Everything posted by Thrylos
-
Neal: Home-Groan: Twins Trouble Drafting, Developing Starters
2. Baker and Garza. But Garza really was a Tampa product since he started only 26 games with the Twins with 0.8 WAR ,4.47 ERA, 1.602 WHIP and constant fighting with Andy about how he should be pitching... And he made the majors the year after he was drafted so really he did not have much time to "develop" in the Twins' system. He so should not count. The Royals drafted and developed Greinke and the Tigers Verlander. I'd take either for both Baker and Garza
-
Article: Commitment Issues
I think that this is a good start of defining the problem but got to take it one step beyond: 2016 should teach the Twins' brass that if you are close to competing, like they were in 2015, they should go all in. They assumed that they can half rear end it in 2015 and wait for the Godot prospects to be better in 2016 to really compete. See what the Mets did in 2015. That's what the Twins should have done in 2015. Buxton. The game's "consensus" number 1 prospect. Bet they could have gotten a bit of help for 2015 and more future help for him before he was exposed for the second time... And this is just an example. Catch-22: This system cannot develop prospects, is unwilling to sell high on prospects (and major leaguers) because "they might get better somewhere else", and that is what is ending up happening. Either gut your development system because it sucks and replace it with another, or forget about it and sell high on "prospects" to get major leaguers developed correctly by another system (i.e. the long standing Yankees' paradigm...)
-
Article: Commitment Issues
This assumes that the Twins' system can do that. Huge leap of faith. Development just sucks compared to other systems. Here is an example: Jeff Manship. He failed to develop with the Twins. He went to another system and blossomed. If your system of developing prospects sucks, no matter what you throw at it, will not work...
-
Article: Commitment Issues
The Capps trade got the Twins in the postseason. The Jepsen trade did not. That's a big difference. Also: Hu was a much lesser prospect in the Twins system (does that say anything about the Twins' system and their ability to develop pitchers? Of course it does) than Ramos, but Ramos was blocked by a guy named Mauer, and if Mauer did not go through concussion issues and had been the Mauer that we all expected to be when that trade was made nobody would be talking about Ramos now... And Capps was a closer while Jepsen was a middle reliever in their respective teams. Bottom line: the Twins need a better way of developing pitchers, so they have several ready to jump in from their pen. I have still not seen a pitcher since Neshek and Crain, come in from the minors and be very successful in the pen, while others (Hendriks, Manship etc) found success after changing organizations, which makes me think that the issue is not the talent, but the way they develop talent. (and one of course can make a similar argument about starters from the MLB level down.) That is the root cause of the problem and not trades for mediocre relievers. The latter is a (bad) symptom...
- Article: Minnesota's Worst All-Stars
-
Best Minor League Signings of 2016
That guy at MLB rumors should really change the title to "best minor league free agent signings", because the way he has it, it refers to international and undrafted free agent minor leaguers who were signed this year as amateurs.
-
Best Minor League Signings of 2016
What's positive? Saying that 3 Twins with barely average to below average performances are on top of the dumpster diving pile? The bad news is that the are their closer, set up man and starting left fielder and in those roles they are in the bottom quarter in the majors. Sure. Among dwarfs someone who is 5'2" might be treated as a giant, but among the rest of the population...
-
What 2nd half record saves Terry Ryan's job?
I thought that he should be gone in '98 (when he was in the middle of being the henchman in Pohlad's grand plans of grand suckage = lack of interest by fans = no ticket sales = move or contraction = $ in Pohlad's pockets, and in the second of 4 straight 92+ L seasons; does history repeat itself?) rejoiced when he retired in '07 and have been waiting for him to go (one way or another) since '11. No way to sway me, unless the Twins go to the World Series this season, and then, maybe, I might change my mind.
-
The Formula for Success?
Getting away from Brunansky
-
Twins second half record?
May I take the under, based on the Twins' record? Here is the difference in winning percentage of the Twins' teams this decade between first half and second half 2015: -.085 2014: -.086 2013: -.038 2012: -.034 2011: -.160 Average: -.081 So a .283 record the second half would be the norm for the Twins this decade.... No clue why you would think that this team would be the exception...
-
Let's talk about Suzuki's 2017 option.
Is Suzuki (esp with his axe bat hot streak) better than some catchers certain contenders have right now, so there is trade potential? Yes Is Suzuki the long term answer for a contender as a catcher? No Should the Twins keep someone who is not the long term answer in the C position if the want to contend? No Hope that cleared the confusion
-
Let's talk about Suzuki's 2017 option.
I would not, because of who runs it and his MO. Matter of fact, I have Ryan capable of letting him have enough PAs to pick up the option... Should they trade him? (Heck yeah. Yesterday...) That will bring up JR Murphy and push Garver and his .273/.357/.434 AA slash line to AAA and to a September call up, to see whether one of the 2 might be the Twins starter next season or the Twins would need to do something else. But Terry Ryan? No. He'll keep him
-
Article: Breaking Good: Positive Vibes At The All-Star Break
re: Duffey a. he still cannot get past the 6th inning b. his "improvement" the last month is due to a .235 BABIP in that time. His K/9 dropped to 6.9, however during that period; both facts are pretty bothersome. c. but the most bothersome facts is that if you asked 20 people in the game, 18 (*) would tell you that they'd rather have May than Duffey (and his one pitch) in the rotation, because Duffey is better suited for the pen and can actually be pretty good there... (*) the other two are either working or rooting for the Twins
-
Article: Breaking Good: Positive Vibes At The All-Star Break
Reality: 20 games out of the division lead 24 games under .500 1 game better than the worst team in baseball the worst team in the American League 5 games under their Pythagorean W-L on pace for 103 losses 15th/15 in ERA in the AL 15th in Hits given in the AL The rest are lipstick (on the most hideous pig since the franchise moved to MN, btw) The problem is that the FO might think that they have something in their hands and might refuse to trade the likes of Tonkin, Pressly, Suzuki, Grossman, Santana (take your pick), Nolasco, Dozier, Nunez (and I might even add Vargas with that mess they made with the Park acquisition to the list). The opportunity is to sell high. Would they? Based on past experience I doubt it. The above are not part of the future and they might bring back a couple players who might be...
- Article: Examining Potential 40-man Additions
-
You're the next GM of the Twins
That sounds like Michael Corleone's famous like on Godfather III (when I thought I was out, they pull me back in) Bet if they sucked the last month, you wouldn't feel that way You got to trade them when they don't suck, or right before they suck again...
-
You're the next GM of the Twins
April fools' 2017 25-man roster: C: Murphy/Garver 1B/DH: Mauer/Park/Vargas 2B/SS: Beresford/Polanco/Escobar 3B: Sano OF: Palka/Kepler/Rosario/Buxton/Grossman That's 14. SP: Meyer, Berrios, May, Gonsalves, Jose RP: Duffey, Chargois, Burdi, Rogers, Hilderberger, Theophanopoulos That's 11. Barring injuries. Anyone else who has played with the Twins (eg. the Tonkin's, Santana's, Dozier-Plouffe's, Milone, Hughes etc of the world) the past season or two, traded or demoted. Wham! Bam! Thank you ma'am
- Congrats to Eduardo Nuñez All-Star
-
Chris Young (Pitcher)
I was just waiting for the kicker, something like: has allowed an unfathomable TWENTY SIX HOME RUNS IN SIXTY INNINGS this season. and his ERA is just a point over Tommy Milone's (True story. Chris Young has a 6.24 ERA vs Milone's 6.23...)
-
Trading Dozier Redux
I believe that Terry Ryan should not be making any more decisions regarding who should stay and who should go Dozier's "leadership" is a lot like Tommy Herr's and Garry Gaetti's (after Tommy Herr) "leadership". And that's another good reason for him to go.
-
So what happens if the Twins DO trade Ervin Santana?
hate it when the only guy who can be a true ace in the Twins' organization is dismissed because of misuse and general minor league Twins player development malaise... Alex John Meyer. That's who.
-
Your 2017 twins lineup?
Too early to tell. But Centeno? Really? How about Murphy? And flip Nunez and Polanco, trade Nunez and find a second baseman (Beresford.) Really, this should be the Twins' 2016 lineup
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (6/30): Walker Walkoff Highlights Night
1. This is a killer shot. Really. 2. Glad you are jumping into the Palka bandwagon The Twins first baseman of the future
-
Article: J2: Come Here, International Free Agents
In addition to Felix ($260K bonus) and Wander Valdez ($400K bonus) they have signed Dominican SS Stamy Urena ($130K bonus). Everyone is a SS in the Dominican, but I expect both Felix and Valdez to play at corner positions when they reach the majors. FWIW, the pitcher crop this season is not that great. I suspect that the Twins might look to EU for some signings as well. Cuba is a wild-card because of the recent political change
-
Trading Dozier Redux
Why? Won't work for competing this season? That bird flew away. They got to play young players (Polanco is out of options next season) to figure out what they have. I see no reason not to go with a Escobar/Beresford-Polanco-Sano IF right now. Might beat the Dozier-Nunez-Plouffe one. If it does not work, they deal with it during the off-season.