Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TheLeviathan

Old-Timey Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TheLeviathan

  1. No way they give us 6 for him, but I'll take their second rounder and a pick next year. I am actively rooting for this team to move Cousins and Hunter this offseason. Cook too, but I don't see that happening.
  2. Fun fact: A million seconds ago was about a week and a half ago. A billion seconds ago was the year 1990 A trillion seconds ago was 30,000 B.C. Any argument that suggests "wealthy" is all the same is equivocating to a ridiculous degree.
  3. Sounds like baseball in 2022 to me!
  4. I wouldn't be a fan of it either, but there will be a lot of QB movement this offseason, so who knows what opportunities present themselves.
  5. You made the claim that a world champ didn't use analytics to win while obviously not knowing they had an analytics department in two of the three seasons you cited. So, if you want your claim to hold could you please thoroughly research how Bochy ignored the analytics department? Or why the Giants were paying people they were actively ignoring? It's your claim to prove in light of that evidence. It'd be a cool story to read. By all means PM it to me when you have it done so we can keep the thread on track.
  6. 1) Yes, I contend that baseball teams were not steeped in analytics in, say, 1953 or 1908. They could have been, had someone been forward thinking enough, but they weren't. That's a fact. They also warmed to the practice slowly despite all kinds of evidence for it once it became more prevalent. 2) MLB teams are actively going to court to not pay players for spring training....so yes, I put nothing past them in the rest of this post. I'd think it silly too if they didn't actively engage in exactly that kind of bizarre, inexplicable behavior despite piles of evidence to the contrary. The evidence on the side of "baseball teams screw players over, nickel and dime them, are indifferent about their circumstances, and are cheap as hell" is a god damn mountain. So...yup, I gladly stand by it. Makes about as much sense as 15 minutes CBA negotiations. But here we are!
  7. Seriously? I mean, the Giants have had an analytics department since at least 2012 (Same guy still works there - Paul Bien), but don't let any evidence get in the way of your false argument.
  8. Watson is definitely a reason to hedge their bets considering his interest.
  9. Cool. Fun fact: I never said anything like this strawman. Like, even remotely. I know, I went back and reread to be sure. So, yes, I am declining to acknowledge a thing I never said. It's why I declined previously, I didn't want to engage your strawman. However, you appear intent to grasp at that straw (pun intended) because it's being made obvious by a host of other posters that you're delivering false conclusions. To clarify, cuz I'm nice like that, I said baseball ignored and/or didn't discover analytics until the game was a century old. It was always there to be used had some enterprising team wanted to employ it. Yet they didn't. Maybe that was purely ignorance of the value. But then...even now people brought up in the pre-analytics tradition still rail against it. Meaning there is a history of baseball ignoring things out of traditional thinking. Or out of stubborn, greedy thinking. Which is, you know, what I actually said. Apologies to your strawman, but the third path is pretty obvious and as as baseball as apple pie (Or some other clever turn of phrase): MLB is really good at inexplicably ignoring good ideas because it's cheap, ignorant, or weird.
  10. I'm so glad someone brought this up. This is the investment vs. commodity I was alluding to earlier, but maybe that's not quite right. It's closer to investment vs. asset/property. The teams clearly know spring training has value for the minor leaguers, otherwise they wouldn't invite/require them to be there. They also clearly think their time is worth some compensation. Yet they fight tooth and nail to keep that compensation at the absolute minimum, even in situations where they fully acknowledge the value. This entire situation stinks of "yeah, those investments might be really fruitful....but I'll be damned if they get one red cent from me!" And, yes, this is behavior and thinking completely in lock-step with a variety of issues from the CBA to funding stadiums to building facilities, etc. This is precisely how the MLB owners think across a variety of topics, why are we at all shocked it exists with the lowest rung of players?
  11. Baseball did not use analytics until recently. It could have been done just as well in 1908 as 2022. The advantage such a strategy could lead to didn't just come into existence in the universe in 1977. It was always a possibility, only no on had thought to consider it. Meaning through some combination of ignorance, oversight, stubborn behavior, or whatever else they were eschewing an otherwise wonderful tool. Your contention that the same couldn't be the case right now with investing in minor leaguers is a point with no merit. It's demonstrably false and your fallacious reasoning is the root of that false claim.
  12. The point was the flaw in your logic. It's literally the fallacy of false alternatives. Your entire argument on this entire point is one big, fat pile of fallacious thinking. And you're so stuck in your own bias about it that you can't pull free. Go ahead, google the fallacy. It's unquestionably what you're doing and why your point requires some serious re-thinking. As for the argument I made: Bill James was publishing mathematical evidence for it as of 1977 yet it didn't take hold for decades after beyond a few pockets of individuals. Applying your logic would lead someone to believe that it took so long because it outlawed by rules or that they studied the benefits and found it lacking. There is no possible third alternative as you say. Of course, we know that isn't the case. Sabermetrics are not outlawed, nor were they ever, and they reaped massive benefits had anyone pulled their heads out of their rear ends long enough to consider the possibilities. Teams didn't adopt them because they were rigid and lacked the desire or willpower to be forward thinking. Just like they are on this issue. What will need to happen is similar to SABR - a recognition that old arguments don't apply and past thinking was flawed. Players are investments to build up, not commodities to control.
  13. Baseball spent 100 years ignoring analytics. Decades intensely avoiding it when it was openly advocated. Still to this day dismissed by many in baseball. This conclusion is obviously false. Several of your conclusions on this issue seem to carry the same burden.
  14. You have made your position more than clear on this issue, but I don't think it holds up under any reasonable amount of scrutiny. It simply doesn't make sense to put forward so little care and concern for significant investments. Baseball has been nothing if not great at ignoring rational, obvious ways to make itself better. Including teams and their strategic thinking.
  15. Not only are these logical from the position of running a smart baseball operation that helps players succeed, it's also just basic common sense in terms of how you handle your business investments. Appel, who has a fat signing bonus, is talking about how he and his peers have to struggle for good meals, good workouts, and a place to live. How the hell can any rational person see that as an effective system for building up players to play a rigorous, physical game? How no executive has been smart enough to invest peanuts into this for a better return than the rest of the league is beyond me. It's a huge competitive advantage for minimal investment. God baseball is full of short-sighted folks.
  16. Adam Zimmer really thought he still had a shot I bet.
  17. We are all too desperate for worthwhile conversation. We are several steps past "welp...how bout this weather we're having?" It shows. Stupid lockout.
  18. I see what you're saying about Colon or Madbum, but the truth is the vast majority of pitcher ABs are ugly, useless, or predictable. IMO that doesn't help the game or the aesthetics of it.
  19. Universal DH is the headliner for a reason: it is a wonderful step to improve the quality of baseball viewing. Long overdue
  20. I'm with you, but I imagine the fan base isn't going to agree with us in general.
  21. At 12 this would be an ideal place to pick a CB or trade down. The two things Vikings fans least want to hear, lol.
  22. Um..... it literally says in the part I quoted "thousands". So......no, I changed nothing. Players you cite as staying with their team and foregoing free agency are doing so because they don't want to risk free agency not being as lucrative as the offer on the table. It's still about dollars and years there's just a risk analysis going on.
  23. I missed the part where you acknowledged you were wrong about the 2020 negotiations.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.