Everything posted by Sssuperdave
-
Berrios or Santana?
This Berrios run reminds me so much of Liriano in 2006, when he was 10-1 at the All-Star break. He was dominating even more than Johan Santana, but I don't think anyone considered him an Ace yet. I don't think it's possible to be an Ace after half of one season, though it is obviously possible to pitch like one, which Liriano did and Berrios is doing. Unfortunately the ace-level performance didn't stick with Liriano, but I'm sure hoping it will with Berrios! There are a few key differences between the a Berrios/E Santana comparison and a Liriano/J Santana comparison though... I think Berrios' success is more repeatable since Liriano's success depended upon torking up the Slider to an unhealthy level, which caused TJ surgery.I'm awed by Berrios' "makeup" (work ethic, committment, attitude). This isn't to take anything away from Liriano, but Berrios seems to stand above the rest on this.E Santana certainly isn't the ace that J Santana was, so the bar for Berrios to clear isn't as high as Liriano's was to be the team's best pitcher. So, all that to say I'd still call Santana the Twins best pitcher or ace, but Berrios could change that with a couple more months like he's been having.
-
Article: Ervin Santana: To Trade Or Not To Trade?
In my opinion, the bolded parts show what it has been like to be a Twins fan over the last 20 years. We are so beaten down that we only set our sights as high as winning one of the weakest divisions in baseball. How is the fact that the Astros are a much better team than the Twins not a harbinger of doom? It is exactly a harbinger of doom if the goal is to win the World Series. If I'm Falvey and Levine, my goal is to be a better team than the Astros, not to sneak into a wild card spot and then hope we get lucky. And it's not just the Astros, after you beat the Astros you have to beat a team like the Cubs or Dodgers or Nationals!
-
Article: Part 6: Seth's Midseason Top 40 Twins Prospects (1-5)
Very exciting that the top three prospects are in AA and performing well. Even though the overall farm system isn't as strong as it used to be, the top three could start meaningfully contributing to the Twins as early as next year. When you add Gonsalves, Romero, and Gordon to the already forming young core of Sano, Buxton, Kepler, Rosario, Polanco, and Berrios, you have the makings of a team that could compete for several years. It kind of feels like the early 00s when Mauer, Morneau, Hunter, Cuddyer, and Santana were all breaking in.
-
Trade or stand pat
I often read the phrase "Once you make the playoffs, anything can happen", but I don't really believe it. I know there have been wild card teams that won the WS, but back in the 00s when the Twins made the playoffs in 6 of 9 years I never felt they had a reasonable shot at winning the World Series, and they only made it out of the LDS once. If everything breaks right this team might make the playoffs, especially considering how weak the Central is, but even if they added another starter I just don't see them beating the Yankees, Nationals, Dodgers, or Cubs in the postseason.
-
Max Kepler Appreciation Thread
Totally agree, and now that Berrios has had a couple of strong starts it feels like we're finally bearing the fruits of the youth movement we've been waiting so long for. I've been salivating over the idea of a team led by Berrios/Sano/Buxton/Kepler/Polanco/Rosario for about four years now. Of course, I was hoping Kohl Stewart and Oswaldo Arcia would be in the mix too, but you can't win them all.
-
Fangraphs: byron-buxton-is-slowing-down-in-the-good-way
Saying he's an out 83 But he's not an out 83% of the time any more. From April 3rd through April 20th he was an out 92% (!!!!!!) of the time, and since April 21st he's only been an out 74% of the time. That's a huge difference. Slash line from 4/3 - 4/20: .082/.135/.122/.257 Slash line from 4/21 - 5/14: .265/.357/.388/.745 While that second slash line isn't exactly all-star material, when you couple it with his elite defense he is already a meaningful contributor.
- Game Thread: Twins@Rangers 4/25/17 7:05PM
-
Relief Pitching, 538 way
I couldn't agree more with this. There is nothing wrong with using counting stats to talk about what actually happened. They help tell the story of what happened in a game, a season, etc., and we're all baseball fans so shouldn't we enjoy that? The problem is when a non-predictive stat is used as a defense for who should or should not be signed for next season. Take something like RBIs. They are heavily situation-dependent, aren't always predictive, and don't even do the best job of differentiating a players skill. But, if a guy has 120 RBI in a season it means a lot of exciting stuff happened while he was at bat that year, and I hope I was watching some of it!
-
Relief Pitching, 538 way
You could "use WPA" to measure relief pitchers, but the Goose egg stat helps put some heuristics around when the opportunities for a high WPA will present themselves. Goose eggs inform reliever usage and WPA informs reliever effectiveness.
-
Relief Pitching, 538 way
This is a seriously good article and new statistic.
-
PA interviews Falvey
I keep bouncing back and forth between two ideas, but I think it's possible to agree with both: 1. Opening day rosters really don't matter very much. It will most likely only be a matter of days before the first change is made due to injury, trade, etc. 2. This roster doesn't make any sense. D Santana and Haley over Park? 13 Pitchers with a bunch of early off days? Whaaaaaaat????? I think it's possible to acknowledge that #1 is true but still be frustrated with #2. These roster decisions reek of group-think. It's like there was a committee (perhaps Falvey, Levine, Molitor, and someone else), that talked themselves in circles until they made decisions that don't make any sense unless you were there for the whole conversation.
-
MLBPA Special Assistant Kevin Slowey
Souhan absolutely ripped Slowey to shreds back when he was sent to the bullpen and didn't fare well. I obviously have no clue what really went on inside the clubhouse, but in all of the interviews I read or saw with Slowey he seemed very intelligent, kind, and articulate - not at all petulant or a malcontent. My impression, and this is 100% speculation, was that he operated on a different intellectual level and had a different approach to life than most of the other players or coaches, sort of like Robert Smith was with the Vikings, and as a result didn't "fit in" to the "clubhouse culture". I felt like Souhan had some sort of odd personal vendetta against Slowey because of this. I've always thought Souhan was a great writer, but my personal opinion of him went down several notches after the way he treated Slowey.
-
Chuck Knoblauch
I think you are over simplifying here Dave. You yourself said that "It is a lot more complicated" when talking about the woman's side. I think Chuck's side is more complicated too. It's way too easy to label someone a coward and brush them aside than actually look at why they behave the way they do. I'm in no way trying to defend Chuck here. He obviously was completely in the wrong here and should be punished. But I don't see what good it does to write him off as a coward. It's an easy way out.
-
Chuck Knoblauch
Man, such a sad story. The thing that has always stuck with me the most about Chuck is this quote from a story in the Strib a few years ago: He told his real estate agent to throw away a Gold Glove?????? There has got to be so much pain under the surface. It's really hard not to feel bad for a guy like that, even if he has responded to it with some very destructive (to both himself and others) decisions.
-
Why the Twins should spend top $$ for an Ace?
This is where the "Ace" conversation always bothers me. I don't think you need an "Ace" to win the world series, but I do think you need at least one pitcher who has a really really good season, and that pitcher doesn't have to come with an "Ace" label. Scott Erickson had an ace-like season in 91 but I don't think anyone would have ever given him an "Ace" label. Erickson had a higher WAR in 91 than Felix Hernandez has had in 5 out of 8 full seasons, so I'll take Erickson's 91 over 62% of Hernandez' years. There are plenty of candidates currently in the Twins organization to have a year like that - they don't need to have some mysterious "Ace" label.
-
Article: Minor League's Salary Structure Unfair?
I would expect that MLB has a hefty D&O insurance policy that would prevent Bud from having to personally contribute very much.
-
Why isn't Drew Butera a Pitcher?
In all seriousness, Drew pitched twice in mop-up relief this week for the Dodgers, the first time retiring the side 1-2-3. He did give up a couple runs in his second outing. According to this article, he touched 94 mph on the gun: http://www.latimes.com/sports/dodgers/dodgersnow/la-sp-dn-dodgers-drew-butera-reliever-20140514-story.html With his career .508 OPS, I would think his ceiling as a hitter is back-up catcher. Couldn't he add a couple ticks to his fastball and develop another pitch with a couple of years in the minors and a good pitching coach? It seems to me like he's got a higher ceiling as a pitcher than as a catcher.
-
Max Kepler - 2014
Kepler hasn't played for a few days - does anyone know why?
-
Game Thread: Twins v Dodgers double-header, 5/1 @ 12:10pm and 6:10 CT
These lines seem pretty different to me, especially if you focues on strikeouts and # of pitches. If Deduno had been starting all year and had that line after 4 innings you'd expect to get another 2 innings out of him. If he doesn't give up any runs in those two innings you've got a quality start. Pelfrey's line on the other hand just looks awful. Of course assuming another two run-free innings from Deduno is optimistic, but his line doesn't look awful to me, just kinda bad.
-
8 Walks
I agree. I was at work and refreshing a game log. After the third run scoring wild pitch I figured it had to be a website error. I actually game to the game thread here at Twins Daily to see if it was true.
-
Article: On Potato Cannons, Community and Free Pizza
Favorite All Time Twin: Kirby Puckett Favorite Current Twin: Samuel Deduno Favorite Pizza: Sausage and Mushroom
-
Article: Why Baseball? Why The Twins?
Wow, great article and great thread. I've got so many thoughts and could type for hours, but I'll try to keep this to a manageable length. Baseball is definitely my favorite sport. There was a stretch in the late 90s where Basketball and Football took the lead, but Baseball was my first sporting love, and is head and shoulders above the rest now. Here are a few reasons I love baseball: * Stats. I love numbers and statistics, and baseball has more of them than any other sport. Not only does it have more, but the stats tell such a story. I've got two young daughters right now and don't have cable, so I hardly ever get to see a game any more, but I truly enjoy reading the box score every morning. There's no other sport where you can get a good feel for what happened based on a box score alone. * Lack of Clock. I know this is a cliche, but it really is true in basebal that it ain't over till it's over. In a basketball game, if you are down 20 with 5 minutes left, it's over, but it baseball if you're down 6 going in to the 9th inning, you really can come back. It' doesn't happen much, but it happens just enough to keep me glued to the very last out. * Beauty. There's something about the colors, smells, and experience of a midsummer night at the ballpark that is just awesome. Even the metrodome was incredible for me. I'll never forget attending my first baseball game at the metrodome when I was 8. We got there really early and there weren't very many people there yet. The seats were sooooo blue and the field was sooooo green is was almost unreal. * Strategy. There is so much strategy in baseball, and so much can happen on any pitch. I love the war between the pticher and batter on every single at bat. What pitch will be thrown next? Where will it be? Will the fielders change position? Should the batter bunt? Hit and Run? Swing away? And I'm just scratching the surface. Now, why do I love the Twins? It all started in '87 when I was 7 years old. No one in my family was in to sports at all so I had never even heard of the Twins, but once they were in the playoffs with Detroit I heard friends and teachers at school talking about the Twins and was curious. My Grandpa was visiting when the world series started so I set down with him to watch the games, and I was hooked. While I was hooked by the postseason, like another poster a bunch of my most vivid Twins memories are from the regular season. Some of the best are when Randy Bush had 8 RBI, when the Twins turned 2 triple plays in a single game (and lost, then turned 7 double plays in the next game and lost), a walkoff home-run by Gary Gaetti, just about every one of Scott Erickson's starts in '91, and Kubel's grand slam off Rivera. The most crushing regular season defeat was Mike Trombley giving up a grand slam in the 12th inning (or something like that) to lose a three run lead to the Yankees. I was never very good at playing baseball. In fact, in my first year of little league I literally struck out in every single at bat. I was that bad. Seth hit .420 in high school, but I wasn't even good enough to make the team. "Easy Out!" was the most common refrain when I stepped up to the plate in little league. Yet, my best memories of playing sports are the few good baseball games I had. When I was 12 I was finally one of the better players in little league, and I'll never forget the game when I hit home runs in my first two at bats, both of them to right-center field. In my third at bat, as the catcher saw me approach the plate he stepped forward and yelled "back up outfield!". It was the only time that was ever said referring to me, and man did it feel good.
-
Article: Moving Goalposts
I'm not certain that the goalposts are moving, rather than expectations were unrealistic to begin with, and probably still are. I think we've all been salivating thinking about a team built around Sano, Buxton, Arcia, Rosario, and Meyer, but I don't expect those five to instantly produce the moment they hit the majors. Even if everything breaks right and all five of them become all-stars, I wouldn't expect it to be until their third year in the majors. So, if Buxton and Sano debut in 2015 we're really talking about 2017 before this team really hits it's stride, and even that is optimistic because I don't think you can plan on all five becoming all-stars. The one good thing about all this losing is that hopefully all those high draft choices can produce a pipeline of talent that lasts a while. I think the problem we all have is that we're impatient. Kohl Stewart has the potential to be a #1, but he probably won't even see the majors for thee or four years, and again will probably need two or three years after that before he's really producing at a top level.
-
Article: Glen Perkins Signs Extension With Twins
This kind of logic results from looking at the team payroll for each individual year in a vacuum. Front-loading contracts doesn't make financial sense for the team because of the time value of money. Even if you have cash up front, it always makes sense to pay for something later and invest the cash now. For example, here's some mental accounting TR and the Pohlad's could do: Set aside an extra $8.475M this year in a "Perkins contract fund" (to bring this year's "salary" up to $12M) and count it as part of this year's payroll. Then in future years pay Perkins out of this "fund" and don't count it against that future year's payroll. It has the same effect as front-loading the contract but they earn investment income in the mean-time. I'm sure they don't do anything exactly like this, but I imagine they actually do things much more sophisticated in an attempt to maximize both the financial value and competitive "value" of the team over the long term.
-
Berardino: Gardy's Comments on Attitude
So earlier I said "Meh" to this thread, but this is all pretty interesting so I'd like to expand upon my ambivalance. I'm not a very good athlete but I used to be a very good classical musician. I considered trying to be a professional but I doubt I was good enough to truly make a living out of it. I would probably have been the musical equivalent of a AA flameout. I did have a lot of success in auditions and solo performances though, and I attributed some of that success to a sort of cockiness that I would try to turn on as I walked on the stage or in front of the judge. I would tell myself things like "They are here to listen to me." and "I'm going to show them what this is supposed to sound like." Arrogant, cocky stuff - it helped me relax. But, that was all going on in my head. I never said it out loud, and I did my very best to think the opposite as soon as I walked off the stage. If I let myself believe all of that when I was in the practice room I would have gotten too complacent and quit working when I got tired. I think I had the right idea, but I never perfected the balancing act. Sometimes I beat myself up too much on stage and get nervous, and other times I got too complacent in the practice room. Taking this analogy over to baseball, my "meh" response is becuase we don't know how good each player is at this balancing act. I question whether it's even possible to be successful on the field without confidence bordering on arrogance, but I think some guys try to or choose to turn that off as they step out of the batters box.