Everything posted by PseudoSABR
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
I'm not denying Skinner's influence on psychology; I'm denying his applicability to the argument and that behaviorism is something new to anyone here. I wonder what Lacan or Irigaray would say about the yips (or rather, who cares). I'll stop now. Apologies to the non-snark crowd.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Well, the attribute's value would be relative to the rest of population of baseball players, so whatever minimal percentage you want to assign, it should still have a tangible affect in even an elite population. Pardon the glib example: If everyone has 99 Poise, the guy with 98 Poise is the ****ty non clutchy guy, right? I totally agree, hence my evoking (or failing to) the word 'poise' into the conversation. No one's going to get better under pressure, they will simply maintain their poise. I think we're on the same page, mostly.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
This whole paragraph is patronizing (The "true Father," for example). You're not the only one whose taken a handful of psychology classes or read a book. BF Skinner and his behaviorists are looked at with total suspicion these days, but I'm sure you know that. BF Skinner is about as 'scientific' as aromatherapy, in any case there's nothing in your post that evidences your points about baseball, you're merely educating us on points most of us are pretty familiar with. You didn't use those quotes, I'm making fun of you to show the ridiculous slippery slope you've created. And it's obvious to so many here (again, hence why you are patronizing) that human behavior can't be quantified. Look, you'll get a lot further in discussions if you stop assuming that the other posters here aren't as well-read and smart as you. Heck, I'm probably on your side in this argument (at least in spirit), but you're posts are so sloppy and disingenuous that it makes my skin curdle.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
I think you're pigheadedness on this point is only saved by the unquantifiableness of abstract human characteristics. Because you really can't say what percentage of baseball players are actually affected by pressure or perform with excellence in spite of it; we have no one way of knowing, right? Jokin suggests lots of players are affected by pressure you say .001 percent, you're both just guessing. Look, I'm not arguing in favor of clutchiness but you're being awfully stubborn about admitting there might be something to pressure/poise/whatever, in spite of the fact we can't really measure it.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Look, in my prior post to the one responding to yours I state myself that being unable to quantify a factor doesn't forbid its existence. But this post is again glib and even patronizing. If you have no desire to be taken seriously, continue right ahead. But I'd recommend picking your battles. It's perfectly fair for people to scoff at "winning attitude" and "clutchiness" because really they are likely made out of baser attributes, like poise, as I've mentioned. Meet the postivistic posters half way by getting them to agree to some abstract attributes, rather than inventing ones like "capacity to find the silver lining in bad inning," or "ability to handle booing during an at bat."
-
Article: Trade Target Team Profile: Atlanta Braves
It may work in the Twins favor that they play in the AL, as the other teams with top-flight starters all play in the NL, and the Braves may not want to deliver a young starter to teams their directly competitive with (all other things being equal, that is).
-
July 2nd
Sano with three errors and was eventually lifted for a pinch hitter after two at bats. No Ks though!
-
Article: Twins vs. Tigers, 07/02/2012, 6:05pm
If Butera's on the team, I wouldn't mind seeing more of him replacing both Mauer (moving to first, if need be) and Doumit defensively after the 8th.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Look, no one's going to take "winning mindset" as a serious characteristic that people actually possess. I think everyone can agree psychology affects baseball (how could it not?), but you can be much more precise in how you go about identifying such elements. Of course people are going to cynical of concepts that can't be quantified, so you're going to have to be far more convincing than glibly mentioning the Yankees.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
I wonder if we might get somewhere more profitable if we redefined terms. I think clutchiness is too slippery and something evaluators of talent wouldn't know how to identify within the player, but rather clutchiness is created out of specific conditions, conditions so rare that any data set seems untrustiworthy. But with that said, I can completely relate to the notion that what we know about the human condition suggests that there's certainly an element of grace under pressure in all human activities--we can all admit that such notions are abstract and ultimately judged just as abstractly with our intuition rather than our rationale. What I'm wondering precisely, is that rather than argue over the existence of clutchiness, we find common ground, in another abstract concept but one that I believe scouts actually look for. Poise. I think we can agree the concept is easily associated with pitchers. An old Baseball Think Factory article*, lists it among attributes that a pitcher is judged by (including some other slippery concepts like baseball instinct and aggressiveness). I think there's a hitter's counterpart for such a concept that everyone can admit probably affects how a hitter performs. In any case, such attributes are going to be mutable and dictated by conditions larger than the in-the-game situation. While sample size and quantification problems prohibit anyone from "proving" or "establishing" abstract characteristics like poise and clutchiness, I think it's just as silly to assert that such qualities don't exist (or don't affect baseball outcomes) because of they are irreducible and unfungible. *http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/primate_studies/discussion/mckarmey_2003-07-28_0/ " Pitchers are graded for fastball velocity, fastball movement, control, curveball, slider, change of pace, "other" pitch, mechanics, poise, baseball instinct, and aggressiveness"
-
Deep fantasy baseball league
Dude, I'm happy he's working out for you. I was skeptical. It's easy to count against speed for some reason.
-
June 29th
Sure, but that hardly explains his current hot streak--or rather doesn't dismiss the hot/cold streaky player we've seen over his minor league career. Perhaps there really is a psychological boon gained by not batting in the middle of the order, but its hard to hang one's hat on the premise.
-
Twins more willing to trade Span
There's Span the player and there's Span the contract. The sum of both is worth substantial pieces, whether at the deadline or next offseason. Given the public rumors over that last year, the Twins seem intent on capitalizing on Span's current value, which can only decrease over time...
-
Article: Twins Ink Doumit to Two-Year Extension
Riiiiiiiight.
-
Twins more willing to trade Span
You know how I can tell Heyman knows baseball? The way he holds the bat in his photo on the blog.
-
Crasnick: Twins close to multi-year contract with Doumit
Savvy move. Nothing not to like. Doumit is still a good trade trip if Parmlee or Herrmann force the issue.
-
Terry Ryan PMKI in the SABR
Ramos will continue to play for the Nationals far longer then Capps will for the Twins and at far more inexpensive contract. Using WAR to compare a veteran traded for a prospect is totally disingenuous, and would look even more foolish if Ramos wasn't out for the season.
-
Deep fantasy baseball league
Supposedly he is. It's been a while since I've read anything about his defense, but the notion of him needing to move seem quelled over spring training. I'm a bit pissed I took Harrell and his shutout out for Bauer who was only allowed to pitch four innings. Wack! I'm still having a pretty good week though.
-
June 27th
Right. His name has been buzzing in my head; I'm not sure if we disliked the third round pick or had some hope. I did some googling (not research) and found http://voices.yahoo.com/pitching-starved-twins-dean-hill-11082706.html . It's fan fiction, but maybe there's something to wish on... btw, anybody, how do you create a link to just text...not familiar with the code around here
-
Waldrop recalled; Manship optioned
What makes you say that?
-
Valencia, Morneau LH/RH splits and 1st base
Right. There was also word that he was remaking his swing over past several years, I'm not sure we really know what Parmelee's ceiling or floor is because of that...
-
Valencia, Morneau LH/RH splits and 1st base
I think RP should institute a word filter that corrects all the possible misspellings of all the Twins players to their correct spellings. It may take some time, but it'd take the heavy weight of spelling away from the heathens.
-
Deep fantasy baseball league
Last time we played, I think you won our match with a walkoff grandslam. Turnabout is fair play. Also, do you have any interest in trading some of minor league infielders (Odor, Rosario, Schoop)?
-
Deep fantasy baseball league
My team has been playing much better lately (12-4 last four weeks). And with Bauer and Perez up my time to contend may be happening a bit sooner than I thought. It looks like a Timmy L is coming around after today and his last start, which is a godsend. I almost wish I would have waited to acquire a catcher, like one that's actually playing this season. My trouble is I get so attached to some players, that it's difficult for me to assess where my team can best improve. I still believe in Smoak but firstbase is an obvious place where I need more production. I need an upgrade at second, too, but at least that's not a typical fantasy producing position. I also don't have a legit thirdbaseman this year. But I really like what Davidson is doing at AA.
-
Article: White Sox vs. Twins, 06/26/2012, 7:10pm
Thanks for the new screen name, RP!