other teams (Mil, SD, LAA, LAD, ATL, Philly (1 rookie),NYY, Bos, CHC, Cards, Col, SF, Texas, did I miss any teams trying, and not 1 is starting multiple rookies in the field. Also went though a bunch of teams last year, and guess what not one started multiple rookies. Finally you stated Tampa Bay constantly starts the year with rookies, going back to 2017 I couldn't find where they ever started the year with more than one in the field, so either I am bad at researching that or you just made up something and stated it as fact. Maybe there has been a bunch of teams that were really trying to win with multiple rookies starting in the field to start the year and front offices don't think that is a bad idea because the back up plan is other rookies or AAA guys if they need more time in the minors. I would love to know what they teams were, because it isn't something teams recently have been doing.
- Has Luis Arraez Earned a Starting Role?
-
Kirilloff's cold start
You replied to my comment which I stated my opinion on starting a season with multiple rookies in a lineup with "This is only logical if you assume rookies are much more likely to start the season cold--I don't ascribe to that thinking. " First you don't scribe to that, but didn't back it up with any stats. Second if you didn't like my opinion (which is also the opinion of most front offices in baseball that are actually trying to win that year) move on, I am not trying to sway your opinion or argue a point, If you want to sway my opinion, please feel free to throw out the data that shows my assumption/suppositions/speculation are incorrect.
-
Kirilloff's cold start
I don't have any data, but looking at a couple dozen of them, it seems to me as if most start out a bit slow, do you have data that rookies start out not slow? I also say that because people expecting rookies to be better than average are most likely to be let down. Baseball people like numbers if you start 4 rookies or close to rookies, the odds are probably one is good, two are average at the absolute best and 1 is terrible. Also if you are 0-12 or 1 -15, I think by definition that is a slow start ( I would say Correa, Sano, Kepler and AK are all off to a slow start, doesn't mean it won't change tomorrow) I also disagree with your premise that Miranda and Larnach are in the minors because they wouldn't play everyday, the are in the minors because the FO believe the other players they have would perform better, which might be the same thing as you are saying.
-
Former Twins - a quick first week look
Here are a few more Wade on 10 day IL Tyler Wells 21.6 ERA for Balt Hill hasn't pitched for Boston Ynoa 15 ERA for the Atlanta Luis Gil in the minors for the NYY Rosario .259 OPS Atlanta Castro has 2 AB's for Houston Goodrum has 8 AB's for Houston no hits Romo 2 innings for Seattle - no runs Garver - .250, 1 HR, 938 OPS (12 AB) Kinney Colorado - 2 innings 0.00 ERA Colome 1 2.3 innings 5.40 ERA
- Prospect Retrospective: Josh Winder
-
Kirilloff's cold start
I don't assume rookies start a season cold, I assume rookies are going to start slow regardless of when they are called up (not all do, but the majority does), so putting a few guys in a lineup that are almost guaranteed to start slow is not a good strategy. I assumed you were not replying to me about him being sent down since I don't think I even inferred that. That is why having Miranda and Larnach in the minors is a better strategy and calling them up when they are hot or forcing the FO hand, then it is hoping they all don't start slow and have to send them down for who?
-
Opening Weekend Thoughts
My take is it might be a while before a Twins pitcher has a quality start. (Hope I am wrong)
-
Kirilloff's cold start
This is way you can't start the season with too many rookies starting, one (AK) and kind of a second (Jeffers) is OK, a team can afford to let one work though some issues (AK), but imagine if they had Miranda, Laranch and maybe even Lewis up and multiple players struggled, then what would they do. (Giving the FO credit for starting the season as they did, and I don't give them much credit ever) So as long as the vets pick it up a bit (Kepler, Sano, Polanco, Correa) they have some time to let AK figure it out.
-
Justin Upton to the Twins?
It is only 3 games and the Twins corner outfielders are 1 - 21, so that has to get better right? Actually if you throw Buxton in there they are 4 - 33, with all 4 hits being homers. (With as bad as the top as the offense has been, 1 -2 isn't horrible)
-
Game Score: Twins 10, Mariners 4, Bats Come Alive with Six Home Runs in Twins First Win of 2022
Besides Duffey the Bullpen has been amazing, 12 1/3 and 0 runs, but lets not get ahead of ourselves yet on the starters, yes it was their first game, but only Ober made the 5th and his ERA is 7.20, Ryan's ERA is 4.50 which I would assume everybody including me are expecting that to be sub 4 this year. Gray is 3.86 which is good. (If Bundy, Archer and Paddack can do what Ryan did (or better) I would say it was a pretty successful first time though the 6 starters.
-
Opening Day Game Thread: Mariners @ Twins, 4/8 @ 3:10pm CT
He is at 51 pitches, I see no chance of him coming out for the 5th, unless it is a 1,2,3, 8 pitch 4th inning, and then still probably not
-
POLL: Grade the Paddack-Rogers trade.
I gave it a C, they traded a first round pick for a soon to be 31 year old relief pitcher, not a great return for a 1st round pick, but Rooker wasn't living up to expectations. a FA RP next year for a few years of control for a fairly young pitcher (by Twins standards) so that part was pretty good. I don't see how it could really go down, unless of course Rooker is really good in SD, but it could go way up if Paddack turns into a serviceable starting pitcher and if Pagan pitches well.
-
Twins trade Rogers, Rooker to Padres for Paddack, Pagan
Does a 6 man rotation take longer to stretch out or less time because of the days between starts? FYI, I hate the idea of a 6 man rotation because that means less pitching from Gray and Ryan. Unless they can keep those two on a regular schedule and mess with the last 4.