Everything posted by Sssuperdave
-
Berardino: Gardy's Comments on Attitude
Meh. All this talk about attitude is interesting and fun, but it is dwarfed 100-fold by results on the field. Thome was known as one of the nicest guys in the game, but the results of his hitting should have put fear into the cockiest pitcher around. I know clubhouse leadership is important, but it's pretty tough for those of us not in the clubhouse to really understand what guys are like inside it. Leadership is a nuanced skill, and every leader exhibits it a little differently.
-
2014 MLB Over/Under Contest!!11! Win BIG!
I really do hope I'm wrong.
-
2014 MLB Over/Under Contest!!11! Win BIG!
Arizona Diamondbacks - 80.5 - Under Atlanta Braves - 87.5 - Under Baltimore Orioles - 80.5 - Under Boston Red Sox - 87.5 - Over Chicago Cubs - - 69.5 - Over Chicago White Sox - 75.5 - Under Cincinnati Reds - 84.5 - Under Cleveland Indians - 80.5 - Over Colorado Rockies - 76.5 - Under Detroit Tigers - 89.5 - Over Houston Astros - 62.5 - Under Kansas City Royals - 81.5 - Over Los Angeles Angels - 86.5 - Over Los Angeles Dodgers - 92.5 - Over Miami Marlins - 69.5 - Under Milwaukee Brewers - 79.5 - Over Minnesota Twins - 70.5 - Under New York Mets - 73.5 - Over New York Yankees - 86.5 - Over Oakland Athletics - 88.5 - Under Philadelphia Phillies - 76.5 - Over Pittsburgh Pirates - 83.5 - Under San Diego Padres - 78.5 - Under San Francisco Giants - 86.5 - Under Seattle Mariners - 81.5 - Over St. Louis Cardinals - 90.5 - Over Tampa Bay Rays - 88.5 - Under Texas Rangers - 86.5 - Under Toronto Blue Jays - 79.5 - Under Washington Nationals - 88.5 - Over Tie breaker: The two AL WC teams will be: Yankees and Indians Tie breaker 2: The two NL WC teams will be: Giants and Braves
-
Reviews/Comments on Twins Prospect Handbook 2014
I've read about half of the handbook and I love it so far. I particularly like Seth's players of the year articles and how the prospect profiles are organized (amatuer, stats, scouting report, forecast). Here are a few more things that I think would be great: More/Expanded prospect lists at the the back, like top 40 or 50 instead of 20 or 30, and maybe include another list or two from other contributors at Twins Daily Include these "rankings" in each propsect profile. For example: Kohl Stewart (4, 3, 4). I'm not super familiar with players outside the top 10, so I find myself constantly flipping back and forth from the writeups to the prospect lists. More info on each affiliate, espcially 2013 stats. I like what you've got on page six, with location, twitter, and manager, but I'd love it if it were expanded to 1/2 page to 1 page per affilliate with 2013 results, hitting/pitching stats, and maybe team MVP, pitcher of the year, etc. Oraganizational leader lists. I remember Seth doing this once towards the end of last year and it was really interesting. I'm thinking top ten lists for things like IP, K, ERA, H, BB, OPS, HR, etc. players across all Twins affiliates combined. Tool Ratings. I imagine this is asking too much, but I'd love to see someone's 20-80 scale rankings of each tool for each player. "Day in the life" articles. As other commenters have mentioned, I'd love more articles that focus on what life is like in the minors, and perhaps some player interviews. I know a lot of that kind of thing already gets posted on TwinsDaily, but the prospect handbook seems like a good place to include a couple. Thanks for a great handbook!
-
Question on Options
Interesting... I'm surprised the bolded part doesn't happen more often. It seems logical to me that there could be two teams that are both really interested in an out-of-options player but don't want to make room on the major league roster. So, they could just take turns claiming the player and trying to pass him through waivers, and the player could bounce back and forth between the teams until one of them finally gives up. I don't recall ever seeing that actually happen though. I suppose if a player is valuable enough for more than one team to want him this badly a trade would be worked out instead.
-
Question on Options
I've done some reading on baseball transactions, but have a couple questions on players that are out of options. Here's the scenario: Team A wants to move a player to the minors who is out of options, Team A puts the player on waivers, and he is claimed by team B. Team B then tries the player out on the big league squad for a while, and like Team A decides they want the player in the minors, so they have to put him on waivers. Now for the quesitons... How long must team B wait before putting the player back on waivers? Can team A claim the player back? What I'm getting at with question 2 is this... say you've got an out-of-options player with a lot of upside who for whatever reason isn't a fit on any major league roster (like Vance Worley if he has a really bad start to the year). Multiple teams that want this player in their system, but no one wants him on the 25 man roster. How does this get sorted out? Say the Twins are Team A and Worley is the player. Could the Twins get Worley back and put him in the minors if he were claimed and subsequently waived by another team?
-
Favorite Advanced Stats for Pitchers
Okay sabermetrically inclined - I'm ready to be enlightened by your wisdom... What are your top three favorite stats to look at when evaluating pitchers and why? Feel free to post different lists for starters and relievers. Go!
-
Give me Garza at 4 yrs over Pelfrey at 2
My evaluation of pitchers is definitely skewed by how horrible our pitching has been, but Pelfrey's good year look pretty good to me. In 08 he had a 3.72 ERA over 200.2 IP, and in 2010 he had a 3.66 ERA over 204 IP. I think I'd be very pleased if he duplicated those numbers for the Twins. I suppose folks will say his peripheral numbers suggest he's unlikely to duplicate that success. I'm not that good at using more advanced stats for pitchers yet.
-
Article: Twins Sign Jason Kubel to a Minor League Deal
I like this signing a lot. He probably doesn't improve the big league club as it stands now but if he's willing to accept starting in Rochester (and I assume he is since it's a minor league deal) he'll be a decent replacement if injuries happen. And who knows, he could return to 2012 form.
-
MLB votes to ban home plate collisions
This wasn't directed at me, but here's a list off the top of my head: Plays I think are more exciting than bowling over the catcher: Suicide Squeeze Triple Plays Stealing Home Grand Slams Robbing Home Runs Diving catches in the outfield Gunning a runner down at the plate on a fly-out, even if the catcher doesn't get plowed into Walkoff Home Runs Every pitch of these other baseball situations (not exactly plays) are more exciting to me than bowling over the catcher: No-Hitters after the 7th inning Bottom of the ninth down by 1 with a runner in scoring position Game 7 of the world series Think of the 91 world series. Puckett's catch and home run in game 6, and every pitch of game 7 were more exciting that Harper getting plowed into. I don't even remember for sure who did the plowing - was it Lonnie Smith? Heck, I even liked the Kent Hrbek/Ron Gant controversy better. Oh, and Rick Aguilera pinch-hitting in game 3. I could go on, but I think it's obvious where I stand.
-
Kirby Puckett, Greatness, and Game 6
Kirby Puckett is my favorite baseball player of all time, and it’s not even close. Of course, I am as biased as can be on this. I first started loving baseball in 1987, when I was 7 years old, and Kirby had an electric energy and charisma that any kid would love. Then he gathered 234 hits in ’88 and won the batting title in ’89, and I was hopelessly hooked. Now that I’ve grown up and started learning more and more about advanced statistics, I’m really struggling with where he ranks among the greats all time. He had some power, but that wasn’t really his game. He stole a few bases, played great defense for a few years, and pounded out a ton of singles and doubles, but none of his stats really scream “all-time great”. His career OPS was .837, which is probably hall of fame worthy but isn’t eye-popping. Among position players all-time that places him between Jayson Werth and Hugh Duffy. According to baseball reference, his WAR was 50.8. Of course his career was cut short, so if you figure another 4 WAR per year for 5 years that would bring him up to 70, which would put him between Scott Rolen and Gary Carter. But, that all ignores Game 6 of the 1991 World Series. I still get chills whenever I think of that game; his dominance was incredible. It wasn't just his catch in the 3rd inning and his walk-off homerun in the 11th - he also hit a triple in the 1st, a sac fly in the 5th, and stole 2nd base in the 8th putting him in position to score the go-ahead run if Shane Mack got a hit. He had 3 of the Twins 4 RBI, scored 2 of the 4 runs, and had 8 total bases compared to 7 for the rest of the team. It was all-out dominance. But not only did he dominate – he knew that he would. Check out this quote from this Tim Kurkjian writeup several years ago… So, how does a game like that influence a player’s all-time greatness? It seems like the true greats in sports have games like that, rising to the occasion and dominating on the biggest possible stage. I can’t think of other specific examples off the top of my head, but I know Jordan and Kobe both did it a few times, and I’m sure there are examples for guys like Ruth, Gehrig, Mantle, etc. Was this game evidence of just how awesome Puckett was, or did he just get lucky? How much does this performance move him up the all-time greatness ladder?
-
Max Kepler
Kepler has hit safetly in 5 of the 6 AFL games he has played including 2 doubles and 3 RBI, for a .304/.346/.391 (.737) line. One good sign is that he has better numbers against lefties than righties. Check out this writeup on his 2-4 game Wednesday: Glendale's Max Kepler outshines arms, Twins teammates | twinsbaseball.com: News I imagine the Twins will have quite a dilema on his hands if he has a strong rest of the AFL deciding whether to add him to the 40 man to protect him from the rule V draft. Also, I apologize for not posting more towards the end of the season. I can tell posting slowed down as this thread is now at the bottom of the 2nd page of a google search for "Max Kepler". For most of the year it was the top result.
-
Contraction Revisited
Wow... that draft is fascinating. I always knew prospects were hard to predict, but I didn't realize how hard it is to predict future performance of guys already on the 40 man. Seriously... Guzman, Mays, and Milton above Hunter, Radke, Cuddyer, Mientkiewicz, and Santana. Check out the writeup on Joe Mays... ... And after 2001 he amassed -2.8 WAR.
-
Max Kepler
Unfortunately Kepler suffered another injury this past Sunday requiring stiches to his right index finger. It was a freak accident, that Jeff Johnson of the Cedar Rapids Gazette described this way: I haven't seen anything about how long Kepler will be out with this. In other Kepler news, his bat has cooled off a bit since my last post, with his slash line down to .241/.320/.424 (.744)
-
Historical Payroll Tool
It's probably too early to worry about paying all those guys at the same time. If they all pan out that would be a huge success. However, the danger you're describing does kind of resemble what happened in 2011 when payroll was all the way up to $112M. There were 13 guys that made $3M or more (Mauer, Morneau, Nathan, Cuddyer, Pavano, Capps, Young, Kubel, Baker, Liriano, Blackburn, Thome, and Nishioka). If my memory serves me right 9 of those (all except Pavano, Capps, Thome, and Nishioka) were guys that had been with the Twins since before they were arbitration eligible. (not sure on Young or Nathan)
-
Better than we thought?
In my opinion, whether Gardy keeps his job or not should already be decided and shouldn't have much to do with whether the team wins 65 games or 75 games this year. The better question is who do you want coaching the upcoming wave of prospects? You've got Sano, Rosario, Buxton, and Meyer with debuts in the next year or two, and Hicks, Arcia, and Gibson with a taste of the bigs already. What head coach is going to help these 7 players reach their potential? Is it Gardy or someone else? I don't see how winning a few more games than expected this year changes the answer to this question. Full disclosure - this isn't really my idea, I'm pretty much ripping it off from Phil Mackey.
-
Gammons: Morneau placed on waivers
If this is an attempted salary dump, then it makes sense to me that you'd want him to be claimed, and that Ryan waited to put him on waivers until he got hot. Perhaps Ryan wanted to trade him in July but no team would accept his full contract - they would only trade if the Twins paid some. Now if a team places a claim on him, they have to be willing to eat his entire remaining salary. Yes, if he clears waivers you can trade with anyone, but you're in the same spot you were in July with no one willing to eat his entire salary. Obviously this is entirely hypothetical - I have no idea what the market for Morneau was/is like.
-
2 outs away from his 3rd straight complete game
That run could easily have been a three run homer to Butler or Gordon.
-
Max Kepler
Kepler has rebounded nicely from his 1 for 22 slump the 2nd week of July. From July 15-28 he hit .333/.455/.533 (.988) with 2 homeruns and more walks (10) than strikeouts (7). He also stole his first two bases of the year. The slump a few weeks ago is pulling down his overall numbers quite a bit to .273/.361/.468 (828). I'm moving into cherry-picking territory here, but if you expclude his 1-22 slump his full year slash line looks very nice at .316/.412/.547 (.959) with 18 walks compared to 19 strikeouts. His splits have improved slightly since clutterheart's post above, with 6 more at-bat's against lefthanders and only 1 more strikeout. His OPS vs lefties is a putrid .437, but that's actually a couple hundred points higher than it was 2 weeks ago. Of course, 29 at-bat's is a very small sample size. Max has seen a lot more action at first base lately, having played there 9 times since July 15th. The rest of his time in the field has been at left, where he had played a decent amount of CF earlier in the year.
-
Article: Five Goals For The Second Half
When I first read this sentence I thought to myself "that's ridiculous, Arcia is totally going to be better than Delmon." Then, I looked at Young's minor league stats. Based upon things I had read in the past, I had always assumed Young was just rushed through the minors without regard to his actual production, but check this out... In 2005 Delmon had 370 plate appearances in AA as a 19 year old (19!) with this slash line: .336/.386/.582 (.968) and 20 homeruns. Yup, 20 homeruns. For comparison, Arcia had 299 plate appearances in AA as a 21 year old with similar stats but a few less homeruns: .328/.398/.557 (.955) and 10 homeruns. I'm still excited to watch Aricia and think he will be better than Delmon, but I guess this is example #956 that prospects, even those with great numbers in the high minors, don't always pan out.
-
Max Kepler
Kepler had a rough week, going 1 for 22 with 9 strikeouts. This slump brought his numbers for the year down quite a bit to .242/.303/.429 (.732). Hopefully things will turn around this week!
-
Max Kepler
Kepler had an up-and-down week at the plate, with monster games on Monday (HR and Triple) and Friday (4 for 5 including a double), but went 0 for 3 on Thursday and 0 for 5 on Saturday. All together he had a great slash line for the week of .345/.367/.553 (.918). His 4 hits on Friday brought his average for the year over .300, and his full year slash line is now .304/.377/.551 (.927). Kepler played 4 games in Center,2 at DH, and one game at first base on Wednesday. He played 3 games at first back in 2011 at Elizabethton, but other than that has always been an outfielder.
-
Max Kepler
Kepler had quite a week, especially considering it was his first full week in A-ball. He hit .273/407/636 (1.044) on the week including 2 doubles, 2 homeruns, and a walkoff single to give the Kernels their 10th straight win and a free meal. Check out the metro sports report article linked in the post above for a couple nice quotes. In the field, Kepler played center field in 4 games, right field in 1, and was the DH once. Here's an interesting stat - Kepler has 11 hits so fat this year, and only 4 of them are singles. The other 7 are 5 doubles and 2 homeruns. All of that makes his slugging percentage (.550) exactly double his average (.275)
-
Gotta Listen on Perkins?
I can't decide whether this means he should be traded or should not be traded. He should be traded because his very team friendly contract increases his trade value, and he should not be traded because the Twins have a top-rate closer locked in for three years at an awesome price. I think there's another more complicated reason to not trade him though. I recall reading something recently from Denard Span where he felt that he intentionally signed a long-term team-friendly contract so that he wouldn't be traded, and that ended up being part of the reason he was traded (i.e. his contract increased his trade value). If the Twins do this too often could it make players less likely to sign deals like this? Of course, there is risk on both sides to that sort of deal. Nick Blackburn signed a simlar length contract at a similar point in his career to both Span and Perkins, and it didn't turn out to be so "team-friendly."
-
Max Kepler
In an interview a couple of summers ago Kepler mentioned more than once that he aspired to be a Josh Hamilton type. Hamilton is listed on Baseball-Reference as 6-4, 225, which is the same height and just a few pounds heavier than Kepler now. Hamilton has played plenty of CF, so I don't think it's out of the question based on size alone. I don't think Kepler would ever be playing CF on the same team as Buxton or Hicks though.