Everything posted by kab21
-
26 year old Cuban SS Alexander Guerrero
Some guys take this don't spend on a rebuilding team bit too far but most simply don't want to be committing 12-16M/yr for 4-5 yrs on guys that probably will be below average by the end of their contracts. Edwin Jackson I'm talking about you. Buehrle don't act like I can't see you. Guerrero is rumored to be available for less and he is in his prime right now. if the Twins like this guy then lets spend some money.
-
The Silver Lining of Kyle Gibson
He routinely got lit up in AAA early in the season. Overall his numbers were okay but things could have been ugly in the majors. Or we could have had more of this 6+ERA that he is currently putting up. I think Gibson starting in the minors and staying down for as long as he did had to with him not looking great even though he threw some nice games.
-
26 year old Cuban SS Alexander Guerrero
Your arguments so far in this thread: A) If he can't play short then I don't want to block Rosario We got burned by Nishi so maybe the Twins shouldn't pursue high dollar int'l FA's. C) He will be 26/27 and sat out 2 years. This is pretty standard for Cuban FA's. It sounds like you would argue against using an entire avenue of player acquisition to make the team better. D) 27 teams aren't rumored to be in the mix so there must be something wrong with him. This is actually pretty common in Cuban and even normal FA. Only one team was in on Puig and the rest of the baseball world (FO's and writers) thought the Dodgers were completely crazy signing him for 40+M. Obviously the Twins will have to scout him and they will have significantly better resources than any of us but the fact that they are interested has me interested.
-
Twins top ten starting pitching prospects
Torn ligament in the shoulder. That does sound horrible.
-
Twins top ten starting pitching prospects
I would take Stewart and Meyer over Appel and nobody.
-
26 year old Cuban SS Alexander Guerrero
We agree on many things but this is a terrible analysis. I don't care if Guerrero can't stick at SS. If he is a legit MLB player then this would be a great move. I wouldn't care if the Twins signed a Cuban OF'er (Alvarez). This team needs to add talent to the roster and worry about where to play them later. If Rosario truly ended up blocked by Guerrero then he would be a very attractive trade piece that could net the Twins a decent pitcher. And the scouting reports only say that he probably won't stick at SS. The same scouting reports said that Rosario and Sano might not stick at 2B/3B.
-
August 4th
Not surprisingly worley is injured. I don't think he was ever alright after his relatively minor offseason surgery.
-
Twins top ten starting pitching prospects
You still aren't close to half and that is including guys in the majors. Cole/Taillon - one is not a prospect Bundy/Gausman - I don't care if bundy is injured - he's good Gray/Butler - Butler is closer to Berrios imo Bradley/Skaggs Walker/Hultzen Wacha/Martinez Wheeler/Syndergaard - one is not a prospect Appel/McCullers - mcculllers is again closer to Berrios imo Barnes/Ball - one more to help you
-
2014 MLB (Rule 4) First Year Player Draft
Ugh... Buxton's other tools are probably all in the 55-70 range while the rest of Turner's probably top out at 55 (or maybe 60). Sounds more like Billy Hamilton imo. Not what I'm looking for in the probable top 5.
-
Twins top ten starting pitching prospects
I think the Twins pitching prospects rank higher than a lot of people give them credit for. Not many teams have a 1/2 of Stewart/Meyer. Even the depth has been improving lately.
-
Arcia
Are you just being argumentative? 2 yrs of rk ball and 2 injury plagued years covering low A to AAA while being promoted to the majors at age 21. That is moving fast according to almost every organization.
-
2014 MLB (Rule 4) First Year Player Draft
You lose all hindsight credibility if you think there was non-zero chance of the Twins taking Lee. Other teams wanted Wimmers and he would have been taken in the first rd. Sickels considered it a good pick as did most at the time. It was boring that but that doesn't mean it was a bad pick. 2010 MLB Draft Grades, Part 2: Cubs, Yankees, Mets Get Day One Thumbs Down - SBNation.com
-
Arcia
I'm not sure why everyone thinks that Arcia is finished with the minors. He was promoted quickly through the minors and he does have some bad habits that are holding back his raw skill. But Cletus shouldn't be playing everyday... Hicks has actually been halfway decent (if you factor in CF defense) in May, June, and July. Not great but not nearly as bad as some are making it sound.
-
2013 Trade Deadline
Iglesias has a nice glove but he sucks at hitting. I think he will hit more like his 900 PA's in AAA than his 200+ PA's in the majors. What was Chi doing here? Giving Peavy away for some MiLB scraps.
-
2014 MLB (Rule 4) First Year Player Draft
It's tough to hate the Wimmers pick except in hindsight. Perhaps you weren't as excited about it as others but draft picks in the 20's usually come with big question marks. Taking a safer guy at that point is not terrible. Taking a Wimmers type in the top 10 or even top 5 would be infuriating though.
-
July 28th
Comparing minor league stats of prospects and elite players is fun but pretty much pointless. Elite players are the exception in baseball.
-
July 28th
Rosario is nothing like Carew. Rosario is more of a Todd walker type. Revere had a similar offensive game to Carew.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
The more likely target on the Orioles is Jonathon Schoop. He has been promoted aggressively so his numbers are all over the place but he has the raw talent to 2B/SS/3B. On the O's he's never going to be a SS (Hardy and Machado) but on the Twins he could stick there possibly.
-
Tigers Trade for Closer - Perkins related
David Robertson says Hi. Any combination of players similar to Danry Vazquez is an unacceptable return for Perkins.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
And they are usually talking about 30 somethings signing 50+M contracts. Cespedes was more like a really expensive prospect. At the time Cespedes was mostly dismissed around here since the Twins are loaded with OF'ers. I had a bias against Cubans at the time but Cespedes and Puig have been awesome so far. I would trade Perkins for Bundy in a heartbeat. I would not even think twice about. TJ is really successful nowadays and I can wait 2 years for another potential front line starter mixed in with Stewart and Meyer. One of them might reach their potential.
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
The board is acting like he wasn't aggressive nor creative last offseason. I would consider that both aggressive and creative.
-
2014 MLB (Rule 4) First Year Player Draft
I really don't find myself loving Trea Turner. Perhaps I'm just weary of players whose top tool is speed though.
-
10 Days of Walker
His K:BB ratio is awful. We don't have cool data like pitchFX but K:BB tells us that he is probably chasing a lot of pitches and/or having trouble making contact even with strikes. He has shown improvement which is encouraging but he is already striking out a lot against pitchers that don't have a quality breaking ball/fastball combo. That won't be true as he moves up to A+/AA ball and definitely not in the majors. I'm definitely not comparing MLB K rates to low minors K rates. Most MLB'ers with high K rates didn't start having problems until high minors or MLB pitchers found the holes in their swing. You are focused too much on K rates for comparable MiLB players. Goodrum (whom I don't like much), Kepler and harrison are all younger and all of them walk twice as much. And the K's are still a red flag for all 3 of them although not as big of an issue.
-
Article: International Signing Preview
We are and were in agreement.
-
Article: International Signing Preview
There's a difference between being critical of the MLB team and being critical of spending big money to build up a farm system. As a matter of fact if Cubs fans should be critical of anything it should be of the ignore the farm system strategy that was used for so many years that put them into this hole.