Everything posted by kab21
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
If they don't then trading for one starter won't matter.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Are you talking about the team that is 14 games under .500 with the 5th worst record? This team will rebound but it will be when the prospects start contributing. Trading them away is not a good idea.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Gallardo is a complete mess right now. Velocity and K's are way down.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Just because a team is taking a long view doesn't mean that they will take lesser talent. Kepler is a borderline top 100 guy with good upside so he is a start. Why on earth would the Marlins trade Fernandez before he even finishes his first season? Expensive arb years are 3 years away.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Norris will become available at some point but he will be a FA in 2.5 yrs I think. I could see Norris costing a Berrios/Rosario level prospect. Definitely someone in the 50-100 range. Fernandez will require the moon to trade for. At least Sano if you are not familiar with the moon.
-
Dream Trade Candidate: Profar
Yes. SS is a position of dreadfully awful players and he was 5th and 6th in WAR in 2011/2012. Even if you don't like WAR it would be very difficult to name 10 SS's that are actually better than Andrus. Nevermind that he's 24 yrs old.
-
Dream Trade Candidate: Profar
I would gladly take Andrus and his contract. He's a young, plus defender that hits .280/.340/.350 most seasons. I will take a decade of that even though he will likely opt out in 2018.
-
Another chance at Shortstop for Dozier?
If you are pretty certain that Rosario can be an average MLB'er at 2nd then it is much easier to try Dozier at SS again than it is to find a good SS (draft, FA or trade).
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
What exactly has Perkins done to show he can continue to pitch effective? He has pitched 2.5 seasons out of the bullpen. That's not a long track record. He also missed half of the 2009 season with a shoulder injury. If a team is putting a Crick, Barnes, Webster or Castellanos level prospect out there for Perkins the Twins should jump at the trade. I don't care what position the prospect plays as long as he's top 50 (or better) talent with some upside. Anyone that is critical of Castellanos needs to consider that he was a 20 yr old in AA. He's now a 21 yr old in AAA (not the PCL) putting up a .800 OPS with excellent K:BB numbers and solid power numbers.
-
Article: One pitcher the Minnesota Twins should sell high
Fein has minimal trade value. Best case you trade him for a guy whose reasonable upside is what Fein is doing now. Perkins is the guy at peak value. And that's about the only guy on the team that is at peak value.
-
Trade Sam Deduno?
Deduno is worth very little. if you want to get value then it starts and almost ends with Perkins and possibly Plouffe. Everyone else is worth minor league scraps.
-
Ryan: Safe to Say We are in Trade mode
If you look at those teams they typically have one thing in common. Most of them had a couple of young players that were becoming stars. Verlander, Glavine, Davis, Longoria. They also had several other young players (and a few veterans) in place during the 90 loss season. if the 2014 Twins lose 90 games then it's possible to go from 90 losses to 90 wins. Next year the Twins just don't have the players in place (especially pitching) to make that big of a turnaround this year (imo). In 2015 that could be possible since potential stars (buxton and Sano) should be up full time and several other young players should be up and established as well.
-
Trade Sam Deduno?
fixed that for you Why on earth would a team that has an awful rotation trade someone for a C level prospect? The Twins have a lot of rk ball prospects. They need some stability in the rest of the rotation.
-
Article: Trade Talk: San Diego Padres
So basically the same as the Twins?
-
Twins' prospect Alex Meyer's return date still unknown
I think people need to realize that TJ is a bump in the road and not a death sentence.
-
Article: International Signing Preview
That's the one loophole that I see. If you are going over then you might as well go WAY OVER and sign everyone. As long as you don't mind the 100% tax. It's too bad if the Twins lose out on a good prospect because of it though.
-
Twins to promote Michael Tonkin
Roenicke has pitched well in the same way that Burnett pitched well last season. And Burnett didn't last long this season despite of that. I wouldn't be shocked if he wasn't around in August.
-
See What Sticks: Phil Hughes
I think some will be disgusted by what Hughes gets this winter. And then there will be the other camp that says to sign simply because they won't spend the money elsewhere. I actually like Hughes a fair amount but his age and former prospect hype will cause someone to go crazy in FA. I think he will ge 5/60. Yep...
-
Gleeman: Buxton/Sano vs. past top prospect duos
My concern about Sano remains unchanged. He dominated the FSL but the K's were still there. He could be awesome or he could merely be a useful MLB'er. The important part is that he could be awesome. Same goes for Buxton but his floor is a little higher because of defense and the lack of a major red flag.
-
Reusse: Extending Morneau might be better than a trade
I see a lot of warnings issued on here that prospects are not sure things. I think the same is true of injury prone 32 yr old players that haven't been above average for 3 yrs.
-
Reusse: Extending Morneau might be better than a trade
You didn't really get the sarcasm in that post. Parmelee doesn't have to hit like the Morneau of old either. The Morneau of old is gone forever. It's quite possible that Parmelee can match Morneau's recent/future performance.
-
Reusse: Extending Morneau might be better than a trade
Let me help you with this. Justin Morneau is never going to be as good as Justin Morneau was. I'd bet a lot of money on that. Useful player? Sure. The kind of hitter you sign for 10+M/yr? No chance, IMO. I think you should be holding Morneau to the same standard as you hold the other hitters. I like Morneau a lot. There's also a chance that he could rebound but how many years do you wait?
-
Reusse: Extending Morneau might be better than a trade
So far the only arguments for extending him at 2/20 (or give him a qualifying offer) are because his name is Justin Morneau and the Twins won't spend the saved money elsewhere. I think this is a poor way to run a team. The Twins are stacked with guys that play OF/DH/1B with more coming up next year.
-
Is Dozier a Keeper?
It's still too early to tell if he's a keeper but there are only two potential MI keepers above low A (Dozier is one). Despite lengthy debates regarding potential neither Escobar/Florimon belong in a starting lineup long-term. Dozier will get his chances and it wouldn't surprise me if he moves back to short in a couple of years. I also wouldn't be surprised if part of his success this year isn't due to being able to relax a little in the field. Once he's established as a hitter it's possible that he could move back and be solid offensively and defensively.
-
Giants looking at Twins Bullpen - Should we trade?
I would trade Perkins for Crick since he's pretty good and SP'ing is what will make or break the team in the future. Fein I would just hold onto unless there was a pretty good prospect offered. He has been really good since he came up last year. Adalberto Mejia is the type of intriguing prospect that i would be looking for. There's nothing wrong with Burton or the contract he signed. He's solid but not great and he never had much trade value.