Everything posted by stringer bell
-
Good News/Bad News
On attendance, certainly the Twins were due for a dip since they didn't have the "hook" of the All-Star game. Add to it that they have had four straight losing records and it makes sense that every portion of Twins fandom is down. MLB is easily the most affordable major sport to watch. Almost all the games are on TV and going to a game doesn't cost a week's pay. Every sport seems to target what I consider the wealthy, unfortunately.
- Article: The Top 5 Moments in Tim Laudner's Career
-
2015 SS and CF
Let's be realistic here. Neither Escobar or Santana is really proven and either or both could regress significantly and this whole discussion would be moot. That said, based on performance, both Escobar and Santana should be in the lineup and that means Santana in center field. To those who say Escobar will get his playing time, remember that he would be backing up the three best position players from last year and two of them hit from Esco's stronger side.
-
2015 SS and CF
If the Twins are deciding by past performance, Escobar must be in the starting lineup from Day 1. He had a fine season with the bat and demonstrated consistency and a strong arm at short. Santana deserves to start somewhere and there is an XL hole in center field. It makes sense to me. Hicks hasn't performed well enough to garner a spot on the 25-man roster and we have seen two seasons in a row that his spring training performance is no predictor for his play when the games start. Defensively, I think Santana was approaching league-average by the end of the season. Put him out there for another 50 games and he will be average or better.
- Article: The Top 5 Moments of Jacque Jones' Career
-
Rockies seek pitching for Outfielder
The Rockies have been looking at the Kevin Correia level on the free agent market. The Twins have a lot to offer at that level. The Rocks still have an excess of outfielders, but after his second half I don't think Blackmon is a good match with the Twins. My scenario remains trade for Bourjos or any other elite defense right handed hitting outfielder available. Schafer plays more if Bourjos struggles at the plate and less if he hits. Schafer gets several starts for Hunter vs. RH pitching and occasional starts for Arcia. Hicks goes to Rochester to compete for a recall.
-
Article: Trevor Plouffe's Improved Defense
I thought Mauer was shaky early at first, mostly on popups and ground balls hit to him (to flip or not flip) and he was unsure of himself positioning and cutting off balls. As the season wore on, he got more and more comfortable. He's pretty athletic and has a really long reach. He's probably more prone to win a Gold Glove than a Silver Slugger IMHO.
- Article: Trevor Plouffe's Improved Defense
-
2015 Arbitration Signings
Split the difference and get it over with. I am as big a fan of Schafer as almost everyone, and I thought it was questionable that he would even be offered arbitration. Apparently years of service matters quite a bit. I was looking at some of the numbers agreed to by arb eligible players and Casey McGehee is filing for more than Plouffe will be getting and in the same range as Josh Donaldson, even though Plouffe profiles better and Donaldson is an All-Star.
-
Article: Trevor Plouffe's Improved Defense
I'm with Brock on this and have learned to appreciate Plouffe for what he has done to become, by almost all measures, an above-average third baseman. In the Dozier thread there were comments about having 3-4 good players capable of having a great year. I would put both Plouffe and Dozier in that category. Their floors have gone up to capable or average and in good seasons could be in the top quartile at their position. Regarding the comments above, Plouffe isn't one to make many highlight film plays, but that shouldn't sully his defensive reputation. Making the plays that should be made is much more important than having Manny Machado throw out a guy from beyond the coaches box. Plouffe's (and Dozier's) improvement didn't make the Twins a contender in 2014, but having guys that can be counted on makes the climb to respectability and contention that much easier.
-
Is Brian Dozier Underrated?
Dozier is the rare player on the team who is at least average offensively, defensively and on the bases. Having eight or nine players like him would be great. He is a fine player, but not a superstar. I think he'll be the second baseman the next time the Twins make the playoffs.
-
Johan's Venezuelan Debut
Santana is a skilled hurler, if he were 100% healthy, he still would be at least a better than average pitcher. However, it isn't whether he has enough stuff to pitch in the majors, it is that his arm is connected mostly by surgical thread. I sincerely doubt he could hold up more than a few weeks. Beyond that, some other part probably will fail him. Unless the Twins are convinced he has found a magical cure for his ailment, they shouldn't sign him. I do want to remind Mr. Pleiss that Bartlett signed a minor-league deal, the problem was that they let him make the team on attitude and experience rather than performance. Perhaps a new field management team would hold their veteran minor-league contracts to higher performance standards, I sure hope so.
-
Is Brian Dozier Underrated?
I don't consider it sad and I do think Dozier has been the best position player the past two years by a decent margin. Dozier is a good player and I think he will continue to be underrated by many until batting average isn't the first thing considered for offensive performance.
- Article: Last Chance for Winter Meltdown Tickets
- Article: Last Chance for Winter Meltdown Tickets
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
I liked Jimmer's comment, but I would point out that some pitchers consistently exceed their FIP, while others consistently fall short. Nolasco has consistently had a higher ERA than his FIP.
-
Article: Rocking The Boat?
Tempest in a teapot further complicated (to us) by language issues. I hope this is the case. Winter ball intrigues me and I don't really know how to consider performances in these leagues. I know many of the players are living at home and playing abbreviated schedules, I know that there are good crowds and good players when they are in the playoffs. I don't know how seriously the players are taking the competitions and I don't know if strong (or weak) performance shoud be an indication of future performance.
-
Is Kennys Vargas the Real McCoy?
I have liked Vargas since I saw him hitting in ST a couple years ago. His prospect status was effected by not playing full seasons and being considered "bat only" at a young age. DHs just aren't considered as valuable as other position players unless they really rake. Vargas skipped AAA and does have some holes in his swing, but the power is epic and he is a switch hitter. I am slightly concerned by his lack of productivity as a RH hitter, but from what I remember, he didn't have severe platoon splits in the minors. It wouldn't surprise me to see Kennys struggle this year and it is possible he will need to go to AAA at some point, but I think that he'll be a good major league hitter for a good period of time.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
Hicks' history in the lower minors was to struggle early, repeat and succeed. He has basically skipped AAA, or at least not mastered that level. If Buxton or Rosario need playing time at AAA, move Hicks to a corner. It is his projected place when Buxton arrives if he stays with the Twins anyway. IMHO, Hicks fundamentals and psyche can't stand up to the challenge of big league pitching. It is possible that success at Rochester (if not domination) might build his confidence to the point that he would come back to the major and hit well from both sides of the plate. In answer to Dante above, I believe the ship has sailed on switch hitting. Despite the talk about how fundamentally poor some of Hicks' PAs have been, the biggest thing he is lacking is confidence. However the club can build Aaron Hicks' confidence is the way it should proceed. I firmly believe that a trip to Rochester the best and perhaps only answer.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
Based on what? HIs lifetime .609 OPS, the total lack of power he displayed in 2014? His nice smile? My point all offseason has been that in nearly a full year's major league at-bats Aaron Hicks has not shown himslef to be a major league hitter. He has shown that his spring training performance can't be counted on, so based on those two factors and still considering him a prospect who can get better, the only destination for Hicks should be Rochester, New York. Schafer's month of August was superior to any month Hicks has performed in the majors, by a lot. In my book, he should get the at-bats versus right handed pitchers and since I firmly believe Hicks should work on his hitting in the minors, the only RH choice to play center field to start the season is Shane Robinson.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
The problem with a Hicks/Schafer platoon is that the guy with the tools and (perhaps) unreached potential won't get many at-bats. If Hicks only starts against left handers, then he starts less than 50 games. That is not the way to develop a player still regarded as a prospect. I have advocated long and hard for Hicks to be optioned to Rochester and see if he can master AAA pitching and perhaps become an acceptable big-league hitter. I really think that is the only way to go for Hicks. If the Twins want their best players on the field, Escobar should be out there, even if it means that Santana is in center. Personally, I want to see how long the acceptable hitting for Schafer will play out. Even with his much improved performance in Minnesota, his numbers screamed "platoon". Still, if he can perform close to last year, he is an asset who provides speed and base-stealing ability, two things the club lacks. Since I've called for Hicks to be optioned, the logical backup outfielder would be Robinson, not really an All-Star setup, but again the RH half of a platoon doesn't get that much time on the field. To me, making Aaron Hicks into a platoon player lowers his value and closes the book on him becoming much more than a career fourth outfielder. While I have been critical of his performance and doubtful of his future, I do believe he still has a chance to be much more than a platoon player/fourth OF.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
Since Hicks has a lower OPS and the same OPS+ in approximately the same number of plate appearances, I guess neither of them belong in the majors. Seriously, what is best for Hicks is to go to Rochester and master that level. If it means that Robinson gets some play for a month or two, so be it. The Cards have made the playoffs almost every year and he's managed to get 2.141 years of service, so I guess Robinson fits on a good team as the 25th man.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
Hicks-Gomez? Not me. Gomez was overly aggressive and Hicks is overly passive, so as players they are really opposite sides of the coin. In the sense that they started in the majors before they were ready there are similarities. Further, we have only seen glimpses of Hicks that were capable major league players. We saw more sustained stretches from Gomez paired with slumps where he looked like he couldn't hit the ball if it was on a tee. Regarding Rasmus, I don't want to see the Twins bring in someone that would only be acceptable in the outfield and I think that is all we would get with Rasmus. He also has an injury history and has trouble with LH pitching. If the Twins were to add Rasmus, they would have four players with severe platoon splits--Mauer, Arcia, Vargas in addition to Rasmus. I also get the feeling that Santana is going to struggle more against LH pitching just from his ABs last year.
-
January Mailbag Call
Are the Twins really going to go with their current options for center field? Related question--will Danny Santana see considerable time in center this year?
-
Article: Extensions for Dozier and Plouffe?
According to ESPN, Dozier had the fifth highest WAR amongst second basemen. Plouffe was tenth amongst third sackers. With a serf salary, Dozier is a tremendous bargain. Meanwhile, Plouffe was underpaid for his value, but not nearly as much as Dozier. If they both maintain their production, they would continue to be great values. The waiting replacement for Plouffe has a very high ceiling, but is probably half a season away. Not now but later, Plouffe is a prime trade candidate. Dozier would appear to be a Twins' regular for next year and two arb years. He would be 30 at that point, with one more year prior to free agency. There is still time to get a an extension done, if Dozier continues to improve his performance.