Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
Sign Byron Buxton! (Buxton rejects initial extension offer)
I could be wrong, but I think there is zero chance Byron Buxton gets 5 years with a guaranteed 100M. If that is offered, it will be with a litany of opt-out options the team has built in to protect them. Effectively making it a much lower deal with incentives. Just like the ones the Twins seem to be offering. In a league where almost no one gets 5 years....it ain't gonna be Buxton that breaks that trend.
-
THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
I encourage you to find Van's laundry list of lost games on the way to the hundreds and hundreds of lost games by Buxton. I don't care if they are nagging or not, its brutal. I agree about his age being a major positive for Buck, but his game is built on speed. There is no profile of a player more likely to decline with age than one whose game is built on speed. Buxton's hitting has been great in only a smattering or the smattering of at-bats he has actually been healthy. Without his speed, Buxton is a significantly less valuable player. And his speed will decline.
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
-
Sign Byron Buxton! (Buxton rejects initial extension offer)
I agree on that second paragraph. His best bet will be to take some large, short-term contracts and bet on himself. But I don't expect those to be much more than 2/30 with protections built in for the club. (Like, the second year is mutual option) My beef is with people not understanding that a 7 year offer structure has a lower AAV because of the security it provides Buck. He is trading larger salaries for a longer commitment by the club with incentives. Likewise he could trade the years for more guarantees. But he will not get both. That's what people need to stop conflating.
-
THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
Buxton has less track record and worse injuries than Donaldson. And Donaldson had to scrape to get a four year deal while Buxton is getting offered 7. And, yes, he could blow what they offered out of the water in 3-4 years. He might also be so injured and declining that he doesn't earn half of it.
-
THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
I agree with many of you that it's very hard to peg what he'd get, but I'm pretty confident of a few things: 1. Anyone who gives Buxton a contract term beyond 3 years is going to want it heavily incentivized, with a lot of outs, or with a lower AAV. Possibly all of those things. He won't get a deal longer than 3 years without at least significant protections of that nature. Again, this is how teams behave now. The free agent spending binges of years past are not the same. 2. The only way he gets anywhere close to a $20M AAV is on a 1-2 year deal with mutual options and other protections that the team will insist on in order to swing for the fences. They won't box themselves in. I don't think people are looking at the current pay rate of centerfielders in the league when they think he's getting 150 or 200M guaranteed. That's just not reasonable. If he had no history or injuries, sure. But Buxton's track record is ugly and teams are gun-shy when there are red flags. GMs know they keep their jobs, in part, by protecting the owner's pocket book from ugly contracts. On top of that, I think a lot of this fanbase is still in love with the myth of Byron Buxton. He's such a likable player and so easy to root for and it doesn't help that he fuels that for 40 games a season when he's just phenomenal, but GMs can't be starry-eyed fans. The sober take on this guy is that guarantees in his next contract are going to be few and far between unless he makes significant sacrifices in other areas of the deal.
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
-
THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
Before we rush to call the Twins cheap skates, shouldn't we know a bit more about the "unique incentives package" and Buxton's counter-offer? Hayes seems to hint that Buxton wants more assured money in case he gets hurt again, which is totally reasonable, but isn't it also reasonable for the team to be wary of that? If the incentives are low-ball and meaningless, then I'd say the Twins are being cheap. If, however, he can hit 20M a year by just getting on the field, say, 60% of the time than I'd say they aren't being cheap at all. Only ten players in the entire league have gotten contracts in free agency over 4 years in the last three offseasons. Only 5 that have gotten 7 years or more in term: Harper, Machado, Cole, Rendon, and Strasburg. Teams don't hand out deals like this much anymore, so it wouldn't take those incentives being all that elaborate for them to be well in line with MLB behavior right now. (I'd argue they would be acting very generously on the term aspect relative to the rest of the league)
-
Sign Byron Buxton! (Buxton rejects initial extension offer)
A lot of that depends on how easy the escalators are to attain and how much they pay out too. Sure, the base isn't amazing, but I also think people WAY overestimate how much money is available to him as a free agent. Teams have a several season behavior trend of being much more risk averse. Especially on the term component.
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
-
Your thoughts on the Nelson Cruz trade?
Not at all. Firstly, you're declaring this a win for the future two months for the Rays and a "bad result" for the Twins. Now, if you have the ability to predict the future I'd prefer you use your powers for more good than TD posting. (Like, for example, telling me what to bet on in Vegas) But assuming you don't have those powers the truth is you are judging the trade the very next day in the most unfair way possible. Secondly, yes, we can judge it now. As a 41 year old DH-only bat with two months left on his contract, we had an expected value for Cruz. By virtually all accounts, the Twins exceeded that expected value right now. (Because, like Cruz, those pitchers have expected value too) And lastly, Nelson Cruz has no tangible benefit to the 2021 Minnesota Twins. None. Getting anything that even MIGHT have future value for him is a win. Much less guys we might be able to plug in next year. Not to mention more available at-bats for Rooker. Not to mention, in a lost season, who cares about wins? All of those things can be fairly judged right now except for the one way you tried to judge the deal.
-
Your thoughts on the Nelson Cruz trade?
Isn't that something we should just wait until the future to decide then when the point of the post is to discuss the current context of value? Nelson Cruz might pull a hammy next week jogging out a double and your post will look silly too. Hand-cuffing yourself to hindsight as the only means of evaluation doesn't seem like a fair way to judge things. No front office gets to do that, we can only judge good processes and hope evaluations are being carried out at a high level. Those later judgments come....., well, later. As they should.
-
Pay minor league players.....
I'm glad more of the minor leaguers are sharing their stories. Putting the spotlight on this stupidity puts pressure on owners and the MLBPA to stop exploiting them.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
I like the DeDe news, not so much because I think Cousins will throw to him in the slot, but because it's insurance if Thielen or the kid gets hurt. We're paper thin at WR. And good on the Vikings to act decisively on Dennison.
- Twins Trade Nelson Cruz to the Rays for Two AAA Starting Pitchers
-
Is Max Kepler One of Baseball’s Most Valuable Trade Assets?
Team control is perhaps the most valuable commodity in the trade market.
-
MLBTR: Twins setting sky-high price on Berríos
I'd argue that first paragraph might be the same for Berrios.
-
MLBTR: Twins setting sky-high price on Berríos
He's banking on himself. A young, durable FA is going to make a ton of money. He'll blow past what Wheeler got fairly easily IMO. 6 and 150M is the low end. I don't think they get him to ink a deal with less than 150M on the table.
-
MLBTR: Twins setting sky-high price on Berríos
I guess my first question is.....how many contending teams are even in a position to meet that price? I'm all for setting a high bar for a trade, I just wonder if they narrowed their own market.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
One advantage Wade Davis and Ezra Cleveland have is the incredibly low bar for guard play we have. It'd be hard for them to be worse. Speaking of unresolved.....Gladney?
-
Multiple Twins Defenders On Pace to Be Gold Glove Finalists
Am I crazy or does this list only really have one contender in Simmons?
-
Contenders or pretenders
We could absolutely contend next year! Best way to do that? Not pretend this year matters beyond prep for next year. Sell the parts that won't be here. Sell Donaldson so we have room to add to what we have. Sell Berrios because he has no intention of returning. Play the kids. Let them experience and adjust to big league ball.
-
Loki - SPOILERS
It was a kid's game, but Lego made a Marvel Avengers game with Kang as the main villain and I found him fun and interesting as a big bad. But yeah....not much of a comic backstory to fall back on. Maybe that's an advantage.
- Not Good? Be Interesting (Twins Pitching)
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
Excellent post. And despite all of those advantages for Donaldson.....he still had to wait out a 4 year deal. I don't think people really have context for just how unreliable Buxton is or how risky an investment he is. We see the awesome dude with the awesome skillset who was an awesome prospect for us who really impacts the team. But we aren't seeing the fact that he's 27, he has literally missed hundreds and hundreds of games, and his best skills are the ones most likely to erode the fastest by all historical comps. GMs have to be sober in their decisions.