Everything posted by TheLeviathan
- Article: DET 9, MIN 3: Third Out Eludes Gibson, Eades Debuts
-
2020 Presidential Election
Biden 24% Sanders 16% Warren 15% Buttigieg 15% Front runners are starting to create separation in Iowa.
-
POTUS Donald Trump
None of the rural community I know of is happy with subsidies. Subsidies rarely impact family farms, they simple aren't to scale enough to matter.
-
Twins send slumping fan favorite Willians Astudillo down to minors
I'm guessing they are doing this to help him reset. I'd guess Romero is the call, but I hope I get a pleasant surprise.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
I've long said, if you think a certain deficit becomes insulting - institute a mercy rule. In lieu of that....play the game.
-
Article: MIN 6, DET 3: Offense, Bullpen Come Through Late as Twins Take Opener
4 shutout innings from the bullpen. If the last 72 hours taught me anything its to now conclude they will be perfect the rest of the year. Long term extensions for all!
-
POTUS Donald Trump
Thought crossed my mind.....
- Article: Cali Connection Jumps Draft Boards: Q&A with Keoni Cavaco
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
Im not sure context matters either. Just play baseball until the game is over by the written rules.
- Article: Miguel Sano: A Fading Superstar
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
You used a small sample.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
If one were to compare baseball (either as a crapshoot or not a crapshoot) in that sense.....would that be a rational use of the term? Baseball isn't random like throwing dice, so I try to interpret the term with the best of intentions. Go back and look at what Bob said that got this tangent rolling and I think his intent was pretty clear: you can add players but their effect size is rather minimal because of the variance factor. That Levine can be justified by the numbers that dumping assets into acquisitions for playoff wins is unwise. I sometimes agree and sometimes not with that last part. I think that's what separates the best GMs. What I do think is true is that the numbers do bear out that these sorts of midseason and playoff-focused acquisitions are not nearly as impactful as people think. At least for the actual playoffs. But there is a subset of posters that will ignore the impact of playoff variance and overinflate the impact of trade acquisitions. On that basis they claim "Not a crapshoot!" and on that basis they are most definitely wrong.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
Variance doesn't explain everything, certainly. But it's a major factor that you have limited control over. The post I took issue with said the playoffs are "not a crapshoot". Well, what's a crapshoot? If you argue that "crapshoot" means totally random thing you have no control over I'd suggest you aren't using the word "random" correctly and what you've said is mostly meaningless. Your terms are wrong and you've basically made the equivalent of a one word strawman argument. If what you mean by "crapshoot" is that it is subject to small sample variance, then there is only one correct answer: Hell yes it's a crapshoot. That is what most people mean, so the contention that it is not is simply not true. We have data showing that. Now, lots of factors come into play in the playoffs. Certainly talent disparities are a major part of that, but on the major league level those disparities are generally not that large. Not enough to remove the tyranny of variance for sure. There are intangibles that come into play as well. So can you close those gaps? Yup, for both talent and intangibles IMO. You can even target players you think might specifically be valuable weapons against other particular teams. But those changes are incremental because of how narrow the gap is and how powerful the variance can be. So, yeah, incrementally make this sucker better. Playoffs are still a crapshoot though, so brace yourself,
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
And if you want to die on the hill of random....take it up with Harvard. What I think you mean is variability and, statistically speaking, baseball has a lot of it in the playoffs.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
I just have to point out the irony here is.....astounding.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
This marks the third time you have confused small sample and random. At this point, given your confusion on it, it doesn't seem like a conversation to continue. I will say this on the larger issue - I believe the run of playoff failures had more to do with the team's psychological make-up than anything else. But being a team surviving the weakest division with less talent than the others didn't help. This team has a much better edge to it. It's already deep and talented. It has the ingredients, which is why I'd invest in it. Heavily. It's why I'm disappointed about Kimbrel. I'd be on the phone with the Giants every day about Smith and MadBum. Because, how do you protect small sample flukes? Well, you try to be as deep and talented as you can be to insulate yourself from perils of a small sample. So adding talent is, really, your only way to do that. However, the degree to which it can do that will always be more incremental than dramatic. Still, I'll take increments when the opportunities are there.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
I'd argue each of those handfuls are that and you are wrongly lumping them together. It created the false sense of a pattern. I too expect this team to be better and I too want them to add an ace an bullpen parts. I'm just not going to delude myself about the playoffs. The playoffs crown the World Series Championship. The 162 games decide the best teams.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
I already stated that. I understand that small samples aren't "random", that's not my point. Max Kepler didn't "randomly" hit 3 home runs last night. But I'm going to go out on a limb and not draw any huge implications going forward either. Or in assessing Max Kepler. He had a helluva night. Drawing more conclusions than that (which you are) is the mistake. That kind of sober approach to a small sample apparently is completely abandoned when people judge playoff performances. They say a team like the 116 win Mariners wasn't "as good" as the Yankees. No, they were probably better. They got beat in a small sample. If we could run that sample a hundred times perhaps the outcome is different more often than not. Which goes to the Yankees - yes, it can happen. And did. It is a historical anomaly. It's much better explained by a combination of psychology, talent, and good fortune. Not as some massive pattern we can just "figure out" and magically win the next 10 championships.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
Pretty sure it was! If we lose three of the next five to the Tigers....should we cede them the division? I will say again - add talent for the playoffs. 100% on board. But the playoffs are always a small sample and all the things that come with that.
-
Twins confirm interest in signing pitchers Dallas Keuchel, Craig Kimbrel
I don't think that's true at all. The playoffs are a small sample size, sure the results aren't "random" but they are subject to the kind of wild variations that all small samples are guilty of. You can prepare for them the best you can and then laugh as dudes like Brandon Backe pull a rabbit out of their rear end.
-
2020 Presidential Election
I certainly can understand questioning the authenticity of it.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
Just in case you thought this issue had reached it's low point....
-
2020 Presidential Election
That kind of plays into the disapproval ratings. Yeah, people don't like Trump, but if they don't like the other person even more (see: Hillary) then they vote for the lesser of two dislikable hacks. By anecdote, I know quite a few farmers who did exactly that in 2016.
-
2020 Presidential Election
We don't want politicians to change wrong views? I'm cynical he did this for good reasons, but I sorta want people in office willing to listen. I like a lot of what AOC stands for, but I also hope she listens that some of her policies are not well designed. Ditto Warren. Ditto Mayor Pete. One of my biggest issues with the guy in office is that he doesn't listen to good reason. I can't fault Biden for doing so, even if it was nothing more than saving political face.
-
Article: Craig Kimbrel and Risk Tolerance
There are ways to stream that are very budget friendly. I'm sure any of us whipper snappers could help you out in PM if you're so inclined.